ATAS/69/2008 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATAS/69/2008 · Contract Modification Validity Dispute (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The cases involve disputes concerning the modification of several agreements, where the court determined that subsequent actions and purported agreements did not legally supersede or amend the original contractual terms, particularly regarding compensation and obligations, because the attempts at modification either lacked necessary assent, failed to meet statutory or contractual prerequisites for validity, or were otherwise unenforceable under established legal principles governing contract modification and enforcement. The reasoning consistently focused on the clear language of the initial agreements, the lack of demonstrable mutual assent to the changes, and the failure to satisfy formal requirements necessary to alter binding legal relationships, thereby upholding the original contractual structures.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Modification Validity Dispute: The reasoning consistently focused on the clear language of the initial agreements, the lack of demonstrable mutual assent to the changes, and the failure to satisfy formal requirements necessary to alter binding legal relationships, thereby upholding the original contractual structures.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA

validità del contratto fine del processo requisiti di forma esecuzione competenza in materia di contratti conclusi dai consumatori intese

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for the costs allocation in the dispositive orders.

Generato dall'IA

A/4365/2005

Contract Modification Validity and Consideration Dispute

A/1487/2002

Contract Validity and Modification Dispute

A/1104/2004

Contract Modification Validity and Consideration Dispute

A/4090/2005

Contract Amendment Validity Dispute

A/3040/2006

Modification of Contract Validity and Consideration

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for the costs allocation in the dispositive orders.

Testo completo

#$%&'#$(() *#+,#$((%

*

* !* ! !

!-./ & $0 12 $((%

!" # $ %"&" % & ' %&&( )

&

'' * ++ , &!" -./

!"

,1041,

3 *

46 7,%8 9 *" &: " 4.32 & &&%&;<" =%>%% *!%6 &="&&)&&- 3%&!?1554@5%&!, ?155A%B 11>6*B# .B%(& A(%!%&C8!6

16 %%& 12(&155A B> )= B; &B%" ) & &!&; *%% !& DE%&< =& 8= 7,%8 9 D: <%" ) %&& >>& !?;%&" %)&)*"&&;;=" !& )*"&&F& &=#455G %42>"=155A6%"") ;%B !? !&& &"-&B" @ 3 &-% ";""&> *= @5 G = && &?&" ;%B ><&<&6

@6 !?%&)"2H&155A!"= &"-&B" ; 3 A ;""& " !& %& %&",%" )&=&"?3,A"&%& &&= < A6

36 *!%-""%%& &=@5%&!?155A * &&&6

A6 1A = 155I *" "%" ! %&& *, = &"& &#*& *&6

I6 %%& 2!155IB; ;&)"= "% %&" &= !?; B) = & &"-&B" @ 3 <&& % = < 6 !&" %&" &= &8 455 G 8 42 >"= 155A & % " "&!"6 )")%&&%;& !?? = & <&&><&<& & >&; & *!6 &&" - ! =&"? !? & &"-&B" @ 3 )* "&& &&6 *< %%& !" !F! ( &!" ) *&=&" <" ()* *"&& % <;? & )* *? >!& %=& % <; *")*<JK&&&=&"6>&"&& %?&"%%&& && ?& &# <B%( !B% & !<!!4*555!8& =%& "% B; )&#) L ! =B *!%?&" # *; ?& *%?>>& !=!& !!? &= B&"B "% ";%&6

012340155/ ,@041, /6 4I(=155/*>>& *= &"7,%89 : >!"*")*"&&" %" #<%&!" %8 +=!" "; *,= &"7,%89+:6

26 %%& *<%& 4.>"=155/ %"& !" %B-) & "" & ! "= ; ) M >= *%;)"#B&%&42 +!-&B >= * % &-% >?!-;)6 ;&)" * %& = "% %&" &= !?&; # %" ! ;B&"-&B" ; 3,A& %&B"&;" 7 3@64: *& %& "% %&" &= && %8 % &6 "")-!%&!&;;)%"&" % *" "&& %>& ")& = &= ;) & &&)6 = &&&?(&=#&"#%&" &=&& *&=&"&" &&- &#%&" &= &B") 455 G &=&" %&" && !%& !&& >&&&>= !& !& 1AG=& !&& >&6 %"" ) >J ;? *" "&& ! *!%&&>! *&=&" &-%" &&%& B; %!&&& =& %& >J >")& & "% & = %&" &=<;? /AG 8>"=155A6

.6 %(& " 45 ! 155/ * >!" *" ) ! "&& (&" !&> ) !% = = & = &" %!&&& & ;" *= &" 1@ G ) "&& >>& %= &#&&) !%>>! !&*"&&% )" %&% &>& &)!&!% ")&6%"") ! "&&!&=""&& %"#%" #*<! * "=& %!&6

456 2(155/*"&&"*%%"& %&" &= &=&" %&"6 % & %%& I ( 155/ ) >& "&& %?? %&& # !% &=< %B-) ! !<! A5 G # = !! = =& ! B &8 >? &= " !% 8 )* -; # A2 %& & >6 & *" ) ! = *<%&<> "&! !8%"&< %&" &= " 8 ) *%%& % !%& # & "; 6 >%B"#* %=%" "#?&&!& 15G =&&&)&&!%& K; = >!&& %&" " &= %& )* & ?&&!& %!&&& &&< *= &" I4G6 *& "(#&"*& * %!&6

012340155/ ,3041,

446 !!& 43 ( 155/ * >!" *" )* &&%>&& BB *!%& >%= %!&6

416 " !F!(>!"%&6%"")* !& %%"!& (&>& % 8 )* ? !& 1A G =& "(#"&"%!%&6

4@6 & 4. (& 155/ *" & & " %8 ? "6#*& *)& & *= &"& "%6 ";" ) %&" " &= =& "&" ><" # /A G )!&? "&!" &!%& >& !" < >>&& %&" &= & !&& "?!& %?&" *;;!& ) # = K; >!& !&" # *" %! && & %&?& !! %&" " &= # &!% %&6 "" ) & >& (&>& %" # ?&&!& 15 G = *= ) %!&&& &&< *= &" 3@6AG & &#)& &6";!&% &%%& 1(&155/>& "&& * %"(& &? "&& ;) % = " & !&&%&"" &= A5G &=&" %&"6

436 "% 2H&155/*&!"(& 6 "" ) & %"&& !&& " < " = # &&" # &"; *&& "( & ) !&& >& (&>& % " & %%"!& %)* =& "(# "&" % !%& *"=& %&" &= # /A G6 %"" ) (% >& %=& % F& & > % %" # *?&&!& &&&)6 &&> !)*<&&>&!&&>#=*K;)%!&&& # ?&&!& 45G)! >&&&>% " 8) ;" *= &""&&&(>"#35G6

4A6 "%) 1@ H& 155/ *" %&" %"" & 6<%")&8 *K;*"&&%&8)%=& # !& &&&)!)*>&";!&% "&*? >!&%>, # *"%! & %&" " &= # &!% %&6 ";" ) = !&" >!&%"&"&&%&" ; &=&" %&" &! %&" * %&&&%&& &!&&&> !B" &==%") *F&!?"!""6%"" )* ! & % " & %%"!& &&&) % "#B %!% *&>&)*"&&%

012340155/ ,A041, %%&=%?8! &"&=&> "? %&" ;"6

4I6 "& 15 %&!? 155/ * " # %) & !&%&6

4/6 4 &? 155/ ? !!)" && "& & & >!"%&)"&&; "#(;6

*

46 >!"!& # *&6 AI 6 4 &6 B6 1 ;= *;& ( 7: ? & N& & ) &&& %"= # O& AI >" " %& ;"" & I &? 1555 7 : ) & &=#>" "O,= &" 4.(4.A.7 :6

+!%"&%(; O%8&"&?6

16 & &" =; 4 (= 155@ &N& ! >& !? %&"; ! *,= &"6& %%? *%8 8 ) >& ( )!& "&!& & ""%&"!&#&"=;7>6 '4@533I 64 41. 3 6 461:6 ! >& "; & &&& 8; ;"" = >!" (% &= < & % & =& *&" =; P * " ! >& %& = & & ) (% "=%%" # %% %& F& % & %%)"

7 ' 4@5 @3A 6 @:6 %& = 14 ! 155@ ! >& 738!"=:&"=;4(=15537155@ @2A1:&";%!F!%%&& %%?6

>>" " 4I "!?155A! >&>" "*, = &" & &" =; 4 (& 155I 7155I 155@: %%&& ! >&)&&!!&%" & =& ? & & *& & > (& !&8 &&& %&& *& > %&& * ) =&&&155>6&4*555>67&6A1A2&I4&6 & &6 I. 64 ? :6 *%8 %"& & ! = & %)"&">!"%84(&155I7B6&6 %& &&&=#! >& 4I "!?155A:6

012340155/ ,I041, @6 +O&6I564 " & &&(6 " 43 ( 155/ "&" J % & 42 ( 155/ & " * !!"#) ! "%&7&6@264 :6 " & % 4A (& 4A H& =!& 7&6 2. &6? &;=%" !&&= 41%&!? 4.2AP : & @2 6 3 &6 ? & ) " & =" # "B" 4. H& 155/6 &(&" >! & " %"= % "%"42(&155/&=?=& &6AI 6

36 &; %& ;" *= &" & & %&& & # )& & *,= &"6

A6 &"%&"= &"*%&" ;&&%&%"!"%!& ; " "&& * >!&" ;"& * ! * & 7&6 2 6 4 & 3 6 4 :6 + *&6 / & "%&" %&" ;&& !& *!? *%& %?&" ; *" !B" &=")?" ! *&=&" && !&"& *&&&#&"%B-)!&%-B)& )*%&%8&&!&&! " %&&<;?6

84(=1553O" &#&&8O&= #/5G !#&,)& &*&= #I5G!# !, & O & = # A5 G ! # )& & O & = # 35G!6

*?;&%*" ! !!;&%%;"" & 7 '41.3I@ 636141@1@@ 6@44/ 1/2 6 1? 355 & ">" &":6 (; %& % > !%!& &= ) *" > *&! ,!F! %? > % "?& %&" &=%"=&)& &&&" *>#%>& ;" = &"7 '45I2I 6 1%62/:6 I6 %= ;" *= &"* !&&7(;*- : ? !& ) !" "=&!& *& %"& =&>6&KB !" &#%&(;!& *"&& &"&# ) )!&%)&=&"*" &%? &=6& "!" &&&""!& & % "&! ) &=< %& ?!& <; *" 7 ' 41A 1I4 6 3 44A 4@3 6 1 443 @43 6 @ 45A4A2 64:6

+%% ?%%"& %=)O%%)? %" !&&=)O%" & !&&>7&635 '"&=O&64. P&6.A61=&644@& 4@1:O !&&(;%%"?!&%=F&"%

012340155/ ,/041, 8; >! %" & # %%"& !%8& & ; %=6 8(; &<! !8?(&=&!- %=))O&%=% " !&# %& %!&&& %&(;!&=? &&;<6)%%& !" < & & & (; %& &B *>> ) % ) > % !" & % &6 & "; *""!& "&!& *& *; ";& !- %=!!%%&<%&!&6!%&) %& &;< !%&& & >& *?(& * "& >" ) %%& > <! !%& )* % ";!& "& %& <%!" )* & "&" "&? % 7!8:) %& &>"!" &&>) *<%&&?!&="7 '41A@A4 6@:6

/6 &8;)%&"" &=& A5G&)*&!" ! # && %" # ?&&!& 15 G = &&&) = &&!%& K; %&"" &=%&& =!&" >!&6

%& *&!" 8 )* * % # %" # & ?&&!& "&& ")!&&>& &(&>&% " & %%"!&#) "(#"&"%%)"&&%&"" &= /AG&)*"=&!&?&&!& 45G%&F&& *K; & ! ) !F! && "=&&" ;" *= &"&>"#35G6

=& && *? *<! *&!" & # (& && %&" " &= /AG &=&" %&"6

%%& *<%& %8 = ;&" %& *" % %" " *%&#!8>!%%>& & % -&8! *& %& # <! ) ;&)" = "% %&" &= !?&; # %" ! ;B&"-&B" ; 3,A & %&B"&;" 7 3@64: & "% %&" &= && %8 % &6 <%" ) *<! !" ;"" !&&& "= B; % "&)); ;&"? M )+!-&B%"&)**? 44%&%">) 42+!-&B ;& >?!-;%=&%F&& >J >!6(&")*!8*<!)&%& "=&- ! <!&>!6 "")*<!) >!& !& !?&" = B !? = "B!& &=&?&"7!&?&"3& A:&)*!&&&"= %;)B-%&B" >>

012340155/ ,2041, !!?>";B!&&()*<;<&% &%# && 6 ! %&" &= && *&=&"&" &&-&%&" &=&B") 455G &=&" %&" && !%& !&& >& &&> = !& !& 1AG 8>"=155A=& !&& >&6 (& 8& *%&!%?&"# %& B;%"#/6AL >J"%"&&=# %&%& %&,#,><>< B#*;#&%&&&) , # @5!&& ?&, # A#45!& *&%& !&& %"!8& !B#= !,B6

*<%&*&<%!"*"=& *"&& &" &%&" &=&!&&>&> H!&<%)"&!&=" %& =6 + & B"& & =& && ) &!!& %& &&& ?(&=%&& &-% *%%"&6

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

012340155/ ,.041, & !%& >& ) *<%" !" &&& & ;""!& &#% %&%%&& & >)*&# 7 '41A@A4 6@?0??&:6

&& " ) *%%"& !" &&& %!& % & =%?& %%& & %%"& *%&" &= " /A G ?!& <;? &=&" %&" > & && ) %%& *<%& !%& && & (% & %!&&& N& % > %?& 7>6 '41A@A1 6@&">":6+& =% ?6

26 =&!&& %" &< *= &"6

!% = *>>& 8; B>>& <&!&)%?!&& <=&>&&* = *& >>" %!&&& &< *= &" 7!"&B ;"" !% =P '412@5 644534@I 6 1&1?:6%" #!% ==& % !!& & # &P = = & = &" =&F& "&!"%%%&#!F!!!&&! >& =%&? *> &#&=()*!!&Q "& =&F&%!%&7 '41.111&4124/3:6

8; ;"" = B-%&B"&) % = "&! "&?& ;" =!? %"% "& )* & >>&=!& % " !!& "&!& "&& ? &" && !%& *"=& ()* !!& %" "7 '41.113 636@64:6

&= *= &F&"="=&&&>& && %>8& *&""6)*"*%% *&=&" &=&" %&"%!&&& !&&%!&=%&" &=" &!&#)&?!&<;? %& = *= %& F& "=" ? " &&&) & )*"&& *)F&&& 7,%89++:%?" % *>> >" " &&&) 7,%8 9 '+: ? &&&) 7 '41I/A 6@?0&??:6">8#&&&) ?&& "> &&(!" =&

7 '413@1@ 6@?0??:6

! )&& &&&) =&F&" & "% *!? & % & %> %& 7!&& " B % K; " = &&"0&"; *&& "( & &< *%&: & "& *

012340155/ ,45041, "=& !& %= *%%"&6 " & ;? !<!! 1AG&&&)%!& &!%& >>"& ""!&)%=&>= *&=&"&=7 '41I/A 6A?0,:6

.6 %%& *&61.6 4 &6 ? % %" # !% ==& %155I%)*%&" &=&&&&" %42>"=155A&) ! %&& & 1A=155I6

+ )& % *!%- 41 ( 155I & &"&"155I 11>6%B&&&#&"6 .B %(&A(%!71@35B%":*"8=#A4*325 >6%&C8! 3*1.5>67A4*325941:&== &" AA*//5>6F!& &) %1553&!& *&!"*-% * %&!&&#* %&& 155A & 155I 8 ) *!%- %"" & )& ) *" ;;&( *B&155I11>6

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

012340155/ ,44041, ")& - %" # ?&&!& 15 G !&&"&<%& *%&#*&" =#K;& #>?& &)= *= &F&F&"#@A*A42>6 35733*@.2<25G:&&< *= &"#@IG7AA*//5,@A*A426359AA*//5:&< )&>>&% &#& *= &"6

*,= &" * % # "% >>&" & % &= !% %%%" " # K; # !) >!& %>6+*&=) &>&,"&;#*= &",(& E";;?% "&! &&=&")*%& ?!&<; *"&&&% & %%"!& ) # %& &8 ?!& <;? * &=&" & %&? *> *"& *= &" !F! * & %> >> = !%? BB * % & %&& *&& %&" &=" 7 '45/4/ 61%614 ' %?" @//0.2 12(&4... 64&">"%?"+4...%613I& 452105I 13%&!?155/ 6161:6

456 > "(&"6 = & - ! &%!& *"!!& 155>6

012340155/ ,41041,

! 4* 3 * !* ! !

5.

46 "=?6

5

16 (&&6

@6 &"!!& 155>6#B; &6

36 >! %& )O %=& >! & %"& F& " @5 ( 8 &>& %8 ? >" " 7+BRCB>)II553 :%= !&8 & %?>!"!&<&621 >" " ?>" " 4/ ( 155A 7 ':P !"! & ) !&> & !- %=&%&;& & ! &P & F& " ? >" " % = %& % = "&) < & *&6 31 '6 %"& F& & %8 % &=)"!!!- %= =&F&(&#*=6 ;>>8 %" & ? + "&,(&9 B%% S

%>! %"&F&&&>"<%&)O#O>>>" " %;>>

012340155/

Contract Modification Validity Dispute

Sintesi Legislator

Regesto Legislator

Parole chiave

Disposizioni normative citate

Decisioni correlate

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Testo completo