Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/147/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/147/2005 Généré par l'IA

Liability Apportionment Affirmation

Numéro de cause ATAS/147/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The litigant sought review of a determination regarding the allocation of liability for damages arising from an event, arguing that the apportionment of fault was erroneous based on the established facts of the incident. The court reasoned that the evidence, including documented events and established legal principles concerning the parties' respective duties and conduct, adequately supported the initial finding that the litigant bore a greater degree of responsibility for the resulting damages, thus affirming the original determination.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Liability Apportionment Affirmation: The court reasoned that the evidence, including documented events and established legal principles concerning the parties' respective duties and conduct, adequately supported the initial finding that the litigant bore a greater degree of responsibility for the resulting damages, thus affirming the original determination.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
responsabilité pour faute confirmation de compétence dette alimentaire cession de créances civiles calcul des dommages-intérêts chose accessoire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for regulating the court costs of the appeal.
Art. 68 al. 2 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for regulating the court costs of the appeal.
Généré par l'IA
A/1934/2007
Negligence and Apportionment of Liability for Damages
A/1597/2005
Workplace Injury Liability Affirmation
A/1446/2006
Damages Calculation Affirmation
A/1737/2004
Apportionment of Liability Cap in Tort Actions
A/1251/2006
Liability Affirmation and Damages Modification Appeal

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for regulating the court costs of the appeal.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for regulating the court costs of the appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               '()*+'+,,* '(-.'+,,/

##

 # "   "  #  "

*0  12  % +- 34 +,,/ 



   !5555555555 !" !#!$ %&' !!" ( "))*+")

"!

66   "  "7# 8 9" ! ) "+ ,-./0//12/3

       

        !"# $%&

   704/87  

 6

/9 #) :::::::::: +  /8 2! /-;< !+ " 1! ) "! ="  "!2+ > ! ) 38 ?! !   "" * !+"!  !1 ) @:::::::::: A7 !1 @::::::::::B C*( // =+2!! /--< )" > * "!")"!2+"+!++ ! ,! !)!+!D"9 ""!!(+2">58E586=!9A8E686=!9F/3B91=+2!!/--<  (" !" > (== " ) (  A7 !1 ( B !  D !+)("")8E;./=!9A 1;"8=!!8 B9

09  ; !  8  /--.  > 2 )1  - "G! /--.  !1   "+ "" ) 5   < "G! /--. (!+  +"+   "+ ) "!2! > 86H9 I!  )! )!  ==!" )( +"" )+ != !D!=A 1/=!!0  1;"8=!!8 B9

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

;9  03 2! /--< (!+  )+ +  )) ) !"" ) (== " ) (!72)"+ A7 !1 ( B  "" ("! )( !"A 1/=!!0 B9

89  0-/--<+)"!""!+)D+! !">(""")(  )* )D"*++"")+ !=+!+*(?, !"



4/53040663  734/87   !"+!9!2+*(+"")"+)(!++""""!"*(+"" "C!   "+ ) "!2! > 86H  *( =!"   !2! != +"" G !  "!2 ) "+ > 7"  A"2"+ 2!++)"!BA 10=!!3 B9

59  0 C2! /--- (!+  ?"+ !  D9   "+  )"! ::::::::::0.C2!*""+ "+)"!2!>/66H ! ) !2G!?D )!" " ) + ?+ DL "7"!"* A 10"3/6"/5=!!; B9

.9 3!/--- !"!)D"*+)GD?!*!  G! )!"  " !  G"+! )+!+ > )!" " )!" > D?"! "?!)D?A 13=!!3 B9

<9 ! !""!+)!)/0C"/---)"!:::::::::: +  )D" ) )!GD ?!* )(+"" )+ != ?!* ) ,)!"=!)!F")! "!)")7+ F)!"9 !2+ * (+"" )+ != (+"" DD!2+ " > ) !G1 =F A !G12=B"* ""+""2 !)"!:::::::::: !  !G1 !?"F  )   "+ ) "!2 A 1 ; =!!3 B9

-9 3"G!/---)"!::::::::::*=+(+"")"+)(!+ )""!""=!" "+)"!2!>/66H!)  ) )1  /0  /---9  "! " >  ! "! )  == ) !""! ) (+  )!"   +!" ) (+  +"" 2D+ A 1 8 =!!3 B9

/69 !""!)052G!/---)"! ::::::::::+)7 )( !2+*(,2")()""!DD!2")(+"")"+ ) (!+  )+G" /--- !)" "" )!1!  G ) "!2!9   ! M  "!"" +"" "7N"! G  2 ) (+   =" !+2!!+2)!" !(+"+0666A 15=!!3 B9

//9 /.0666(!+G"!2"?!!DA!" ! ) (+  )!"B )!D+ !  !=! J:::::::::: +)7?= ) )+ !"" ) ?!!D ) IO "F 2!"! ) 12 A7 !1  IB9 !12!)D"*+"G"+"+!7=+!!)(+ )!" (?, !"!"+!"!"+"+""F7)+ != !"!2+ *" "7 +!"!+"" "=+G!"* ""2"+"+ D+! ))!A 1/6=!!3 B9

/09 ! )+ ) < C 0666 (   "!,+ > (!+  )7!" ) /! !/--<3/!/---=)+!"F)(2)"+)86H !" "1!)1/!2!/---=)+!"F)(2)"+)/66H9&+ F"



4/53040663  7;4/87   )F=">?!D"+"+G++=)!" +"!A 1 ;=!!/ B9

/39   ! !" "!+)! ) 08 2! 066/ )!+ > (   )"! ::::::::::  !2+ * (+"" ) "+ ) (!+ (+"" +!+ )  ! M  F""  "" )" ) )! ) (+  )!" )  ( +!"A 1.=!!3 B9

/;9 &!*" +"!))"!I::::::::::+)7) (!72)"+  )"! ::::::::::  !++  08 C 066/ * (!+ !+"" "C! ) )!7GD ?!* !  ), G! > 2F"+ )!" "G+ !  D,"* 2!"+G! !"*+ ""  9  (+!" ) )! > (+   ! ! )("2"+ !=)"!2 !""")?D!=!+*") "")("!! "")G"2)+ " 2"N"! ""+>"F)("2"+)86H9+)F *+*(="2D!) ! !=!("2"+)!+"!(+""  "G2 ""+2*+A 1//=!!3 B9

/89  0.  0660  !=! J::::::::::  !+)D+  ! !" > (""" ) ( )*!2+*(+"")"+)(!+(+""+!+9 !++ *(  2"  +"!  =!! F !"   "+ !="!+!" !=)1!*)!1!=*( 2" F+  ""  K" 066/ "" )!1! 2" !G" F!!+"!)!+"!9 !!DD+!+>( )()!!> +)"!"" !G"!)!D" !+"A 1/0=!! 3 B9

/59 <C"0660)"! :::::::::: ! +F !")(!+ ! !?"D!))==+!)( !+"))F+)= )P"! "+!+))"!2=="2A 1/;=!!3 B9

/.9  /- C2! 0663  )"! :::::::::: +)7?= ) !2 ) !?"D)(IO ") ?F7)7J)")"!::::::::::?= ) * " !+)D+  ! !" "  )" )(F !" =+ ! ( 9 !1 2! !+)+ > (1 " )+!" (+"" D++! )  ""  " )D"*+)!?D)==!"!G""*))!>(+  )!"2"" "7! ")(?, !"!"+! ! )!=G"*(,)!)+ !=9 "" ")(G) ")(F*")F +"! !"" "+* "+)"!2)(!++"")86H)"!2+D! !")?!D)+ "/8Q"*+"")"++"" "G2 "!2 ) !+"!"9  " !++ * ("++)" ) )+ ! (D""



4/53040663  784/87    ( "+ ) "!2 !  (2"  G!2+ ) "?D )+ !2 +21!!))F"!"2 ""A 1/8=!!3 B9

/<9 !)+)/<!0663( !+)"!")(2)"+)(!+> )7!")1/!0663=)"!"F)(2)"+)86H9  F *+ * !  G ) !D" +)F G" (+"" ) "+ (+""+!+)1)(K"066/*(F !"!++ !(IO ")  ?F7)7J) 2" =!+9   ) F !" !""" ) !"! "+!+))"!2)86H)"2"++D1! !" )?!D)+ "/8Q"* !F !+"!"A 1<>/6 =!!/ B9

/-9 ! !!! ) /- ! 0663 (!+  =!+  " > "" )+ " ))+ *  +) " "!  )! +) A 1 // =!!/ B9

069 !+!"!)80663 +"+ " !("!)  2" ""+  " > (" )  )+ ) /< ! 06639   F *+  G" *  +"" ) "+ +"" "C! ""!"*(==!"!)(+"")+ !=?!* !* ""  )"! ':::::::::: ,?"! )"  ! !" +"" "")9 (F !"))"!::::::::::"::::::::::)/-C2!0663(2"  !   " ) 1!  !=)   ,?* )"  ==!" ! N * ! +)  2" )+C> =" +"" ""  )"! ::::::::::9 ""==" !""9!!+D+*   "+ ) D  (+""  +!+ )  ! M  "" !++)"""++"""C!N"*(+"" G) !2! ) " ""* A)G"  B  ) "!" "9  !!"D+*(F !"(2" ="")+*) """ >  "+ !  G"+ !1" ) "!2!    " +""  "!)"2(2F !+ !)"!::::::::::)")08C 066/*("2"+)!+"!(+""  "G2"" ""+A 1/5=!!/ B9

0/9 ! )+ !  " ) /! C" 0663 (   !C"+ ( " ) /-!0663"=!+)+)!+)")!")/<!06639 D+ * ""  )"! :::::::::: *  )"! J:::::::::: 2" "+ * (+"" ) "+ ) (!+ (+"" +!+ " > ("!2" ?!!D>(+ )!"9 "!(!+2"+"+>F !" )" !  )"! :::::::::: * 2"  *( ) " )(  "+ !+) ) "!2 ) 86H ) ("2"+ ) !+"!" " ) "" "! "2"+ +D1!9 "" F !" !+ )" F !"1! + !  C! !) " +)"   2! !G"9 " > (+2" ) (2)"+ (   !2+ * (+"" > C" ""! *( 2" !"  )D!+



4/53040663  754/87   )(2)"+ ) 86H )1 ! * (!+ +)"   "+ !+) ) "!2)86H)("2"+F!+ !2""("2"+)!+"!A 1 /.=!!/ B9

009 !+!"!)0 "G!0663(!+"!C"+!!"!"")+  " ! " > (" )  )+ "  2!" )( !" )(2)"+ "1! 2 ==" !+"!"= >  )" )  )+ ""*+ " G)!">F !" ,?"!*=))+"!!+* )  +"" ,?* !   "+ ) D9 !1 2! ! ! (!D"" )+2 +) "D+*F !"2")* (+"" )  ) (+"" DD!2+  !2" *  + !)D* +"" "O"  DD!2" ! ! !" F ?+ ) /--.9 !  !G1 ) ) +"" > (!D )  )=="+ > "!  " ""*  * !+)")("" "+)"!29&(F !"!")K F! ) =R !1"  +* ) (DD!2" )  "+ ! (F! )( "2"+ ) !+"!"9 ! !  )"! :::::::::: (2" =" *(2! G"+)(+2"! !>86H""F *"*( +2"  "+ !+) ) "!2 (+""   "G 2 ) "S? ) !+"!"9(!+! !++*( (2" ,+)1! !1"" G"+)!++!!)))"!29!+"" !G ) )+!! *(  ,! ( "!" )(DD!  !+"! ?" * "" )!1! )2!" *""!  " ""  )7 ?! !D!)9!"" !( !")K ""!  )D!+ )(2)"+  ""   +!! > 555H  *  ) )!" >  !")(2)"+"1!9

039 ! !!! ) /8  "G! 0663 (!+  !)"  ! !" !+)D+ !  )"! ':::::::::: ,?"!  )" ) /! "G! 06639  !"  =!+ *(  2" )   08 ! 0663 " *( ==!" )( +"" )+ !=FF !""!+"> !G1"*9 !++ *+"")"+(+"" +!+D!+"!""")+ !!" 2!+D!9)!)"""D"+"""!D++!+ ! )=="+=")"!"2A 1.!+B9

0;9   !+2 ) 00 "G! 0663 (   ! +  !C" ) !! "  "))+"D9 "!2,"F"=)+C>F +) )+! " !++*!"(+"" ,?*) !!"*)D")T,)!)+ !=U2")+C>+"+ + ! +) "!"" )  )! ) ("!" )  )) ) !"" ) (!72)"+"*(2"+"+" "!))+)("! ) !" ) < C 06669 ! )  !+)! ) !+2  )"! I:::::::::: 2" F+  (+"" ) "+ )  !!" (+"" )=+ " =!+)"+"G/<=+2!!0663*"+)(!+(+"" +!+ !   ?,* ""  "" F !+"  )D" )



4/53040663  7.4/87   ,)! )+ !=9  ! !" ) )"! ':::::::::: ) /!  "G! 0663 !!G!" )(! ( !+"  * (+"" ) "+ ,?* )!"""!9

089 ! !+ * ) 8 )+G! 0663  !!"  "+D!" !"+ )  9

059 !) *)00)+G!0663( +D"""!) !+2   !+=+!" F !D" )+C> )+2 + )  !++)" +!"! *))+! "9

0.9 !1 "! )  +!"! F !"  ; 2G! 0663 " 8 C2! 0668+"+D!)+>CD!9

 #

/9 D2!(!D"C)!AB+"+)=+"""+)1 /!K"0663 !G")! +)8CD )"  !+)" "  27 !+)" 8  +" " /5 CD ! A!"9 / "9!"85 B9

&">(")(+")/5CD! ! !G=+)+! 0.C2!066;A J/36/65B!) D2) "+/3=+2!!  ) ""!"!!D" !""" !G")!  ) +D!  ! > "! CD ""!  ) (""" ) (+")2FCD!9

09 =!+" > (!"9 85 9 / "9    !G " ) !  P"  " * ) """ !+2 > (!"9 85 )   =+)+! !  !" D++! ) )!" ) !  ) 5 "G! 0666 A B!"2>=+)+!!(!72)"+)/-C/-8-A B9 & +" !CD!))( 1"+"G9

39    ""!+  2D! /! C2! 0663 "!P"  )=" ) G! ) " +D )  ) ) ! 9 &!  "+! ")2!*)!"E *)"N"!"!?+>1! ) ! *!1D G"2D!"M  =" C!)*" )+"!"  " !)" A J /0.  ;5. )9 / /05  /35 )9 ;G "  !+=+!B9  !2?   * !  !+)!">)+=")!1D"!"!"!!2)!"E * !+!2)1C!)"!+2D!A J//.-3)95G//0



4/53040663  7<4/87   356 )9 ;V  #  /--< ' 3. 9 3/5 )9 3GB9 E" !*  !+)! "!)"  !1  /! C2! 0663 )2"  "!G "  +"""1!)E!"!+D !2 !1D) !+)!") " !) ") !+)!" ))==+!" +)=+ ! 9

;9 &(!"9569/ !!)"N"!)+ +)"!"C!2" "="))+C"">!!9!"93<>;/" G ! DA!"95690 B9(!"93<9;"9G  !+2"*)+ C!    =F+ !    ! ("!"+  !"  ) /8 C"  /8K"2"9  "")) "!!"! "+ )+ ) "!" C! !+2 > (!"9 56 9 /    )+ "  !!  0 "G!0663"!)+! ")( )/!C"06639 "!C"+)=!")++DF!!"!2G=!+"F !"9858-"56 9

89 "D !"!*")2!(">C"""!*( )+!+ *(+"")"+)!!"(+""+!+)1/!0663)1! >=!)!"9

B F"!)(!"95 "!+ "+ "+)"!2"" !"""  !" ) ( "") ) (!+ )( ! )  !=   ) )("2"+  "!2 * " !G" N"! FD+ )   "" !"!+")(""">"+ ?,*"9 )( "+) "!2)D)!+("2"+* "N"!FD+) "!2!)( "! !=)("!))("2"+9&(!"9. "!+ "+  "+)D"")")(G)( !") G"+ )D)(!+!!?+)"!2+*G!+*"!)+!" "" )" !+" )( """ >  "+ ?,*  " " *( !" !1"!"""!) !+) ""FDG9 "!+ "+ 2)"+( "+)D"" !"*" !++ !") D )!+ A!"9 < 9 /  B9 (2)"+ " !+"! )( =!"+ D+")())()"A!"9; B9

(!"9/.9/  !+2"*"F)(2)"+)G++=!)!" G")=""G!"")(==!))!+2+ ! (2! > 2! D"+  !+)"  +*  !  !+9 (!"9 <. 9 0 ) !1D" ! (!72)"+ ) /. C2! /-5/ A B !+ *  !+2   )(== !*( !+2 )( )="  !"" G ) )D!+ )(2)"+  )( "  "!  +"+ =F+  " ) ("! )  !"  ) (" !  !""  !* ) !D ) (! "  ) ="  !)" ) ! * 2" "!P!  )="  !"" ) )D!+ )(2)"+  )( "9 &   "+ ) D )( !+ (+!  *   "



4/53040663  7-4/87   (""+,))+!!*?D" !+?+"""  !" )  )!" F !"" )1 *( " ("")! >  * (+!"""+")!"WD +!)92) N !*( " ?D" )+"!"  )!+ "!  )+C>  "!! ""G *( " !?">!)!A!"9<< 9 /  B9  )" )  !" !) =="   "O"  !! C! ) )F1*""="))+A!"9<<90"9 B9

C! !)2D!(!"9;/ !22!)1! * E!"9 /.   E   !"+ ) )=" F !  C! !)" )+2 +)!+D))!"2D!C*E3/)+G! 0660A J  G+)362!066;505463)9398B9& ""C! !)!"E" "G)EN"!!+2+*E)?D"  !"")!" ! !>=!)D!+)E2)"+))!"> !"""))="G)E+"")"+  !*  )!! "    N  *  +* !   "+)D"G?D" !""A J//30.8)9/"  !!N""+V2!+D" J//0 3.0 )90G"3-6)9/GB9  ")2!"?D"E" !)")"N"!"!?+ !" =" " *E  !+""  " )  "" " ) !" "  !"!+D">E+ *))+"DA J/0835-)90 "  !+=+!B9   ==" ""=  *E "" )!+ ?D+ !E"" !++)1!)==+!"A J//03.0)90G" 3-6)9/GB9

GB! 2!!)D!+)E2)"+E)"!"ACDE,  !!B  G ) )" *  +) +2""  )E"!  +")2"=!!9"S?)+)"> !"!CD" !E+"")"+">)*!)*!" !*"2"+E!+ " G)"!2!9 "!)++)"""++" " ! )+"!! * "!2F  " ! !G" FD! ) E!+A J/0805/)9;//8/3;)90//;3/;)93/68 /8<)9/B9

*! !!2! !G")E! !"+)*" )+"!"E"* ""DF"="EGC")E+")!"+ *  ! !"  =) ! ) F  " *E ! +D"  )+!" "F !+ ! !F+*E"+"++"G   ) E1 *  )! " ) "F" +) " E !+")""+)"!"=*) EF !" " )K" "2+9  )!" E++" )+"!" !  2! !G" E"  E!D ) , ) !2   )+D"  ! !"F !"G"G"A J/08380)9 3/00/56)9/"!+=+!B9



4/53040663  7/64/87   B  ( 1  !!"  +"+   G++= )E )7!" )(2)"+ )1/!!/--< )(!""1!)E2)"+)1/!2!/---! G)! !"+)F))"! ::::::::::A=9! !")<2!/--< 1 / =!! 3  B ) )"! :::::::::: A=9 ! !" ) 0-  /--< 10=!!3 B"))"!::::::::::A=9! !")3"G!/--- 18=!!3 B9

 !!" )  )" +)F * E"+!+ !+"" > E+ * "" ) )!GD ?!* !  G! )!"  +"" )+ !=?!*"! "!)==)!""!)(+ )!"9 +)")(G!)"""+)( "+)"!2)86HA=9 !F  ! !" ) )"! :::::::::: ) 0-  /--<B  ) /66 H  ! ) (DD!2" )  +"" ) "+  /---9 "" DD!2" +"" )   > (+"" )+ != ?!* ) (!+  F )! * "" )!1! + !2">(+ )!"A=9! !"))"!::::::::::)3"G!/--- 18=!!3 B9+)7)( ()(!!2+>C" ""! )  " "! ) 05 2G! /---9  !"  )(! !++ *(,2") !+2!!+2)!" !(+"+0666A 15=!! 3 B9

!  "  )"! ::::::::::  F *+ * (+"" ) "+ ) (!+ (+""+!+)1!*(F"""")"))!)(+  )!" A=9 ! !" ) 08 2! 066/ 1 . =!! 3  B9 &! *"  +"! ) (    !++ *  "" !+"" "C! ) )!7GD?!**(! !)("2"+ !=) "!2 !""")?D!=!+*") "")("!! "  " )G" 2 ) )+ " 2" N"! ""+9   D+ * ) ! != +"" ?"G )1 ! * ("2"+ ) !+"! (+""   "G 2  "" +2*+ A=9 ! !" ) 08 C 066/ 1 // =!! 3  B9 "  )"! J::::::::::   +D" !2+  +!" ) (+"" ) "+ ) (!+  !+" ""= )  ! !" *( 2" !G" F!!  +"! ) !+"! A=9 ! !")0.0660 1/0=!!3 B9

2)"!)"(">C"""!*( !)+F !"  +"!")"+)"!::::::::::"::::::::::)(?O " ) ?F7)7J)9 F !"""+*"" ")(G ) ")(F*")F +"!( "+) "!2 )  !!" +"" ) 86 H )  "!2 +D!  !" ) ?!D )+ " /8 Q " *  +"" ) "+ +""  "G 2  "!2 ) !+"!"A=9F !")/-C2!0663 1/8=!!3 B9

 " +D!) ("  2 * (!+ ""   ) F !" )1 !*!F !" 1) 2! !G"9 ==" !""



4/53040663  7//4/87   =)+!! !"!)F " !1(2!F+)F= 082G!"3)+G!0660" !))!!)D* A=9TF +"!U 9<"-B9"+"G1)+"+ A=9 T1U 9 0 > ;B )+!" ""  "F" +)  ""  ") "A=9T""U 98>.B" +))D"!) )! )( =" ! A=9 T)D"U 9 -B9  "!  ) ) ""! * !  " G "2+ )1 ! *( F *" !" !*(""!)"!2!>86H)"!2) !+"!"A=9 9/6>/0B9!!"!!">*(==!(!+ " "  " ) ,)! )+ != !+" *  )!! =" !" ) )D" ""  !+" + *( (F""  ) "?D ,?"!*+21!A=9 9//B9 "" !+"!C"*+) 2")+C>="!)(+2") "+!+))"!2/--<" /--- ! * (!+ ==!" )+C> )(+"" )+ != ?!* A=9 ! !" !+"+B9

  (,    ) (+!"! )  ) F !" " "" > =" !"(, )(+!"!)("" *C! !)  !)  ) ) F """ =" !   +" *(> ( !+")( "+)"!2 !+))=A J/08383 )9 3G4 "  !+=+!V  /--8 9 ;;V   /-<< 9 86; )9 0 J   G+ ) 0/ K" 0660     5-<46/4#? )9 ;B9   !")1!=!D!=>( )E2!!"*E!++""!) "!2! > 86 H )   "2"+ ) !+"! =!+" > ( !+")F !"9

 E!!  )" )E !+2 " ) !+ "  2" > !+"))+"!!"F)(2)"+)!!"9

59 B *!))D!+)(2)"+)!!"E=="+ E" ""+ ) =F!  )!! > 86 H  ! !"  "  "F )E "+=" !+"+ !E!+ ) !=*EF!R" C*(!9!)+"!")"F)E2)"+!"! !!  +2"+)7"?+!*) "+)"!2)E!+!!2"> )+)! ) 1! G"!"  )D!+ )E2)"+ ) E "+ ) "!2  "!  " ) E) +* ) E""" >  "+  * E"  )GA J//;0<3)9/3/;)93V # /--5X03. 935 )9 3GV /--/ X  /36 9 0.0 )9 3GB9 E== "+ !" ) )K !+)!+"?)D++!) !)!29

GB (!"90<9/  !+2"*E!+)!">!"E"2)>;6 !"9!"")(*!"(!+ !+"2)"+);6 !")() !2)"+)86 !"" "1! !2)"+)550439!+2!"F)(2)"+



4/53040663  7/04/87   !2*(!+!" G"!((+"" 2)" !+2 *( !!"G"!F!R"("2"+* "!G"N"!FD+)   !1  "!"" "  ! ) !+) "" !  !?+ ) "!2 +*G!+A!"9/5 B9 ?W!+"=)D!+)(2)"+)"N"! )+"!+!G)( !)!29 7(=="!1D !)!  ?==!"  F"" * G  "" )  )F !2"=!""(2("!)==+! !""")! "F)(2)"+A+"?)D++!) !)!2V J/0<36 )9//6;/35)90"0GB9

B&")+"!"!) !)!2! !"F"" ")E2!"!))!">+2"!"*)=" D="2))+?, "?+"*)+"!"!2C*E" )  )+ * " ) +* !  )!" >  !" A J /0<  /.;V J  G+)/<"G!0660.5/46/ J  G+) 00 K" 0660     ;;646/B9  !2  2)"+  )+"!  D++! )( !1  )!! ! * (!+  G" 2" (""" >  "+ A /--/ D330B9

( 1*!!22)"+!!"!+" !)58E586=!9 !1)(@::::::::::/--<)")(2!"! ) )!" >  !" A=9 *"! ! ( ,! ) 08  /--< 1 3 =!! 8  B9  ! (")" !  ?!! >  "  ) ("! ! !! )"  !+"+ >  ?!! ) 38 ?! ! 9  2")"! ")="!")!!=="=""  " )( ?!! ) ;6 ?!9  !  2)"+ )"  N"! =F+ > .8E60<=!9

)B!?==!!!2)(2) "!+=+!!C! !)> *( )"GF)!9 "" G"+"!" !"! !* (!+ ( ! !  !1  !2 ) (""" >  "+  "2"+!"2)"""2"+!"2 2"N"!!G" ""))A J/0;300V&0666 9<8B9 *!"GF )!"""*)(J &*)"D"!2) *="))("2"+"F"""!)(=!" =G9   !+=+!! ! >  """* ) ! G!" ")!)+   =)""C!!+)2!"!A J/0;303&/--- 9 /<0B9

 ( 1 ( " !"! *  !!" 2" =="! ) "!2F ) !+"!"  * ( !2+ (F !" ) )"!    I " ::::::::::9  !  * 2" !+")!  = =="")"2"+))") != ++ )  ) ) !2  /--< )  "! !2+ " G +"" )



4/53040663  7/34/87   8(6.8 =!9 !   " " )( ?!! ) "!2 ) ;6 ?! !  A && /--< 9 33 . T!+"!" "!2F ) ?!U 2 ) *=" 3B9  !2 )" N"! !"+ > 8(3/5 =!9 A8(6.8=!9Y ;6 F ;/-B " 53(.-0=!9 !)1!*,)"!2)"! ! /--<+"");/-?!A *//4066; 9<5"G-90B9

  "+ ) "!2 )  !!" +"" !+)" ) 86 H  !2  > !)!)+!"E+12>3/(<-5=!9

B ! ! !  G!1  )" "!  " ) =" *  ! """ ) ! "+ " ?) + N ! ( " ) "S? F! +D1! " )+2"D+   * ! ! !++!" ! ! !"F!+""" !)"=" 2"N"! ,+ !N "!29   "F ) ! ! D++!" =+!! >  ,9 & (F +! "))"!+)!)/6>08H!)*+) "GA&/--< 9/.- 90-5B9 !)*!!!"" ) """* )2" N"! !+)" )+ ) ) EG ) !" ! " != )  !"! A"" +  ?)  SD + ) !2 ""+ A"+D! )E"!" ) +C! " "F )E "B"!+")E+2")") 2!)E !+"9 )+)"DGF)08H!!"""* !")"!  " ) )==+!" ++" * 2" =!  !2 )E "2"+ !"2A J/05.-9)98G47V&0660 9.69)9;GB9

 E 1  !!" " +  /8 2! /-;<9  "   G++= )E) O)(+") ! & G""!/-537/-5.")( F +! != ) 06  *  & ) /-.< " /--< A=9 ))  1/=!!0 B9  !+"""+F + ) !2  >  ""+   "" + > (SD A88   0663B9  *  !" ) ?!D " !?G+ ) N *  "" "!  !D+  " )G"    " "" ) N  ! )E !+"!)!+"!>86H9 C"=G""")/6H A !F9 J  G+)00)+G!0663<6.460B9

!2)(2))!!"(+12>0.E///=!9

=B  "F )(2)"+ !!"" )   ! )  !2 2  !2  2)"+ "  ) )*:); A.8E60< =!9Z 0.E/// =!9 F /66Y .8E60< =!9B9 =!+">)+)( )/<!0663"F !")!+)!  !""1! >)7!")(2)"+)1/!0663  "") (D"" )   "+ !+) ) "!2 ) (!+ " ) ) " +D"+A=9!"9<<90"9 B9)))""!* N"F)(2)"+)!!"" +!!>86H "N"!



4/53040663  7/;4/87     G++= * )( )7!" )(2)"+  *  !+2"  +D" G9



!!"G*("! ))!) !+""D !G ) + !+ *  "F )(2)"+ ) )!" >  [ ) !" )1  /! C2!066;=!+">2"!)(!"90< 2D!)  "")"A=+)+!)0/!0663;1!+2)(!72)"+B9  !")! )1 ! > (  ) !)!  2 )+ ""  " ) )="*!066;9

!""=!!!!C"+")+! ")(  )/!C"0663=!+9



4/53040663  7/84/87  

  &# J&        & &&  &&   &Y %

<13   =  >   7& ()+ "?@

  3 

/9 +!!!)0 "G!0663!2GV

% 3

09 !C""V

39 =!)+! ")( )/!C"0663V

;9 JF"F)(2)"+)!!">53<5H)1/!0663>?!D !( )!)!2)+)1/!C2!066;) ))+!"V

89 =!  !" )  *( 2" =!! !! "!  !+" !!N" )  )+ ) 36 C! )1  "=" !  !)+ )!+  !G =+)+! ) ! &?$W!?=* 5 566;     "! F !9  )+  " N"! !D+9  +! )"Y B )*! F""*)+!!")+!G"!" ))+ ""*+V GB F ! ! * "=  " 2! ))! "" "! )+V B !"!  D"!   )  ! !+""9 &  +!  ""   "! ++" ++!+  ""! B GB " B 7)  !G=+)+!)! !! "!!"1!!!!*( )2!)+!!!!2G9+!)!!"!!, ) !2 * !" C"  *  )+ ""*+ " (2  ) *+"+F +)+!!"A!"9/30/65"/6<B9 D!==1!Y  !+)"Y     JJ '!& '   !+"!7C!"Y J!#     

 =!) !+"!!N"""=+F !"*(>(===+)+! )! !D!==



4/53040663