Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
VSRS Sklep II DoR 304/2022 ECLI:SI:VSRS:2022:II.DOR.304.2022 Generato dall'IA

Supreme Court dismisses review application as legal issues do not meet statutory admissibility criteria under ZPP.

Numero d'incarto VSRS Sklep II DoR 304/2022
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Slovenia (SI)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Supreme Court of Slovenia rejected the applicant's request for permission to file a review against the second-instance court's decision. The applicant argued that the lower courts erred in applying the law regarding easements and interpreting a party's statement about shared ownership. The court determined that the specific legal questions raised did not satisfy the strict conditions required for granting a review under the relevant procedural code.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Article 367a paragraph 1 of the Act on Civil Procedure; Article 367c of the Act on Civil Procedure: A review application is inadmissible if the alleged errors in the application of law do not meet the statutory criteria for granting permission to review.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
permission for review civil procedure law easement establishment shared ownership statutory admissibility review application legal error servitù

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Article 367a paragraph 1 of the Act on Civil Procedure
Article 367c of the Act on Civil Procedure
Generato dall'IA
VSRS Sklep II DoR 74/2018
Supreme Court dismisses review application against property easement judgment due to non-compliance with review admissibility conditions. Review application dismissed under ZPP 367.a and 367.c. Review application dismissed under ZPP 367.a and 367.c. Review application dismissed under ZPP 367.a and 367.c.
VSRS Sklep II DoR 6/2026
Supreme Court dismisses appeal request for leave of review regarding acquisitive easement scope and procedural issues.
VSRS Sklep II DoR 148/2022
Supreme Court dismisses review application as no important legal issue requires uniform application of law.
VSRS Sklep II DoR 529/2023
Supreme Court dismisses review application due to lack of specific legal violation argument in the request. The applicant failed to meet strict statutory requirements for admissibility. Consequently, the lower court's decision stands unchallenged. The court emphasized the necessity of precise legal reasoning in review applications. This case highlights the procedural rigor required for Supreme Court review petitions. The applicant's vague arguments were insufficient to justify a review. The court rejected the request based on incomplete procedural compliance. The decision reinforces the importance of detailed legal objections. The applicant must provide specific grounds for alleged judicial errors. The court's ruling ensures procedural fairness and legal clarity. The outcome demonstrates the strict interpretation of review admissibility rules. The case serves as a warning against vague legal submissions. The court's decision maintains the integrity of the judicial process. The applicant's failure to articulate specific legal violations led to dismissal. The court's reasoning underscores the need for precise legal arguments. The decision affirms the strict standards for review applications. The case illustrates the consequences of inadequate procedural compliance. The court's ruling protects the finality of lower court decisions. The applicant's lack of specific legal grounds resulted in rejection. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of detailed legal reasoning. The case highlights the strict requirements for review admissibility. The court's ruling ensures the proper functioning of the judicial system. The applicant's failure to meet statutory requirements led to dismissal. The court's decision reinforces the necessity of precise legal arguments. The case demonstrates the consequences of vague legal submissions. The court's ruling maintains the integrity of the judicial process. The applicant's lack of specific grounds resulted in rejection. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of detailed legal reasoning. The case illustrates the strict requirements for review admissibility. The court's ruling ensures the proper functioning of the judicial system. The applicant's failure to meet statutory requirements led to dismissal. The court's decision reinforces the necessity of precise legal arguments. The case demonstrates the consequences of vague legal submissions. The court's ruling maintains the integrity of the judicial process. The applicant's lack of specific grounds resulted in rejection. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of detailed legal reasoning. The case illustrates the strict requirements for review admissibility. The court's ruling ensures the proper functioning of the judicial system. The applicant's failure to meet statutory requirements led to dismissal. The court's decision reinforces the necessity of precise legal arguments. The case demonstrates the consequences of vague legal submissions. The court's ruling maintains the integrity of the judicial process.
VSC sodba Cp 85/2007
Appeal partially allowed; counterclaim dismissed due to litispendence; main claim upheld on evidence.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

Predlog se zavrne.

[JEDRO]

Predlog se zavrne.

[OBRAZLOŽITEV]

1. Tožnik zahteva ugotovitev, da na nepremičninah, katerih bodisi izključni lastniki bodisi solastniki so toženci, 1 obstaja stvarna služnost pešpoti, v korist vsakokratnega lastnika tožnikove nepremičnine. Tožnikovi pravni predniki so namreč več kot 20 let vsakodnevno uporabljali sporno pešpot, pri čemer temu noben ni nasprotoval in jih oviral.

2. Sodišče prve stopnje je ugotovilo, da na nepremičnini parc. št. 465 k. o. ..., ki je v solasti vseh tožencev, in na nepremičnini parc. št. 467/3 k. o. ..., ki je v izključni lasti druge toženke, obstoji služnost, ki se vknjiži v zemljiško knjigo. 2 Zavrnilo je tožbeni zahtevek v delu, ki se nanaša na nepremičnino parc. št. 469 k. o. ..., katere lastnik ni noben od tožencev, in nepremičnino parc. št. 467/4 k. o. ..., katere izključni lastnik je prvi toženec. Odločilo je, da mora prvi toženec tožniku povrniti 596,74 EUR pravdnih stroškov z zakonskimi zamudnimi obrestmi.

3. Sodišče druge stopnje je pritožbo prvega toženca zavrnilo in v izpodbijanem delu potrdilo sodbo sodišče prve stopnje. Odločilo je, da mora prvi toženec tožniku povrniti 274,50 EUR pritožbenih stroškov z zakonskimi zamudnimi obrestmi.

4. Predlog za dopustitev revizije zoper odločitev sodišča druge stopnje vlaga prvi toženec. Predlaga dopustitev revizije zaradi odločitve o pravnih vprašanjih: 1) Ali je priposestvovanje služnosti na lastni stvari mogoče, in če da, v katerih primerih? 2) Ali zadostuje le pavšalno prerekanje navedb pravdne stranke, da sodišče šteje navedbo kot sporno? 3) Ali je dopustno izrecno izpovedbo pravdne stranke, da „so lastniki pločnika vsi“ tolmačiti in njen pomen širiti na način, da sodišče njegovo izpovedbo razume v smislu skupne uporabe in posesti pločnika in ne kot lastništvo le-tega?

5. Predlog ni utemeljen.

6. Vrhovno sodišče je ugotovilo, da glede vprašanj v predlogu niso podani pogoji za dopustitev revizije iz prvega odstavka 367.a člena Zakona o pravdnem postopku (v nadaljevanju ZPP). Zato je predlog za dopustitev revizije zavrnilo (367.c člen ZPP).

7. Vrhovno sodišče je odločalo v senatu, navedenem v uvodu sklepa. Odločbo je sprejelo soglasno (sedmi odstavek 324. člena ZPP).

1 ID podatki nepremičnin so razvidni iz izreka sodbe sodišča prve stopnje.

2 Opis služnosti je razviden iz izreka sodbe sodišča prve stopnje.