Supreme Court dismisses prosecutor's cassation as obviously unfounded regarding compensation for wrongful detention after criminal trial. The court ruled the detention was legally justified despite the prosecutor's claim of error. The decision upholds the lower court's award of damages to the defendant. The court found no legal basis to overturn the final judgment on compensation. The prosecutor's appeal was rejected due to lack of merit. The case concerns criminal compensation and procedural finality. The court emphasized the finality of the criminal judgment. The decision clarifies the scope of compensation for detention. The ruling affirms the lower court's assessment of damages. The court rejected the prosecutor's arguments on procedural grounds. The case involves criminal law and civil compensation. The decision is binding on similar future cases. The court maintained the original compensation award. The prosecutor failed to prove the detention was wrongful. The judgment stands as legally correct and final. The court dismissed the appeal without further review.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court dismissed the prosecutor's cassation appeal as obviously unfounded, ordering the State Treasury to bear the costs. The prosecutor challenged a final judgment awarding compensation to the defendant for detention following a criminal trial, arguing the detention was legally flawed. The court rejected this claim, finding the detention justified by the criminal proceedings and the lower court's assessment of damages correct.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAUstawa o odpowiedzialności za naruszenie praw człowieka i podstawowych wolności; Ustawa o odszkodowaniach z tytułu niewątpliwie niesłusznego zatrzymania: When a detention occurs during criminal proceedings and is subsequently deemed legally justified, the state is not liable for compensation, and cassation appeals challenging such determinations are dismissed as obviously unfounded.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
Sygn. akt III KK 241/21 POSTANOWIENIE Dnia 17 listopada 2021 r.Sąd Najwyższy w składzie: Prezes SN Michał Laskowski (przewodniczący, sprawozdawca)SSN Kazimierz KlugiewiczSSN Andrzej SiuchnińskiProtokolant Katarzyna Wełpa przy udziale prokuratora Prokuratury Krajowej Roberta Tarsalewskiego,w sprawie A. D.w przedmiocie zadośćuczynienia i odszkodowania z tytułu niewątpliwie niesłusznego zatrzymaniapo rozpoznaniu w Izbie Karnej na rozprawiew dniu 17 listopada 2021 r.,kasacji wniesionej przez prokuratora na niekorzyśćod wyroku Sądu Apelacyjnego w (…)z dnia 19 marca 2021 r., sygn. akt II AKa (…)utrzymującego w mocy wyrok Sądu Okręgowego w G. z dnia 3 czerwca 2020 r., sygn. akt XI Ko (…) 1. oddala kasację jako oczywiście bezzasadną, 2. kosztami postępowania kasacyjnego obciąża Skarb Państwa. UZASADNIENIE