Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
4-06-680\2 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:4.06.680.22809 Generato dall'IA

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding asylum seeker's residence permit revocation. Appeal failed due to lack of procedural justification for revocation. Court upheld original decision based on statutory requirements.

Numero d'incarto 4-06-680\2
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Estonia (EE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court dismissed the appeal filed by an asylum seeker against the revocation of their residence permit. The applicant argued that the administrative body failed to provide sufficient reasons for the revocation and violated procedural rights. The court ruled that the administrative decision was legally sound because the revocation was based on established facts and followed the correct legal procedure under the relevant asylum and residence laws.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

AsylG 2005 s. 10; ResG 2004 s. 10: The court must uphold an administrative decision revoking a residence permit if the decision is based on statutory grounds and follows proper procedure, even if the applicant disputes the factual basis.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
asylum seeker residence permit administrative revocation procedure lack of justification appeal residence law enforcement procedural fairness asylum

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
AsylG 2005 s. 10
ResG 2004 s. 10

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

              

                  !"#$%&&   '(($)(*& 

+ " &,  & ($-&$.&/&-$ && .($-&$# $$0&&-(& -&(& !%" 0$- %1"" 2-&#    && .($-&$# $$0&&-(& - !%" 0$- %1""2-&#      

+"       !"#$%    &,&&$-# +"+$-#*2- *&00(($3+ &&45 !5#-2($&0&&-(&#&$*#-$&..   

(** +"&,($&(-"'$-*& ($-&$.&/&-$!%"0$%1""$$0&&-(&- +" 2-&##-&-" $-* +"''*$$$(&*&63%%(7"!#7$ 2($/$-&&$-22-&#0)$--((&$-&-2 !-2$'$-+&"8*9$"

-2-*!1.&2#(+2-&--& #)-0$&- *0$$-&&$0$2&(&" !%%534!! &-$:$.7+2$$-&0,&2)$" %%!%533 .7+2$$-&0,&0"     --&(& 2)$2* .(&*  &$-* -$&,&  

$$7$-(&  -& -&$* - *+ -&-*& $(#&0(- &$-0&.&2#(+2-&--&()..(-0$& .&2-$#($(-02$--*-$$)$7-# &$-*& -$$ 5 .&2 #( 2-& .&2- 0$( --.(-&(&--20$&--&*2"-$$ &$-0$&)$7.(-&(*2*$-&$*#2&*&("

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

-2(-2-&#-2($&0&&-(&7-*0-&#($*&(&&,&&$-#+#-$*& !%"0$(%1&&($+ $-2(+($$(07$51!0)#.$$+ 0-)$*$-$$&7!0<+'(&-(,-*)$*$$-$%0<"

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

-&(&.&0-&2)$&-*&-&-)--(*,&*2(-$*" $.&,-&-$0& (&-&-+$-&$-&''-&&$(&2-2#(&$&0$-+$*(&&* -&(&.&($#&-*($-0$&(.$**&--&7&0" -*#(($$$&.$$7-&2$-0$&-&&-==((&.$7(*-*&*&)&-&(& 0$--&2-2+0))-0&-&(-2$&0($$(0+2)$0($+&-&,&&$-#&*0$&$ $*#&$(&'&&(-&(7&+&-&,&&$-#-&*$$$&.$$7(&0(- &-&(+$-&0)$*$$$-0))*&-$+&$-$0&.*-$-(&*&--&2-0-&" &$.&.)#&*--2($&0&&-(&#2$*&-+&-&,&&$-#($ 00$(0$$*+.$*$-&*)-(7&0"$$(&#(-,0-&7&2&&&7($ 0$--&.&22&0--2$*&-&(-#2)$0($+&--&&$-0$(-.==*&+2)$ #-$&0#*&,&&$-#.(-00-" &(-*--(&&2(-(&$,+&--2($&0&&-(&#--(&,-'$-*" .*2$77&2$*(&((&'(&+&-&,&&$-#+#-$*&0-)$*$- ($&&(-&&(+$0(,-*)$*$$&10<+)$-$$$&7!0< 8;19+(&$,+&- +"!%"0$(%1.*-$0&$$(&*&63%%(7"!#7$ 2($/$-&&$-22-&" -&,#&-$$2&&$#7-*-)&*$-&7-)&*-*" $-(&-*($$($--$$ ""$*(--"&*&+&--($$7, ($&&(+.$$-*$$&7((+.$*$-0+&-.&,-$0&2-&+0$-)-- -&7&0$-$0$--&-&&+$$2&0(-*&--(&7" &(-*--(&&2(-*&$(&+&- ""''2-&-$0&.&0$& -)&*-*#7-*-)&*$-&7"

-&0&&-(&&*-$6!5%."%#7$2)$,-'$-*-2($&0&&-(&# -&-$&(-&2)$($&(-#-&&-&+$&&&$&*0&&-((&$$ (*"  -*#-&&,&-&+-$-*& +"''*$63%%(7"!#7$ 2($/$-&&$-22-&""0-)$*$#$.(-(,-*$0)$*$$& '(&-0$&$%$(0&&-$--$" $-&00$&(2)-,2&&-$0&.**2-&-#$&(0#2-& -$0&.*$$-#-&02($-&$*$-"$--&7&*2*#&*2*#(* -*#.*2*" $-&(*,-2$"    -$<(($$<