Court convicted defendant of theft, reduced sentence by one-third, and ordered partial civil compensation for victim.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court convicted the defendant S.W. of theft under Article 121 of the Criminal Code and imposed a suspended sentence of six months, later reduced to four months. The prosecution argued for a heavier penalty, while the defense requested a lighter sentence based on mitigating circumstances. The court accepted the reduction but upheld the conviction and ordered the defendant to pay the victim 300 euros for non-material damage and state costs.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAKriminaalmenetluse seadustiku (KrMS) § 121 lg 2 p 3; § 233 lg 3, § 238 lg 2: The court may reduce the imposed sentence by one-third upon application by the defendant if mitigating circumstances are present, while still maintaining the finding of guilt.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
Kohus
Otsuse tegemise aeg ja koht
!!"#
Kriminaalasja number
$!"$%&'%
Kohtunik
(()*+()
Kohtuistungi sekretär
(,)()
Tõlgid
,(()(-./(/(0
Kriminaalasi
/)(11(2!/,!-&.3,(
/1()/
Prokurör
4)(),))-( (-5(()
+(+)
Süüdistatav
S.W
((6&7&8&9":/6 ;;;: (6;;;:
/6;;;:;;;
(()/0/(# 0((( (
"!',2!/,!-&.2
!/,!-".3,(:28%/,!///(((%
97-300),(()'!!"
4)(-//
Kaitsja
0)0,((<33(.=
RESOLUTSIOON
Kriminaalmenetluse seadustiku (KrMS) § 233 lg 3, § 238 lg 1 p 4, § 306, § 311, § 312 ja §
313 alusel kohus otsustas:
1. Tunnistada süüdi S.W KarS § 121 lg 2 p 3 järgi ja mõista karistuseks 6
kuud vangistust.
2. KrMS § 238 lg 2 alusel vähendada S.W-le mõistetavat karistust 1/3
võrra ja mõista S.W lõplikuks karistuseks 4 kuud vangistust.
3. Kohustada S.W ilmuma vanglasse karistust kandma kohtust
saadetavas teatises märgitud ajal. Lugeda vangistuse kandmise alguseks S.W
vanglasse saabumise aeg.
4. Rahuldada osaliselt kannatanu A. L. (isikukood: XXX) tsiviilhagi ja mõista S.W-lt
Andrus Liivandi kasuks välja 300 eurot mittevaralise kahju katteks.
5. KrMS § 180 lg 1, § 175 lg 1 p-de 4 ja 9 ning § 179 lg 1 p 2 alusel mõista S.W-lt
Eesti Vabariigi kasuks välja menetluskuludena määratud kaitsja tasu 680,76
eurot ja sundraha 1230 eurot, s.o menetluskulud kokku 1910,76 eurot.
6. KrMS § 180 lg 3 neljanda lause alusel tuleb S.W-l tasuda menetluskulud
1910,76 eurot ositi 12 kuu jooksul selliselt, et alates kohtuotsuse jõustumisele järgnevast
kuust tuleb iga kuu viimaseks päevaks tasuda 159,23 eurot.
)/// $.//((0/0/&%%!&"
>)#%!!!!!&!8"""9? )#"99!79!&())04(
'%9999%!&%7% >))(), ,(/ 3(0(()
99924700035381
( /()4-/3(/3,/# ))4
3()//3 (0(((3((/3()/(3
7. ))))()2&7/,%-!///#0(
/)())3,0 (.())(-((-4,)(
Edasikaebamise kord
>( (-//()( /1()/11(4(0
-/(/)/-//)4(,(-/-//()-//()
/ ((),))/(./(/&-30.//0/(/
0,(())(-((0(( (0)//()04( (-//()(
&-30.//3((())(-((0(( (0/((/
@/# ( 4/,((./(/# 04( 11(0 04( (.(
-//()(&-30.//4/,()(3(
-//()(4(, / (.04( -//()(4(,/ 1)
(/(./(/)4//
(()/)//10((04( 0(/-//()(04(
33 /)()/33 / (/%
-30.//-30#(/(((0(/0/)(04(-((
KOHTUOTSUSE PÕHIOSA
Süüdistus ja tsiviilhagi
1./)(11(2!/,!-&.3,(//##//(
("!',)$'$''92!/,!-&.3,(.//
())(-0%80),/#/4(9&!!"//"6&-(
),/11(4()$!/))/(())(-0-
3,10/-/-3,0,(0/.
0(.6 )30-/)(), (//.(/1 -()(
0(,,-)((2!/,!-&.3,(0/(A((0(#
(()(0(.(.0/(0/(033/(0/
2. )))((()/.(0((/,(#(//)4 (/(0/(
.10(()&(0(..A11(/(0/#(/(
())((0).(03/"$%-30()(0/.0(.,0(
/.()##)5(. ())
Kohtumenetluse poolte seisukohad
3.>5.3(0(/11(.)(),/(11())((.
((2!/,!-&.3,(8$/(0),(,#(03)2!&7/,
! // B& 044-/((4(" 0),(( 4(
11(0/03/.)//
4.)))( 0()(),(/ //)/,(
-)(( )()( (33# ).8/(
0),(,
5. 11(0())((),(/#( 11(.(0((/,(#
))()11(#)4(()/./)(,/1()/,/))
1//(/((#(0((/,()4)/((,(/03(#
)4//,((4)/(11(0#)A/((/
---./)4((0#(11(#.
-1,(/3)4# (0((),)(( 33,( # .reageeris
enesekaitseks-/8./0),/,(/)
6.(.55)(#( 11)4)#(/((#(,)0
./)/ 0#()(/,-/4(1/(
(3(()0),(./<((-/()(=(((4.
(/(!$/(0),(,#(03)B&04((.)
/4-/((.-300),()))(0((/,( /
(///.04(/(/)//((
./
Kohtu seisukoht
7.2!&&/,/04( /)(()/.11(0.-(
// ))(.(# .).(.-03/./1()/
(()/((./(-4./(/)/-(/
//1()//(</ 7"=# -((()/.
/1()/)(), .11(0# (..-5( 04/
/1()/3.3,(0) /1()//(/)(/
3(#(()/((./)(()/./)(-((0./
//(11(11())((0((/,(/ //(/
Süüdistus KarS § 121 lg 2 p 3 järgi
8. >,.(0(/-/114),(0/(A(()(1/)(),
())),/)11((./A(/(./(()/(((/0
4)(,4).(,0/ 0/(A((2!/,!-&.3,(
(//) )))1/# 55 0),/.) (55/().
9&!!"(/(./3(,/#-(!/))-4)- /
"6!%-(/(./(.(() (#/--(./)4(
0())((#-)./)/(/(/((0.1/55())C.
(((()D./(((55(55,(3#/((,
)#.0(())/(.(.)(),(((/(
03,/3/)(),1(4,).1//033/)(,0)/6
C(//)((1/(ED0/(/6C(///(),(-)()
()D./ ./#(/4-)(4)#/4( /-
(,100/4/55,(./)(,00/
,()(),#(55,(/,)3,.(-/#1(
(/6C((ED//-/4)(3.)
/A)((0),/(($. ))/#(.3/((0(,A(((
((()()/(30./0),)(,33(()(
//(F/)./(,0-0/./4/0/)(),.3,(/
-30//(/4/# #-.,0)3-/.0/)(.3,(/
(/(0/0(,((</%$8=
9.3,( # )))/A(1/,/),0),/
0/00(/0(#))(.1/#0(()()//(4()#A
0(,.03/.04(,.(((/) 0(/0(/#03/.
9&!!"//"6!7 (# (( ( 40/ ()
..) (/./#(() (#55 (
#4))( 55((/))55,()4)-303/.
(.4))( (55,(-/3 (#4))( //0)(),
..3301((#0/0/@3/55 -
(,0/-/)3#(-/-( (/.4))(
030/-4/((,/-55 1 .
4))( /,()(),( )(/30-4(55,(-(),(/.
.33 4).)((())((55(/0!(())(-0#04 3
-4/3#0/ (())(-0,#4 4).-3-1(.4))( (
55,(3,1)03//(0.55,(/,#00.
(0/(0/./))-/)(),-550//)3
)#(0(()-( (/))(.1//, (
)/1/,#((9&!!"((()()0(,(
A((#/().)/(,#(0().)33(./(4)
())(#/55(#.../)(1/#/)0
/4-/0/)3,(#0(//()-)0.)0()
0(,(-/). (-/)0.#((0()-1/,( (</7=
0(()()//(4()</!= 1/,.A/)3 #0/
/4-//./(</'=4/1//,)(,.
A((#9&!!"0(,A(((/)(((/(.3,(/
-30/ <7&!!"=)30/ -// 03)#0))/(
1-(/().-/-()(/ 0//(&!!" (,)(( muud silmalau ja
silmaümbruse pindmised vigastused </&$&!=
10. ,5/#))( 11(0/55(/)/
/,(#/39&!!"-3.//)(((#/)0/
()((--./)4/ (40/0(/,/
./55#1/#(().(()(),(/ /((0
./)4,. (( 0#)()/-0(#)(
(.-)(./)43-/)4(,(/3.4)
,((//((,#
(
et mis mõttes ta kommenteerib,
pole midagi otseselt
teinud./355(.#..1(6C(//)(((
1/(ED#(-/-55(-/.06CG/().(((D)
(//(#(//(0(./(-(),#
(
.
lülitus
sisse enesekaitse
automaatselt lõi enesekaitse huvides(,10(/-(()
0-/#((#(()3())(,5/)(,(
-551 ./33(#-))())(#.0/((
/,(/)A/(()(),.((4/(
/04(1))#(//()(),1/4,))(/6
CG/().(((D ,</&'=
11. ))(..1/(/((.0/()A/((3(,
(),(4)0((/) ))(.1/#(55,(/
,.40/((
((/(()3()
see, kellele lõuga anti, oli vist L.
/55,(#(/(#1/
1(6C(( D#
aia või midagi sellist
(-/00(()#/4(//./3. /(
33()(,,#(0(()/4(#(()3()(),(0(,(
</!=))(.4)/(/.,55,(-/,)3()/55,(#((
#
.(0/.33/,33()(),
midagi seal oli.
midagi seal
toimus nende vahel. ( 3-/5/#((#( -55)///
3/-)(0((- /()(),(-))3/#(,(///1/
1(6C(.D#(-/0#(#(.(..(
.</%=
12. 03/.#4(1//3(/4)(<(1/=/),0
#/4(9&!!"4)03(,1-(,
0/-/)3(,(0/#/)A/((./4(
enesekaitse huvides, ) )03(/ /033(//,
0(/0(/.1/1(#/4(3(/(/#///
//))(1)0/0((03(H.1)
((1(0.33((0//(/-/)(/03((
/4(/(0#- )(//,((/)0/)0/-11
)(33(())),/0(003)B11-()
(- )A/((/,#((//)(0()0//()@/#(
(1/004/.-(-3.//)( ()((
./)4-# -/)/ (),(4(/(-4.()).3/ ./(/
0(/-(((#0(//(04(/(//(//(/
/)((/, (,0./(-(/03/.-/
(1/(#--3.//)(3.-((
./(//((0./)0/)0/1( )/)(,
-./)433(1)003)B11-()
.3 )( /03303(,(/40/
13. ,()/-/ )/11(/033/4)(,(/</55(
(1//=#0 (#/4( 9&!!"//"6&-(
),/11(4()$!/))/(4)03(,1
-(,0/-/)3)(),(//,//A11(/(0/#)3
0-/)(),(//.(/1 -()(0(,
14. )(/(./,0/(4(,/(())),#3,(
#2!/,3 ()(()(0(.(#(0/
(0/(033/(55()3/),(/(033/(,)(),
)(( ( (//.(/1 -()(0(,.0)
0(.(()()4)//55,(./,00//)0/)0/
)3(2!/,4/(/)((0(.(3(()0
2!/, .((0/))/
15.0)3(2!/, .((0))>((/#
/4(4)03(,/(,)3#(.3/-(
(/#/(/55-((0/,0#-(03/(-(/(-4./03/
04(/(.55)(#( /(,0,0/(/)04(0A11(/(0/
)(), 0(,( <.-()(0(,=,,
/,28/,"4
16. ( (,((03/.04.(()/.)$'$''9
/)(9&!!"(,0),(/,2!/,!-&
.3,(0/(A((0(</8.9%$99=/)0/3/ 0(
-)/()033/()0/(A((2!/,!-&.3,(
17.>,.-04(,003/(0./(,(0/#
/4(
/,//03( /033,-/
enesekaitse huvides,
/0334)(,(-4.//4(,003/(0(./(-4./(/
)/11()3/0/./-/1103/(0(./(#/ 2
!/,!-&.3,(11())(
Karistus
18.2!/,!)3 /((04()(%$0),(#(
/-/04(/((//((4()-,.-/
,(((4(,((,#0()(/(033/(
.//(((4(0),(0/(033/(.550((</
9%$98=#).3.03,(0//(0),(4(()03/(2!
/,$!30),(()33)
!.8
ca
19.)/11(( 11 # 03/.# /4(
4)03(,1(,)3#(//,(/(A11(/(/0//
()(/(0(,(<.-()(0(,=>((//)0#-/
(,(,(#11)03(.)04(/((//(///
)()((33.3300),(,
20. (,)0(,)0(./(-/(,( 0/
/)//0)1//(/# ,#)4
-5(,#-/((,3,(#-11(1/.33)
1/)((-./)4()(33(003)B11
-())(),))(,110(#()4)(,<3
0(/0(,=)((,(1 /1/4)/(/(
,/(/(,,)))003,(0//(#0(-(), -,
)/1)04(/(// ()(/
21./0 (-0)((0//)#( ) 00/
(()/(3-/) ( (/.(,((
03/.04.3,((()/('<(0(((!=.0(( (
/(033/(./0),/%/,)((!
2!.3,(#&2!.3,(#%2!9".3,(#()((27#2
!(2!".3,(((()(.0(/"!'$'!!"/(((
0/(033/(.550((</%8#8$8.89$9=(0/
03,(0//(,/0 /((3(()0),/(- /))(),
(//((0((0),(./((-/()"#
0/0/ 0((/(..3(((-3,((0/
3((/)(/-,(/3 ((</%8$%7=04/(/-/)
()0((-)(.(,.3/(011(4(0
#00),(,((-/()(#0(.3,((0
.03,(0/3((/)0/)0/-/04(/(((()(33
/3/.330!$/(0),(,
22.31//,(#4( (/(80),(#
(/ 2!&7/,!//03)B&<!=044-/((
.) ,"0),(),()(/,/ /,,#(/
0),/()
Tsiviilhagi
23.)4 (0((/,((,((0/(.10(()&
(0(..A11(/(0/#(/(()((0).(03/"$
%-30()(0/.0(.,0(/.()##
)5(. ())())),/)4)/))4-4.)/(/
24.F2"&/- (/((/4(,0/.()((.
10(#().((11(04(0 .((00/
//)0/F2"%/,-$!).(()4(,0)/4(,((#
((()))/0(,04(0(.((,F2%/,
.3,(11/(),F2!7/,%/4/ (0/()./4(,
.((A11(/(.(),/(0/)(),))(
25.0#/4(1(,)3#(0((/
A11(/(0/)(),0(,).-()(0(,3()0/0/
))))1//(/#/(///#)(0//55,(./#/(/4/)
.,0-0/./4/0/)(),.3,(/-30//(/4/# #-.
,0)3-/.0/(/(0/-3/55(0(,
A(((/30./0),)(,33(//)(0/(.
0/0(,((</ %$8=3/.04(,.4) 3()0/#7&!!"<
.3,(/-30/-3/55(=/()30/-//03))(),//)(
0/0(,((.()(&!!"<%-30./ -3/55(=&!!"
(,)((
muud silmalau
ja silmaümbruse pindmised
vigastused
</&$&!=>((/#0(,((//)))/A11(/(
.(),/(0/((#/( ##/119&!!")(),-4.
////,0/./3,(0(,#((0/(.)F
2"%/,-!/-)(,(4(,0/)(),F2%/,.3,(11
/#- (.10(
26.30/F2&"/,$!/ ((/0(,((04(0(
.(().10((///.((/
(0/(.10((4(/(F2&"/,%.3,(0
(0/(.10((33(/ ((./)(),.(.
3((.(.((-3((
27.10((()/33(/ 0 //55(,))
0(,.3,()))/#)(/55(./A11(/(0/.//((
,(0(,(55(,))0/3(((,-30/0(4)
-30)(),0(0($.()/(- /(()0(,
A(((/0/))5(#/0(). ())()(,(-(/,
/0))/33//0/((<(0(),(-1/,( (=
/)0/)0/))))A11(/(.0())04/((03(
28. (- (/#11(0()))/0/.0(,)(),
//,))(0/(.1(/55,(,)3#.1)-4./(
)))311(03((/()3(().(,-30/
3(,03,(0//()(4(,(,( 11(03((,03)
03(34.//)A11(/(
03,(0//,,5/# ( ((/,# ( ( )3
(()/((#/)))/0/.( /(0-30 )
-/)4(/)0.-(0<>(.(//#-(
)/11(0/(.10(()4((0((/.!!$!!!/#/$%"$%%=
)(0/(.4(/(10((&
29./)0/)0// (0((/,(/(/.4( (/
03/.&(0/(.
Kriminaalmenetluse kulud ja kannatanu teavitamine
30.27/,(//10( 11(4(0/
)//1/./11(4(/)0/29&/,-$.29%/,$)
)//33(././)())-4.).0./(
/<-"=)(),11(4(0,)0)<-'=))((
11(2!/,!-&.3,(#((29'/,-!/)(
(11(4(0,)0)#% -/,
/33#!&<#%I7!J!&=()(33(.
/)/&&8#9!</%#79.'!=)/((./
((,(4(, (()/33(#(///-/(,3(/(/
,&""#" <3( =,) 33(.
(()/)/87#98<&&8#9!K&""#"J87#98=(),4()//
)'#98<!&K87#98J'#98=
31.(),(/-/(.04(/27/,$/&,()(/
)//((./0)(./-4.),
3,(#0 )/(()(/'!!"<03(
,(=#//0),/0(( ())(%.8</"!'=0
/(#(/4( 03/.7) # /(,(
!$)//,()04( 3((/1/.44(/
(//((03/.()(<4/-()(=-/)(#33 27
/,&)/.)/// )//(((!./
32. (()/(()30/) )))/))0((
11(4())3,0 (.())(-((-4,)(</8=
<//(.(,(//=