Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/988/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/988/2004 Generato dall'IA

Statute of Frauds Bars Oral Contract and Promissory Estoppel Claims for Real Estate Sale

Numero d'incarto ATAS/988/2004
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The lower court correctly granted summary judgment against the petitioner who claimed breach of contract and promissory estoppel based on alleged oral assurances regarding the future sale of property, as the court found the statute of frauds barred the contract claim due to the absence of a written agreement memorializing all essential terms. Furthermore, the promissory estoppel claim failed because the petitioner did not demonstrate that reliance on the alleged oral promises was reasonable given the clear, written terms of an existing agreement which contemplated a formal, written contract for the sale, thus affirming that the oral assurances were insufficiently definite or supported by consideration to overcome the written contractual framework or statutory requirements.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute of Frauds Bars Oral Contract and Promissory Estoppel Claims for Real Estate Sale: Furthermore, the promissory estoppel claim failed because the petitioner did not demonstrate that reliance on the alleged oral promises was reasonable given the clear, written terms of an existing agreement which contemplated a formal, written contract for the sale, thus affirming that the oral assurances were insufficiently definite or supported by consideration to overcome the written contractual framework or statutory requirements.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
compravendita beni immobili truffa controprestazione contrattuale ipoteca legale del venditore principio dell'estoppel

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               &'())&)+ ,&-..&)+

,

 , "  , "     "

(/ 01 $ )+ 2 )+ 



$ 3333333333            $"$   !"#$!%!&" '()))*))   ))

" $

44   , "  "5   6", $ % ! !01 +",-" .*')*))   )/

            !" #$%

   3*2/3  



%1!!"%*/0$*((.%455! "%4$3!6!%! 17!3$89  : $ & !3!  $# 1  %0% % 0$ $"5!" % ;"!$;<<<<<<<<<<=

  %1!!" $ ""! !" % > #!  *((. % 4  $ & !  $# 1 4""! !"5"$01$4$1" $ $0!8$%1!!"=

$"$%)>#! *((.$?*(!6 %4$1" $ %1!!"$ ""! !" "  !0!! 0  @ "  !"   4" $"! % 0$ % $1%  !" $"5!" !! & @ ! $ A!%!!$ @ 4" $"! %4 $  %4!6!%! 1=

  !5"$0 !" "010 !$ %"1  */ "B  *((. $  %1$ 0  % +C! $!%CD! E!6$! !$%867F:=

"010 %$"$%." "A$*((.%$ $!%4$1"0  "$  "0  %  %$!$ "  1G0  @ 4 !" %  %1!!" @ 4" $"!%$  !"%4$3!6!%! 1" 00 %0$%$1%  !" %4"$%$ $"5!"    $6"! %   @ 4! !01 "$  0!  H6$ %4 A!%"01 $"5!"%$"$ =

%1!!"%)$"60A$*((.%4! !01$&!3!%1!!" %*/0$*((.!!&%1!!"$""! !"%>#! *((.%"  $"$  %1!%%$$%$4! $ !"%%0%%$  !"%$"$ =

 4$ ! >-  * %  "! $  $"1%$ %0!! $ !6 % )*  0A$ ),I' 7 : " & 4 "$! 1 % $0!8$ !     "$ % $"1%$ $"!%1$$ " $ !$$  %1!!"   " !5!$ %    "6 %1!!" E $ ! %"$"!@4 "$! 1%$"$=

 & 4 "$! 1 % $"$  " ! @ $! $  $"$ & %  0$ "J  "6%1!!"4$%"A# =

 &  !  5!   4"$$ %$"!  E "!" % $"$  $  "6%1!!"%)$"60A$*((. %1!!"%*/0$ %>#!  *((.=

4!"6! $"1& %"!%1$$&$1 $"$ %6"A#   %$+$%$D=





2)'2*((.  3/2/3  

  ,4 " , "  , "     "

$

708 9  :   5% ';) "<=

  8

) 1$  "A#   $"$ ! $# 1 $ ;"!$ ;<<<<<<<<<< " $  %1!!"%455! "%4$3!6!%! 1%>#! *((.=

* +%$D

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

"!"5"$0%$1 $$K  " !5!1E$ !!!&4@455!51%1$ %$"!$G$55



2)'2*((.