Statutory Interpretation of Penalty Calculation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant challenged the application of a specific regulatory provision, arguing that the lower court erred in interpreting the governing statute regarding the calculation of a penalty. The court reasoned that the clear and unambiguous language of the statute mandated the penalty calculation method used by the agency, rejecting the appellant's suggested alternative interpretation and affirming the lower court's judgment upholding the agency's decision.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Penalty Calculation: The court reasoned that the clear and unambiguous language of the statute mandated the penalty calculation method used by the agency, rejecting the appellant's suggested alternative interpretation and affirming the lower court's judgment upholding the agency's decision.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appeal is rejected on the merits of the main claim, referencing this article in the dispositive.
The costs of the federal procedure are imposed on the losing party.
Testo completo
"##$%"&$$' "()%"&$$'
+ *!+ +* !
,- % & ./- &$$'
#!#$
!"#
!$#
%% & %% "$". "'(( #! ) )*+, - %
0!
!
&,-1& )( #2.""!)1!$!3#,) %#4"5#&"6#!.. 7 588""$"! 5!88" !"# . ,, 9" ):01 $ ! .6! .)0!43#):0; 6#<"&" %% 76#$"#)#!$!3#,)(
,( .6!2 5.$$ 6 ="$$. # !$"$"! 6!# 6.#"!5!$!3#,)7#,, %% >"7#!$#6#4!" 6!#"$(
/( , !?$ ,, %% 4. !66!"$"! 8!#. 6# .6!2( #"# !$ "$#9$. #!# 6#< #"3 ""$#$"8 !# !6.$$ .>$ = # @."! 5.$"$ 6 43 < !# =5" 54"$ 6 ">. $ =5" 54"$ 9" #A " !"$"! >..# " $$# 3"4(
0( # 9>$ B 94"# ,0 #"3 ""$#$"8 #9$. #!# .6!2 !8"#. 6# ##C$ #"3 8..# # + 9"$,0(
+( .6!2 5D$ $!9!# 6 6D. # !$"$"! %% #.7@52#66);8.4#"#,+$"#)) #,+6!#6#""6D.94"#7#,+ 8#"!$"! (
B( ,B4#",+ %% .6!.2#.=""$"!6!#"$7588" 6!#"$ =!$"8".)*",+!$6D# 6!#"$ !*+1;):1)E #.$7!"#6"$! )F))+ 8#( 0* 4 "$.#C$ 7 + G < )# 94"# ,+ 6 /* 8#( 8#" ""$#$"8 8#"6!#"$ !##6!$2!$"$"!"6D. )#94"#/)#,+(C9!# !$6D# 6!#"$ !( *+ 1;):1, H 8?$ !$"8". 7 5"$.#. #.$ 7 6"$ C !$$ 6!# !$"$"! "6D. 6$ 6.#"! $"!.(.6!2!$8!#.!66!"$"!(
1( # 2 .""! )# 9"$ ,+ %% 6#!!. "4. !66!"$"!2!$6D#!(*+1;):1)E$*+1;):1,H(
;( .6!2!$8!#.!66!"$"!$,B9"$,+ .>$=5"!$ 6 #. 6#< "&" %% < !# =5" 54"$ 6 #6""">.8!#"#5""!(
:( %% #9$.!66!"$"!6#2.""!.6#.,B!?$,+(
)*( ,,6$3#,+ .6!2!$"$#9$.#!#I! -//*0-,+$ -//*+-,+J !$75$"!#6!"5#(8!$4!"#
-//*0-,+ &/-1& =5!$ #"5!$9"">.!$#$5#&"4 %% (
))( #.6! )/ !$!3# ,+ %% #66 = 5##C$ K 0 9"$,0!8"#.588""$"!5!88"#!#$$="6!"$"! !!3">$"!#$"47!"!5!$#$!$666"3 $"<#5#&"!3">$!"# !$"$$!"6."( !$ #9$ #!# $ 7 !$"$"! 6!#"$ 6!# !$$)F)0+8#(0*6!#@=.6!2 8#"6!#"$!!6#" 6 "$.#C$7+G<)#94"#,+(
),( #!#!)1!$!3#,+ #"3.9!"$! .#! -//*0-,+$.$.>#.79>#(
*!
)( !">4!"#5!#>"$"!9"""#IJ.$.!"8".$"$"$. < )#!?$,/ #"3$!#!" !6!.+9> !$6#."$$4"&6#."$ +66.$$)B9>#I#$()$( #$+B J(
%"$75$"!5.$"!)B9># 6# #"38..# ,194"#,0I K)/*)*BJ # !">4!"!6$. )/8.4#"# "6!"$"!$#"$!"##>$6#$$$ #"3$!# !" ".># # 7 $#!" 9> $"$"# 5$$$ 5.$"!!429>#(
%!6.$6!#9>#56<$"".$3"(
,( !8!#.$ 7 F#$( +B ( ) $( @( 0 #"3 $! #!"!L$"$"=!$$$"!6#.475#$" +B !" 8..# # 6#$" >..# #!"$ # !" ; !$!3#,I J="!$#$"47!"8..##5#&" );#)::0I J(
%!6.$6!#9>#56<$"".$3"(
/( $$#. 4"># )# 94"# ,/ $#L$ !"8"$"! !3# "6!"$"! .> !" # !"( %# 6$.#" 6!"$4!"#=#!"$F66"=!"$C$#$#@.7"<# 6#""6!=#<>66"3!$4">#!$!M 8"$ 9#""=$ .$#"$ !$ 6#!"$ I K ),1 0B1 !"( )
-//*0-,+ &0-1& ),B )/B !"( 03 $ #.8.#J( #4@ =" !# 6#!.# $7.8$#<>$#"$!"#!$#"# !4#!"$F66"= #.#4<9!#!$#.4">#I K))1:/!"(B3 )), /B*!"(0N )::;O/16(/)B!"(/3J(
5!## "$">6!#$#!$"$"!"6D.,+ !#$= $66"3(
0( $#9$.8!#$."6#.46#!" #!#$#43I+B$B* J(
+( #!#$ !$$$ C$# 88"". 6#< 5"$". < !# =5" 5!$ 9"#A!"$"!>..#"">.!$#$5@."!(
" #66# = 5 3$ 6#""62 $ ## 5#&"!3">$!"#6!#53 6!6$"!%"( " 3"5#$(/() 6!&$&"6#""65!3">$"!5#6!#$!$ 6#!!""".%"I K),B,B;!" /3$#.8.#J(
6#! $ 5## @!""$ "3#$ 6#" ## 6#$"=$ 5# !3">$!"# !" I#$( 0 J( .8$ 5$!#"$. .">. 6# $! !"$ %#4" 5#&" I% J 7 <4 88"" 5!88" $!$ 6#! $ 5## =" 5 6 !. "$ 7 $$ !3">$"!$6$"I#$(B J(
5!## 5$6#.".$6#=#!#$5.$"$688"". 6#< 5 "&" # @!"2 = % 4"$ 88"". 5!88" 6#<5"$".<)#!$!3#,)( 5#>$#!#$=$7 "$.#88""$"!#.$$!&">$#6!"5#$ !&#.6$"! !"$"! >..# 5# $ !.= "8$$##!.( #"3.5$##64$>$"<# < !#==$"!"3#$.!$#$ .$..976!#$.6##!#$ 4$$#"32$=58"$5!39$5##C$ K $+9"$ ,0(
B( 5!3">$"! 6D# 6#" .! 5#$( B) N !$"$ !$#6#$" 5!3">$"! 5## 5# 6#" @#> .4.$ #.( $ !.= 9#""= "6.#$"4 $!$ 88""$"!6#<5"&"$5.$7$!$#.&"I ):;*6()B)N):;)6(B)J(6#"!"4$C$#6D.754$6#""6 $!!"I#$(:*()5#!#5#&",;9")::+ P N 8( @"88# )0() !"$"! >..# 5# 6!# 5# !3">$!"#!"& 5 %% J(
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
1( #.$6"<!"#=#!#$5!$66D.6#"6!# 6.#"! )# 94"# /) # ,+ I/1) 8#( 6# !" 6!# @= #.J >#.#66$"#5"$".(
#"3 . !$$ = 6#!.# #!4#$ .$. #">!#$#6$.6#5"$".$=@#!#$#$"4!"# !)F)0+8#(0* 6/*8#(8#"""$#$"8 ""=8#" 6!#"$(
#!#54<#!.=8!.(
%5>"$"$.#C$!#$!"# 5#$(:*(, 6#."=5"5.<4$7 + G 5 6!# 6#" .@ ! 5#$( ,B ( ) ( 6#" !$ 6D3 54 2 .@. !4 I8( #$( )+() 5 %% J( 5!## !$ .@ )# @= !"$ 6!#$$ "$.#C$ < $$ $N " 5"$ = "$.#C$ 64$ !#"# < )# 94"# ,+ # $!$"$.6#" /)#,+( D "#$"##. !D 6!#=!$"$"!!$I/!"!$"$"!"6D.-,Q))-, !"J !#$="$.#C$!#$!"#!#$<)+8.4#"#,+(
;( 6#!.#$>#$"$6!#6#$"I#$(B)$( N#$(;:R!"# 6#!.# ""$#$"4 ), 6$3# ):;+ P J( !$8!" .!$9$"$8#"6#!.#64$C$#"7@#> 6#$"=">"$"<#$..#"#!$.!">.><#$.( 88$ ""= #"38..##5" 6!"3""$.""$#>#$"$. #!# $..#"# ! "$#9$. 7 .><# $ 6#""6 >..# 6#!.# 6#.46!#$!$3#@#!"I K),B)+)!"(03J(
-//*0-,+ &B-1& %! 9#"6# #!# 4!. 7 5.@ #"$ C$# "". 7 #!# 6#.$$ #$<# .><#$. ! $..#"$. I K ),0 ,;+ #$"= % )::; 6( ):0J( 8$ =5 ..$ P #"$"=3 P 59!$ 39$"4$ 6#$S 6#$" !#. !"$ 4!"# $. 6#!.# = 3"C6!4"$$###!6$ $5$$$"!=5! 6!4"$ #"!3$ 2"># 5 = ! #!# .$"$ .6!#4 @ <(
56< #!#6#.$7$!$!"#$<#.><#$. 7""$ $..#"$. # !M #>$ 6# = #!#$ 5!66!$ 6"$ # 6#" 5#&" !$ C = 2"4!=.6#..$4$ #"3""$#$"8$ K (# 3" =#!#$!$.$.$"<#$.3!$. "6#"$$765="$$# #!$"$"!$7#!#"#D$.$"=$(
.># 8"$ = 5"$". 5 6 8"2. !##$$ .3$ !# "$.#C$ !#$!"# #"3 . #! 7 !# #!#$ 6"$ 5 .!$( $$"# 6$ # $$$"! =5" 6!##!$ 7 54"#C$#!. !8!#.$75#$(;:R() 7.!$$ 2.3!#5"6#"$$7#!#"#4$ #"3.88"# 33$6!#C!$"8(
-//*0-,+ &1-1& * !0 *!+ +* !
1.2. 3 4.. . 56 7)&
2.
)( .##!##43(
2.
,( 5$6#$"$(
/( #!! "4. .8""$"4 5!66!"$"! 8!#. 6# !"# !$ 6D# 6!#"$ !( *+ 1;):1) E 7 !##)F))+8#(0* 6"$.#C$+G<)+8.4#"#,+ ""=/*8#( 8#"""$#$"8 8#"6!#"$(
0( #!! "4. .8""$"4 5!66!"$"! 8!#. 6# !"# 6!# !6$ ! .6! 6!#"$ !( *+ 1;):1,H7!##)F))+8#(0* 6"$.#C$+G<)+8.4#"#,+ ""=/*8#(8#"""$#$"8 8#"6!#"$(
+( "$=6#!.#$>#$"$(
B( 8!# 6#$" =5 64$ 8!## #!# !$# 6#.$ ##C$ ." /* 9!# < !$"8"$"! 6# 6" #!. #. #"3 8..# # %@T"U#@!8=" B B0 $#!" 26"#( ." 6$ C$# 6#!!>.( .!"# !"$S J ""=# 2$$=.""!#!#$."#!3$"#"$6.""! $$=.N 3J 26!# 6!# = !$"8 " $" 6!4!"# # $$ $# .""!N J 6!#$# ">$# ! ! #6#.$$( %" .!"# !$"$ 6 $#!" ..$ ..#. ! $$# J 3J $ J "& #"38..##6!##6$##$"<###!#=5" 4#.##"##43(.!"##!#$"!#!#!D 6#4 =" #!$ 9!"$ "" = .""! $$=. $ 54!66 =.$.26.".#!#$I#$()/, )*B$)*;J( >#88"# #."$S V" "
!6"!8!#6#.$##C$$!$"8".26#$"""=57588"8..# $.63"=6#>#88
-//*0-,+