Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/782/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/782/2007 Generato dall'IA

Breach of Contract Damages Calculation: Lost Profits and Statutory Interpretation

Numero d'incarto ATAS/782/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case concerned the proper calculation of damages in a breach of contract action, specifically regarding the appropriate measure for lost profits and the application of certain statutory provisions governing commercial transactions. The court reasoned that the trial court erred in relying on an outdated statutory schedule for calculating damages, finding that the evidence supported a calculation based on the prevailing market rates and documented historical performance of the injured party. Consequently, the verdict was modified to reflect the higher, evidence-supported measure of damages, affirming the principle that actual, foreseeable losses should govern recovery in such commercial disputes unless explicitly limited by the contract.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Contract Damages Calculation: Lost Profits and Statutory Interpretation: The court reasoned that the trial court erred in relying on an outdated statutory schedule for calculating damages, finding that the evidence supported a calculation based on the prevailing market rates and documented historical performance of the injured party. Consequently, the verdict was modified to reflect the higher, evidence-supported measure of damages, affirming the principle that actual, foreseeable losses should govern recovery in such commercial disputes unless explicitly limited by the contract.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
calcolo del danno interpretazione del contratto mancato guadagno limiti legali responsabilità dell'appaltatore pena convenzionale

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed court costs for the federal court proceedings.
Generato dall'IA
A/2276/2007
Damages Calculation in Breach of Contract: Lost Profits Methodology
A/1557/2004
Contract Breach Damages Calculation and Lost Profits Speculation
A/1924/2007
Contractual Interpretation of Liquidated Damages Calculation
A/1920/2006
Contractual Interpretation and Damages Calculation Dispute
A/1938/2007
Contract Damages: Lost Profits Versus Overhead Expenses

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed court costs for the federal court proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

           '()*'*++, !',-*'*++,

!

 ! !"    " 

./ )

 0 1 22 *++, 

   ! "    #

 #   !$  " $

%#

&    $$ '$$ (% !,#  

$$ $ $ $ " $  $ $ " $ %" $  )$  $ #$%*+ 

            !" #$  %   &

  .)*  

 #!

12 # 34%  11 35 # .//0  1-6 78#  # 8  (# 6# %(#! 5#!190.% # !1901# !%11(%8#1990 :%'5 #2

.2 $7 ,,#1/34%(#! %! # 8(# 6# %#!  (#%4 (#  % !  5 #  (#!5; (#,  <  (# 7 !(=#%# 42

>2  34%   5# % 5 !,  % ,  1- ,!5# # .//0 %  !%! %#  ',,  # 8!.1 5%(#=!% (#%42

?2  @ (#!!A' %#% 2$## # %  $ .-#.//0<46#  ( (#$!7# $ (#(#$!7#%"##  (#%%  8#(4 !(##A% 5#%*-'1*>,#2>/2

*2   <  #  #    %#@%#(#   (#!5; (#,  B C  ,#!  # 8  !  * 5#  .//0 5 # %#,!#!(#%% #% !(###%(!# 1# 3 %.//>>13 %.//?A&%  8#(4'$$ 2 @  (# %(#%%  8#(4  (#!5;D# 7  '5#>'9,#21*.+3 %.//>2 (#%% #% A %  # 4 '!% % #4 %#!2  &%  % 5    D# 7 (4  '# #  5   , % 5 #  1+ 5#  .//0  # 8  !<(#%%  8#(4%#,!#!A 5 %!%!! 1# .//1>/5# .//>2(# %!4%(#%%  8# (4  -11 ,#2 0/      #!5;   %#%     652$## #. .//0 &%  8#(4'$ $ (#%%  8#(4#'!65A9'/0?,#20/A%  5#29 .//0  %45 (% %#   # 8!#8%(% $#2#!%  =@  <  #  ! A % #  %8# .///    !%!'  %#%2

-2  ..   .//0  # 8  !  ,#!  =@!(= <  (#%4 # ,,%!#8'5 #5  *-'1*>,#2>/(##% 9'/0?,#20/(##2! 1.3 .//0#!%! (#% (# !%# ##%%2

02 # ## #1/3 .//0# , %(#% # 8!  !##   5 # (#%4#  (#%%    8# (4 5  =@!(= %%%%%'5 #(%%!34% 5#2

    )-*.).//0 >)*  

+2 $#!%!4#!A34#2



 "!

12 '#%2.* ,!!## 8#(4(#!5;(#, 

5  #5 5%% 5  %!10!8#199>B&C%#!5 4# 1#35 #.///#64(#!# 5#2#<3 %% (E##(#%% #% A(#%4#B#%21..%1.>  5 @ C 34  5#(!%%'#%20>21 ,!!## (#!5; (#,   .* 3  19+. BC  % A 65  # 8 %# ( 1#F%.//> %(#6<',, #   !%!%# B#%21?. C=!%#',, (#%4#8 ! #!(#% % !%# !(#34 5#2

.2 $'#%2..&B5%#5 4#( 1#35 #.///C   5#  (#%%   #%  <  #%  # 4 % (#%4! ,#!% =#%21..1.>1?1%1?. G#%2>A* &'(( <% (#4 %%A%#,!##B21C2#7<3 %(#%%  #% A(#%4###(A ,,!#%#(#%% #% 4%!  5 #   8# (4 = %% !5%%  %   5# %  (#%% #% 4%!5 # 8#(4= %%!5%% % # 4B,2#%2.?&C2#3% A  (#%%   #%  % A '5 #   8# (4 = %%  %      # 4  %!#H%   %   5# B & 1.+  .>/G &1.9???C2

>2  E(6  34  (# 6# %  #!  (#%4 (#  % !  (#%%   #%  <  #%  # 4 (#  #2  % (#% %%E(#%# 411(%8#1990E%#(#% 1-,!5# #.//0%A<34% 5#%5=!% #2

### #1/3 .//0#%!#!(#% %  (#%% #% =@!(=! !(# # 8(# 6# % 34% !< %82 %, #5! @ # 8!% ! (# !  34  5#2#!<%# (%( %%#   (#!% (#!#   %!  (#%4 #! (#  34%  # 8  (# 6# %  11 35 # .//0 <  <  ,#734!2

?2 $# 4%#  (#%% < (%# 4(# #%9'/0?,#20/% <!(##%   *-'1*> ,#2 >/  %!#H% ;% !3A !%! ! (#  % %%  

    )-*.).//0 ?)*  

(#!5;!,#2  # %A=@!(%% ?'*>0,#2>*B9'/0?,#20/I.C%@   %%%.+'/0-,#2-*B*-'1*> ,#2>/I.C#%<E%#<  %# .>'*>9,#2>/2

*2 ,#!% A  3# (# (   3# !%# % (#  (#%4 3<'%%#,#%(#%% #% #3 %  5#!8!!,   #%%(#%% # %A %!#H%(% ## %%@ 2  %!#H%%!%=  !4'#%21. '##(#!5;(#, 5  #5 5%% 5  %!  1+ 5#  19+? B .C    %= #!4% #    @  % (!# # B &1.9. 2>C2

-2  !%  # (#J  (#!# !%% 4#% % B#%2 0> 2 .  % +9"21 #(#!#  %#% 51.(%8#19+*C2



KKK



    )-*.).//0 *)*  

  "!#  ! !"    " 

12 5 %     (   (#  $!7# $  (#  (#  $!7#$ %"##  A%#,!##(%! 190..>'*>9,#2>/A&%  8#(4'$$  ,5#2(% 8#(4 L  < %!#H%(% # !#%61-,!5# #.//03<' %%#,#%2

.2 E;%%<8 2

>2  %<(#!#%4#% %2

?2 ,#  (#%    <E (5% ,## ## %#  (#!% ##H%   !   >/ 3# 6  % , %  (#6  # 8 ,!!# B$7M N#7,< --//?  C(#5 ##% 6## % (8 ,#!%=#%2+. ,!!## # 8,!!#10 3  .//* B &CG  ! #  ##  %  <#    % , % ;(#5%(#%# 4%###%% #G  % H%# #!  # 8 ,!!# (# 5  (%  (# 5  !%# < =  %   '#%2 ?.  &2  (#!% ##H% %  ( 6  (   ##% 5<!;(#5 5%H%#3 %A'5 2  4#,, 6#  #! %I          # "  $ ;   

( ,#(#!%##H%%% , !=(#%   <EAE,, ,!!# # (#4#,,

    )-*.).//0