Statutory Lien Attachment Without Actual Notice
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a challenge to a statutory lien that was held to have attached to property regardless of whether the lienor had actual notice of the lien's claim against the property owner. The court reasoned that the relevant statute did not require actual notice, relying on the clear language of the statute which provided for the lien to attach upon the happening of a triggering event, thereby establishing a priority interest in the property which was effective against subsequent interests even without actual knowledge of the lien.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF, Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF; Statutory Lien Attachment Without Actual Notice: The court reasoned that the relevant statute did not require actual notice, relying on the clear language of the statute which provided for the lien to attach upon the happening of a triggering event, thereby establishing a priority interest in the property which was effective against subsequent interests even without actual knowledge of the lien.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal in points 1 and 3.
Used in point 1 to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Used in point 5 to declare the appeal inadmissible (based on summary procedure).
Testo completo
!"!# "$$% &!' "$$%
(
) *)+ +,+ )+ ,*
!" -. "$$%
#/ 0 1
2,+*,+ *+*)*,+ )*3 !"" #$% &''& ()
)
4444444444 *+)
, -./,
+ 2*
&1 ( 23333333333 4 "5 633333333337 (8" 8") 8)1 5" * 9(8:) 8 )"* (" ; 9) <"= ")% * * )>* 8) " " )8)+" 9),"" )" ?**) " )( :" 8 )@ 4 8" ) ?**) " )8)" )( A ? , 71 )"B) +"
)88) ; 9 )" * )" 8) ))") -' *(<) -''&1 ++ * 5 9(8:) " )* ") 8*)") @ ") )* 8)* 8) " "+"" 8 ; 9<"= " *= 9++"" " ; " 8)*: 8)+"1
-1 9 )" * )"% 8) ))") # C") -''-% ((* ( 23333333333 9++"") *" "@ (" ; " " " 8)*:% 9"+)( 5 8) *" "(8) "% ") )" )(" ; 9 " " 88* " 8) ++"" " 9++"1
#1 9" *)* 9: 8 88) * 8) ++"" " 8)B 9 " " " 8)*: )=" )*% 9++" 8)*: 8)+" 9 * ; ? " " " 88* " 4",8)B ? "7 8) ++"" " 9++"1
01 ) *"" #' 8 (<) -''-% ? " ++""* 9(8:) 9++" ++ )* ) "+ &) C") &//D1 *"" )* +) ") * * *1
$1 <)) )"< " * * * <" &' C" -''#% +"@ ( E ; ?)1 &&F&0G1,, 8) 8*)" C") &//D ; *(<) -''&% ;
8:) #' C)1 *(8 * * * <" ) < ") 2 &//D% &//H% &///% -''' -''& )=" )* 8) ? , % (8 +" 5 ") )* ))8 ") <) 2 (" * " )" "1
G1 ) ))") &0 C" -''#% ? " +)(( ((* 9(8:)
8:) ( 5 )) )* (8 ) % ;
") ?)1 &-F0D&1,,1
D1 &# (<) -''#% (8 ) 9*" ; ?)1 &-FG-&1,,1
.&-&#.-''0 , #./,
H1 0 () -''0% ) )*5"" " ? "% 9++" 8)" +"" 4",8)B 97 "+"* ; 9(8:) ((( 8:)
I '# -$/'#& J 8) ( ?)1 &-F0D&1,, " *)K ; $L B && E -''# ?)1 &$'1,, +)"1 9(8:) : +" 88" "1
/1 ) ))") - )" -''0% ? " "(8) " ; 9(8:) *" "@ C) +" 59" C "+" 88" " 59" ) ")1 ))") ) ) ) ( " M )+*. )*(* N1
&'1 / C" -''0% ? " "" )"< * 9 )5K ("* *+"" " 988" "1 ) ) ( % 8)" <)) )"< "% ((( 8:)% )* (8 9(8:) "" 5 ") (( "1
&&1 " * ; * )(")% *+) 9 8 ("+ *1
.&-&#.-''0 , 0./,
+ ,*
&5 " =" ) 9)=" " C""") 47 * * ("+"* " " *% B &) E -''#% )"< ) " 4 27% (8* "5 C=% 8)*" ",8)*" % "5 88* "O C= ) 4) 1 & 1 ) $G 71
2" ; 9 " 9* " "O C= ) 8) )"< +**)
4 ?7 -D C") -''0 4 ? &#' &'G7% ) " =" 8 *% &# +*)")% "8" " )" ") )= 4) 1 &G- 7 8)( 2 "*=) )% ; )" C= " ")% 9 9* " @ C= )1
2 ) )) )" 8<"% ? % ))K ) &) C" -''0% +")(* 5 "8" " )" ") " " " 8 ) " * " % ))P % +)( )" +**) 4))K &1 &H#.-''071
=( "" 5 " F* " " "" * 2% ?
"(* 5 )* " )"< 8" K ) )(" % +) *)= ") )" +**)% 8 8) ""B)( 9) 1 $D 9))1
-1 +)(*( ; 9) 1 $G 1 & 1 < % )"< ) " P " "5 " ) " ; 8)*: 8)+" 88 " " " 8)*:% (8:) : )" % :
(8)" ")% "" 5 8)* " )8<"" *1 2 (8* 8) C=) 98B "" * <"1
#1 " +**) ) 8)*: 8)+"% ""% )" """ * -$ C" &/H- 47 " " )*="( 9) <"= ") )"* 4) 1 - 1 & 71 2 9) 1 && 1 & % (8:) 8 )"* (" ; 9) <"= ") " K ) ++""* ; " " " 8)*: ")" )=" ) 8)*: 8)+"1 2"
9(8:) +)( 8 ; <"= "% 9 )" * )" (( 9++"") "@ (" ; " " " 8)*:1 9@8") " *"% 9(8:) 5" 9 8 < (8*)* ; "C " * ; 9" " " 88* " 8) ++"" " 4) 1 && 1 $ 7% 5 ) " ++ )* ) "+ 4) 1 && 1 # 71
.&-&#.-''0 , $./,
01 9) 1 # 1 & 9) ) )" 9" " " 88* " ( "B) 8)*: 8)+" 4",8)B 9) Q 2 H#&10#07 8)*"
) 5 9(8:) " )) ; 9" " " 88* " " " 8) 9(< )"* (" ; "% ++ (( R " )" E K ) ++""* ; " " " 8)*:1 @ 9" *)K () ") ))8 ; " 5988"5 !<" ( 9" " " 88* " ) ) 8"( " " 4) 1 # 1 - 9)71
$1 @ )( 9) 1 D# 1 & % !5 *"= )"< 5" P % )"B) " % " 88 " " " 8)*:% (8:) : )" 1 9 8 " " * 8)*) 988" " 8)*< )) )"<1 C)"8) 8)*"* ) 5 " " " " 8)*: " 9" " " 88* " 8 )
988" " ; 8)" ))( " " 8) 9(8:)
8) *"" "("< ; C=( 4 ? &&$ /$ Q &//& - &0/71 )"< * 8 "" P ) ") ( 988" " +" 8) *<" ) ((( 8:)1
*"" )" * ("" ) " +**) 8) ( " ;
8:) (( 9)= @* * 8) " 8)" 8) % +" 8* +)% "("* ; C=( @* ") 9) 1 H' 1 - !1 - " +**) ) 8)" 8) +"" && )" &HH/ 4 Q 2 -H&1& Q 1,1 % (( ") % &///%
81 &--G% !1 0$71 (K( *"" 8* +) )" * ("" ) " )"B) " 5" % 9(8"( S! )" 8<" ; +*)* 8) +**) "% 88" " )" +**)% (" 5" 8 *+"" "( ) )" +**) T )( " % *"" 8 "< 9 )) ("" ) "+ 8)B 9 )" * +**) 9 )) )" ("" ) "+ 4 % 81 " 1% 81 &--D Q 1 % = O U<) 2!< )"<= VW)% &///% 81 G-&71 ) )" * ("" ) " +**) T 8) @ " )" * ("" ) " )"B) " , % " + ) )"<@ +**)@ ) )" * )=" " "*8 9("" ) " +**) 59 9(8"( S! )" 8<" ; +"* 8) +**) " 4) 1 & 1 - 1 < 1 " +**) ) 8)*) ("" ) " -' *(<) &/GH X& Q 2 &D- '-&Y71
)"< ) " )"B) " 9(8"( S! )" 8<" 8 % 5"
.&-&#.-''0 , G./,
8)*B% 8)) ("* *+"" " 8"5% +% ( " 8"( "("* ; C=( @* ")1 " 9") *5 +" 5% ( "B) 5" )) % C= ) ++ "( C= )"") 9) 1 D/ 59" B ) 5" * 8) ) 88" " ; 8)" ) +
4 ? &'/ $&71
G1 98B% )"< * " 8) * <" 59 5" * 9(8:)
8 )"*% *+) " <"= ")( K ) ++""* ; " 8)*: 8)+"% 5" ) 9 C(" * * * 8)
)"B)% B ) 5 *"" 9++"" " 9 +" 9<C 9 )) )* +)1
" 8) ") 9( ) 5 *(8 ? " @ 1 ++ % " )) 9(< 8"B 8)" 8) () 5 *+) ) * *<" )" 9 ( ?)1 &-F0D&1,,1 )% "(8 8"" * *+)% 5" 9 )*=" " @ (( " ? " " ;
)"< *% )" (8K!) ? " 9==) ") 8)*) ))( +" 9< ") )" )" 1
5" ) +)" 8)" % " 9++" 88) * 8) *<" ) )5 8)" < " 4 &/D0 #-71 " *)K +)" 8)
*+) 8) ") 8)* ; 9) 1 # 1 - 9) ) )" 9" " " 88* " ( "B) 8)*: 8)+" 8)*" * ; 9) 1 D !1 #% 0 G " " 9++"" " )(" ; 9(8:) ) *"" 9++"" "1
) ( "+% " : " 9( ) ( 8)) ("* *+"" " 988" " ((( 8:)1
D1 5" ) +)" *8 % 9) 1 D# 1 - 8)*" 5 " 8)*") 8)*) "(8% )8" % 8)""8% =) " 1 9) 1 H/Z 1 & " ) 8)*) ("" ) " &- 8 (<) &/H$ 4 7 8)*" 5 ; " 5 8)*) =) " 8) 8) "1 +"% *<) *(( 8 K ) (" ; !)= 8) " 5" =" ("B) *(*)") *("= *=B) *1 ++ % "" 5 )"< +**) ) 9 ("% 8"<"" * "(" ) =) " * )) *(*)") " )C * ; *=B) 8)""8 =**) 8)*) 8)* 8)
<)! ) " 4 ? &-G &$& "1 0<71
.&-&#.-''0 , D./,
C)"8) 8)*"* 59 )) * ; 9*! )" K ) "("* ; )) 8)* ) B) *=B) * *(*)" *1 +" 59 )) " *8) ! B ++" 8)")" 8 ; " ; " +*)) ) B)1 ) + ," 59 **( T )" "5< T 9C <C "( 8) A 8) " )* " ") (* 8)*) 5 <" (K( 8" ) )) (8 % 9 " 5 9 8" )"<( @"=) 9% 5 )) * " *8) ! B 4) "5 2 &//H 81 &/071 ) " "= 8) ) " " 8)*: 8)+"% 8" ") " 8)B *(*)") " K ) )!* @(" ( (8) ( *<" ) " " 8)*) C""")% (" *=( (8) ( 8)B 4 ? &-0 -H$71
)"< +**) ) *=( )88* 59" : " +") "++*) )% 9 8) " " * 8) (" +)" 8)*) ; !)= 9 8) " 5" =" 8) *=B) * ("B) *(*)") 9) 1 H$ 1 - 1 " +**) ) 9),"" )" 4 2 Q 2 H#&1&' Q ( ) 1 G& 1 " +**) ) 8) " =**) ) " X T 2 H#'1&Y "=) 8" &) C") -''#7 % 9 ) 8) % )" @ *8 9) 1 H$ 1 - 1 + 2 4 ( ) 1 G& 1 = 7% )" 5" 988)*" )" B) *88* C 9 " *8 ; 8) " =" ( ") 4) "5 2 -''- 81 G&71
)) "@ 5" < " =" 8)*) )8)* * 8) % 9 ) ("B)% 8) 8) 5"+"*% 8 8)* ) ; *8 )5 8) " ) 8)B *=B) * ("B) *(*)")1 9< 9 )8)* "% ) " " 8) 9 )" *8 ; 8) " )8)* * " K ) *% "* ; *(*)" * ; *=B) * 4 ? &-H #-#71 2 9))K 8<"* " ? &&' � "1 0% " 9: 8 " 9) *8 8) +)" )" 8) 8) "% + ") 8) ""B)1 " " 9@8 " " K ) (" )5 " " " ( "( )*" A " + 59" 9=" 9 ++") (8"5* ) " "=" **1 + ) 5 =) " *)K 8) " 5 " *" =) 5 " * )" 5" *8 ) 5 9 8 )(( )"<( @"=) 559 8) 98) ++") 8) Q " + ( )" 5" =K ("B) "(8) 8 " )( 48) @(8 8)+"71 +"% " + 59" : " )88) )"< )
.&-&#.-''0 , H./,
)" +)" )* =) " *)K 8) )*
4 ? &&' H- "1 D &#$ "1 0< Q ) "5 2 -''- 81 G'71 < ) " " )B 8) " 5" )*( *8 8) C=) " ") " " )(8" ( "( 4 &/H/ 81 -D0 "1 $71
H1 98B% " " * )(") 8)(") " " *+) =" *=B) * *(*)" *% 8" +" % " *8 8 K ) ):* ; ()1
9 " *+) 8)B "" 59 ) 8)*) C""")% *=B) * (8) ( " K ) *1 ++ % 9 C(" ++""* ; 55 " " " 8)*:% 5" (* ? " ; 9++"") 9++" +)(*( @ "8" " *=1 9 " 8 5" * " " % +)[ "" () ; *8) )5K ("*1 )% 88* ; * )(") 8) )"< *% 9 8 "=* )*8)1
"++*) **( % )"< * +*% (8 C)"8) 8)*" *% ; " )*() *(( ; " ) +)" 8)*)1 ) +"@) ( % )"< "(" * <" 8)
)B=( " 9 1 +)" 8)*) 5" 8 K ) (" ; !)= 8) " (8) 9*(( 9))K * *<) 4) 1 & )B=( ) +)"% *(( "(" * 8)*) ("" ) " Q $ &'1'#71 )B= =**)% 9*(( 9))K * 9@B 8) &'F''' ?)1 4) 1 - 1 & )B=( 71 )"< () ) *+) ; 8:) *(( ?)1 $''1,,1
*+) : =" ("B) *=B)% ) ; @(") 5 " *81 )"< 5 ? " =" ( ") 8) +") ") )*1 9))% " 9=" 8 8 9 ++") (8@ " +" )" )" )5" 9 8 *8* ) 5" )(( *") (K( =)1 " "% " ) ):* "(" * *8 ; ()1
\\\
.&-&#.-''0 , /./,
,*2 *)+ +,+ )+ ,*
67-8- 9 :-- - ;5 !&" ,<
&1 *) )< ( *8* / C" -''0 8) ? " " " 88* " ")"=* ) ( 23333333333 Q
-1 9( Q
#1 ( ( 23333333333 ; 8:) ; ? " " " 88* " ( ?)1 &-F0D&1,, " *)K ; $L B && E -''# "" 5 ?)1 &$'1,, +)" Q
01 ) ("* *+"" " 988" " ((( 8:)
I'# -$/ '#& J% ; )) ( ( "* Q
$1 ( *+) ; *(( ?)1 $''1,, Q
G1 *< () ) 8 (8 " Q
D1 +)( 8) " 5F 8 +)() )) ) 8)* ))K *" #' C) B "+" " 8) 8" )((* )* )"< +**) )% 2!]"O)!+5" G% G''0 % )" @(8")1 *" 8 K ) 8)=*1 (*(") " A 7 ""5)
@ ( 5 *"" )) *") < ") " 8 *"" 5*Q <7 @8) 8) 5 ( "+ " "( 8") () ) *""Q 7 8) ) "= ) )8)* 1 2" (*(") " 8 )" **( *(*)* ) 7 <7 7 ",% )"< +**) ) 8)) 8 )) ( "B) ) )) 5F" ) *)) "))<1 (*(") )) ( ") ) (: 8)% 5" ) C" % "" 5 *"" 5* F88 5 * * @8*"* )) 4) 1 &#-% &'G &'H 71
=)++"B) A )*" A
" ?? V)" 2 V
8" +)( 8)* ))K "+"* @ 8) " "" 59; 9++" +**) ) " 8) =)++
.&-&#.-''0