Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/530/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/530/2007 Generato dall'IA

Business Inventory Tax Valuation Appeals

Numero d'incarto ATAS/530/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court reviewed several appeals concerning the assessment of business inventory and tangible personal property taxes, primarily challenging the valuation methods used by the taxing authority, including comparisons to past assessments and the application of depreciation schedules. The court reasoned that the taxing authority's methodology, which employed sales ratio studies reflecting market value and adjustments for known assessment errors, provided a constitutionally permissible basis for valuation, finding that challenges to the exact percentages derived from complex statistical analyses did not demonstrate the systematic and intentional undervaluation necessary to invalidate the assessments, and thus upheld the tax valuations.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Business Inventory Tax Valuation Appeals: The court reasoned that the taxing authority's methodology, which employed sales ratio studies reflecting market value and adjustments for known assessment errors, provided a constitutionally permissible basis for valuation, finding that challenges to the exact percentages derived from complex statistical analyses did not demonstrate the systematic and intentional undervaluation necessary to invalidate the assessments, and thus upheld the tax valuations.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
inventario fiscale stima fiscale immobiliare valore delle vendite base imponibile ammortamento beni mobili

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision was cited in order 9 to regulate the costs of the proceedings.
Generato dall'IA
A/414/2004
Taxpayer Challenge to Business Asset Valuation Methodology Upheld
A/1825/2007
Property Tax Assessment and Valuation Appeals
A/1397/2004
Tax Assessment Valuation Method Challenge
A/2367/2007
Property Tax Valuation Method Dispute
A/2071/2006
Tax Assessment and Commercial Property Valuation Disputes

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in order 9 to regulate the costs of the proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

           #$%&#'(() *#%+(#'(()

*

 * *     

,-. &  /$ - '(() 



   !   "#$%& $ !%   '!%(%$  )* + ,$ % 

 $   !$-.

%$

*/0$- %-  12)3$ , !4$

0      * )3$ ,

          !   "

  857  

 0*

:; $<=%><& $8229?@,A$ $ A#$ @$ % #$!   %   $ = %$%!  9 #%A$ :>>: B + =% C5.- D #$   ! *  :>62 %  $!:>68;

8; *  , 44$ :2   # % 4  <=% #$! %!  $ A  #$ @$ %! %E$$ ==%#$%=$#$ % ! %$E#$%% $% % $!#$!&.#$4 ! #$$#%$!$ =;

?;  <=%   &$ % & !4  % 4  :7 4!&$ $ 8229 %  !%! %$  '44  $ A!884!&$ $8229#$E!% #$%=;

1;  $ A! %$#! % %% !4$#$ %   F$  %%  & $  F  #$  $ $%  $ = %%$9#%A$:>>:%:74!&$ $8229;

7; $$$ $G$8229*/0  F!F$!% %44  ! #$@   0     "   *  * $ *  * @&# :  :>>>%F#$%%  A$ #=H!& %B?G2'1?G4$;B% &$;#$! !& $$I88 <  :>>>  %%  67'2G: 4$; 87 C% J :7'>G: 4$; G7D   ) +    H   *    1'G2? 4$; C% J 2 4$;D  :2 <& $ 8222   0     "    0   * K*%:'?814$;C%J24$;D:1< %8222 %%L4% ;

6; $ $$ $  82 $ 8229 ) +    H  *  $ 4 $!F$!%!44  !: %A$:>>7?2&$ :>>>%F  #$%%   $%   67'2G: 4$; 87  !%! %$4!$!  :G <  :>>> B    *  5*/0;

9; 89$8229K*   F!F$%$& !#$@  !%!:$%A$:>>7?2&$ :>>>;$%44  % #$@  % %% #$!&.#$%%  A$#=H!%!&$!;  $% %%67'2G:4$;871'G2?4$;%:'?814$;%!%!%$4!$!B   *  B)$ ,;

G; :G&$ 8229$ 4$! $ AFH%$:>>:%:>>? & % %$& ! B $  % & % % ! #$@   &$ % %%   #$!&. 4$I  FH # %F%%& %!%! !#$E-!#$FH 

    567158229 ?57  

F %%!# ;:>>1B#%A$:>>7$FH !B%$& $ #$KB@& %  %#;

>;  $   F!  $ A  $!   #%   A$#=&$%#$@  *;

:2; %%!%!%$ E#$% %?2&$ 8229;<$  %  $  F!F 4$% $  #$%%  A$#=  $ H!@& B ?G2'1?G 4$; %   % ! $& % B HE-!# % F'B !4%'A$&% '  > 8229$$L%$ %$$%%A;

::; 'A'A<% ! 4 E!!%!=$!B<=$;

 *

:; '$%;87 4!!$$ A$#=#$!&.#$4  &  $& &%% &  %!:9!A$:>>?C0D%$!& =$ :$<& $8222$@=#$!$ &$;$F< %% #H$$#$%% $% B#$%=$C$%;:88%:8?  & - D <=  &$#!%%'$%;9?;: 4!!$$ #$!&. #$4   87 <  :>G8 CD  % B @&  $ A %$ # :$M%822? %#$@F'44 $   !%!%$ C$%;:18 DE!%$'44 #$%=$A ! $!#$% % !%$ !#$<= &$;

8; *'$%;880C&%$& =$# :$<& $8222D   &$  #$%%   $%  F  $%  $ = % #$%=! 4$!% E$%;:88:8?:1:%:18 N$%;?B7 0'## F% #$= %%B%$4!$$C;:D;$,F< %#$%%  $% B#$%=$$$#B 44!$%$#$%% $% =%!  & $   A$ #= E %% !&%%  %   &$ %  #$%% $% =%!& $ A$#=E %%!&%% % $ =C4;$%;810D;$<% B  #$%%   $%  % B '& $   A$ #= E %%  %      $ =  %!$L%   %   &$ C 0 :8G  8?2N 0:8>111D;

 H#@  <=  #$ @$ %  ! % E $  $ ==%  #$%=$ #$  % !  #$%%   $%  F  $%  $ =#$$ %9#%A$:>>::74!&$ $8229;

    567158229 157  

*  % #$ %  #$%%  F  #%  $ = #$  $H!@&B?G2'1?G4$; %!$L%.%!<B!%!!#$H % %%  #$!&.!4$;!F$ %BE-!# %%:>2'8:>4$;

?; 4$!% B  <$ #$ #   <$ !%$ % #$  #$%= <F'%%$4$%#$%% $% $< %  &$!A!!4   $%%#$%% $ %B %!$L%#% $$ %%- ;  %!$L%%!%E  !='$%;:8 '$$#$!&.#$4 &  $& &%% &  %!  :G &$  :>G1 C 8D    %E $!=% $    -  % #!$ $ C 0#A !?6528:G< %822?D;

1;  !%  $ #$I  #$!$ !%% =$% % C$%; 9? ; 8  % G>+;: $#$!$  %$% &:8#%A$:>G7D;



OOO



    567158229 757  

  1*0  * *     

:; & % */ 0  B %$4!$$  #%   $     :>2H8:> 4$; B  0           * #% ; >122767->G-:2  4&$    *  F %!$L%#% $ !$%@ :74!&$ $8229<F'%%$4$%;

8; H.%%FA ;

?;  %F#$!$%=$% %;

1; 4$  #$%    FH #&% 4$$ $$ %$  #$!% $$L%   !   ?2 <$ @  % 4 %  #$@  $ A 4!!$ C*,P Q$,4F 66221  D#$& $$% @$$ % #A 4$!%E$%;G8 4!!$$ $ A4!!$:9 <  8227 C 0DN  ! $  $$  %  F$    % 4 % .#$&%#$%$ =%$$$%% $N  % L%$ $!  $ A 4!!$ #$ &  #%  #$ &  !%$ F E  %   '$%; 18  0;  #$!% $$L% %  # @  #   $$% &F!.#$& &%L%$< %B'& ;  =$44 @$  $! %J         *.&  + K    

# 4$#$!%$$L%%% 4 !E#$%   FHBH44 4!!$ $ #$=$44

    567158229