Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/476/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/476/2007 Generato dall'IA

Contractual Warranties and Disclaimers in Goods Sale

Numero d'incarto ATAS/476/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The petitioner appealed a decision regarding the scope of implied contractual warranties for the sale of goods, specifically contesting whether certain representations constituted express warranties or were merely puffery, and whether implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose applied despite express disclaimers. The court reasoned that the seller's specific affirmations of fact regarding the goods' capabilities, made prior to or as part of the bargain, created express warranties that could not be entirely disclaimed by boilerplate warranty language; furthermore, the court found that the circumstances indicated the seller knew the buyer's particular purpose, making the implied warranty of fitness applicable, and the disclaimer was ineffective as it was not conspicuous, leading to the reversal of the lower court's judgment on those claims.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Warranties and Disclaimers in Goods Sale: The court reasoned that the seller's specific affirmations of fact regarding the goods' capabilities, made prior to or as part of the bargain, created express warranties that could not be entirely disclaimed by boilerplate warranty language; furthermore, the court found that the circumstances indicated the seller knew the buyer's particular purpose, making the implied warranty of fitness applicable, and the disclaimer was ineffective as it was not conspicuous, leading to the reversal of the lower court's judgment on those claims.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
compratore garanzia del venditore contratto commerciale cosa determinata titolo rappresentante merci difetto della cosa

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the final orders regarding the imposition of costs for the federal appeal.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



           !"##$!%&&' !(')!%&&'



+, *-.,      + ,*  - 

/0  1  %)   %&&' 



   !  ""#

#"

$$   %  && '( # ! )#*+*, -

                 

   &1.3&  

+,  2 -

  &  !#!    4!!5  % ! &" %  #  "#/,6 #1++(/76 #1++78

)"!  ,9#1++(%55 "!: )#;<)"!= #"  )   " # = %  #! % "!  >#" 6"  # 5 >%%' #)55#!"?"?%) '# " )# 8

3#4"1++(%"!5"!)) # =##!  8

% ' #! = %@) >" "  #" '#!   )) #  %"!  !:! )" "" "  12 #4" 1++( >%=  # 5 #    !    %' # ) !#! ""## " :! "  " # # >     ?A: %' # ) " '"#! &"%  # 8

)"!  ")) # 106' "1++2%55 #%) ; < ### >  !    # :  !# # #!  , 9# 1++( # > %"! %' # 5"! )) #  >% #  3 #4" 1++(  # )"B %!?!  !  )"#  )"5 "' "!#"!>%' #!#!)C?!%: "#)# )"   !)#   '#!  !"! %)) #  #" ' # )"## ""'48 > %   "'! >  !    # :  #  #  "#  ' " ##>5 #> % #)"##!"" #=%  #!  %"!  # # #       5" 6" %)C?#  )"!"'"" #8

)""" "135!'" "1++2%"! #"6#!""#"##!   5 #' "":#"#) " #>  !#! 5 :!8

% ' #!=)""% # !"!)3'" 1++2"6# "" )"B ' " "'! > %"! %' #  # 5 '4  "# ##   ! 8

-+*   +*-

 /3'4"1++1 5 # :' "D": # 6   " ;<#"!' :"/"9#1++* # #! " 4#"   ###  #  > ## "  ###  "# ' =    5!!""D"&?A:106 /,71; <8

)!# " 4!)"E#" # :#  !#4 8

   "#  3, F /     :'   # B"  ?A: ; 1 1+< # 0*F / #F 4  "B:# D@!#      :'   # B"  ?A: ;11+F+/<!  )" )""' D":D@!#  



./00,.1++2  &*.3&   # # 5!!" )'# C#" ##>!   #"# 6"  '# " # 5 # )"' D)) # )"B "# :!!"D8

D !  )#!  6"  = " "       #  ;"#F*7 F /     5!!" "  )"#  :!!"  " #  "   G H<8

!" # '#C#"" )#"" "6"! =D""= "=)# =")"!##  )# > "  ;"#F*,F/ <8

D D)B  !  !:  #"# 6" )" 5"" )) #  # "" '! = !?!/3)#4"1++()##5!" /06 #/09#1++(8

 5" # B "  ##" &  >  D#  "# ) ##! & > D)) # 5"!3#4"1++(D#) #"'! !:8

D'"#D"#F3+F/ ! !:)#)C#")":!8

D55#!" #!" #@ :>"# #) #)C#")  )!"# )#)I#"#   @) 4  #!###   #  B" >  )"#  ?# ' "# # > D# >  # D46#   )"!"#!5  # '##"!5"; """ #  #"# 5'F1 "/,,/)F/7/<8

D"# ## ! )#)#C#""! B"@)# =  # >">!"## " #!#!)C?!5#D: " ! 5 @!;"#F3/F/ <#)"##>D"# ## # '!  >#  #"  D)C?#  # )"!#!    @ 6" = )#"   J !8

D  D: # =   ) #  )!"# ' @>   )# C#" !":! ;" )"  #" #!   #"# '   5!!"#  G H (+./,,(  F0F3)F*(28 $//,72 F18 $//110( F1<8

6" )"#4## 5"6"> !'!# @#""  " # )"!'  4 >  "' #  ?"   )?B" %# ' #!  % #!"! # >  % )# =    %@#!" "  5K ""! # 4 ;L /,,,//,<8

DD)B' " #!# # "#  >!"!   # :  "#>%"!" #95"")) # )"':""" #> ##= "# ""  =  )!#" )"   #  5#   #" !   )"  =  #"8

!  ")) #  #  C#"5 "!#"""6#!F



./00,.1++2  &3.3&    *  3 -2  *-.,      + ,*  - 



 4 0

/F !""""'4F

 4

1F "6##F

*F  #>)"!"#:"# #F

3F 5"  )"#    >D )'# 5"" "" #"  )"!# ""C#   !   *+ 6" B  # 5 #  )"B  " 4 5!!" ;L?M N"?5> ((++3  <)"' ""# B"" # )4 5"!#@"#F71 5!!"" " 45!!"/2 6  1++0 ; $<8  ! "  ""  #  >"    # 5 # O)"'#)"#" :#"""## "8  # C#" "!  " 4 5!!" )" '  )#  )" '  !#" > @  #   %"#F 31  $F  )"!# ""C# #  ) B  )   ""# '>!O)"' '#C#"6 #=%' F  :"55 B"  "! #I              $$ P" L  P

) 5")"!#""C### 5 !@)"#   >D=D55 5!!" )":"55





./00,.1++2