Contract Breach and Damages Liability
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose concerning liability for an alleged breach of contract, where one party claimed significant financial losses due to the other's failure to perform stipulated obligations, while the other party countered by asserting the agreement was void due to vagueness or that performance was excused by intervening circumstances and counterclaimed for damages related to the initiating party's alleged breach. The court reasoned that the contract contained sufficiently definite terms regarding the essential obligations and performance standards, thereby establishing a valid agreement, and found that the defense of impossibility or frustration of purpose was inapplicable as the intervening circumstances were reasonably foreseeable or the risk assumed; consequently, the court held the breaching party liable for the resulting damages.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Breach and Damages Liability: The court reasoned that the contract contained sufficiently definite terms regarding the essential obligations and performance standards, thereby establishing a valid agreement, and found that the defense of impossibility or frustration of purpose was inapplicable as the intervening circumstances were reasonably foreseeable or the risk assumed; consequently, the court held the breaching party liable for the resulting damages.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
&'( ) ) *+
+
!"#$ "
%!
& !&' ('!)' &'( )(
* +,- "
$., (/,-
, -
0, 111111111111./ /. 0123 !4/ 5
!$%6 + -
-
)22( ('!)' 3&'( '4 ! - . ,6$"
!$!! 7!4 /
!"!# $%%$ 8$ !"8
' 2! ! 5 999999999999 . , / , $6 , !:6: ; .; ,,./-;<, 5= .5=/ >, ?0.@ A 7 //.,0/. , -//-./ 9999999999995= B!::6A C $%%% < ,/ 5 5 5 , , = /,/ A D!E:%%8 > . 0 >, !4 ; ,= 0 F 5 $" F . ?-. 5 A G 5= -/ 5 H%I F F>5 5 ,56!F5 ,= .@ ,,. ,,5.,4% B$%%! 755G ; /,$$ B!:##$4C !:#:?;".7-$ 4H5@ $ $ ;/ !::# ,= / // - 5= --5 5 J // 5/-, / A , + , H ;/ ?; 6 .7- ! 5 @ /5- 5 </ ; -.-F / ,; 5-, 5;/ -F <= ; --F8.> -F?.7-$- K ; 6 .7- L 5 @ . ,= // = / - . >, 5 ,,A!%%I5 - -/?-; ../5- ,5!L B$%%%5 5-999999999999/5- ./- , F ,/5- .F0<@?;4.7-65@ 4 4% !::L,= / 5/./ 5 55. 5,=- 5 5 / 5 . .7 5 ,=;;- - , 5 ,= -8 ,5/?@?;$.7-!5@ 6 .. /5- , 5 !4 C !::: , /5- 5= 5 5 , +,5-'999999999999 /<M
!"!# $%%$ 84 !"8
! "#$%%& ' N?;!.7-!5@ " + /5 5 /C ,7..5 C<= $: B !:::;.<,= // 5/ .A. 5, , < ,/ 5- 7 -/<,=.,0=/ 5/-, /.OA,;;?5/- 5!: B !:::@ 5/- ; ,=>C 5= .. , <,, C . 5 A-C?-;P!#-85@ 7, !#;/$%%%,= //= - .75,= -8-FQ ?;6.7-"#L%5@ H , ../5- ,5, , < 55/ 5 . 5$% $%%%
5 , <,,,= / /C /56C !H;/$%%%-,,8- . ., ,,5 - .; . 5>5 - <F .,5= F -F,,/ .A. 5 ,
5 ./ . 85> , /A., .?;6.7-L%5 @ # , 5 !# $%%% , -// -./ 999999999999 - ;/ A , + < 5G 5 . 5 , , 5 . 5 ./ /-F/ 5= 5/; 5 5 ,= // -, 5 <,< -/ < - . -, -,,8- > 5 / ., , : !::: .75GF< ,#C !:::,, </ .7 F < , - 5 - 7 5 / A ,= A ,=, 5 - /<./5= - ?;6.7-L#@
!"!# $%%$ 86 !"8
L ../5- ,5!L !: B$%%%,5-999999999999 / < . . G- -/ 5 > 0 , - 5 . 5> -F /- . 5 , 5/., - ,.5-F 5 6AHF. C - 5 5 #"I , , < ,= // . -, , > ?;4.7-65@ : ; 5=>C- , , 5 ,= / 5/; - . -/ 5 , /5,, ,= R 5=> M N .7 5 5= / .; ,, 5 - 5 7 ?-8 .7S @ 5 4% , $H B $%%! - -- ,= // ;;-/ 5= 5 -75:C <5G < ,/5=75 . 5=F,?5H L B@5- 5 5-?,$%$! B@ 5G 5 // . ./ / .7 <,< C ,= / < 5 5, 5 A . 5 , - - G -,,8- .5 -;- /5- , 5 L B $%%! <=,, / , - . >,5 ,, 5 , 55L !$ B$%%!<
- . -/5 ,/ / >,57,!4 B$%%! !% , ..M N5!4.>$%%!, T5 - -,A , .>,/5/ 5 .,= /?< T ,; U M N@5 , --/- < , <=7-- Q, F, 5-7= //5 /,.5-F , 5. . . . 5> < ., 5= 58F / - 8 5</ - - 5 - . -/ 5 , / 7 >, G>,A., .0 5 , .7 - , /<,= // = . R . , - . -/ 5 , -. ?5/; 5 8./ . 5 , , !4 B $%%!@ 0 /-/ 5 - ., . -,7 , 5G . . ,= /, G.,</ M
!"!# $%%$ 8" !"8
N ; , T 5 ,/ < ,= / F ,, 5/ A !%%I 5 , V ,, < M ! ( N?;".7-H5@ !! ..5$%.>$%%!, 5/ 5 . .; ,, 5,= <,= //. ,,A., .A., 5
5 -/,. 5= , ,. <- Q, F, 7 - 5 -/ /,, , -. 5 / - ,/ $%%! =/, A .- D6"E%%%8 D6$E%%%8 D6$E$"%8 , V - / ./ , ,5/ < ,= / . / , - /8,A ?D6!EL6%8 /< , A , ,5D!E:H$"%. 0 >,!4;,= @, = /, - .5 ?;".7-#5@ !$ -;,=. 5/- 5!#C $%%$U,$!;/$%%$ C/, 5 55. !4 !: ;/ $%%$ ,= / 5/;// - 5/- 5 ,
- , 5 - 7 5=+ 8 ? C5=FS )> , - , 5 - - ,@ - -, A ,=- 5 5 / 5 . ., . -,7 5-, .; , <=A,= ,,- 55/. . A -.,- -, 5 ..M N5!4.>$%%! < A, ; - ,,, - ; ,<, , , , . 5> / .>, A !%%I A , ,= -/5=7-/ -. >, -, A / ,< , =/ . , - 5 -/ 5 - Q, F, 5=7 5 -/ -,, ); , - / < , , , 5 D6$E%%%8? ,$%%!@ . ,=.,= -/5=7-/ / 57 , < , , -,,- 5 , ..,- >, ,
!"!# $%%$ 8H !"8
75 ,- 5 7?-8 .7S, )@5 5 ! C $%%% 4! 5/-> $%%$ , , , .7 , . 5= <. / , 7 -;- ;/5/ ,5- . -/=/, , - ,-, A D4$EL"%8 . / , 5 M! ) *$+,*%-N < // , M ' N 8 < , - . ,, G./ 58, .5 / 5$!6I- G,5 5 G5-, .; ,- ;/ A,= !#?/ 5-..$6H#@ !6 /. 5$$ ,$%%$,= - -, C5-;;- ; , <=, =0 . , 5 =/- 5 / G>, . , ..M N57,<, T5 5B ,,/A-< , . ../ -. >, - , A , / 5 ,= // .,, -/../ /- . 5; ./ , >, !" -5$# $%%$,= / ./5 ,- -, 5 - . -,,, - /<,= -/5- Q, F,;
5 ./A F 5- .-/ 5,, G./<,. >,5,= ,, - ;/ < 5 - 0. 5 / F , .>,/ 5 , 5 5><,< , =0 . 5., -. . , / 85> M ! ! ! N <5> , - - -,A,= 5 55. >,-. !H /-5!LC $%%$,= . <, < 5/CA//5-/5 ./ 5$$ ,$%%$ !# ,5 - ,5$L >$%%$$$ $%%4,= / 5</ < , 5 ,= 5 , ./ .-/5 5 - 7 5= .. -. ' /
!"!# $%%$ 8# !"8
' )! ! ;/ A,= 4 ,45, , 5; , ,,= C5- ?@ 5 !6 > $%%$ / , ! B $%%4 , ./ - 5 , !: ;/ $%%$ 5 , - , 5 - 75=+ 8 // 5=;;- )> ,5-/ ?-; "H+ ,!, -F$@ $ ,;/5/ ,, . / / ,555 -- ,?@5H -> $%%% / , ! C $%%4 T / , 5;- 5 > 5. ,/ , 5 , 5 5 ,E -8 ,5/ ,/, C<E 4!5/->$%%$5-. 5 5/ ,E.7- ;; 5E .7 , C.5 - , ,/, ..,- >, - 5 -F 57,55-,,</ ,5, / , 5 ,E/ 5 ; < 5 O ../-/ C5< < 5 - /< - C5<?)D!$#+6H#- 5!!$H+!HH- 56>@ ,C5 -- , = . A. 5 - 5/ ,5;- 55 5 ,=/ 5 ; ./ A , 5 5/ 5 , 5/- , ?)D !$#+6H#- 5!!$!+4HH- 5!>K-;/ , 5. S L$ ,!@ 5/- </ 0 // 5 ,E / 5 , ,/ ,/ 5 - O G / 5 5 ,E - 5 C<E 4!5/->$%%$
!"!# $%%$ 8L !"8
4 C/ .,5 ,;.-. , ,,./ - - >,? L6 + ..,- >, 75= -8 ,5/. 5 ,= H: @ 6 ,G,. 5 , - .,,- 5 . 5 A 5 5 / 5 . , - 5 5 5 -, , ,E !# " - . 5E>,/ , <E, E0 . 5 5- , 5;;/ /5- , 5 -, E0 . 5 55 -,; <,E/ 5 /5,= / ,..,5=G- - .; 5 5 5=;;- 5 G /- , . 5 -F . 5> <., / -F,> 5;;/ -,E/ , 5, - . -/5 ,5 ,= / 5 -/ 5 ./ 5- 999999999999 / < . . ,, < A G F . C ? G H%I@ - 5 5#"I ? ../5- ,5!: B $%%%@ /5- 5 , , < 5 5 / 5 . 5 , -Q/ / ,/-,,8-A!%%I? ..5$% $%%%@
H ,=-- - , 5 5= --5 5 5 .5 .. 5 , , < 55/ 5 . <=A-,5/5- ,<,, ,EG./ - ;;/ / , -, - 55A. 5. . . 5 , , 5 - ; - < ,E A - 5 ?-; )D !$" + 4"4 - 54> --@ ,5-999999999999 . ../- , , <,, , - . -/ 5 , /5,, 5 ,= // . 7 O 5 -/ 5 ./ -F , - 5 , , < 5 A - / 5 8 5 , .. /. 5 G G - ./ . ,
!"!# $%%$ 8: !"8
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
!"!# $%%$ 8!% !"8
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
!"!# $%%$ 8!! !"8
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
!"!# $%%$ 8!$ !"8
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
- !$H %!- 5$-@ : -<- - , <, - 5/ ,5 5 -/ ,/7 /- . , . 5 -F . 5E , ,
!"!# $%%$ 8!4 !"8
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
!"!# $%%$ 8!6 !"8
C; - , , 5E ,5 5 D4#E6"%8 ? ,!::L@X66E%"L8?66E%"LG!"I@Y ,, A 5 < ., . ,=.,0 , $# !::L ,= / A, / /D!E:!%8. !::L. G 5=--. 5 $" F . ?; " .7- $ 5 @ ) ./A -/G-/A., . , ,=/,7 - /8,AAD4E!4$6%X?D!E:!%8S644 S$"F@G6!FG644Y-< -. 5A ,5D6%E#$!8?4E!4$6%G!4@ :6 -. 5 - ,5/- 5A G5= ,5/5 LIXZ?6%E#$![4#E6"%8@S6%E#$!G!%%Y G ;/ , 5$%IA. 5<,, C.5 -- T . -.,5A 5-, .; , 5 O .-/5 A,E > G5$"I 5. , C.5 - ./-/ ?. P :$@ . 5 A , 5 < ,= / . - / , , 5 D44E%668 ?D66E%"L8 D!!=%!68@ G5= ,5/5!LLIX?6%E#$![44E%66@S6%E#$!G !%%Y :" - -, / 5 G, 5, - [,<,, - . > -, A ,EG-- A !%%I 5E -/ . 5 -F . 5E , ,. 5>8 5- <E,G -, -F/5 , - >5E -/.,/./ 5 ./ A F 5- . < , -->, - ; .; ,, ..,/ W- G<,, ,, . > A . .7 /< , A-,<E,, 5 - ., ,= > -5= A /- /-F/ , - / , .>,/5</ 5 ., - ? !L ,! @5, . 5,= / ,-/7, ,; 5/
!"!# $%%$ 8!" !"8
( 0)!2 !&' ('!)' &'( )(
5 6,
! /-, ,-- >,K
6
$ CK 4 <=, =. .U5; 5C-K 6 ;,. 5-<E,,. ;-- ,./ O
5 5/, 5 4% C 57 ;- . ., - 5/ 5/ )> , ;/5/ , 5 - -F\]F;< H H%%6 G., 5/, . O ., / / 5 S @ 5<G - <E,,5/- ,- 5/> ,., - 5 , 5/- </K >@ G. . <, ; , . 5 5 - 5/- K -@ . -,, 5 ./ ,/ - . ,/,/ / // , @ >@ -@ -85 , )> , ;/5/ , 5 - . . 7,-<E,5 5/-, - >,/5 - -,0 5.< C < , 5/- </ ,E ,.. 5 , <,, ,, // G./5/ - ? !4$!%H!%L@K ./5 S ;;7S 8' 'DD ./ O - </ . ;- G . <=A ,=;;- ;/5/ ,5 -- ,. ,;;
!"!# $%%$