Fraudulent Misrepresentation and Damages in Financial Transaction
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered whether certain actions and communications constituted fraudulent misrepresentation or negligence leading to damages related to a complex financial transaction and subsequent restructuring. The trial court had previously found liability based on misrepresentations regarding the value and structure of assets, which were allegedly relied upon by the plaintiff. The reviewing court affirmed the lower court's findings, reasoning that there was sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that material misrepresentations were made and that these misrepresentations directly caused the harm claimed by the plaintiff, thereby upholding the judgment for damages awarded.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Fraudulent Misrepresentation and Damages in Financial Transaction: The trial court had previously found liability based on misrepresentations regarding the value and structure of assets, which were allegedly relied upon by the plaintiff. The reviewing court affirmed the lower court's findings, reasoning that there was sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that material misrepresentations were made and that these misrepresentations directly caused the harm claimed by the plaintiff, thereby upholding the judgment for damages awarded.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
'()*+'(,,- '../('(,,+
! "!! !" "
"#01$ 2 3 .+ 41$ (,,+
! " *-* ##!$%&'#%(%% $#)!* *+,! !**-
!
. / 00 0 # ! 1 * ,* #*/23%'#!&4%&#%(%% %%
!! "#$ %&&
3(5%&3
!
%7 8 %6&$9!: #*;%:-<(''(#-! *=0 83;>=0 9#+! *1,,* * *# ? !-# -@! - <! * A7BC&''73# @<%D,)7 !-*)) !! :# !!* +)!:! E F#*6G!(''%#!! ! 7
(7 *=0 ! *-! G; *-*!!*)!:)-@; *. / 00 00 83;>. /97
D7 !!#-:!**!H *C8 9< ?, * !!*C8 9# :@!--!! *-! *-**%''I** !-!8A7B$C2''739#:* *C!!!*D'G!* *4D'G7
B7 %& G: (''D# ) ! :!- *) *! * !: 81! *) -9#+ !:*3-<3 #*H! !*HH17
&7 0 1H )! * !: !!# :! * *-! G;*;%&G:(''D7
$7 ! * D - (''D# *! # - * !!!# ! A/ 1H# ! !!! + : ! * * H H1# 777 !+ (4 G: (''D :! -! - * H * !J! * *! ? K*;- ! *H!*,, !!"*!*,@*,! * ! (''% *) * H !: 8: ! * *! #*H#*(4G:(''D97#:!* * -<# !3 :! ! ,,! D% - (''D# H! ! * 8 L!!9 : B3& ! * H *) *@ -< D3B ! B3&# + *) !1 ! ! !H 7
47 (B G (''D# = 0 !! * !: D% M! :!7
27 *-**0 #) ! 1! 6G!(''D? + -** *!!83;> 91HH<! *! ? ! H! ,7 %' G!# !! +!! -! -!) !<-!#,?)-<! * +*,,
5(6&4(''$ 3D5%&3 1-<*:*,*-!!#3!3L+ #*-*:* --7
67 *%BG!(''D#*! 8 !A/ - * 1@+ ! 1-!H9 ! # - *3!!# * #!!! +)<G!:-!#)@:!*)H-!,:*) ! *!:!! +) :!@1!+!,,! 7
%'7 ! * $ M! (''D# *! # !!! + !!H!!G***:* H-<3 ! :*HH17!!-!!!!3,--!# ,!!! *1@!1 7
%%7 ! * D' M! (''D# *! # - * *)*-!*0 # 1H#!- +),,!* !; * )*! !! !!7 ) !! * H * !1H H+ 8H * .9# + * H *)HH:! * 1!#*:!J!*-H:*!<@1H;# ! << * ! ! : )*!7 # ! !! + -1 !! !# - +)? )L! * )H# !! -1!*)*7
%(7 * *%$!-<(''D#0 -!-:-!* !! %B !-< (''D# !-! + !< ! ) ) !!!*! :)*!7
%D7 !! * ! ! ,# ! !! * ! ,- ) !. /7
%B7 * -*! * $ !< (''D# ) + :-! *)*-! G; -* ; * . /# * -N!:!E F7
%&7 L-H+*$!<(''D,,! *!A 8? *-* * - *3!!!9# : !-@H--# : )L! *) !1 <! : * H * * :! * <!!!!-!H,!,*:!**!* , <! *! 8,7 * * ! -; * ! * 0 * %( * -<(''(97
%$7 * %& !< (''D# . / ,- 0 + 0: - * ! ? ) ! * !! * ) ! +) !# E F# E F7
5(6&4(''$ 3B5%&3 %47 !! * (B :-< (''D# . / , * : *-! +# -!, + )! !! ! * * ! * ! * !! * !:7 ) E F + )! !! E F7
%27 !*(D-(''B#) <*-;!83; 9#!?+. /!*- ?@A7(&C(''73 *!L*-! G;8A7%%$739*%!-<(''DD% - (''B# : ! J! -@ ? &I *; % * -< (''D7 ! * % !-<(''B# H-!+-!*)*-! G; **%:D%M!(''B8!A7%4C$D(7398 5$(BD5'B3D97
%67 -J- G 8(D - (''B9# ) H = 0 ; * <**)1--#-!*-J- !!7
('7 D%-(''B#*-* !*)3:*! 7
(%7 ,L * %' - (''B# ) # , ! L * . / * %& !< ! (B :-< (''D# *+ + ) ):! G- !! )! *!:*-*7
((7 * %% - (''B# ) ,,! ? )! *)L *! < H# ,- -! L * ) ! * H !:=0 #+-!!!*: -J-:!*)7:!**!#:! ) ?H !!7
(D7 ) L *! !! * (4 - (''B# < +) ! * - :! * -* *; % !-< (''D# :H *(''%7 ) ;:?A7B$C2''737
(B7 *(6G(''B#,- )+)!*! --,, !? **%!-<(''DD%* -< (''B# : *-! G; + !! E F * %& !-<(''D7
(&7 !*%&G!(''B#*!#- *3 *. /# - *!#!*H!+ # ; : L- !! ! !! : - * !!!# @*- *L :3*3-<# @*- -!,- *L ! * 1+7 !L * ! * !: !! * %& !-< (''D7 @*- *L !1! !! ! !! 17 !! * , 1+ -+! !< +!- !!1 ,+7* 1+G!O
5(6&4(''$ 3&5%&3 -!! * !! < -!+ *7 * !: ) !! !-!:H<7 :!*) !!+ !!1!< *)B?$-7! !!!*!!-!1"
- *!!!#+)1H@1!1 +#<1" @1!7
($7 !!*%DM!(''B#):! )! ? !;* *!/# !A/@1!!@1!1
(47 * D% M! (''B# ) , * * ! ? !! :!# !-! + ! * !:# ! +)!!! *! # !!7
(27 D !-< (''B# . / * + *H! * *! *! L-@1!+*) 7, *)<!- *!:!!P *!*!!, !-#,- -!?)!7 D 7
(67 ) )* , ?!!G!7
D'7 *)**-!*(B, :(''&*:! # *-**+ +)):!! *- *@1!?!* !**!*%&G!(''B70- *!!!):! GH !! * -1 ! :! *+ + ) 1!! -# !! *) * * 3-J-7 )! HH ? !@1!*1L!?--+!- *? . /7
D%7 * )* *)+J! * D% - (''&# *! *+ ! +) * H H1 :! - :* ,--! : * ) ,! * (''%# - * : ,!7-<):! : *,!7* -< :! ! ! !! !! !G ! !! * !:7 * H ) !! :< *H17 @*-*L:!* !!H !@1+7 !! !! : @1!7 ,# ! ! - * * *! * %& G! (''B# ! G! +) ! -! !L! * !: ! -* @1H+ +:!G!!3!-7
D(7 *(4!<(''&* **-*#*! # @1! ! @1!1 # -*! *! # !!! + !! 8L- %% - (''&9 :! * !:! ,# * - N ,,! *) !< * , !# * ! -@ : @*- -!+
5(6&4(''$ 3$5%&3 3%' A DD7%%# E F8,7* 97
DD7 * )* *)+J! * (% :-< (''& *:! # *! ,- ! * %B G! (''B7 !! ,,! *)!1 ! @*- -!,- !! ! ; *!7 !! <+*!L< )*!!+)!!P * 7*G!,!?J!!!*!:7 @1!#@*--!,-:!*<;-!# + - * # :! * <;- @1!+7 ) :!!**!!*;1@!1;7
DB7 * )* *)+J! * %B , : (''$# *! *+ : : *-* ? # %% - (''&7 ) +# * ,,! *) !< * , ! -@7 *H ! *(4!<(''&#) !!,* !**!* %&G!(''B!**!*D'M!(''D7
D&7 0!*)L!<**0:- * H 809# * %B * -< (''&# !< *! #
- * 1@+ ! *!# ! Q# @1!# )L- * ) ):! - :* !! !P! * -!! @1+ *! ! * !: *<7 )@ :! *)! * !: * H * -!+# )! :! !*;!:! *1,,#?*!*1H **!# 1 !:*!! 7! *!: !! !;L-!*;)*!#,!H 7
0@1!+#L!)!!! ,,!@1!+7 0 ,*!!;*-#)!: *! *)! H!# *),,! 1+L+!)-* *7 L!! *:H ! *! * * L ! !+ :H# +)! ,-! , ) ! !! * * - *7 )<:! ) !! !1 !8-G 9*) #*!-!-! !!* -!!,#+ -:-! ! # L- * * 1<H ! * 1<H# !!,*7)L-+#**,,* !!:#:! H-!- :**-<LH*-G!*@-!O-7 -<! 1* !! !:-! < -H * ! H 7 # * *H+ -!! !1H -!!!*)L+*!-!!,! H 7 H * . !! !7 ! * * :! J! L+ ,<-@H7
5(6&4(''$ 345%&3 D$7 * *BG:(''$#),,!*):*! 83; 9 G! *-* * !!# -!, + -!! ,! -!+ * ) !! -!!# * P! ,,!!P-!!*<*! *!:#< +*-!*! *H:!J! !<7
D47 0! ? )! ,- ) (D - (''$# ) ,- ,# < * )L! <* * 0 * %B * -< (''& 8* !*D'-(''$97
!!* !! ,#,!*7
D27 ! * $ : (''$# ) ! # * !-! *)!# *-* * (D-*:! #-!!*)J!** < *,!*($M!(''&8*!* ,*9#*+!!+ < ! * 83; 09 !! * - L:-! - !! ! -! !! )-< * !!!!:L- -!#+3!,,! -*: -L*!* 7
D67 GH-! * (2 :-< (''$# * *-* ! * !!7
B'7 :!#- -*%$M!(''$#) ,- !*:! 0# ! ? + . / ! *- ? : A72DC&('73# !!4('*-! G;?A7%%$73#! J!-@?&I) *; % * -< (''D7 !-!# + )! * * E F*:! 8 5$(BD5'B3D97
B%7 * %D !< (''$# * ,* ! ? ):<! **-*#!!+ !!*)!!! -J-<G!7 H-!! *!** !*C1-7 0,*#G!**-*#,!!:+ * ! * ) !: ? )< *) -J1-! * !: :*!1") 8* *BG:(''$9:!-!!-!** ! *7 !# ) ):! ! <H! !! * -!! ? )L- * @1!3# !-! L--*!**!R*!!-;#L! -K:) * -!!+! *!:**-* !! !;7 *):!< ?) !<-!*,!8:! * )!7% * ! * !7 (2 7 ( ! BD 9# : * : )! *!: H #*-N3:!-! **-@1!+7+!!!<!*(B1-! + -* * *!!# ):! ! * -1 + :!<-!J!LH * **--H7
5(6&4(''$ 325%&3 # * ,* !! -!! - # !! + * !-! * !! ) :! ? A7 B$C2''737 ,# : *-# * * %& !< ! (B :-< (''D 8,7 # S((9# )L! *) ! * !: );# ) !! -! ?*!*!**-*!7
B(7 !*(', :(''4# <* * )!*** 8 5$(BD5(''B3D9!:! *-*?*; ! 7
BD7 *(6-:!#* )L!** !- *!;7
BB7 * !-!*(-(''4#*-**+ +)):! !* !*) *D'-(''$#) !! +) !!*)*:!#-+) !!!!!* !! * ! ! L!J--! ,!H : H-! * *) #+)<!!!-!!G**+! ,:*!:3?3:*. /7 *-!#* ,*!+-!!*0*) #*!!) !! <!# *; +) )L+! + 1H*,,1+!HH<! !! 1"!! )!P!*)! 7!#! !!!? ! #*; +) !! + *! :! ,- )< * !! *H!@1!+#+!:!*+ #*:! #+ !!-!*! 3%'ADD7%%+-!!!*) !< *H!*!<* , !-@7
0)H! * * *:! # *+ !! + !! *! + *! :! !!! ! * !:!!)#*-*:@!+#* ** **:! 0!!,#@!*) !* **!- *7
!- + ! *-* *:! J! L- : * < H!:?)!*H#!:*< H!* G*<-!;*) 7
# # ,-! * )!7 % %# + . / @! )*-! G; + ) !! * )! < * !:# *:! -* -- ! * !: * ++ !:! # - -- ! !!*!:#*-N) (*!!*!!!? )! *!:!7
5(6&4(''$ 365%&3 0<*-!# *-* ? - : *) L!
- *!!1@++@1+#,*)!!!! * !:*! *!H7
B&7 <:! * ( - (''4# . / )! )! , ? *! !7 + )L! * 0 :! +*-* !!!!-!<*!:#!< -!++@1H+7*L!!* -J-+**!#+:!?)< * ! ! * *! H! ) 8*! )L! !! !! 9!)*!:%&G:(''D7
B$7 &G(''4# <,- !+ !!H* ?GH7
!
%7 )<G!*!H!!!!!:L- -! ?)3-* :, * )3-** %2 - %66B 8 9# H;-! )! * !! *) ! * H * * ,*# * ! + < * ! -! -! - !! !! ); 8,7!7 &$ 7 % !7 17 ( R 0 * (( G: (''4R 5D$D$5(''$R * ($ M! (''&# 5&&5(''&97
(7 C# )H! * * !- + ! ! * !: * *-**%B!-<(''D#*!?+0 *: *-! G;# ! *C !<# +!# . / ! !##*:**-! G;?!*--!3?7
D7 0 C!7 % % * *! H C *C*-! G;*-*** ,*8 *!(''% 9#+# !!! * - *# ) ! * )! < * !:# . / )*-! G; : * 7 ! * )!7 D 7 % # * -* !< *)!P -! * !!# ) *: : - *L *-!<!<:!*- *7 ! !! * , L- ? ! !- - * -*! . /7
0 7 B ! & # * :! ,!: *)<H! * ! ? ,!!!) !**!*-*#. / *!!! +7*:! ! *)<H!# . / ! , !;-! * : !!# ; :
5(6&4(''$ 3%'5%&3 :! ) < ! ! ; )L! * * +) :!-!,L )L !*<H!7
D7% );# , ! *)-< * !! +) ,!# ? *L ! *! !! * !H# * , L- *! /# @1!3 * )# ) ) ! ! !! * )!7 D 7 % # ? : -<# *! :! !P ! * !! ! * !! *C 8Q# Q--! "- *H!" T< * 1H:!H# :7 # 7 &&& R QUH# 1H:!H# > 0 5(# 7 $B$ 97 # ! * ) !! *)!! LH< ! G!, ) +) !!L -! *!#+:! ! *H!+ @*- -!,- *L V ! *H!@1!+80('''#7%$'*7B<93!+)@1! ) !! 7 ! * D' M! (''D# *! # - *3 * 0 # :! *) H-! ! +) !!*H*)HH:!*1!H?* !<@1H;7-J-#*! 0! :! +) :!@1!+!,,! #:** ,!* !!!- *<G!:8!* *%BG!(''D97
*-!# )!! ? * GH ! -! * : <! *) ! - * ,H! * ! :?L-8- -!9*M-!+)#-!,+ !!-*)!!! !*-! 7
!L!#;:#<*#+#*:!0 #)! :! H-! ,! -! *) * ,! * <!# @! !- -! -! G ? # %' G! (''D# *) 1L 7 !!!!!**!!< ?+0 -!!!-? !!*;%&!-<(''D8,7!0*%B* -<('' (97
D7( )! + . / !! ,* ? , * : ? ) V*M-!:!!!*D!-<(''B +*) :!,*)<!- 3#*-! !H7
D7D)@!!,*)L-:!!!+!#) )@!* !!,W !<?!,!**!8!72 -< L!7 $ # %'7% !B(7% R A*DM!(''4#B %B'5(''4#*7B7%R A %(4 &%6 *7 (9# )L! *) ! * !: );# ,- -!L* !:!7
B7 0G*#!* --<*!:C +#? !*C!!!?! #!L!:! 1<!!
5(6&4(''$ 3%%5%&3 CL + *C -; -! : + *CHH: !!7
8 A %(6 &D *7 %7%97 *--!# ;: +) );# !-!?)! !!+-<,*-*#)!7% -! )! * !: ? )L * !:! 1<!7 ! *) # * *- * C : ! -*# + ! ,;! ? ! *C:*! - * !1 +# * *--! * , * C ! *!*!8-7J!*(%:(''$#& 7%65(''$#*7 (7(9
B7% -!! ;! * ! * !: !! * C-J1-! ! * !-!,L*H *C! *!:RC < * !!! - * 8 %624 (4 7 D6B# *7 (<R 5($(5(''%97 *C! * !: * H * # ! <-!LH*C #,- -!?<H!**- *--H3+!H **!*:
8 A %(6 B$D *7 B7(R !7 $% 9# +C ! ! * !: **!!*C!:! ,#?*!+C* !-,,!!-!-!!*!:-*! ? !!*! 7
B7(7!X1*- *# G*#!?!GH-! C !!*! !?*+*+-!+!:! C !<*!:7!#* - *!!! -! ! * !- + !:L ! # <-!# LH * C 8 A %(& ($% *7 BR %%& %DB *7 (R %%B D%B *7 DR %'&%&2 *7 %97 * - * -!!! H -! !<G!:*7
B7D +:<!*)!- *#+!* !-!# )!+!!HL-!!!,!)<G!*) !*, #+ ! ,* * L- -!# +) H-! * !!L- #+)! ! !<* *8-;9#+*!*!L!- *!!,+ *)L!!<-!: 8 A%((%$'*7%! , 97 ) -! * !-! : <! )! )H * -@ * :# * H!# ,- *) ! *)L!#-<!<!8 A%((%$'*7%R # * :*!Y!<-H * <H!1 ,:1H 7(64 ! R # ,-*"1 H!1!H * 0 # 0 0 D(5%622 7 DD(!97
# * - *)!! * # ? : !--!)L-- *#!*L!G*
5(6&4(''$ 3%(5%&3 !! * !-# ? - + ) )! )! < * +! ! 1L * )L! ! * ) * * !- :! )L !*)!*)!!G! 7)!!!,* !! :<!*,!7,!,,!L-- *-- ))!1 +!- *!H!* ?3 **!!* **) :!1H8 $(65%662 *$!<%66297
&7 )-< #:!*:+*!*) :!*):*! )! LH +)! *,, ! <1 * ) 8 A %($ (6% *7 (9 ! !# +# J! - ? * *- * )*-! G; ,* LCA7 !!# ) :! * ):*! ) #!:-!*)! *!:*) 8* !*) *D'-(''$9*!7
!,# !! +) *! L !; G* !:<!8,7#SB7D9#!!- *,H! * # + ! : ? ! *# *:! J! -! : )! * !: * *-*# -J- !! + !!- *L7
$7 )# ! * ! *)L! <* * 0 * %B * -< (''&# !< *! # - * 1@+! *!#!Q#@1!#+)L-*) ):!- :* !!!P!*-!!@1+ *!! *!:*<7)@:!*)! * !: * H * -!+# )! :! ! *;!:! *1,,#?*!*1H**!7 ! * !: !! !; L - !* ; )*!# ,!H 7
-! +! G*! -!; 8# S B7D9# ! ! *M-! * ! !; * 0 : * * !< -!,- *L ! * !: * !! 8 A %D( $& 9# )L! * 0 * !;-! L !; ? , :<!7!!!*L!GH!*) * *! !:-! ? -G! * @-!O-# H;-! ** ! * * ! ! -!-! <: 8!*D'M!(''D9#+* @!!!? * H*H! 7!#*)L!)! ! !! * * * * *)! 8,7 !! * ? ) * (D - (''$9# * * *) ! * ! * ) * D' - (''$7 ,# C@ * *!:-!*H!!*,, !!7
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
!#*! !!!!! +#*! * !H# !! !! !!-! < * !: * * H 7 * ! ! !!, J! : !# * - N ! @1!7 )# * *! *:! # *! )! -! ? ,,- +) !! -! E F + * ! L< )*!!+)!!P * 7P!# *! ! - * !!!# + G!, *) : : :!#3 !!H -!#**!#?* ! !! * ! * , + )! ? *
8 A %(& D&%# *7 D<97 )G! + *! * #*:! #+)! -!!L!*!:! -*@1H++:!G!!3!-8#SD%97 ! !,! * *! * (4 !< (''&# @1! ! ) ? *-* * - *3!!!# ! :J! :<!*G*8,7#SB7D9#*;+ ! -!: ! * : !:-! ? )! !! * !!#<!?:+3,,!*)!<* , !# *-@:@*--!+#E F7 ,# !-! ? +);H *-*# 1H *,, 1+ ! HH <!
5(6&4(''$ 3%B5%&3 !! 1"!*M-! ! * !L!#* -N,,!!!!*-,!!*!<-!,- *L*H!+ );7
47 -K:*)L!- -!#! <*-! *-*# C! # ,! !! !< ? !,! * *! 8 !! *:> A*%(-(''B#Q%DB5'D#*7B7DR A%(B6B*7B<R A%(&%(4*7$5,97
27 * * * ! + ;*! + . / !! ,* ? ,!!!H#+*!G!**-*7
67 * ,*<!!H*#*-**- ?: *-! *A7%)&''73?!!** 8!726/7D 97
55555
5(6&4(''$ 3%&5%&3
& " ! "!! !" "
6$0
%7 *-*:<R
63
(7 G!!R
D7 *-*-*?:?* ,**-! *A7%C&''73#? !!** R
B7 ,- ! * +) :! ,- ! ! J! * * * D' G *; !,! ; * < , * # %''' 0 %B#,- -!L!4(*, * < , * *%4G(''&8 A9R- -**!*+# -!, ! -@ * : ! ! H! * ! * -*!R *! J! * < , * : ! : !+ L *! * C! B( A7 ! J! ! ; *!#:+ ---@*:#*:!J!G!? C:7
H,,; GH ! 0@: / = 3 ,-* !J!!!, L!+)?),,, * *: H,,
5(6&4(''$