Preclusion Doctrines and Prior Judgments
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant appealed a ruling concerning the application of preclusion doctrines to prior judgments involving similar transactional facts, asserting that the lower court erred in applying issue preclusion to an issue not actually litigated or essential to the prior judgment, while the court reasoned that the issues in the current and prior suits were distinct, that the specific legal question was not determined in the earlier proceeding, and that the facts presented did not satisfy the criteria for applying either claim or issue preclusion, thus affirming the decision not to bar the current claim.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Preclusion Doctrines and Prior Judgments: The litigant appealed a ruling concerning the application of preclusion doctrines to prior judgments involving similar transactional facts, asserting that the lower court erred in applying issue preclusion to an issue not actually litigated or essential to the prior judgment, while the court reasoned that the issues in the current and prior suits were distinct, that the specific legal question was not determined in the earlier proceeding, and that the facts presented did not satisfy the criteria for applying either claim or issue preclusion, thus affirming the decision not to bar the current claim.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the allocation of court costs in the final orders.
Testo completo
"#$$$"#%%& "'%&'"#%%&
( )*( ( )
+, $ ! #% -+, #%%&
!"# $
$
%% & ' !()*+,- $!" .$,/00
! !
(/15(
.)
,6 7" $ -.$!'/338$$ 9!. $!. : %: ! $ ;% < . " !=! * !6 >: $$> 9"$$ . !$" $ $$ +$ "$" 9$$$ 9 ??$$ "$$ ."" @ 9" :$A$B .$ :7$(@$C. :$$ ""6 .!$ ! = C7 "'$" - .$!'/3386
/6 :$B$$"$"7",D?":/335=$! @9$"" "$"??$": "!!">E>.." -?": ,,.$!'/3356
26 ,/.$!'/3359"9$".F %% &G ;(.FH<$$":!$ 9 !$" CI!76
D6 " /5$'/335" $B9 !$"!$? @9"$. *! $$"$@9$ !$? '"$ 9'7$ $.:$A$..@"6
86 -:!'/3359"?!"..$B$$ ""7$@9 :$"$"77".9$$ F:. " *! $@ :$J!B$$6K$"@9"$$:@99:$ .=" 9$:$"??$: $$$$$." "$$"!$"B .$ 9$$ F:6
56 "..$ 23!/334?!" " - :!'/3356
46 ,8 K /334 9" $K$" $ $$ " "7$@9 :$:L$ " $$ *! -.$!'/338,,.$!'/3356.7!$ "KB ":.." ..$$$'$@$$"$$7B 9!.+"$:$..@9:$JA$$". !.+.?$:!@ $$$." 9"$$$B .$ 9$$ F: @9 :$ . "@$ ??$ .$$ $ @9 !$$$ 9'"7@" :$?. @977B$:: !.+6
-6 :$"B.9$!" ". 2K$/334K$ 6
06 A$ $ 0M$/334 ' ". ." 6 ??$ /4 ?": /334 ' " :$ K7!$
1/2221/334 (215( ?? @.$!A!@$ ..(B:"$" 9 $: ??$? ( ; % /3-1/334<6 $$ ?? :$ "$" .$" :$ '?" "; )<6 A$ $ ,4M$/334; )
- ,5-1/334<6
,36 $ A$ "$" !!@" . ?!$ $ @ . D .$!'/3349$..$"BK$6
,,6 %"$"7 "BK76
)
,6 @$ !."$ ' " $ :'$" +$ 9$ "KB"$"=!". ' A$ $ 9$." 9+:6
/6 @$ .. 9$$$ @." :$"$". ( B : ." $ @ " "$" ! '""? 9 $$ $!.A$??$"B!..$!.$!!." $$ ( "$" $C" . ) $ ,4 M$ /334 $ @9 + . ." 6
26 :$.! ..@9" $B9 !$" CI!7 9!.$ $$:$!!$B." $$$ '"";$6-6,$6 :$6,2$,D < 9$(B( @ !$ " .": B $ ??$ ;$6 0 6 2 < =" $ *!!$:$"!B $$;$6,2 6, ::7 .,K$/332<6
: .": ' @ .$ : 9 ?$? $ 9!.+ $ $: K$ @ .! 977 $$!$B: K. F@"$ $ $: B ." $$ .".. @9 "$" "!$:"$:; /33,.6//-<6A$"$; ),2, DDD< ) .""$$K. @$@9@$ ." $$ $ $B9 !$" CI!7"$$ ..@9"$="$:$"!B$$ $." "$!$6 A$ ,4 M$ /334 ) ."" @ $$ K. :$ .A$ !. @9 :$$ :"$"??$:!$:"!!.!$@.:@9:$' $ ' "$" .+" "$$ !.$$ @ $ .: 9=??$? 9$:$""; ) ,4M$/334.6$6 6/6/N ) ,2, DDD 6 2 .6 DD0 $ 6<6 K$" @ 9= 9 $:$" ". $ *!!"$$ $B.$$F. "$ ." $$$ @:!$ 9??$?
1/2221/334 (D15( 9"$$.?"!$=7"!.!$$$' ..$.: $$ $:$" ."$ @ :!$ "" !! . !.+ ? $ . $ . B ."!.$ ?$ @9 $:$" " !B$$:$"$"="; ) ,4M$/334.6$6 6/62<6
$:$"!B$$?$$ $$$:$" 9" $" B 9'$$ 9 : ! B $$ . $ " 9 ..$ $:6 .. 9= ??$? 9 $:$" " ??!!$ $I'; ) ,4M$/334.6$6 6/6D$"?6$"<6
D6 =!". )!!9.F$$ 9!.$!. $ .$ 9$ $=$ ! $ ?: CI! @ 9$ . $ = .$$ 9(CI!7 $ @ :$ B .!$$ $$ $ = .$$ . ' 9 $:$" ! B $$ 9 " ??$ 7 9$6 ,2 6, 6
) ! @ 9= 9 $:$" ! B $$ .7!! 9.$ 7 .:$ A$ . "$ B $$ ." $$ !A! 9 ! '(? " ! B @ $ $ .C" . ??!!$ $ CI! B "$"7!C" $: $.$$ ?9=@ $C; ) ,4M$/334.6$6 6/68$"?6$"<6
.$ ' " A$ /4 ?": /334 ; % /3-1/334< :$ "" @ !A! " 9$:$" ??$: 9"$$ . ??$ .$ '7$; <$:B ! 9!.+ "$$ ..'6 ' " :$ $ ?$ @ 9" 9"$$ 77" B $ .' ?J .!$ 9$$$ 9 .!$ $ @9 $:$ F $$ ! 9!.+( .$. .$ $:!'??$. . !!" $!$ $ . " !.F$ $$ $ CI! "6"@ ' ":$K7"@997$. 9 $$ $: ?$? .$' 9A$ ="$" ! 9 $$ $: . @ 9!.+ . 97$ :$ " !!$"!$ = : $:6 "?$: ' " :$$!"@"$" .$$ $:9"$$. "$!$@$B ?=$ ." $$N :$ !" $$ B $!!$ 9!.+@ $:K@9B9"C" " 7". "$K$?" $$ $:6
A$ ,4M$/334 )"$"!$6.."@ "?$ !A! $$ $: .!$ 9 . 9!.+ !.@ ?$ : . $: :$ 9$6
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
$ )$!"@9+:$ 9 !$$@$$." . 9$$ : . CI!7 ."$$ . $"$@ 9 $$ $:$@9$ . ! 9!.+ .@9 "$" $: $$ $ 9'$ !. $ . !.$ 9 : 9$$ $ .F 9 $ !.+ ; F CC. $:@!'$<$@"!"$ :". $$!..9$$ F:=7?$ 9$: 9..$$ ' . B .$$ 9 @9B :" $.$ 9.$$ $:!B$$; ) ,4M$/334 .6$6 6/60<6
!A!!F )$!"@9.:$$.F$$$ $$ $ 9 $: @ 9 . $:" ! $ 9!.+ $ :K@9B9"C" " 7" "$!$. "$K$?" $$ $:; ) ,4M$/334.6$6 6 /6,3<6
86 9.F "$K. ) !O..L$@ 9" 9 ??$:!$ $:" @ ! * ! $ "( $$ !.$ . $ .": . 9$6 ,2 6 , 6 !.$B$"7 @9$J$@ $$$"$" " $ . $." $$; ) ,4M$/334.6 $6 6/65<6"@.$A$@K$"6
1/2221/334 (515( / ). )*( ( )
!
0 +
,6 $?B. ." 6
! 0
/6 K$$6
26 $@." $7$$6
D6 ?! .$ @P .:$ ?! $ ."$ A$ " 23 K F $?$ .F ' ?" " ;%CQ*C?@5533D <.: !$F $ .'?!"!$=$6-/ ?" " '?" " ,4 K /338 ; )<N !"! $ @ !$? $ !+ .:$.$7$ $ ! $N $ A$ " ' ?" " . : .$ . : "$@ = $ 9$6 D/ )6 ."$ A$ $ .F . $:@"!!!+ .: :$A$K$B9:6 7??F ." $ )) R% R
. ?! ."$ A$ $ $?" = .$ @P %"$$ 9$$B9"!.7??
1/2221/334