Statutory Interpretation of Easement Extinguishment
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute centered on the construction and application of governing statutes concerning the establishment of property rights or easements, specifically related to the use and maintenance of certain prescriptive or dedicated pathways. The court reasoned that the clear language of the relevant legislation, read in conjunction with established precedent, mandated that the prescriptive rights asserted by one party had either expired due to nonuse, been abandoned, or were never validly established because the requisite elements of adverse use or public dedication were not met under the controlling statutory framework, thereby affirming the ruling in favor of the opposing party who sought to restrict the claimed access.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeAMENAGEMENT DU TERRITOIRE; AUTORISATION DE CONSTRUIRE; CHANGEMENT D'AFFECTATION; PLAN D'UTILISATION DU SOL | Demande d'autorisation déposée par une régie immobilière en vue de transformer un arcade pour y déployer une activité de bureaux ouverts et d'accueil.Examen du plan d'utilisation du sol adopté par la VG qui détermine l'affectation du rez-de-chaussée de l'arcade litigieuse. Cette dernière, telle que conçue par les recourants, doit s'analyser comme un "bureau ouvert au public". Recours admis pour tenir compte notamment de l'absence d'intérêt public prépondérant. | LEXT.15; LAT.14
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
!"
# $%%% !"#$$%&'
'
& # ' & ( )#
* # *
()*+(
12 2 #3 '" "''% )/#)//,% 4" ' )135/0(6% 4" 72 82 2 9"(:; 4"< =" "&3 '" "'' "' 3#4# >? @((A '('3"##>""A#' %1/% $"1%'##:&% "' " (8'?2
' B 3" =C "" ' #": "& ; @((A 3"% >% >*" " "'%>*" "'% " '$ 'B A' ''" '('"'2
>2 4" ' "" '?""=3$).+#)%B4 >?% " 1 4 3"##> = "'2 'A" $$ 3#>'?B3 "&" 34""##'>"":2
2 '? @((A 3"##> " "A#' " ## ?'" '## =" ' $"" 2 ": "&" '? 3 $ % &'" 3 >"D' "2
)2 '& ,% '#" :4# " '" "$3 "" "''&":&9"(:;&"<% ' )1D"1-++98<2
,2 2 1)#")//,%3" "'=C %&" #"&"$&'>%#' "$='D 3 " '$'#8 #'E"&"" B"#$3 "&" '& >"9$< &$>?2
>2 8" B%4"'#'4 "' #'"$" ' 4" : # 3#4# %3="# '4# 9"(:; ' # <1,D")//, " '? @((A '## " ; F"G% F>? 4 "' & G% F" & G F " '$G% ' B A' ''" ' "$'# "=2
2 &"%&'D #'"$"%'&&"$&'> )1D" )//,2
'=%""' 1-'H )//,% # $ "& 3 '" "' ' " '"" " "' 3 " + 82
*,-.*)//0 (,*+(
02 ' )6'H )//,%4"""'##""' ' '# ":' "'9"(:;'##""'<2
> '&? '? " 3I #4 '##" '& >" @((A '& #" 4 ' &"#"" "$2 ' " "# %' ## 4B "#"' " ' " 3 4 J "'2
52 '" )- #> )//0% &" # B '&'" " &" '2 $" &"'>& "'')/ ' '>)//,2
62 )-' '>)//,%'"#"" "$&"$'## $ 3' '" 3 '4 "' 3 " - 8% '" = 'D ='" " "'>?$#>"2
&" "= 3 " # ":# '4 "'4"%"''="3&" "&" 3 '" 'B'" "'2
.2 " 3 1) #> )//, & '##""'%' = 4"' ""== ": " DB' " '?% ' " %1 42 I"'" 3 "'%& 'D'AA # B''B&2
+2 ""' -D&")//0%'##""'D '#' "$ = 3#4# 'D 3 " "=# '& >"% "=3" 34"" 3 "&" >? =%'K %&" "" $# D'"2 &" " =3 '4 "' 8 3 " &"4>"'$?:'"#"" "$&"2
""' ' "$""'##)6D&" L 4")+D&")//02
-2 ). $&" )//0% 4" ' & "> #"" "$ ' " ""'2 ' B ' "' "" =3 &# 3 =" >"#" '2
2 ""''##""' " >" " &"'" ""34" " # 2 '#> 4" &" " '? 3"% "' >? '& >" " @(( A%@'' '& " "'' 82 #C#% 3 "&" &"% " ?" " "$"" 3 $$ B "&" '##" #"" "&2
*,-.*)//0 (0*+(
>2 4&" "' >"" #= % $$ B $'" B " "' ' B >? " F' G% & ' &" = '' "## ' ' 3""%' ='L4"&" 3I '##F>'& >"G2
2 $"%3" "' " "&3 "+A"$$18$" "# ' " "'# "> & 4 " ' " "' '" "& "> '## 3" "' " " "2
1/2 '10&")//02
2 3#4# 'D &" A4# 3$$ "'% " " "4" = "' &'" " 3 "&" &"4 '&" C "#" B "&" >? '& >"2 % " ' " " #" " ?":#'D = " 2 %3 " BD " = # &" $3 '" "'' "'"" ""&3 '" "''4 '" " "'3 "-82
>2 8' 34 34" " # % " "' ' &'I" ' 3 " "#"> B 3: " "4"2 $"% "" '' "'" 3&" &"'2
112 )-&")///0%&" '>& "'2" 3: I&'"3"4" " # % #"?4' "$$ 2 #C#% 3 " B ' = ": "&'=" 4 " '" "& ' #C# =3 3 " = ' " '?2 $"% "'" "'8' " " >4'& $" # " "> ''#"=2
1)2 4"'$" &"'>& "'?" # &",/D")//0="I' ' "&# 1+ ,/'H )//02
)
12 D # " & D"" "' '# % ' &>9 256 '"M'4" "'D"""))'&#>1-01( ( )/5N 26,21" 2'"'#"" "&1) #> 1-+5( ( 51/<2
)2 2 3 "" "'' :4# #""'& '" 3 &"41 #>1-++2'4 "''" 3? "' &'" '##" "' 3#4# = " ' '" -#1-)-9 ? O10/N 215 ? <2>$""$"
*,-.*)//0 (5*+(
3>4$$" ' &"" ' B#" " "> 9 *55,*)//) 1. #> )//)N * 2 P2 5 $&"1--) $" <2
>2 "4# #"=M "" "'' " M$$ "' M " 10 " #" '" M" "' '" $M#4# " '"))D"1-.-9 (8.//<%"'" "' "A4#4'&),#1--+9)///2)/0)<2
2 8 ' '>D "$ " 4 "' $ > A # " '> % '" ' "' '&% '" $'# "'>Q "# 9 21 218<2 #"4# 3$$ "' @((A"##>" 1B5&"9 2+8<2 8 "&" &" "$$ 9 2 ) 8< =3" '# B 4# "'"$$ = B' "' B3$$ "'28" 4# '# ' "' 3$$ "' "$$ ' I 3"##>''9 20B.8<2
,2 2 3 " + " 1 8% 1 B 5% A4# 3$$ "''?%$@((A' "?4'& >"& C $$ B>?$# >"2 "'" "'&"'? ">3A4# 3$$ "'% 'DB "">2
>2 8' D"% 4 3$$ "' 3 #4" B >? '& >" ' " A4# 3$$ "' "'" "'" 2 $$ %#C#3"' ">B " "# "' = "%>'& $&'" =3'##9 * 2P2" <2
3:%'D " "4"? "'?@((A(?'" ## '## $( >"D' " ( B F"G% F>? 4 "' & G% F" & G% B F " '$G""=3B'?BA' ''" "$'# "=2 $'# "' 'D ' " ' A4# 3$$ "' '?2 B #""3 "&" &"4' C "#"B "&" >?'& >"=" '#>" ''' 3 "+82
02 2 " ? " 8 $"" ' "' F>? $#G '" ' "' F'& >"G2 &? '" ' " ' 4# # '" 2 ='#' 4%8'" C " '$'## "" A"A" :42 8" " " "'' '$'#B:44"%3" : A'"" =" '' #"? ":% B 3" C >" AA
*,-.*)//0 (6*+(
%B "="&"D=B ?"' $" 9 72 )5'H 1--) $" <2
>2 3" " "'3$$ B>?$#>"%$@(( A' "?4'& >"%$" ' F&" " #' G% ' " #"$ # > 3" C >"% "" @' $= "# 9 *55,*)//) " $ " <2 " C 3''B""&' (="M""> ''#"= =4 "3 ").") ' " "'$ '$ "'"1+&"1---9 2$2O81/1<(B'&'"$$ '?B &"# "%' ## '#"?&'" " : "' 3 4 '$ "" = 3"#' $ &" = $$"A ' "& ' ## ? # B&'B'234"'3?#"3"I" C >" ' B='" " # $$ B>? '& >"'" "&" =3' ="$"#"? 9#"" "& '##"<% =&"4' '" C #"2
2 4% ">D4=3'>"4 "'"#'B'" 'I# 3$$ @((A ' "##> B '## " ''" B" C >"' &"'" "" '' "'" % '= 3"##> '&" ' " 'E '" = 3 "&" 2 '## I ' " 4& "$$" % ' = 3" "' 3 "&" #"" "&% 3'>3"4"% " '">9 *822 21/' '> 1--/<2' #C#' "'%34" 3#""?3" ' >" ' B34$= 9 72" <2
3:%&" "3" "4"3'& 34 "A#' ' AA"2 ?' $= " ' " 3I ' "&" '##" " 2 ' '" ' '" ' " ' " J"4 "&% =" '# "2 3"% "#: '"% == @((A ' $$ B "&" '##" '& 3' I '& "# "##>3A>" "'2
'##&"(%3 "&" &"4' #"? &"B $'" ' DB " 4" 9>" "$< 4 "'3 # B& *''&"">3? " 9>" ' "$<2 '" ' " B "# "' = " =" "?" % 3$$ "' '? ='A" ' &" ' " ' "> B "&" "&" ' =" '# ' ## "$( %"4 AR % 4 &'I4% "' "'&A" ''"$$2
*,-.*)//0 (.*+(
3A'E:& &4&"'4# %3 "&" 4" "##'>"":" " : 'D'42 % "> '":=3" "' " ' "'F>?'& >"G% % '' #"$ # B " C >" ' % " ? "' $" % #" " '# &' "' R " " Q="2
&=":%3 'B ' = "%'##""'% ' '" = 3 "&" &"4 ' '? @(( A '#>" ''3 "+823#4# ''"" '$'# B ": "'" "'2 #'"% $" 3 'D '#" B " "'% "> #"" "$ & '" # % = & ' " 3 '" "' $'# 3 A4 = ' "" "''?&C '$'#'D '"2
52 3" " "4% "3I " 3?#" & 4"$ "&'=' 2
62 ' #"2 "#" ' SP 1M5//2( 'B' %BA43 :&9 2+. <2 TTTTT
+ ) '
,-./!0"1
&> ' " D ). $&" )//0 4" 72 82 2 ' ""' # M#4# % M="# '4# - D&" )//0N
./21
3# N
"&" # B "&3 '" "''"" ' "3 A4= ' "" "''?&C '$'#'D '"N
'B' "#" ' SP1M5//2(%BA43 :&N
" =3"3 L3#'# N
*,-.*)//0 (+*+(
'##"= C B ! "# $$% &' ' % # M#4# %M="# '4# B&":&2
8"4 ; !# '&I% " % !2 IA:% !# S"% !2 A"% !# '% D42
'# "> #"" "$;
4$$":(D" ; &"(" ; 2"'8"4" 2'&I
'"'$'# C '##"=? "2
:&% 4$$":;
*,-.*)//0