Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/675/2005 • CJ GE ATA/675/2005 Generato dall'IA

Goods Non-Conformity and Contract Damages Dispute

Numero d'incarto ATA/675/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute centered on a claim arising from a business transaction involving the delivery and acceptance of goods, where the claimant asserted non-conforming goods resulted in damages, while the respondent argued for compliance with contract specifications and proper rejection procedures, or alternatively, that the claimed damages were not foreseeable or causally linked to any breach. The court reasoned that the evidence supported a finding that the respondent failed to deliver goods strictly conforming to the contract specifications, which constituted a breach, and that the resulting economic losses claimed by the appellant were a reasonably foreseeable consequence of such non-conforming delivery, thus upholding an award for damages while setting limits based on the specific contractual terms and established principles of causation and mitigation.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Goods Non-Conformity and Contract Damages Dispute: The court reasoned that the evidence supported a finding that the respondent failed to deliver goods strictly conforming to the contract specifications, which constituted a breach, and that the resulting economic losses claimed by the appellant were a reasonably foreseeable consequence of such non-conforming delivery, thus upholding an award for damages while setting limits based on the specific contractual terms and established principles of causation and mitigation.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
risarcimento contrattuale del danno difetto della cosa perdite economiche fine del processo invio di una cosa non ordinata elenco degli obblighi

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for ordering the Appellant to pay the court fees.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

  

    

 !

"#!$!%&





&$%!  '''''''''' 



( ) (( ** (( ( )+ * 





     !"# 

( 

()  *(+#,-./011211031 4444444444 51 6.7 3) 4444444444   8  9111* - :1;0  < :/1)

  11=6911*210>11***1/* 61*?@1,A1(++() =66291 *B1  (% /1 !&&'0 3) 4444444444  *29 11 = 691  1C/*1>0*1/*6/19B1/12151 6.7: 8($69B(+D')

!)  :1*6*6: 03) 4444444444=6=** 91.119B1)

$)   (D ?*/1 !&&'0 3) 4444444444 11   11   99  E0 -  C  F (&(     9G9 90 >  /*C1 >=1 11 ? =BA = H  /1)  > = 1**1'&I9"C0**1(((I9"C01*69 /1''I9"C06.*1=92*1*)

  +/1!&&'03) 4444444444G==1?1 >1  1  ** 9* 6  ?1 6 /1 =   2**0 *  !% A1 !&&'0 -  9 = 9  <J !K&&&)  1=61=9619(&A/161)

%)  6*6: 03) 4444444444=*91*((L!&&'6 *1)   1 6 =M.  /10 91 M61>1 /1 **  6*6*691M?06>1/1- ; /C;6*1)9621?:1;- C  1 N 1 *1 1* /    - ./ 6 E /1) O01A1BBI BPC16Q*1*29 99B=*>1611):/*C19B101616 9611/B121)

')   *11  (, L !&&'0  :   1*  691  1  6*1>91091?61=M./1991 (D?*/1!&&' 1*>=1**6/16*/1 B1 6?1611)

#)    *  + 69B !&&'0 91 91 -    =61PQ('69B!&&'03) 4444444444 *11(,L!&&')

 "$!%!"!&&' $"# 

  61M611>?1>=1/1962? - C  1N1*11*)6161M?1 1; /61C;6*10- C  106 ?444444 4444444444)

  3) 444444444466*-=12 1B6G1*- *6:1/11?12>=111P9119Q)

,)   $& 69B !&&'0  61  **   1  96167

 ) 3) 4444444444  M6* >=1 =/1 6 * =  91  1 /1 ?1 =BA  >=1 11 =M.  /1 >=1/1991)/1**6*-=*/12>=1*1 11691M?0=/911)

   /1 ** /119  61 10 91 =/1 6 B1 = /*C1 9*2*  =*1 6 C16*   ?1  =M1   6?1  1)  /11   /1 2**M = 2 61 C2.  =111 6  /1    6?10  *69=1-=196E*)

   *1 11 = 691  1 ?@1  /1  >  9>161G6*-*2=96GC161 C:1)

   10 3) 4444444444   -  *1   *   9 =111  1 -  *  1 910  6611  =1 (# 1* !     1 ?**   11 1.  (! *9B(+'D5 R:,%()&( /18)

 B)   : 0 1  M6* >=1 =211  ?? = 1?1 2/ O111911916*1910 *9E**6*-=96=M./1) 

( * 

()  A*  96 1 /  A111 96*0    /B5)'# 1K211A111!!/9B(+%(    !&'S)#$)(1)16*9111/(! 69B(+D'    '(&8)

!)  991  (D ?*/1 !&&'0 =1?1 BA   6* 6* 9B61611/ 0/1261( A/1!&&')  "$!%!"!&&' %"# 

$)     =1 (#0 1* 691    !  0  691  11*6 *19191199-1>1/1* 2/9.211)

  C 1 6  12M   9> 0  6110  12M?1M/19M195)!,)( S(#!!= 12111.'69B(+,+R:S J(&D#!8)

  1-/1*6''I9"C1*0 /1*16116*1*)

  *69/1=6*S=961 1 >=1 1 G >1?1* =1?1 2/0 O  1  691  101111:1=*91191 91)

%)     6*/   B1 60  ? * 1*- C  1>=1CB1-:1;) ?1/1O >=1 *1 9  A  =1?1  >=1 /1   C;  9*1)

  B16=1**01>=161G61 960  1 G 1/>* - =*2 = 9 =111  1  :1  > =1** CB1  J  >  ?  1*9G96E) M1/1*6?161/ 0*:109116B1 1 196*1M >=1 11 =1* 9111/  =1*  A29-*1*=9=1111:10 91?>=1E1661166611*)

')  9610=*1>910=*91199*2 =1(#1*! )

   E  1  */  9  1  691  1  =1111:1=* 1919M >/1->6*1O   M 9 9111/ 6*1*0 91  6C  191 ?1M* 6  A16) 0  1  /11 2/  .2   11 1. =661> . >  *69   /1 1*  229*1!'I9"C)

  =6.01- B16*1 0 >=1A1?11=*91199*2) ?1M* 1-1>910: ?1A21B*=66*11> 1O1B**11>*1G?19*)

 "$!%!"!&&' '"# 

,)  3 ?*0    A*)     61/*   61B11*1:16*1>910>=1*2119 9E  691  1 >=1 1  ** *1/* 6  1* ?@10 /1  9E   691  1 C/*1>0 6  >=1  *1M961)

  ?1G*- <J$&&) 6611=1D, 1*691 ) TTTTT

,  (*  (    

-./0 #!1

*/B1A*('69B!&&'631 4444444444   *11  /1  9B1    /121  (, L !&&' 1 11  ?1 2   691  1 *2   11 1 61>91S

/0&1

AS

9-C2*99 <J$&&) S

1 >0 ?9*9 M 1 +,  1/   1 ?** K211 A11106*G6G6*06/119111?0   A .  1?110 6 /  1B ?**S  9*91  111>1091?9E6/612 91S11G*1M96191 1B ?**0 (&&&  (%S  6* G   61.  61  01/>*999E6/01/GA1-K/1S

991>  6* G - 31 4444444444 11 >K /1  9B1/121-K??1?**-)

:1*27 39/E06*1033)EC.0 C*10A2)



 "$!%!"!&&' #"# 

9 1B9111?7

2??1. A1A)7  /1 6*17     3) 1 )/E   

61?9G**991>*M61)

 ./0  2??1.7           

 "$!%!"!&&'