Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/672/2005 • CJ GE ATA/672/2005 Generato dall'IA

Waiver and Confession Admissibility Following Illegal Stop and Unmirandized Statements

Numero d'incarto ATA/672/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The appellant challenged the admission of certain evidence, arguing that it was obtained in violation of constitutional protections, specifically regarding searches and seizures and compelled self-incrimination, where the evidence was obtained during an interrogation following an allegedly illegal stop and subsequent unMirandized statements. The court reasoned that even if the initial stop lacked the requisite individualized suspicion, the later consent to the search was voluntary and attenuated from the initial illegality, thus purifying the evidence, and further determined that the interrogating officers provided sufficient curative instructions following the defendant's invocation of rights, rendering the subsequent waiver and confession admissible.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

CIRCULATION ROUTIERE; PERTE DE MAITRISE; ANIMAL; RETRAIT; AVERTISSEMENT | Accident sur l'autoroute d'un conducteur qui a perdu la maîtrise de son véhicule en voulant éviter un lièvre qui traversait la chaussée. En présence d'une faute de peu de gravité, la seule mise en danger ne suffit pas en soi à fonder une mesure de retrait. Avertissement en lieu et place d'un retrait de 1 mois, en application de l'article 16 alinéa 2 LCR. | LCR.16 al.3; LCR.31; LCR.32; LCR.90 al.1; LCR.16 al.2

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
rinuncia alla motivazione perquisizione confessione indizio facoltà di astenersi dal testimoniare registrazione clandestina di conversazioni

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to order the respondent to pay procedural costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

  

   

 !

"#!$!%&





&$%!  ''''''''''  !"##$ %&'  

' 

( ) (( **(( ()+ * 





     ()*+(

( 

/0 !'# 1111111111%  1111111111%   '2### &  1111111111%/)/, # ($0  # #32#'##& )4' '5/6640

)0  7''#3 '2'5## 8'#&# '2'5#  &#9 #':#(;<7 =%' 3  2 #; # #'' #;0

,0   /> ?#  )..-% @ /A"-.% 3#  ##   &'#    &'#  9"3 ''  /# # $'*# #';&07 &#  # B&#'/).C2*"%'DB#8# ''&' @ 9"8#B&# #;&D# &# "9"@'# %@8#5 #  &  #0   ##   2E #  ' &"# D#  "   9##;  8##'&'#9"0

-0   ' '#  A ' '5 )..-   7 % !0 1111111111  ##D DB# '#  @   '2%   &"#  8#      2" DB#B&# 5B''0B#  # &'DB#;& &# '#9#& # D%8F%#&#   B&# 0&#  '8#   &#  9##; 0 2'#&# 92  &B#20

  !0 1111111111  ?'#  @ ' '#     #'  ' 2'$ '8#2 DB#&# '&'##''2#''#8'9'0  ##%#2# 88 &##D  &# '&'#   #22# 2    #F%  ?' '22  # % '  5#  8'#  B9#  #D  5# 'D &#     ' 0

A0  ##')/' '5)..-%7  #2#'# !0 1111111111 2'## #'3 #/+#,'# 8# #'' #;/625/6A>: (74-/0./=0 #  8#&#  9&2 '2'2# 2G&88 &#   #'#F#' 0

+0  !0 1111111111  '  #5 2##  #8     /+ '&25)..- F# #'D3#&# 22 8'#

7 0   # DB# B&#     % DB# '#   2'$ ))3...C#'2; '5'##& '8#' DB# B&#   B&# B#2%# 5# 9&# '# 0  &  B25  #'    '2   92   8#  D 

*),--*)..- (,*+(

8 $'B&#  DB&#' #';9# #'#2    B # 6. "#88 /  % # '  @ 3 #'   ##' # #9#%DB#'## '22 ##;2 &;0

40 0   # '       '2 #' '  /6  25 )..A0  '#'%!0 1111111111 # # B&' %"HD# B ' 8'#'2##0'8#2 2''%##   8# DB#'# &9 #2# &#   '#0&#  ##;&%&# ' # '8#%#  # '&' 'B&# 0 # %&2 %DB2 # '  # %B # "E0 8#%#'#D2#@ ''  #  '&;%'2  5'#'8#'0

  ' '&@'''8 '8  $'%)>'I )..-%##8#9 2 JK,..0('#8 #' F #,/#/ %,#/  6."#88/ 0&# $  20

  7 # ##'% #2 D #'B# %@ &#;&%&#  #  # &'#'D5' 9&0

 50  B#  B#%  ?9 9  #8'2   # D    # 9@?90

 ( *  /0   ?   2  # &   ?## #' '2  %  '   &5: 0A+ '#3'9# #'?###))'&25/6-/(  (  ) .AL  0 +, 0 / # 0    '#   ' 2##  #&  /) 25/6>A( ( A/.=0

)0  /?&#)..A%'&#'# #' #& # 2#  '# '     &#9 : )..)% 0 )4+4 0=0 ' 8'#%  # #'  '2  '#  # '# 9#   8'2     : )..) )4+4 0)4>/=%   #    9#   ;9  &#9  2'2   B#8 #'%8F #''#B;0 B '  ,/25)..-D#B#D ;: */4*)..A //?&#)..A=0

,0   '  '#  ' 22    2E   ' &"#  8M' @ '&'#  '8'2 F &'#       &#  '#  '?' N   F#' : 0,/ ,)0/ =0

*),--*)..- (-*+(

  7B9#   B  #' DB '  '#  &' @  '    @  # #' : 0 , 0 /  =% (# #2#D DB# '#   2   #2  F 9 D# 2   &#% B# 9#  '' '  5# 2 # B #0  2E #  &"# F#9 ## DB#  #' #22# 2   '22  &"#  2#; '# F #' B9: 077O*07 % '# # #'' #;%/66+ 0,/ =0

-0  ' 2#; D3#32# # ? '#%'  &#'#'# #'9 92 #2 #'#(0   2E #      '#'   & 3 #2 &  #'#2 "0 ' 8'#%' # IN 23&#   '5 88  2'&D % D3'   ' '   #82N2'# #'0

A0   8#9 5D%  E   9% ' #   8  ; ' D  9 #   N  &#    8#9 '2 : 0 77O*0 7 % '## #'' #;'22 #/6>-%' )0A0  0 ,/  % 0 /+>=0  ?# 2 % #&   #' % '22 F58# &'# "'##2'&D#%# ;'% E    '#  #'   #    '2' 2  #'# %# %5#  9F3  9: K/)4 ,.)=0   F? #8##' 3 2##(2N2#  #' 9: 077O*07 %'0# 0%' ,0/0)@3 0,/ %0/+6=0

   B;% B# #' '#% '  2'# ; #'#   B '( ' %B#;9#5#&# D'#' ' D#  % 8F%B&# ' '&'  8# 0 #'  ;  ##;  #  ' 8'# BF2   '  8 0 (# & ' 8'#N '#'22  9&# 08 $'B$  2  '2%D#'#D!0 11111111113 #  '5 3 &#' #' #2  ;9   #     3 # 6. #/ 0

  B8 9&# %2#988#    '# @ 8'  2   # 0 B  ' @ '  D  7   8#  # #'  B # /+ # ,  0  #  I &# B# )    #'# #'     '   & #2 % 88#  '  #' 8 9;0

+0  'D%'2#0B## #9%2'2   JK,..0(2#@"97 %D#'25: 0>4 =0  #2#    '  ' % D# B  #  '#'   0

*),--*)..- (A*+(

,  (*  (   

-./0 #!1

&5'# ? /+'&25)..-!'# 1111111111 ' ##'&# '2'5# &#9 #')/' '5)..-#  # '2# 2'#L

/0&1

B2 L

##' D  DB#&' '2#'#  2'#L

# DB& #2  @!0 1111111111L

2   2'2   JK ,..0( @  "9  &#   '2'5#     &#9 #'L

# DB#2# B 'L

#  D% '8'22  F  # 64   #&    '# 8 3'9# #' ?###% N  N ' %&'#''# 2##  #8%    ?' ;  ' #8# #'%  &   #5 8L  22'#  ''# ##D'#'%2' #8 2'$& ' #9  ' ''2 #L#'# N  '#F2#2'# #5 8% /...  /-L    N     #;  '#'  ' %#&'D'222'$&%'#& N ?'# @3&'#L

'22#D    N  @ !'# 1111111111 ## D3 &#   '2'5# &#9 #' @3'88#8' @0

7#9 < !2'&$%# %!!0$";  "#%?90

'2 #52##  #8<

988#;(?# ?0<  &#(# <     !0 ''# 0'&$

*),--*)..- (+*+(

'#'8'2 N  '22#DF #0

 ;&%  988#;<           

*),--*)..-