Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/599/2006 • CJ GE ATA/599/2006 Generato dall'IA

Contractual Liability Contingent on Third-Party Action

Numero d'incarto ATA/599/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute centered on whether a party could be held liable for breach of contract due to failure to perform an obligation that was conditioned upon a third party's future action, which ultimately did not occur. The court reasoned that because the contractual performance was explicitly contingent upon the occurrence of the specified third-party event, the failure of that event to materialize excused the non-performing party's duty, as the condition precedent to performance was not satisfied, thus precluding a finding of breach.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Liability Contingent on Third-Party Action: The court reasoned that because the contractual performance was explicitly contingent upon the occurrence of the specified third-party event, the failure of that event to materialize excused the non-performing party's duty, as the condition precedent to performance was not satisfied, thus precluding a finding of breach.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
responsabilità contrattuale parte contraente violazione del dovere azione condannatoria rivendicazione di terzi nullità del contratto

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

 

      

 !







"#!$$$$$$  !"#$% &%$ 

$ 

%&  & % & '''%&'  (') *& 

+

   &  %'% & ' 





     '()*'

'   

+.  !$#!////// 0 #12$##"#  $ $3 #  $ $"## # # #4# 5.   #   # 6"  $ #77    $  8%&  #$ 5  9"  #"# &1# :;# #  1$#$# #5#""7 $.

(.   (< $=  +>><& 5"##  #$ 1#  $ ?#'8 @ 5 A B  $ #1#C!.!//////7$ #1# #1$#$1#+>>(&C # :#" # $ #1#&+D"7+>><.

  8%" $4$"  EA+,5,,,.'&+>>>&$ 5#"F =$5+>>(5%# C EAGH<5G<<<&HH.

G.  +-"+>>>& C5## # #%5"##  #$%$#&%  !.!//////$ 1# 5$70 5$$ F$$  #$5#"F    #%##$ 5:I  1##? AJB5"##  #$ 1$ #7 #$&"$  0:5K+>>+'+>>(.

   :I $ # $ "" 5K# % $" $     $ #$  %# 11    $ #77 :# %#  " C I  $# $""  $1#$  $""  % "$7##8. 5 9%(>0%#(,,G&$  AJ :   #8  #  : 5 #%#  $L  !. !////// #  6" #""##  #$1$ #%  #   8 $""#. J56#       6# #  +>>+'+>>(&  $$#  :5#  $#   #  $# #$&  $ #77   L  $: #%" #%$:.

D.  !. !//////  1#      $7% #$  $     AJ  (< 1%# (,,G.  5 #   $   1  #  $"     #&$ "" +>>+'+>>(&#$$:#$## # %##$  K #$.

H.   G "7 (,,G&  $ #77 5L  $  #  C  $"" #$ : # %#   5 A &  (> 0# (,,,& $  86"   $5#"F +>>(=& #8#$ #1#$""" L  EA GH*5-*<&>,&  EA -D5-D(&<H $$  K # I  "$ $#& : 15$$# #$.

-.  $#+H"7(,,G&!.!//////#5 A %# K #$+>>(.

)(*+*)(,,- 'G)*'

  J# $ F AJ&#%# ##  #$1# +>>(C(,,,.&$  7#'#&1##   5#"$    $  K# +>>+   +>>( : #  = " 5 A  C $ $ " %##$#  #$.

  1#&#$## # #$$$%" .

*.   ##$  (+ "# (,,D& 5 A   0   "  %##$ $  #% .

   $  5:I     AJ  (> 0%# (,,G %#    $1#"  +>" (,,G& #  K $7% #$  !. !//////.   #  8 $ #$  7 :5C  #    #8  & #'# $##   "$ #1  %##$  "#8 11#  $ $%$# 5#%$:   #  $  0$.

<.  !.!//////%" #$$ # ##$ (G0# (,,D"$ #1:5 A # =$%#$ " $%##$ # $  AJ.

   #&  5 #  :5 "7 (,,G& $: 5"##  #$  $%$#%# $"#81$##6%#&:5#%#  $# $" $% 1$:I .

   K #$+>>(&%$# K #$ #&%# $: I  %#.

>.  ##$" #$+<"(,,H&5 A "#  K #$ # #6#.

+,.  +>0#(,,-&$!.!//////&$""##$ $ $  " #8 5#"F  ?#'8 @  $""##$B   #8"  7$   #.

  7$# #6#K& #1C51#+>>(   1$ 9$#&$%#  #6$" %##$.  &C   5 # HH   $#   $ 1#  D $ $7 (,,+ ?A# ' G+*B&##$$$$ 1$$%# I %#1% $ #77&C"$5$11#&$ "" $:1# #"$   $  % $   #  $% . 5K#6 $ :   $#  1# %#  K"# 5$11# 5    1#   #    #"#    :# ##  #$7 $"    #$ . 1#& # $ #   K  #    #$# #$ : 5 $#  5 #     %#"#$%# 1#.

)(*+*)(,,- 'D)*'

  $&$""# #$ $# 1#%$##  "   0 #1#  %##$  7$ 6%$# 8 $ :5  $# :1#+>>HC(,,,.

++.  (D0# (,,-&!.!//////$C5$  ##$&:# #    $ #1#  (> 0# (,,-.  $  C $  #$ ## :5C $%$# $" $$&:5#1# G,$= (,,-.

   &$ 7#+>>+ +>>($ # $   AJ (>0%#(,,G&:%#  $ "$# "K $#  $%$# 6%$#.

  $ 1$#&585 # 1# :5##  $$""$""2  $1#$%"$7##8 $ '"I":#0 #1##   %##$.   5 #  :5 "7 (,,G& $: 5"##  #$ 1# %$##%# 1#  #  #$:5#%#   #:"$ #1 %##$  #   7#.  $   "  %##$  +H "7 (,,G& $#  "$#  $  0$ 8 %$#  $#  "$ #1  %##$ # &#%# $6# " #.

   $ 12$&# # C5 A $5$11#C %##$& #:5#K# # C$6%# 7%$#%$# K #$&$:; %# $#50 #1# .

  1#&$$1#$#"" #8%#%# I $8 +>>+&:7#"I"&$$ &  AJ$ # C#$ 1#$ #.

+(.  5 A 1#  $7% #$$(- "7(,,-.

   $ "$#C #$# AJ+>"(,,G&$1#"  $$ (>0%#(,,G&!.!//////$## "$ #1%##$ 12$11#"" =$$%$#5#%$:.%# 5#$## &  $7% #$  (< 1%# (,,G  #  $ &  %##$   K #$ 1  $%$#.

    &##"$#7 #% "%##$%#  I  #& # 5 "#   "$# :  $# #$ 5 #   "#.  11 &  %##$  #  K"  K $: 5    " 1##  %$#  "$ #1 :5# #  0C  1# %$#  $ $##. &  58& $ "   $     AJ  #   1#  $ # C  $ #1# #$  7$ # #6#K "# $& #  #  $  "$# #"$77 : !. !////// #  7# "  $%  :5#  #   $1#$$""%"$7##8.

+G.  J:$# 6C06.

)(*+*)(,,- 'H)*'

' & 

+.   0   "  # %   0## #$ $"  &  $   %7? .H- $#5$6# #$0###(($%"7+>D+'  '  ( ,H M  . HG . + A# M  . H* C -H   $#   $ "##  #%  +(  "7 +><H '   '  H +,& #7  %$#  ; .HG.DA#B.

(.  +0%#(,,(&  %#6A#:#86C # HG   #%   $  %   #7 "##  #1. ; # <-    $# # :  86  $ :; $ ;#:  K  :# $  $    "$"   $    %#6.  #$# #$ $ #  ## :# %   6"   $ $ :& 1 86 K $ #&  $% 86 ;#:  C ;"7  11#  $& :  1#   7# $#  $ # $  #C$%$#. '# ###7;8? I  #7 1 ()D++)+>><   ( )H-<)+>><  G+ 0%# (,,,& $#. +,M )*G-)(,,G*$ $7(,,GB.

G. . J$ ; # HH # + A#&  ##$    1$   I  %#  1%  $ #77& C  " $ ;$11#& $:  1#  #"$  $%$ $ $% ? .HH.+ .A#B& $: ; $#  :#     ;   $"   1#  #"$   $  %$ :;$## $%# $N $:;%#$ :: "#8; 86  #$? . HH.+  .7A#B$&1#&$:;#"$# #1##$? .HH . +  .  A#B.  %##$   K $:  :   #%$:  "$ #1:;## 0C1#%$#$$$##&;#%#  1#  %  $   ##6 :# $%#  #$7"  I  K#6  # ? .HH.(A#B."%##$$# I $$  0$:##% $% "$ #1%##$"# #K #% $ #1# #$##$? .H-A#B.

 7. 5 $  : 7$  #1# #1 (<$= +>><& #1 C 51#+>>(  1$&$%#  " #8K"  K #$&5"%##$.

   58&  1#  6   $ &  #7  1$  %##$'C%$#5K# 5#"$   % $  #%#   $1#$  $""  % "$7##8 '& $#%  I  $# $"" $  #'# 8  #$  $     AJ  (>0%#(,,G&$#  +>"(,,G& C:&8:5##  1#      $7% #$   1$""  $    1    AJ  $"  7#+>>+ +>>($"I":$ #%# 

)(*+*)(,,- '-)*'

 $1#$  % "$7##8  #  ="  $  &  $# #$  5"##  #$1# K" $1#".

    #  ##  $  56# 8  5 A    $  0$ 8  "$" 'C& $ 1# %$#  $#  %  C  %##$&  :5#  5# 1# &   #& $  K #$ 1&  $   $"" %$#.    6& 56"   $ & :#  #" :  "  %##$   K #$ 6%$#  $%#  I  $ :58 $#$"8 1# % $%$#&$# I 0 & 5#    $ 5    $ C "$#1#  "  "#  %#   $     AJ.  $N & $""  8% C 0  #  5 A & #    :5#"$77 :  $ #77 #  O7# " O $%  :5# # $1#$$""%"$7##8.

  $7#'C#$ 0$&"%##$ +H"7(,,G # ## #% $0 .

D.  1#&56" $ $:5 A # =%#5$11# 7$# #6#K $"7C1K.

  $ " & # 5 #   C 5"##  #$  #  ":"   $  $: #'#& 7# :5L  $#  1#  $% 0 #1#%##$&#%$:#&"#$&# $  K #5 #HHA#&:5##$$$$   1$   '   $ $#  ' I  %# 5$11#  1%  $ #77 $:5 $%   1# .    6& 5K#6 $ :   $#  1# $#%  K"# 5$11# 5    1#    #"#    :# N #$7$"  #$ ."  ##: 5"##  #$ $   1   %  "$  5K#  5"  #"$7& # :5# #$"7  $ #77  0 #1#  1#  :# #  $  #6  $ $7#6 #$ 1# ?P.  J& $#  1# #&(8"# #$&Q>.DG+B.

H.   #8" "1$&$0 .

   "$"   EA +5H,,.'  "# C  96  $  :# $"7? .<* B.5## #6&##$5#"# .



RRRRR



)(*+*)(,,- '*)*'

*%'&  '      

,-./!0

%7$# 0 (D0# (,,-!$#!//////$  ##$$""##$ $$" #85#"F +>0#(,,-M

./0

0 M

" C96$ "$"  EA+5H,,.'M

$""#: I C!"#$% &%$ $ ##:5C $""##$  $  $  " #8 5#"F    C 5"##  #$ 1#  $.

J#6 @ !" $%L& #  !. L98& !" E#& !. 9#& !"$& 06.

$" #7"##  #1@

611#8'0# 0.@  %#'# @     !. $$# .$%L  

$#$1$" I  $""#:K #.

 8%&  611#8@           

)(*+*)(,,-