Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/598/2005 • CJ GE ATA/598/2005 Generato dall'IA

Taxation Challenge to State Fee as Unconstitutional Tonnage Duty

Numero d'incarto ATA/598/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Spese processuali a carico del ricorrente / reclamante

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party challenged a statutory provision that levied a tax on certain activities, asserting that the levy violated the state constitution's prohibition against duties of tonnage, arguing the tax was functionally a charge for the use of port facilities based on vessel size, which is the definition of a tonnage duty. The court rejected this argument, reasoning that the challenged charge was a fee imposed on the privilege of engaging in regulated commercial activity within the state's jurisdiction and not solely a charge related to the vessel's mere presence or loading/unloading capacity while in port, thus distinguishing it from the prohibited duty of tonnage.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

PROFESSION SANITAIRE; AUTORISATION D'EXERCER; MEDECIN; DECISION; JONCTION; COMPETENCE; ASSOCIATION; QUALITE POUR AGIR; INTERET DIGNE DE PROTECTION | Recours de la fédération suisse des assureurs-maladie contre 23 arrêtés du Conseil d'Etat délivrant à 23 médecins employés par un établissement médical assurant des soins d'urgence 24h. sur 24h., l'autorisation de pratiquer la profession de médecin à charge de l'assurance-maladie sur le territoire du canton de Genève, au motif que ces arrêtés violeraient l'ordonnance fédérale du 3 juillet 2002 limitant l'admission des fournisseurs de prestations à pratiquer à la charge de l'assurance-maladie obligatoire. Recours jugé irrecevable, faute de compétence du TA pour statuer sur des recours fondés sur des violations de la LAMal ou de ses ordonnances d'exécution. Transmission de la cause au CE, autorité compétente pour statuer sur opposition. | LPS.5 al.1; LaLAMAL.3 al.3 litt.b; LPA.70 al.1; OLFLAMal XX; LAMal.55A; LAMal.36A; LAMal.36; LFPM.1ss; OJF.103 litt.a

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
imposta sul tonnellaggio obbligo di motivazione disposizioni fiscali accise divieto legale addebito di tasse

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

  

   

 !"





 # 



$%"&&&&&&&&&&'&&&&&&&&&&' &&&&&&&&&&'(&&&&&&&&&&')&&&&&&&&&&' *&&&&&&&&&&'+&&&&&&&&&&',&&&&&&&&&&'&&&&&&&&&&'-&&&&&&&&&&' .&&&&&&&&&&' &&&&&&&&&&'&&&&&&&&&&'/&&&&&&&&&&'&&&&&&&&&&' &&&&&&&&&&'&&&&&&&&&&'0&&&&&&&&&&'1&&&&&&&&&&'&&&&&&&&&&' &&&&&&&&&&'2&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&'  !! "#$%



1 3#  



     &'()*&

 

)/  00 "!1 1! %1 0/ / 21& 34 00 "!15$ 1 6+$  17%83%$!91:; 8<6):!1$#1    11    3%  %1  1 :!1= >;,<,'6?'6/

'/  1!!   1 >  :: !91: :!1    >1 '     1  @=1  A1   !$  !91: :!1=  1%  1  :1 :!1  )) :1 ') 20 & B + *.5$ 00 "!1  !! :1  9!!A1 > 11 >= 1!1%! 1!C%:9'/ 11!! %!.%:9'+/

+/   %1 >1%1!  :!1 %1  >!91: #1$    $ >  #1 >11   1# 2'+ :!15/ 0  :!1 D !;:$ 8 E!   1%1!  >!91:$  1%1! 1! $ !1$  $  9!!A1 > 11 !1%!  1> 18= A1811! 8?;>&:12)C:!15/

6/  :!111>11 1#811! 8 ?;  >&:1 1   3  1&:1 ::9  0!1 27!!1 1  &:15 > F !1 G  #  : 911!  ?1 H     1%1!/00"!1$'+:!111> 11   1# 8 ?;  >&:1 A1  1   !A!   !1  :!1 !   >!91:2!1;95/

./   D3: !1 :1  0!1   1&:1 ::9  >11<:9!!% 1A!  :!100"!18!D3:/ 

-/   6 <1 ''  !  %1; > A!!  + <1 ''1:11>:11A1 18 1#8 ?;  >&:1 91;1$ 1 F  91G  F >;G 21& 34 > A!!5/      AA  9# 8 3%  !1% >11  1# 8 ?;  >&:18%=:!1$#A1=! ! !<81/

 ('+,-('.   &+()*&

,/  >!  %1;    >  :1A1!  1#  0!1 8 >!;  00 "!1/  1&:1 ::9  >111!8:9! 11 !  >!91:/

C/  A1$:'6$0!1?1!:1A1 1#/

  1!1!:100"!1::F91; G 1#:!1%1I9!!A1>11   1# 8 ?;  >&:1/  % #1A11 %1  AA  A1   6) :!1  >!91:     # = A1=!  > A!!/  1A:1 00 "!1 #>1%11::98 :9 1:!1  1   > 11   1# 8 ?;  >&:11111!1 A1/

J/  0>  1%1 1%    !?;  %  00 "!1$0!1$! :>11!>AA1 A!!! 91#/11;> %!1/

)*/   : '.$ 0!1  !11!   !1 ;9  >!91:$!##1::9>  1?; 1 1 !   '+ :!1  >!91: #1  1 1  >11  1#8?;>&:1/

))/  11!!A1;!!$ 300"!1 #   1$ #1   1  >%1  !! 1A:!  >!91:#1 1;! 1&1>!1 :9!/

)'/   #I  '+ :1  + <1 '.$  1&:1 KLLLLLLLLLL  1! 00 "!1 %  19 91$  A1   ?12:9! 115A! 00"!18=   !$  :1A #  :!1 %1! >!1  11 > 11  1#8?;>&:1>%1 1A:! 111/

   !: %<111/

)+/  A1  ;1  %  91    1 ;%1  :13  :!1 :91 >;$  1 >   !1%! = '+ :!1!$ I!+*:1'.=!19$  11   1#  A1  :!1 8 1 1! $8?;>&:1$1:1!=1 1;!  : >!91::!100"!1/



 ('+,-('.   &6()*&

)6/   >;1   LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ MLLLLLLLLLL$ NLLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ OLLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ KLLLLLLLLLL$  PLLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$  LLLLLLLLLL$ BLLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$  LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$LLLLLLLLLL$"LLLLLLLLLL$LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL$

)./    ! !  6 <1 '.$ 1;!  "1 KLLLLLLLLLL$ F1 <11#   !;1 G$ 0!1    3  19:111A?I!/ 81 #111>AA 1A/

  !1%9$ 1%: !#  #1!  ;1  0!1$ #1 !1 ?! 1:   11!1%!/

  0  A$ >:11 1 :!1 :: A1  18?;>&:1%111A!!@& :1)C:)JJ62 "&0C+'/)*5>=!1/

)-/   1 > $ 1  1  ! :  >1 1    !$ > !:1!   : !  19  !    #I >AA  1A  '- <1 './   8 >1%911! 1  1: !>9#1! ;10!1/

),/   :!1 %1!   11 !1%!$   !!  "# $  !!  9%1    :!:1$  +* <1 './   8 >1%911!  $   :I: 1 #1%#!  1> :1A#>1 1;!  ?911! 0!18 !/

)C/  1:I:<$00:!111! 19!  :11   !  #1! >1%  ::1#!  9%1# :I:1#:!1 11:!: !%911!/

)J/  ;:11:!!% !$#91$ 111& 3/





 ('+,-('.   &.()*&

 1 

)/  #1AA!AA1 81111#8  <11# ::$ @1!  @AA1  <1   :I: !2/,*/)1 !:111%)' :9 )JC.Q Q .)*5/

   '+    I! 11;1= 2 ('+.*('.$ ('+.+('.$ ('+.6('.$ ('+..('.$ ('+.,('.$ ('+.C('.$ ('+-*('.$ ('+-)('.$ ('+-'('.$ ('+-+('.$ ('+-6('.$ ('+-.('.$ ('+--('.$ ('+-,('.$ ('+-C('.$ ('+-J('.$ ('+,*('.$ ('+,)('.$ ('+,'('.$ ('+,+('.$ ('+,6('.$ ('+,.('.  ('+,-('.5 8<11#::$<1 :I: !$:! ('+.*('./

'/ I!: ?=!11/

 /  :13!1111!1%!=:!111:! 1#  A1 8 1 1!      3%/   A!   1 A!!  >=1  A1  :!1$  ?:1   %!!11   A!!1 1  )J !:9 )C,, 2 " & 0 C))/))5    0/  : :   3; 1  1$#1%18 !;! 91# =1;>3 8  A1  :!1 2D3: >11$ %  : !  1$ =1  11%1$ 11 >?911!$ /5$   :1! =12 A1$ 911!$/5%123; 11 11$/5/

   %1    %   "   0  =!   1 >     ::11  %1  A1   ! 2/6)*+05/

 9/  =13: !11  =   1  1#  A18?;>&:11/ !11A  0$:11+-.. "$11# >=!1   1/   1!    :13$    #> :!1 %1!1%11 1# A1 A! "0%1!1:1  1# 8 ?;  >&:1 91;1/   ?D ?3$  1    :9!/ >11 >= 8 ?;  >& :191;111: !:1:!1$1! :9:$ 1&:1$1#>1 1;2#=&1 11:9!  "5/

 ('+,-('.   &-()*&

  %1$:13$=!  1> $:1  1A!!>AA1A!!! 91#2/') "5/

+/ /  : !  !1% 8  :!1 >11  1#  A13%$1! ::#1%11 1 %I:9!  "$3% 1> / A>1.1!)0/

 9/  : !  !1% 8  :!1 >11 >=  A18?;>&:13%!;: 1> $ :1   A  >1 + 1! '  9   1 @ 11    "  'J :1 )JJ, 2   " &  + *.5$ #1 1  # @:11  A1 13%: !1!/

6/  %11 =!11 11#/

 / AA$>1))J1!)0$!11 1 11 02 "#>:R%5 %A1>9<>  19:111A/

   1 11  A1 #    : ! ;!!   <111:13:111%A1;=1.- 1%1  @;11 <111  '' %:9 )J6) 2 &  ' *.5$ 11 :1%1 A1!/

 9/  %?$  !11 1   11    " 1% I #! %1@ 11 3@1!#12/+. /) "5/

  >1!!11 11 19 121& 34 0S/+-/)  "5/

  :11:!::A1 1 %=  A1 8 ?;  >&:1 91;1$  1 >  1%1 :: ; >=!1    "   :: ;  %1 A1!2/+- "+/'/9  "5/

./  $0!1 1!=:!1 11:!>= A1S ? 1> >%1:1 =&1 8 1# 8 ?;  >&:1 91;1/ 0 $  :11 %11  1 +-$ +-  ..  "$    11  :   # A1=!  > A!! 1:1  :11/  E!$:!111:!13#:18>:11A1=!  1>  19=!91::!1=$#00 :!1/

 ('+,-('.   &,()*&

  11; =1%:> 11 " 1 11 >=!1/  >       <111  !$ :1  1 >  #1$ D ;1  #1! >; >=!1    "$1 11/

-/   D  1  !1 # 1 0!1 %1  ## 11 >#  !11  >;    "    0$  1 1 11   ?    "$  >1    #1!  1/

   AA$   11  @1 )*+     1 A!! @;11<111)-!:9)J6+2&0),+/))*5$11 I:18;1 %11:111A$I& :I:?! !11 1$ #@1 91 !A1!I1; 1::9$#1!I1 ::8:<1!:18;:9@=$A1$# ?=&11#1! @ !%18111%12 7)'*9.J 1/)I1!S 7)')+J1/'55S (''+('6 )-:'65/

  #1! 18111%1#1#1 !11 #!1!I1; 18#@1!:1A1! 2/ )*+ /  5/  <1  13 1;  1$    1 11$1!I 1#<11#8::1A11 @1!11#!# A1%1 1  13/@1!I1; 1111@11! 1## @:11 1$@:$A1 @!%1  !<1   !:1#$ 1!$ :!1   #  !11 #! 1 11/ >1!I 1 I 1  S  11$ 1% AA1::!1% !11S@ 1#1@1#:1311 :!12 7)'+)).1/.S 7)'++).1/+9!A! 1!5/

   :13 @1$ 1 1:   11;   11   !11 !   1/  11      !11  9<!A1111<11#411: !91;1$ ?;$  1:!  1   !!   1%9/  11  1 : =/=$1@D$>9>1 11 !1 !;1:1!I$1<11#$1:11 1$;;%191;1/AA !<119 !11A1/!:18 1#11!AA 1  1   8 !  1!I 1;  1$ 1  !1 #@ 1 AA1 =1/  $ 1 A #@1 D 1

 ('+,-('.   &C()*&

%!19: !<1 !:131::!1811  /

   > 3$ 0!1 A  #1!  ;1   1: 1%4  ;:1  :9  :!1 1# 8 ?;  >&:1 91;1 111  ;:1  %:  1 1 !      /  1&:1 ::9  0!1%1!! 11$#1;:1%: 18:9$ 11118 1:1/

  > 1 19!#1%11 1!I1;  ">1 A#1! ;10!1% 1> $#1%$:: >%$: !1! 1$1$ 0/

    >3;  #  1!I   ::9 1 :! >  :13   !11 #!/ 3 $ A > 1!I1!AH !1AA1::!18>9<11;$0!1 > #1! ;1!11 1> $#> A    "   0     1  11:! >=  A1:!183%$1! :: "/  

,/  = :  >1 -6 1! '  $   ! 8  1! 1: !  :1 @AA1 8  <111 :111% : !/ @! !! !88#1!!!8 :131!/

  0!1D!!!819!$1  !! 1%9  :1  1 > $ A1  > 3 :: <111 :111%    >1 - 1! )    $ #>1> 11:>AA 1AA:! 0!12/--/' 5/

C/  3  #>1  A1 1 = 1  11:!$ 1 >  !1  ?  #1  %1 1 >!91: #1  : 1  #1! 1%1 !% 19!/

   1 1> !:1#1! !;;!%1/

J/  >111;$!:: H/

)*/  1:1! ! N7'@/&$8?;0!1$ !=11:!$#1=%1>%/

 ('+,-('.   &J()*&

*  1      

  <1   T ('+.*('.$ ('+.+('.$ ('+.6('.$ ('+..('.$ ('+.,('.$ ('+.C('.$ ('+-*('.$ ('+-)('.$ ('+-'('.$ ('+-+('.$ ('+-6('.$ ('+-.('.$ ('+--('.$ ('+-,('.$ ('+-C('.$ ('+-J('.$ ('+,*('.$ ('+,)('.$ ('+,'('.$ ('+,+('.$ ('+,6('.$ ('+,.('. ('+,-('.:! ('+.*('.S

! 1%9   1<!  6 <1 '.  0!1    I! 1@ +*:1'.S

: 1> 1<!6<1'. 0!1 I! 1@ +*:1'.S

1#>1  H>!::S

 =  LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ MLLLLLLLLLL$ NLLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ OLLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ KLLLLLLLLLL$ PLLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ BLLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL$ "LLLLLLLLLL$ LLLLLLLLLL  LLLLLLLLLL$ 1 <1:  11:$1:1! ! N7'@/&$8?;0!1S

::1#  ! I 8 0!1$ 8 " # $ %  11:!$ 11#@ 1@ /

01!;4 "/D?3$ !1$":%DN1$"/ ?!1$<;$ "/N1$<; !/

: 19:111A4

;AA13&<14   !14     /1&01;1 7/D?3  





 ('+,-('.   &)*()*&

 1A:I!!::1#!= 1/

 3%$  ;AA134           

 ('+,-('.