Enforceability of Liquidated Damages Clause for Late Delivery
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed a dispute concerning whether a contract term regarding late delivery penalties was enforceable as liquidated damages or an unenforceable penalty, focusing on the difficulty of ascertaining actual damages at the time of contracting and whether the stipulated amount was a reasonable forecast of probable harm. The court reasoned that because the actual damages flowing from the breach were difficult to estimate accurately when the agreement was made, and the stipulated charge was not grossly disproportionate to the potential loss, the provision constituted a valid liquidated damages clause and was therefore enforceable, upholding the contractual allocation of risk.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforceability of Liquidated Damages Clause for Late Delivery: The court reasoned that because the actual damages flowing from the breach were difficult to estimate accurately when the agreement was made, and the stipulated charge was not grossly disproportionate to the potential loss, the provision constituted a valid liquidated damages clause and was therefore enforceable, upholding the contractual allocation of risk.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceeding.
Testo completo
!"#$%&''''''''''
()*((*+ )( +
!"#
(
)* !+ ,-./ !''# 00/1- 2 3/ )+ 0 !''#4 5067/--/.646///00,-4 /8- 3 9/ :;;;;;;;;;;4 90 :;;;;;;;;;; 9/:;;;;;;;;;;40///-<=/470 !+ 8./ !''# 3 >-- 3- 3- ";;;;;;;;;;"!''$ ";;;;;;;;;;"!''$* -- 0- 2,/4?-< :@($'* *
!* 3- .0 ,/ 7 ,/ 3 ./ ./-308/3/A/ 3BC./D - / < -5> 3 . 9* :;;;;;;;;;;4 /633./430 :@#'* 4- -)+8/!''(*
$* / !) 8/ !''( 0/ < 3 ) 8/ !''(4 9* :;;;;;;;;;;E,/33F /60///,4/0E,/ 7/ /F* -// 7-/ 3//B0 ./- 00687/7-/3/>-*
#* G 8/ !''(4 3 />4 /6 - /,0- 9*:;;;;;;;;;; 1 7-/ 3 ,0 2 /3// / 3-0///.)!306)&%(A ()'D*-/ )(8/!''(/--/03/3//117//1-/ /*-//./-<3/>>/5 7 .= 203/ H0 />- 3 /* ,/4 / -/ 3-/-1.3-//03/4/-- /.6*
(* / 3-/- -- //6- 0// 9* :;;;;;;;;;; % 8/!''(*
+* //---*
(+
)* I J/ +( /- ) / 3- 0///. )! 306 )&%( A ( )'D4 7 / /4 3/ 7/.6//-4 -/>/ -// 1- / *
"!$%&"!''( $"#
I 7/- !4 7 / ->0 723- 0/, //17///0=3.*3/B/3 /. ? 8/* -,4 8/// // /03/ 6, -/ 3/,/<2/>43/7/.6//-*
$* 73B4 7 /,/ 3 2 2/> 7/ +( /- ) ! 4 1 6/ 0?0 /23-0/--113./K 6--,//-7-/3=0-/*
//4 3 17? -- /.64 //3-6A*G! L "+##"!''$!+H!''$D*
#* 6 7/ //>4 -00 3M A* )' B>0,/4-00/0/-3-0///. $'8/)&%+N ()'*'$D* OOOOO
*(+ (
- /.6 /8- ) 8/ !''( 3 9/ :;;;;;;;;;; ././L
/17/733M7-00L
00/1 3- ? < 9/ :;;;;;;;;;; // 1J ./ ./*
I/->C 9* =5B4 3-/4 9* 5-/4 90 4 8>499* >48>33-*
0 /60///,C
>,,/B 8/C 3-/C */ I/>/ @*=5B
"!$%&"!''( #"#
3/,0?--00/1-23/*
B.4 >,,/BC
"!$%&"!''(