Property Boundary Dispute and Deed Interpretation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed multiple issues arising from a property dispute concerning boundary lines and alleged trespass, where the parties relied on historical deeds and survey evidence. The reasoning centered on interpreting the controlling boundary description in the relevant deed, finding that a specific monument referenced therein controlled over conflicting measurements, thereby establishing the true boundary. Consequently, the court affirmed the judgment confirming the boundary line as claimed by one party and rejected the claims for trespass damages against them, based on the legally established property demarcation.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Property Boundary Dispute and Deed Interpretation: The reasoning centered on interpreting the controlling boundary description in the relevant deed, finding that a specific monument referenced therein controlled over conflicting measurements, thereby establishing the true boundary. Consequently, the court affirmed the judgment confirming the boundary line as claimed by one party and rejected the claims for trespass damages against them, based on the legally established property demarcation.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision is cited in order 1 to determine the costs of the proceedings.
This provision is cited in order 1 to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
!
! "
"#$!%%%%%% #$#%%$ #& #!' (
#
&' (&)** &
)*+)
01 &"#2222223) $#4!5%#%"!#"# 6 7"" # $#8!!9 "88"#$!:%!0; (#..<17#(5=$! = $!:%!" %%%!(#%!0 ..<1
8$"(#=## (%$#8!!'!5%#% >"" (%9"!! ?'%>"$%5" 9:?# $9'!<7#..<1
1 0, 7# ..- < ; (# ../' ! ! " #"# %# " !!#5 9 #?"%$ #"3) $#4!6'$" @!"9 #?"%$ #!5%! %3) $#4! A6 ">"! 5 (% ( %% #7"% $#!%!..-1
5 #!-B !% !# ! !"#! =!")# $# $#8!$#)"0; (#..-3 =)C0,.6'$#%(: >" !$#"! #5"7#(5=$! '>"=$! "#( = $# ( !0#; (#..<'$"( 7#" $# #( $"7!1 # ! #"# ' D >" ! >"!>" $# : #%" ! = 5=$! ..<' (: =!" $7!%1! %@D# "7%%85"%#? 1
,1 A" @ !5#% (?""#' ! 0- ..-' ! =' !5%#% %$% " #>"D $"# !57 5" "# 5=$!# " = #($"7!>" !%5%$ '8%"#!5 #!-B =1
<1 # ##D% " 0# ;" ../' ! A #;% #>"D1 5%#% #$! $ !$#%("@!5 #!-B =1
-1 B;"../'!!!#5 9 #?" A #%$" "="= $!$#%%1$"#!5#5"%#? 5% $ #$!1 !%?! "# ( 9 ! " 0# ; (# ..< 8 5%(# >" =$! = # 8 " " ? 7"8 !
8 "!% =$!! >" !"# % 8%#% $ # ! $ # #1 ! 5 ? 5%(#>"!$#5$#57#"7#(5=$! !! " "# 5=$!# " #( = # ' ">" $"# 7%%8# 5" $# #( $"7! !5#% (?""# ! "(!! !1 $# #% $"( ?## ! 8 !%?! ( "# !#>"5!! ( ! (%@!5=#!"#$#81
/1 + ;" ../' !5%#% ! #7" ! # 8 5" #"# #!5 ##D%"0#;"../1!#$! "!$"#7#" $##($"7!'"#%#(! @! >"!!!7#(5=$!
*,-*../ ),*+)
$# !" ( %%%!(#%1A"!>"!>"$# #"( "" !?"1
!5: ( $ 5%#D$"7!@% ##!$# " 1 %#% "%? !%# 7!#!9 "88"# : 7"!"#7#(>"!>" ( !"!")D1$!"'% #$ $ ! $#$ ! $#$# !% ! $# ###! !7#%%>"5% $ #$!8 1
+1 0< E../'! A5$$% "#"#15 #!-B !% !# =%$!: $ 588#%# 8' " "#%?# #1 !$# $ @# >"15 "# 5=$!#"#( = %$ ' $# ' ? # $ " " 7!% ! " 1 7 8 " #"# 5% $ ' # "" $# !" ( %% 8 ' "" #? !" ( %% ">"%1 ( >"5! ( 8 $"( D# 8% " 7"#!5=$! 5"#( =$"7!>""#!!5"#($#(%1 @"##! !7#%%>"% #$!1
*
01 #;% $ "! ( ! ;"# $%' ! #"# #( 7!3 #1-/ ! !"#!F#? ;" #"(7#0G<0) ) .-H #1/, !10!1 ! !"#! $#%"# # ("0 $7#0GB-) ) -0.61
1 A!!5 #!G !% 0 ='!5=$! 5"#(# $# $# "7#% @ ! %!(# $#% ! 7! !5" "# "( 4
6 "# 5=$!#" =#($#(%>" !% 5%$ H
76 "# 5=$!#" =#($"7!>" !% 5%$ 1
3I6
5 #!00 !% 0 =$"!>"5" "# 5=$!#" = #( $"7! >" !% 5%$ %!(#% !#>"5" $# $9:>"
6 "7%%85" #$#8!!9 "88"# =H
*,-*../ )<*+)
76 (%!(##"$##($"7!H
3I6
%!(# $# #( $"7! " @ " "#" ! ""'%8 "= #!.0 =1
,1 5 #! -B = " $ # #1 A !% $#%( >"' "# ! $## % $# !5#% (?""# ! ! >"5!"$""#"! ""'
• ! =$! 5" = $# ' "! # " 7#( 5=$! ( !0#; (#..<'
• !=$! 5" = $# =#J !"# (% (#"!5 #!-B"#?!5=%"! =0GGG'
• ! 9 "88"# = $!:% "! # " 7#( 5=$! ( ! 0# ; (#..< >"
• !9 "88"# =$!:%=#J ##"$!"# (%$"! ,0 0GGG
#@7%%8#5"$##($"7!'$"# " >"5!=# #88(!"#$#81
!5$'!#"# #$!$ !$#%%' #!5% $ "! #"7#(5=$! $!:%!0#; (#..<9 "88"# = ( !,0 0GGG1!5 $ #'!#'@! %!(# "$# >"5!#>"#1
<1 #"# 7! "# >" !5 #! -B !% !# = (!# !$#$! #%# (%!1
A!$#$'" # 8$"$ %$!:#588 ( #%(?""#3 1 *1& *&1C '#")
! "' (!" ' # ../' 1 K0<0. 0<00 $1 /,/61 ;"#$#" " !5 $#%# >"5! 5: ( $ #%# (% $#$#! "(!!#?!5 $$!>" @"% 9"# 7!' # #%(!" ! $H ! 5 ? 5" #%# (% $#$#' >" $#$ !!$#$ @# >"3 L00 B'1, H000..'10 #81161
%? #' ! # >" $"( 8# >" "# " !' " # 8""# # # 8H!5 "#% (#("!"=!"# " "$$# " ## "!%#"# " # $ # " 8 !%?! ( 3A0GGG$10G1/ $10<061
*,-*../ )-*+)
!5$'!5 #!-B !% =%$!$ 588#%# 84! 8 $ ! "# ! #"# 7%%8% ( ! % !?"1!!@$##$"% 8 $#%= )!5"#)
#! "! #%"5" "# @" $#%)$"### %>" $"# ! 8""#1 $!"' ! =0GGG $#%( $ >" ! "# %!(#%$"$ D# 88%$ #"9 ?!' 5 !!"# ""? # 5 %%% "#"# 1
%>"'?#8# % #%1
-1 A!!5 #!+! "8%%# !! 8%%# ""0B (#! 0GGG 3 1) A 0.06 ! !7#% %>" ? # 3 !1 06 $# !!7#9=! $#8'!!7# @" (%%>" !"# ( $#(% !7# =# 3 !1 61 !7#% $#? " (% %>"$#(%'=#%@#$#8! @! $#"F"? "F"#("3 L0B0G1<* $1G61 !!$"D#(>"% $ # !$#$9:>">"$ #!$## !3& ?" !8%%# ! ".(7#0GG/#! 8@""(!! "8%%# !'4LL0GG+0' $1 0+GH 1 *1 & *&1 C ' $1 1' K /.-' $1 ,0-61 "##F"#8 !D#8%"#"7 !%? !3 #1,/ !10 16';"8%$ #"%#D$"7!"$ #! $#F"#8 ! F "#"3 #1,/ !1 16' $$ # M#$#$#% "7"(%3 #1,/ !1, 161
A "#%' "=$#%%'!##@! !7#% %>"#$ "#"#$!'"#$!>" !" "#%$ #! #% ! F "#%#D$"7!3 L0-,1 , $1,/H ##D" #7" !8%%# !1G.*..-"0B (#!../H 1 *1& )
*&1C '$11'K/B<'$1,-061
#"# !!?" " (! " $#$ ! $#$# !% ' $ # ' !7#%%>"1 !"#! =%#"8>" ?#8 5 $ #% !%1 ! 5 $ % >"5! = " 7 !%? ! >"5" %#D $"7! @ #%?!# !5 (% 9 "88"# =1 $!"' ! !%?! "# $#%%#"$# # ! "(!!! 8 5%(# " $$! % " ! "(!! #%?! 31N '#%# # 8'O!'0GG0' -+B6' #$ !$#$! $#$# !%1
/1 #"# "$!">"! %!?"(!# !$#$ ! 781
#% @ !5 #! G 1 ( ! $"# !57! !5 (% % >"' ! $#$ ! 7 8 =? >" !5 # ! #% $# #%$#>" # !: !1 $ #"!#' !5 # 5 7# " $# $#$# @ #$# !5 #% !!
*,-*../ )/*+)
"# ## "" ( ?%>"5"##""88 $ #1 # '!:$" =?#!5 "#%>"5!! 8# "=$#" "# >"5!!!" 8 #$$ ! 8 >"5! !%? $! % !!1 ! D 8 J' ! # @ ! $# ! 7 8 $" D# (>"% $#%' $!' 5" $# !5 # "$7! 5%(!!# 9P !5 #% " ""$%# !%?1 # "#"8'!5 # )
D##("@!5%? #!5 #% "" # ## (# $#' 8 "# ! $# " ! $# !5 # '$>"5! "# 8# "7#$#%;"
3 L 0G ,/0 1 +10 $1 ,B0 ! #%8%#61 8' ! $#$ ! 785$D9$ !9 ?!H!!%? !!!%?! "#' $ #"!#5! $# ! !>"!!)# $ 8%"# "!!>"!!$ "# $'#% "# >"3 L 0B0010.7* $10/!#%8%#61
!5$'!#7" ! %;@ %>"!#"# $"D# " 7%%8 5" # >"1 # %>"' D !5 >"5 #? " 5= ..<' !5 "#% $" %(!!# 9P ## !5 : %@ >"%##"(%9"!! ?'F)@)#@ $## $ >"5! "# 8# "7# $#%;"' ! "# (>"#! $#! 78$"#(#%!(##!5 "# !!%1
+1 "(">"$#%'!#"## #;%
%!" CL -.1) # @ ! 9 #? " #"# ' >" "73 #1B+ 61
') *
+,-."!/
%! # #( 7!!#"##;%!+;"../$ #&"#222222#! %"%$ #!F%! %"0#;"../H
-."#/
!#;H
@! 9 #?"#"# "%!" CL-.1)H
*,-*../ )+*+)
">" ! $#% ##D @ & # !' ( " #"# >"F " %$ #!F%! %1
A%? 4 &(:'$#%'&&1 :9# 9%!';"?1
"" #7" ! # 84
! ?#88#);"# ;14 ! ()$#%4 &1 1(: $8# ##D %%">"% "=$ #1
('! ! ?#88#4
*,-*../