Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/439/2007 • CJ GE ATA/439/2007 Generato dall'IA

Property Tax Valuation Method Dispute

Numero d'incarto ATA/439/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The matter involved multiple appeals concerning the proper valuation method for determining tax assessments on property, with the taxpayer arguing that comparable sales data from recent transactions should be used, while the taxing authority preferred methods utilizing capitalized income or replacement cost less depreciation due to insufficient comparable sales. The court determined that the evidence supported the use of valuation methods other than comparable sales when such sales data is not sufficiently reliable or representative of the subject property's market value, affirming the initial assessments because the taxpayer failed to demonstrate that the chosen methodology by the authority was legally flawed or produced an assessment grossly excessive or illusory.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Tax Valuation Method Dispute: The court determined that the evidence supported the use of valuation methods other than comparable sales when such sales data is not sufficiently reliable or representative of the subject property's market value, affirming the initial assessments because the taxpayer failed to demonstrate that the chosen methodology by the authority was legally flawed or produced an assessment grossly excessive or illusory.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
stima fiscale immobiliare valore venale dell'immobile valore litigioso ammortamento fiscale tassazione delle spese amministrazione fiscale

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the losing party (Appellant) to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

       

  

   

 







!  !! !    ! ! ! "  #!! $    



%& '()& !   !! " #$$%&'





     ()*+(

! 

,-   !$$  ). /'$ )001&  ! %  $   #2$3$4%$5$( 67! % 8!9 "$"%:! # $ !;$44$ 2% 9 3 %  $ !$  $!$& $ ,)&   $<( 62-

)-   )= 4!'$ )001& "$  "% & 2$   % 3'&$$ $;%$$$4$$2-3 %>$ !$$$!>$!;$ #%$ $!,?+0- %$  $;&  ) % )001&  $  3$ #%$& 4$%>3$'$< $!$< $,?+?9,?@=-

=-  !$$)@%)001&! %$!!$$$$2$-

+-  ,+%$)001& $;%$$$4A!344$B! < ! <   $%$!  !  CD ,3000-(& 9  #2  3 6'- $;'$>3'$ !!$$&' $!$$-

.-  ,=/$)001& $$ $;%$$$43!%$  $%$!- '    !$$& $ '$ $ ! 3#$  ! < E$'$$$>!! %>3,?@=&3$ 3%!2%<$$2$<!$!/944!&4$ !$ >3 %,!2'$3<93F((#!-

G-  )0/$)001&! <  !9!%$ 9>3$%$!$ !9 CD)3.00-(- !'$H! 4$>3 '$ #2-

!  

,-  /!% $'/$$$% !&!%$ ';5-@1-+$ !%$$$',) %; ,?@.( ( .,08-

)-   /$$$ %$$$' >$   !$$    4$  !  !%%   $%$ !;$   62%  $ I    4%!%  $$    $$! 5- @1 - ,  =  8-

 (=*+(

   9 $A$6% $%2$  $%$!   4$ $$ ; !    5- @1 - )  8- :  62%   4$& !%%  $%$!  ! %$$$'  =0 /$ ,?@G 5  . ,0-0=8& I$%$! 4$<! '$  CD )00-(9 CD,0I000-(-

   /$$$ $  I 2 '$ I !$$&  % >  $$   I$ I $%$!& %$ $ > 9  >$!-  !$$4$<%! I $$  ;$IJ%$'!-  &$!# 2$4I;$$5 D,,+==)8- %J%4IA9 $I$%$!>I!%-

=-   3 6&   $$$  '  ;/  $   !'$   !$$ >!   ! %-  4$&  ! <   ; 2$  -  '$ !!  '  $  $< $! -

   & 3$  '$ >  ! %  ! < ! <   $;$$!3J& $)1 %;)00G&! !& $  4$ > 3$  3%!2%  <  , !2 !$ !/9 $> !!$'$! #%$&,?@=&$ K%! %944$'$2$% !%$/ >$ $ $$-

  3$%$!  ! $$ !  /$4$ 4$%  2 3$@1$!)$ !%$$$',) %; ,?@.5 ( .,08&$3A $ $%-

  !%$$%$!/!-

+-   &$! < 9>3$%$!$ 2%! 9 CD )3.00-(  $ /!-  44&  $  !! 4%! 63!%!$/ !'93$@1$!+   & >$  H      !%$ $$

5 *.=0*,??1&/$ $!8-

.-  4%!%9 $> $;%$$$4!%%  !'!   ! !& $  $%$! ! 5- @1  8- LLLLL

  !  !   

 (+*+(

*'+,%&-

! ';  !%$ $/!  ,. /$ )001   ! %  $   #2$  3$4%$   !$$  $; %$$$4,+%$)001E

+)-

/E

$>3$3  M3!%%E

$>3$3 !3$%$!E

$ >& 4%!% < $ @)  $'   $ 4!!   $; 4!!,1/$)00.5 D(:,1=-,,08& !!$$ J ! />$$'$4$$ (' $;4!!& '$ %$6$ ;$E%!%$$$$>$& %$4%A ' $2%$E$ $ J !  $; 4!!& ,000  ,+&  '$    '$ !$> < $$  3$ +)  D-  ! !$$   $6  $  & $'>! %% %A  '& $' J /$ 9 3'$E

%%$> !!$$! %$#2$  3$4%$ $$ >39 " #$$ %& '  "$  "% -

 244$67  /2!!2!7       N$C #$$  #!$ 

 $4%J!!%%$>!< $- 6'&  244$67