Property Owner Breach of Restrictive Covenant for Exterior Maintenance
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellate court considered whether a property owner's failure to maintain the exterior appearance of their property, specifically by allowing debris and overgrown vegetation to accumulate, constituted a breach of a restrictive covenant requiring the maintenance of a "first class residential property." The court reasoned that the covenant's requirement for a "first class" appearance implied a standard of upkeep consistent with the character of the neighborhood, and that the visible deterioration, despite internal repairs, breached this objective standard of maintenance for the exterior, thereby affirming the lower court's finding of a breach.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Owner Breach of Restrictive Covenant for Exterior Maintenance: The appellate court considered whether a property owner's failure to maintain the exterior appearance of their property, specifically by allowing debris and overgrown vegetation to accumulate, constituted a breach of a restrictive covenant requiring the maintenance of a "first class residential property." The court reasoned that the covenant's requirement for a "first class" appearance implied a standard of upkeep consistent with the character of the neighborhood, and that the visible deterioration, despite internal repairs, breached this objective standard of maintenance for the exterior, thereby affirming the lower court's finding of a breach.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order regarding the imposition of procedural costs.
Testo completo
!"#$%%%%%% !"#$%&%'
'
& '(
"()*+"
*/ !'# 0111111 '# 2 3 '4#' 56#' 5"
'7%#8'%9:*;;</
(/ '#*,4%#(--,&!9 111111##'99##' %#'4#' =#"7>'99##'?@# 2 @' !/0111111/
/ %# # 56#' 5 '':799# 2@/' # 9 &@ # '% 2#"#':79@' :'#9#A/ # %# ' '' '# % @ BA##:C C#B/ @C## 4# @9C3 &@35 %#'&A#%# 4D #A'#&%'##959 #/ !/ 0111111 '%# 44 6 9C 2 ' :# ' B@# 49C #AB&#''A##'# @'A 2 44 /
%# E"%' '%9: (--8 2 *; 5/ %# @#9#' A ' '# '%# @ 9 56#' 5 / F# '9 & %# 9 9 #C9 2 !/ 0111111 9C A@# # '#C# / F'# ##&#@C## @9 5' 5 #A%' '4! '5'/ '#'%# #D 9#''5#E"%'/
:/ # '9 &# # B9 5' 5# '4! '5'& 9# 3''C 9##B # '99 # # 9 9## 2!9 111111>
B # 'C'&'% '%'#4'#/
" #C ' '99:#4#=G9#9 4' ?/
" 44C% '# #/
" # '&9D9'/
" %#& 'G' '& %# 3/ , .& ' C#''9:#8,F* '63/
)(+,)(--. "+)*+"
" 9#'# 5 4# # '' '%5 '' :#/
" ' %# C#' '63 %'# ' ## C CHI 'C#2 #/%'# ' 552#:# #/
" # 9 '&' %##C# % % %# # %C#/ # 9 %C#': @#9#@'5C#% /
" ' 9# # 9 & #C @%#' , 9# ' '/ '%# # ' C 5 ' #'%#'*-9# /B
'9 # A B # 9 @ 2 '4' % 9C ' #AB/ @C# @ B 5# 56#A 65#AB/ B %# A # # 9 '99 %#' #' 56#A 9' % :' 3# ' #%## #'/ F# & # % 9#3D # 9 /B
/ 7 & !9 111111 %# # B9# %#"2"%# #A ##B/F'99 #'39#&%# ## 7 56#' 5 ' %'# #9 '# ' 5 #A/ # 9 @%# ' % ':79 / %# #9 A@'%# :'4#/ @%# 9' #99# 9 @44#2'#'99##'/
+/ < %# (--,& '99##' #4'9 !/ 0111111 A@ %# ##@# 2'' /
8/ !/0111111@ 3#9'#*8%#(--,/
%# '#C2!9 111111'#3 :9 5' '4! '5'/%# #' 9 / @C## @ 3#%9 #% C # / %# 5 9# @ # 9#4 :#9 '5' 'C9 /
,/ '# ( 9# (--,& !9 111111 # A ## # %# 'E"%'2':# #A@'## @ '3A!/0111111 # #9## '#3 / @%# ' G9# #9C# A # # D #% C # / @ # A@7 # '#& 4 %'##& A !/ 0111111 @%# #4'9/ %@%# 4# A@ '9#/
)(+,)(--. "8)*+"
./ !9 111111 !/0111111' '"'99##'J/
F' ##& !9 111111 # % ' 3 4'# :@''"##4&'# *K (('%9:(--8/
!9 111111 @ # ' % !/ 0111111 @C# / ##9# %# # ' #9 2 # 5C 5 #A/ %# :4##@9: # 9 A# '9 # # B9 5' 5# '4 ! '5'& 9# 3''C 9##B/ & !/ 0111111 @%# #4'9 C / F# %# '# '9 # & @# G9# # 9 / '9# 'A'# @%# C# '#/ # '99 56' #& ' 9 &3/ @%# #'9##9#4 4/!/0111111%# ##79 ## # C# ' ' # '#/ @%# 9'# #AA@9C3 %C#/ %# C9 :# '5 / ##' # C / 5## A# %# ' '' '9 9 #' #"/ # %# ##AA'@'5#&# #A# 5#5 '/ 4#&%# %%#' '%'# # ' A #' 9# # 2 9'9 "2 'G' '/ %'6# ' # 9 9## ':79 / '%# 2G' #9#/
K/ !9 111111 !/ 0111111 ' 3#79 4'# '"'99##'J/
!/0111111' # A##9#%# # '%9:(--82''9##/'#9# # A@#'## 4## ' 4'#9 #'A3>*K ((9:(--8/ @3# A '# '/
%# !9 111111 2 ' :# # %# 3#A A # #% C # /## '#2''9##'%# A # @#9C# A@# 4## % ' '99 # @% :3/ #A# "5# C & #A@# #4 # '% 9#/# # # :# ' ' A@# '%# @ 9' 7 %'# :9 # '# B4# :44# '% :B/
!9 111111 @ # '' # 9 / # %# ' 3# #'# /@%# '6 &9##%# '#9 4# !9 111111%# 4# 9D9/ '%# 2 ' 9'9 ## '5# # /%# :# #AC # ' ''9#' # %'### 'CC# 3#C /
)(+,)(--. ",)*+"
' % A@# %# # C& # %# 3#A 2 !9 111111A@#@6%# 2# C #A A@#@6%# @9:#CL 2G /M# @%# '#4'9'5'9'3# # # %# '4#9 %'# 3# 39 'A@# %# 3 9C/ '99 # @%# # 2 5& # %# 4# %# ' 9 2 !9 111111'#' '' 5#/
%# 5# 2 # @%# G2 #A #4'#/ '#@ # #:5'99/
</ '# *+ G# (--,& !9 111111 #4# 2 A @ # '%9 # #C#3/
@C## (; '%9: (--8 ' '%9: (--8 '99 99 ##A/ @3#A# '4#'/ ' & @ # :# 56#' 5 (&*( *K'%9:(--8/ %'"9#A@'## 9 #'# 9'#A *K (('%9:(--8/
;/ !/0111111@ 9#*-'N (--,/
' # (; '%9: (--8 '99 2 A @ # ' # 9 # #C#3/ '# %# '#C *K '%9: (--8/ 9# # A !9 111111 # % '% 2 3 # ( *( '%9: (--8& '99 #' #4/ # @9:%A # 9 # #C#3'# 9## 2':# # %# 'E"%'2 # % #"#/' 	# # %#'4# /
*-/ F# 2AD '99##'&!/0111111@#4'9&'# , 9:(--,&A@#3O# ' #%# 2*--P A@#%'6# %#',- # 9#/!9 &5C'4#'9' # 2 QJ,@--8/"'5C#%%'### QJ+@,8*/"/
/ '99##' %# , 9: (--,/ ''# '# @ @ '# #' #A !/ 0111111'#39'#/
A# 56#' 5 & !/ 0111111 '%# C# A # #' ' ':## @ 9#/ '%# ' ## # #%'' # 9 2 # / '::'#9#A' !9 111111# D # # 44 #'65# #AC%A#%# D # ## / 5#A ##!/0111111&A#'%# 3''C#& # ' ' ##A%'#%#9::9 4 ' !9 111111 '9 ': 65#A ' '%# D # / 5# # #C# @ # ' '# ' # #
)(+,)(--. ".)*+"
# 2 @# C# 56#A # #' ' A 56#' 5 # N:@#4'9'9 #A 9 5''4! '5'/
!/ 0111111 # '# @9:#CL 5# #A@# @3O# ':# /99 4# A@'# ' '%& 9 5'& # ' '99 B 5# 56#A 65#AB&'%# D 3 #956#' 5 A#& 'R & @%# 7C 9 # ' ' 3 #'#A@#' # C 9C4# A@#%# '2 '5 3/
4#& # '5 '%# D 4# 2 !/ 0111111 A 2 '# # / #"#& # # #9'#: %'# A %# 9 # 56#' 5 9 A# # %# '4#/ ' & C' ' :# # A 3 3A%# #'#/9%# '# @%# 9###/
*(/ D (* 9: (--,& '# @ # C# 56#' 5 @## #'!/0111111'#39'#/
F' C9 #' # # #A 2 '99##'/ %# ' A&''9 9C& # '%# # #' 65''C#A #A 56#' 5 @%# : 9# 3 #'A#@%# #:# 2@3 #' #% ' ''9#'4! '5'/ @ # '9##:A@'4#' #A 5#A # 2''9###%&' A 9 '6/ C7 % A ## %# # 44# # ' #99 ' /'9' 9 !/0111111 44# # C% '%# D A#4#@C#9 '4#' #' C '# @3# '4#' & :#9 9#3 #% #'9#9#9#(--* =F"H+-,?/F@C# 4# #'& # ' 24# '' #' '9 ' 99 4# A&'@# #'& ##%# ' %'# #A9 5'' '%# # /
*+/ !/ 0111111 ' 7 #: 9## #4 (+ G%#(--./' 2@ #'@D '#@ /
'#@ @%# #'2 ' / %# #A9 5' '4! '5'2 # #% 5'':# /@# G9# '' # 9 2 # ##C #"9D9@%# 69 5# ##%# 4# '9"D /#C %#
)(+,)(--. "K)*+"
C ' 'C'#::# / @%# #56' ## 'C/ '%# A# @ 9 2 ' 9'9 /#%#3 ' '' '%# A@# @%# G9# 55 2 : @/ F@C# A #' @56C#7& # @ # '9# 2 F #A@# #A# 2 # 9 #%/
9 & #' # @3 D9%# #'' #' #A # # # @3 '4#' #3 9'#& '# @ ' #C# 9 #99 24## #%9 ' #%# / %## 44 / F' :# '# GA@ 4%# (--K/ '%# #9#9#7#C#4# #%5C9 #9 ' 2 QJ <@,--/"/ F % #' #3 9'#& # %# ' # A#@#@# :#A/
*8/ '#@ @ 9#'#*,9(--./' G ' # # # C9 9' #4#%'A2@# ##' #/
*,/ (; 9# (--.& ' #: / 9# # ''/
#: #&#%# 4 G'@5# / %## ' :# / ' A # %# #A 9 5' 5 #A # #C# # ' '5 A# @%# # % ' #%# '4#'/#C # # 2A#%# '#C 9C/ %# 69 5# % %# # A@ @ # :#/@%# %'#4#9 # #79 '%'#@# % # 9 / @%# #4'9 % #A 5A C / ' : #'#%# # A@' # 2 'C / % & # @%# # 34'#':# ' ':79 2/ '9 # # B9 5' 5# '4 ! '5'& 9# 3''C9##B&A@##%# 9#&#%# 9 5' 9C #@#C9 A@#%# #%#2SI'T%#C # @/ '4 ! '5' # ' A# 3''C : 5 #A9 5' # 9C'# '#%/
'A@# #A# #%& # #4 # 9# % 7 # 9 / ' # %5 # :' :5& # C / :# & # %## 'G':':5/9'#&#@ ### C A' #A 9# #' #% '63 A# # # '5 /#4 # 9#' # 9 / #AC '%# D 4 9##'9#'99#9 'U 5 # :'56C#7%#A##C ## 9#
)(+,)(--. "<)*+"
:' /GC# 4# #' '%7#A@#9#A# '# 49 ':# A &## '%'/
*./ F# 2AD GCC&' 4# %# #: '# 8 G# (--. '# #' 4# (--(& (--+ (--8##A%# 3 #' #43(--+ (--8/
' #% '9 A 5#44 @44# 9'6 ' %'## QJ *8,@---/" ' QJ K,@---/" 5C %#'/ % 9'6 @9## #' 4# ' (--+ (--8	' 2 QJ8,@---/"%#'/F@C# 4#4' ' & 9 #9 ' @ (--8 2 4' 9':##7 @%#' QJ ,-@---/" ## A@2 #4 '99#3 : @'3#9 #%9 QJ,,@---/"/
*K/ FA'#& C2GC/
&
*/ G 9 # % G## #' '9 & ' %:= /,. '#@'C# #'G###(('%9:*;8*" " ( -, V / .+ / * # / '# ' 9## #% *( 9:*;<," " ,*-V /;F?/
(/ %#' F& %#C* 9:(--* :# W :'C#'M' #''# K%#(--.&' # 4# 3# (; 9# (--. A# '5#9 %#C/
+/ @%# ' & F '%# # #' @7 'A'## #C#3' #2#C 2 # 9 #% C # /
FC9 @3#&2 # #%&'4#' = /( /F?/@@ 56#' 5#= /+5/* /:F?/ #, K F& 3 '4#'D ## C# #'#% @D '#@ /
@'& ' '# 3 '4#' 56#' 5 #8'%9:*;;</ N9 ## C# '4#'2 44 /#C @ #'5# 9# 9# # & '99 # @ ' #"9D9 ' ' # #'% #:/ @ A# A@ A@## 9## # 9 # #C#3 4# A # '# ' 2 '
)(+,)(--. ";)*+"
'9###%5C#3' :# 56#' 5 # / & 4' ' A F @#A 2 44#/
8/ / F%'# 2 #*-< #% #'9## #% ' #4 #' 2 #'# #' ' 2 7C9 ## A@ @C#9 '4#' #' ' A#4# '99 '99##'= /*-<#* (F?/
:/ #'# #' 7% '# ####/ #"# ' # 9: #' ' #' M '# 2 MC M ' #%# 9#'A#' '9#2 #'A#& C#9 ##M':#C #'&4' M':G M%##/ %##' 99 99:4' #':#A&''9# 2 ' # :#A ## =' & & # ? '4#' #: =9#& %' V )+;.)(--, +* 9# (--,V 79 /!&'# 9## #4'/&( # #'&&(--(&/(8&X*/8/+/8?/
/ % @ # .< # + F& 56#' 5 % #AA# #'9#'5#' #### ' ':## ##A # 9 # /
/ C#9 '4#' #' & # 4 @#':% #' @':#C #'4# 2 ' ##@'4#' &4'9 '#2 #A '4'99 '# %#C& @' '9' 9 '4#''##3&@ %'9 #/ C#9 '4#' #' ' 99 @ #4 #' 3 7C@ & 3#%9 5#A&'99##'&'9##' ' %#' #' @':#C #' C @ # #' A % # = )*,;)(--. (* 9 (--.V )+;.)(--, +* 9# (--,V ).8<)(--8(8'N (--8V ).<K)(--+(+ 9:(--+?
/ @C#9 '4#'#' ' A#4# '99 '99##'& @ # *-< # ( : F& ' # ' #' G##A#9#' @# #' D %#:9 G## #' '& 'A "# @ #9 2 5 '# / & # ' #' 4' 2 '# #4#A& A @ '# 9## #% 9#3 2 9D9 @# A@ #:& #:3 9## #4 #: 4 @#9' # 'A@# #9 A @ '# #4# 9#4 9 9#3 2 9D9 @ #:2 ' #''#2GC/@ ## ##' # '9# ' '9 & '# : 4# :# 4O' '97 3 = / F & # '# 9## #4&C++. ++KV
)(+,)(--. "*-)*+"
J*-; (V*-; :(*;V J*;<,C+-+ V !/K9 *;;-V Q/(;%#*;;(?/
@'& #:9## #47% ' @:'A@2 @ # .< # + F& ' @ # '# 2 '#C '# # #C#32#C /F'W # # 9 #'# @'' 9#/ ' 3 & ' # #A9 5C '#C @ # '%# # ''54' 44 #'/
' C9 '# A ' 4# % 9 # 9A9 '% D A#4# @C#9 '4#' #' @ #*-<F/ # 9 #A2#C @ # ## ##C#4# & 2 C& ' 4# 9' @ 9A ' #9 / '99 9 #' ' '' :# '4! '5'& # 9 # #C#3 B 5#56#A 65#AB A# '5 2 @# #9# @##%# A# # 2 '#' B'99 %#' #' 56#A 65#AB/ C& # 9 # D 44 @#9' A'4#' A# 9 '#@## / A# 56#' 5 & ' @ # 2 @%# 2 9D9 # @9## '# # #C#3A#7% '9#3''C# A#'' 59@ #%# 'A# '#23 '7%/ @' C9 ' @44## @ 9 5'# #C / #: 9## #4 # '# 2 @%# '99##'A#&'9'## &'#7A@ 5# # @7' "##A%'#4 /
# # C9 N D #4'9 # 9 5' ##% '3 #'/#4'9 #'# ## ' '%# 9#C9 ' #C # NC# #9 :4##% '999 9C/
' #9 2 A 9: ' & '' # 9 2 # A @' 'R 2 # " @' # 3 " 5EA'9"D @ C9 A / ' & 4# # 6 9C 2 ' '9## #%& '##&C '6 # @ # '2% ' 9:#CL / ' #& A 4' @9:#% # #' #9 9#A#@'9C/
F@C# ##79 '# #' @56C#7 A @ ' 9C& # #9##: A ' # #A '5 3 9C %C#3 C / #4# 9A9 % ' '9##' 2 F 7% @
)(+,)(--. ")*+"
#%' #'9 #: % '4# A @' '# @ @ ## /
4#&9%# '#&' ' 99 @: ' ' # 9 '#C 2 #C 9#4 A 3 E"%'& #: # % '99##' A@ 9A9 ' # C9 C#9 '4#'#' /
% A# 7& #: 9## #4 #9 % '99##' '# @ A C#9 ' 44#' C% A@#'#% D #'/
,/ ' '5 '#@ #%'##4#C #' ' ' @%'###%#'##'' #'# /
G# = J *-( ,((V ;K ,-<? 4## ## '' #'# 39#7>'4'9'99#&##C#4#A 9#'# 9 M #: AM55/
F'4'9:'&9#'# D '2 # : 55 ' '#: #: M##%#& M & ' #':'# 3# 55 #9# 2#: #' # &M /MC# 7' ## G##A #4# 3##MA #'&:### # / ##' #4# ## MA #'& 'AM9 &' &M #M# D :#55 '#V##:### &'A&9##%9A ' 9# '#& A# A# 9C 9#3 # D #%'' # D :#A#% D 44 9 V ## # & 'A # 3 # D :# #%& 9A :###' #C%AM#4#'29%#C=/H &# '# 9## #4&879# #'&Y*;;*/+ 8?/
## '' #'# #9#A A 9'6 5'##& ' 2 # : '#%#& ' M # 9'# C% 3 # D #%& '9 '9 '# %M# D :#= J*(+ (?/
4#& ## 3#C AM 9 # #% '# 2 '# '9 A3"## D # 99'# ###%/ ' & # # # ' #9# #' "2 : %# 3#C ' #': #"# # D :#'#%'9'9#= J *(.(*;'#/(/(((?/
)(+,)(--. "*()*+"
@'& #'#4#C' '/ ' ' 9 # 2# #''9#C9 2 # 9#7## / 'C%# 4# &@# # #' #A 9 A ' @ A@2 @%#& ' 3 ' 9 # '4'99 2A@' '# @ @'4#' /
' 4'#& #' '#@ 44#99 '# #'# #'4##7' / D (--8 = );.<)(--8 *8 9: (--8?& #: 9## #4 %# GCA #'@9#'#39'# 9'U#"### %'4' :=%#' QJ*,-@---/" ? #A #4# # C9 # 5C'4#' '' #''5#44@44#/ ' ''6 # 9' C# 7C%'#= QJ*@---/"5C '9#? ##'# 3#'#A@#'# ' #' '99'# ' A # # ' % ' C#C:/
# #' 4##7 ' :# #44 @7/ !D9 @# 6 '6 9 %'## QJ .,-/"& :4# ' #%# # %'## QJ K-@---/" %#' / 2 4' & '9' QJ ,-@---/" :# 9: @%#' QJ ,,@---/"@ #4'99#3: / '9 4# A' 3 ' ' :# & ' #%# '4#' ' #3 9'# A@%'# 'A 4 # 9D9 ' 44# A# @ 9 : 55 F/ #& ' # '9 @9: #' & #: 9## #4#2 '#9'##'''2@' ' /
./ '' #9 9#/9'9 QJ,--/" 9# 2 5C ' A# '9: # = / <K ?/ 9'9 & QJ,--/"C9 &9#25C '#@ / #9# ' QJ ,--/" ' ' & 2 5C @ 7%/
) &
*+, #-.
%:'# G (+G%#(--.!'#0111111' ##' '#@ (*9:(--,V
)(+,)(--. "*+)*+"
+, !.
9 #9 'V
4#3 2 '# 9'# # #' !'# 0111111 C# 56#' 5 7M 4' D V
'4#9@D '#@ (*9:(--,'V
9 25C' 9'9 QJ,--/"V
9 25C '#@ 9'9 QJ,--/"V
'' #9# ' QJ,--/"25C@ 7%V
'99#A D 2!"# $%&%' ' ##A@ '#@ /
F#C > !9'%6&# &!/657&!9Q#&!/ 5#&!9'& GC/
'9 #:9## #4>
C44#7"G# G/> %#"# > !/ ''# /'%6
'#'4'9 D '99#A3 #/
7%& C44#7>
)(+,)(--.