Breach of Contract Affirmation After Procedural Review
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed several procedural and substantive issues arising from a dispute concerning a transaction, initially examining the timeliness of certain filings and the application of various statutory and contractual provisions, ultimately determining that the evidence supported the lower court's findings on the central breach of contract claim. The reasoning primarily focused on interpreting the relevant agreement clauses, particularly regarding performance obligations and remedies, concluding that the non-breaching party's actions were commercially reasonable given the circumstances, and affirming the judgment concerning liability and damages, while occasionally clarifying minor procedural points.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Contract Affirmation After Procedural Review: The reasoning primarily focused on interpreting the relevant agreement clauses, particularly regarding performance obligations and remedies, concluding that the non-breaching party's actions were commercially reasonable given the circumstances, and affirming the judgment concerning liability and damages, while occasionally clarifying minor procedural points.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the apportionment of the procedural costs.
Testo completo
!"""""" !"#$%&&$'#% % #$ $ %&'& &($#
()*+(
&
.0 !0 111111' #% &$$' 2 % %$$34 5%$ 6 $%2744$)//-#2%8 $8# 2#% 0
)0 %$ , 9$ )//-' %44$$% 274 #% :$( 3; %44$$%< $5%4 2$ =2$ #$ >%0 > $ 5$$ $50 $ #$ %8 % .-'-?%$ $)/%$ 4$$44=$0
$ #$ 4%@ A % 74 $ 4$$0 2#$ +4$)//-'% %55$$ $ )'$#$ % B'?0 2# % ) 4$ )//-' $ #$ %8 B'-? 6 ., 4$ )//-% B0
B0 % ,9$ )//-'!0111111%3 $8 4$$ $5 % $$% % 6 % $% =2 %$ 2# $ =2$ 4$ 6 % 2 %>$ $%0 84 ' %44$$% #$ C $#$ 6 %$ % %$ %4 '@%4$834 %% $%2#$ 0 % #$ %#%$ %% % %4 ' 834' $ 3 2$ $%%44$$%05$$ #%$8 =;
0 %5%44 7$ $# $# &2#% 62%8 $% 8# 2#% . 9#$ )//B :$(3 ; $ $#<' 8$ % $% 4$ )//- "$ 2 #$ 55$$ + 4 )//-' !01111112 $ 4$%#&$# ;
( D@8%E*$%; ( % $#$ $ ./ 48 .+/- ( ( D )./< :%$5%4 %$#$$B/4.+..:$# $=$34;%$ %8$& $%( (D))/<% F
( "#* *D %4; %$).48.+B-: (D B..0/<% F
( D %55; %$ 5 %$ % 5$$ .. #$ .GG+:(D)G.0.<% 0
80 $2%2#$ 5$&$ 2$$ $%$# ;
(H 7 6$%$ $%; * '%$5$8$ $%#% )B 9$ )/// : ( D +B?0,.<' %$ % $#$ ./ #$ .+G-' #$&.%I .+G-: ( B/?<'%$2%&$ $%9$$$ ))%#48.+A.:( )/?<' %# $%&%H0
*),-.*)//- (B*+(
!0 111111 #$ $ = %44$$% #$ $$ $84 7 F $ #$ % 248 2$ $% 7 $3%$%% $%$ $&0
A0 2%$$ =2% &%$ %4$7$ H$ $$ JH0
!0 111111 7% #%$ >$ >%$7 % %44$$%' 6 #%$ $ = $% ' $ = 2% &&$ '%$ # = 0
$% $&$ =$2 $ 6#$55 % 274' !0 111111 #$ 4 $70 @ $ $%' = % #$ 96 % % $% 4$ )//?' $ 3 8$$ 0 % $ 2 5% =2$ $ % 2 $4 $#0 $% 4 $ 2 $ $ =$ % #$0
!0 111111 #$ 5$4 >%$$ 27 % #%4 = $ 4 $ #%$ =2$ $ 5$ $ #$ 5$& 4$ 7 6$%$ $%0
?0 !0111111#$ $ 6% $%8$=.A9$)//- 4C4=2= $$ 0 %$%'!>$$@% #$ 7%834$=%% $%2#$ 08% /'?%$ #$ %7$ =$#$ =%$ $% 2= '5%$=5$ 62 &2 $)-.' $ 4$0 $ = $ $6% $%0
D% $ $#' %44$$% 4$$ $84 7 $ $ #$ %#%$5$8%5%$6 $ 0
#$ 5%4 % #$ > 2# $ %4$$% #$ J2 $% #%% 0
$84$$ $5#$ 969&= % 7 = $%4 9 %#$ C 5%#$ C 4$6$%$ $%$ : *,*)//A,9#$)//A%$0?0-<0
D%$ $#'2#$ #$ C %&$5K%6= $ %$ $ $%%L$ %#$ 2$$ #$ 0'$ '#% %#$ % 4% % %$ =2$ 9&$ $0 #$% $% %' $8 4$$ $5$%$ 2$%#%$2740
#$% $ $80
*),-.*)//- (A*+(
' % =$5$$ 28$ $ 2$ $% $% % 6 $ @ %8 8% % #%$ $ = $%= '%=2$2#$ #%$& $5$2 8%0 %55$$ $=62#$ )'2 $ %.%$ 2$ $% % 74 $ $ @ 85$$ 28%0
,0 .-%I )//-'%44$$%%% 9 %0
2# $ ' $ #$ K %# $% &%' ' 0 #$ &4 6 $%$ $% %#& 4 $% $ $#' 6 #%$ * % ' % ' % 4C4= %% '%$ H#$%9 >$H0 %44$$%$=%$%@4$#$ #$ 4$ % % $% 6 %(%44$$% 5%4 ! @%' $ %0
%44$$% % 834 %$ $8 % 2# $ 0 M$ 4 $4% #%@$ $8 > %$ 0 4 =$5$ $4% ' %48 >$ N $ $ N %$ $ 2 4 2$ $ $ 0 $7 %$ $ %$%4457 $%%>$ 2 72$ /'? %$ 0 5$'$= = $% $ %428%/'?%$ $ $ 04$($5$&$ = 5$ 0 % $% %4% $ = $ $ = $% = $24%#$$%'2 2 72 5$ 0%$ = $%&4$$2$ $$ 6 %44$$% $ %4 2 #%4 $ %4 8%0
$ $% $ $55$ @ %$ 6 2C = $($ 5$ ' % % 6 2 *-A?*)//? G %#48 )//?' ($' 7 &4= $ $$ %% $% $%4 9$$= % % 7 = $% % 2%' =$ 2 $ 230$'%44$$%#$ 4%$5$$ $# %$=2 4$$ $84 7 4$6$%$ $% $ 0
7 C ' $8 4$$ $5 #$ %$ =2 7 & % $ 4 $3 274' 4$ % 2$ $% %#$ 4 2 $8 $%8%7$ =$#$ 4 $%' =2$ %$ %4 834 & %#$ C %$ %44 $ % $ 2#0 7 %$ $ $# $ %9% 6 $%$ $% $ ' %$ 23 % 44 % 0
*),-.*)//- (?*+(
5$' %44$$% #$ = 4C4 $ !0 111111 #$ %8 8%% = $%'% 5$$ (%4%@0
-0 $= % .- 48 )//-' % $ %$%04$ $ = $$ 2 $ #% %@ %$ % #$& '8%%4 %80
G0 %44$$%%6$=)A 48)//-0
& $
.0 9 4 $ # 9$$ $% %4 ' % #8: 0?, %$2%&$ $%9$$$))%#48.+A.( ( )/?F 0,B0. 0%$%4$$ $#.) 48.+G?( ( ?./<0
)0 % % = 2# $ + 4$ )//- 6 = $ %8 % B'?0 3& $&$ $ 4 # $ =$ % 85$$ % #($ 2 8% /'? %$ ' %$ 2%$ % ' 7485$$ 2%55$$ )%=$ #$ 4$ 6 $%$ $% $ ' $ $ $ = 85$$&4 8%= $%0
B0 2%&$ $%%44$$% 4%$ 2745$ & % 5$73&4 2$ $%: 0B)0B%$%5$% 2#% ), #$ )//) ( ( , ./<0 2 $ ). 3&4 2$ $% %$ %5$% 2#% ? 9$ )//) : ( , ./0/.<%%4 6%44$$%5$74%$ 2740 %44$$% 8$#$ %(%44$$% %$ 448 % $ 2#$ 2745$: 0.G0B <0
. 48 )//,' %44$$% % %# $ $# $# & N#% 6 N%8 $% 8# N#% :$(3 ; $ $#<0 ($ $ = N74 5$ HN % $= %89 %$ >%$= $ ' 4$ $ % %4 %5$% 4 $3 $= 80 % $ % %' $ % % $#$ 6 $ $% %L $ %#$ N$ $ #$ 0H $ H=N$ 4% #%$ %4$ 4J $ N 5$ ' =N$ 3%834 $ 49$$='=N$$ $5$4%@ N $%%$'=N$> $$4%@N $%'=N$%$ 8 #% &4 $%' =N$ 4$ # $ % %$ =N$%$ %9%85%%$ % $%=N$%%'=' % 4>' $ & 6 N$ $ C =N$ >&
*),-.*)//- (,*+(
5H0 DN&$ 4 $ 6 $%$ $%' % $ %$ % ' $ $#$ =H%44$$% 4$$84 7 4$ 6$%$ $%$ H0
%44$$% %4%$$ 7$4 04%$ $ %44$$% % $ N#% $$ &$ %&#%$: 0.) 0.'.A .-0B <0
A0 % 4 $3 N74 5$ % N%8 $% 8# N#% C 5%4%4% $5N$&$ %N8$ $: 0B.0) <0
0 $$% 8$ $ %=2 #$%  %4 % $$ 9$$= $$ % %=2 > 4$3 >%= $4 9 $ 2=$ 0 &' $852 % $% 2 %$ % $3 $ = %= ($ 4$5 4 $% 8' =2 %# % $ $% $ #$ $%5$ '$ % 4% $5%89 $5% #$% $% 2 %$ $0 28$ $ 5$ =2 % $% %$ %$ $% % 4C4 =2 $ 580 % =2 $$% %$ % 28$ $' $ 55$ = 4% $# $% 5%4%$ $% 8'$5 %=$$%$8$ $ % : " .)G .-- %$0 )0. 0 .G)F C $8 5A0.A+*)///)#$)//.'%$0) C $ <0
80 6 74$ 3 8$ $ 2 $$%' $8 4$$ $5$ $%4 $854 $30
$85#%$ N# $% N74=N# $$3' =N # $% % % 4 %$ $5$= 4$ &4 %4% 89 $# %77 %74$ $$=%4$%$ 0 $$' $ N % %% = = $ N %$ $ $4 N $ &$ 4% $5 % # N74 % N 4$3 4$5 4 $% 8: ".).))?%$0A0)B/F "..GAGG %$0A0A+?<0
$8 5 N$4% 4C4 %=N$ %3 %$$5$==$=$$4 $ %674 %5%$= $%'%44N 4 $3N74N#% %% $: ".B.A,-%$0B0.F.).))?%$0A0)B/F..G AGG%$0A0A+?<0
0 %5%44 6 9$ $8 5' $8 %$ = N# $% N74 % $$34 >3 $$% % = N4$$ $% %
*),-.*)//- (-*+(
74$ $% N 3&%#%$N$ $% % 5$ N%89 = N % O 9$$$ $4$ : *BAB*)//, )/ 9$ )//,F *-G?*)//?))%#48)//? 5$ <0
?0 $ ' $ 4 $% 3& 4$3 %$� 23'% $ 6% $% %&$%44$$%0$$2%$%%$ 7$&($ 834$=027$4$ % % 6 9 0 2 $8 $% 55 $# % 2# $$% %&$ 8% %(%44$$%' $ #$ %44$$%$30
D% 834 %$ % ' 8% $ $8 7 $ =$ #$ && = 2>@% >3 %L $ %#$ C =8$ $ 5$ '=27%2$$=$ 0' 4C4 $ % 74 4 $% 2% %44 7 4$6$%$ $%$ '2 %$ % % 44 ' % %9%6$%$ $%%44 $ $#0 2%' %#$ C % 4$$2 $ $5$%&& 2>@% >3= 0
,0 %44$$% 7% $% % = #$ $8 % % B'? % #0 4 $3 % O %$' $8 $% 2 %#%$ $ $4$ 6 28$ $ : " .). ))? %$0 A8 0 )B/ 9$ $ F C $85.G*)///)+5#$)///<0
-0 5$ $ = 2$ $% %44$$% $ 5$ 4 5% =$$% $88%% 2 $8$ $0
% 4C42>@% >3%L% $ #$ 8% % $ . %$ ' % % $ % .G'-? %$ =$ 48$$5$7)/%$ 4$$44=$0
G0 %=' % 9 0 4%4 M" ?//0( 4$6>&% =$%48: 0G- <0
PPPPP
*),-.*)//- (G*+(
)#&$ &
*+,- ./
#8%$ 9 ,9$ )//-!0111111% $$% %44$$%N74#% ,9$)//-F
,-/
9 F
4 6>&% 4%4 M"?//0(F
$ =' %5%44 7 $ ..B $# %$ 5 $8 5 .- 9$ )//? : "(D .-B0../<' C C % 9% =$ $# % $5$ $% (# $8 5' #%$ %% $ $%8$$$F44%$%%$ $$=%$%' 4% $5 4%@# % $& % %%4 $F$ %$ C $8 5' ./// .A' #%$ % % #%$ %$= 7 %$ $% 2 $ A) "0 C $3 %$% % ' $#%= %44 4%@ #' %$# C 9%$ 6 2#%$F
%44$= C 6!"#$%&&$'#% % '$$=N6 %44$$%N74#% 0
D$& ; !0 @>3' $ ' !4 %#@ M$' !0 >$' 9&' !0M% $'9& 0
%4 $84$$ $5;
&55$3(9$ ; $ ; 0$%(D$&$ "0@>3
*),-.*)//- (+*+(
%$%5%4 C %44$=7 $0
3#' &55$3;
*),-.*)//-