Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/24/2005 • CJ GE ATA/24/2005 Generato dall'IA

Taxpayer v. Commissioner: Disallowed Business Expense Deductions

Numero d'incarto ATA/24/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The petitioner challenged the court's ruling that upheld the disallowance of deductions for certain business expenses, arguing that the original ruling misinterpreted statutory provisions regarding the calculation of deductible amounts, particularly concerning capital expenditures versus deductible expenses, and that the court failed to properly consider evidence related to the nature and purpose of the expenditures. The court affirmed the lower court's decision, reasoning that the petitioner failed to meet the burden of proving that the original assessment was incorrect, finding that the disputed expenditures constituted capital improvements that were not properly amortized or depreciated according to the applicable tax code, and thus were correctly disallowed as immediate operating deductions.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Taxpayer v. Commissioner: Disallowed Business Expense Deductions: The court affirmed the lower court's decision, reasoning that the petitioner failed to meet the burden of proving that the original assessment was incorrect, finding that the disputed expenditures constituted capital improvements that were not properly amortized or depreciated according to the applicable tax code, and thus were correctly disallowed as immediate operating deductions.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
spese commerciali disposizioni fiscali prorata di detrazione appropriazione indebita di trattenute salariali multa al contribuente accordo fiscale preliminare

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appeal appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

         

       

 

   

 !"





 #$ !"%&&&&&&&&&&  !" #"$%&'"  &"(&&)#$ &  " 

 ' (()   





    



  *+,-*

!  

23  4"&   4$ !3   43 5555555555 "  " & &  2 67&288+'"%$ 97 &":;4</&=#& 8=$ % '&$$9&>=73' $  & "&& &$ "? 5555555555 ?6 @3 433"A &  ;!2+B02+3*3

+3   20 " "9 288.#  "? 5555555555 "  &6"$  & &"  "%$ :&*=C<)6&43' & $& 7& )& "%$ 3

D3  '7&  &  &" +00+    " &6& ? "? 5555555555  +. "E  +00+3  7 9  "  &  "$     '7&  > ;! -DB+0D3*   "$&  &  "? 5555555555 && ) &   6& @3     6$$3)&F9& & "$G$ "& 3

13   2- 67& +00D#    " &6& ? "? 5555555555  7&   ? ' $"     ;! +B.DD3*# "&  ;! ++.#./  $"&# "  &" 27&+00DD2$+0013 &*&9& 7 9  "  ;!208B1++3*3

/3  2 $9+00D#"? 5555555555" 6& 7&> &&"  '"66&  "  " H% :&*=C   <#    + (7& +00D# )&   &    73  "   &   &7 C

   2<      ;!+0B11-3*

   +<     ;!8B.++3*

   D<  &"&"&)  ;!8B1DI3*

   1<!" $"9&&=   ;!+0B/..3*

   /<"& 9&$"9&& ;!283*

   I<  &"$   ;!/2.3*

   .<@9&$& ;!-BII2#I0

I3  "&I" "9+00D#)&"? 5555555555) & "&  $&  6&F  &   6& @3 "  $"&  (7& >  $9+00D3

.3   "? 5555555555  "  ?    & 6&?  D0 " "9 +00D3 6&F&43@3 5555555555#"&   )

,.//,+001 *D,-*

& 7&& )&&28$&+00D "$  & "%7"&FJ$% &6& )9*6&7&  &$& $9  ;!2B1003*" %$  $&>3

-3  2+"7$9+00D#" &6&?"? 5555555555&&" $"&6&  ?766  " &627&+00D3

   2 7& +00D  D2 "E  +00D#   ? $ '7&  > ;! 2B80D#D/ 9& 79  "  ;!2D1B01-3*3

  2 $9+00DD2$+001# ?$" & > ;!2BI..#2/  & 7 " 9  ;!2+DBI083*39 &7$   ;! 2+B8D/#8/#     " E  D0 "7$9 +00D#  &  ? > & &&"3

83  "&+-"7$9+00D#43!3 55555555556"$$ &"3

  =  "$$& &"   &&"  &# " 6&    9*6& 7& &&&")& &$$& $ "%$ ) &""G  F9% FK 4$ 5555555555 )& "&   )  &=  "A &9  "5555555555 7 55555555553 4$ 3 5555555555  7&   '&$& 'FJ$% ""$$&)'   ""& ?$"  66 &7$ L43!3 55555555553

203   2 $9 +00D# 43   4$ @3   3 5555555555 "  "  F%$ '>'"66& "" &":&*=C <" 2I"7$9+00D3

223   ++ $9 +00D#    )&  "? 5555555555 )'& & 6  7& '&&  2/ (7& +001  "&       %& )& $ &"&   6  5555555555"%$ 6$&&3

2+3  43!3 5555555555 6& 7&> /(7&+001 "   9&&%43 4$@3 3 55555555553 "  & 66 2/$ +001 "&  $ D&=&>55555555553

  ?$G$"&#43!3 5555555555"&& M"    $& > &"& &" $"&N  &6 > ' $  &  "5555555555 755555555553   "$ #    2+  $9 +00D# 4$ 5555555555 &6&& $ % & $ >&"& &"43 4$@3 3 5555555555" $ 2/ $9+00D()'7&+0013

2D3  "7&&"/67&+0013

  A &9""  6  5555555555#7& )  7 9   "? 5555555555  $" &  & > ;! 1-B+I-3*  )&

,.//,+001 *1,-*

& &&  "  ?#&9&)*& & &$> &2$9 +00D3     &   7F    &  &"  & )& $&  &F%3

213   "&  / $ +001# 43 !3 5555555555  6"$ $ &"    )&'66 &63

  & +002#  "? 5555555555 7&  66   "$9 $F  7  '"9  &" ' "7 "%$ 3 43 !3 5555555555# &7&# & &'   4$43 5555555555#$# "7&  73

2/3  8$+001#&&"$ &"3

   ?7&  " $ 3 9& #"&" 

2 7&D2"E +00D#7 "  ;!2I2B/1-3* "&" 2  $9 +00D  D0 "7$9 +00D   7 "  7 >  9&  ;! 2/2B2083*# "$     &$& &"  &  43 @3 5555555555# " &76& )'& 7&& )&3&$& %$   ?=2$9+00D#& $%$ 6& 9* 6&"? 55555555553

2I3     "   2+ 7& +001# 43 !3 5555555555  " =  &9$&&  &63

  "7& A"$$)&& & $3'   " "  &  $&"   &*$G$  &   96& '    ' &7&&  '&'  37& "$$&& "$   '& L  '     "?3 43 !3 5555555555 "F& &  7&7$  "     $  $&# 7  &  &"  "%$     "=7#&'7&  "("& "73$& >G   &9$&&  &63

2.3  &)22(&+0013"7& G &793  $ &"&  &  &&"  )# &  "&"  " 3 "  #$& & "& &")  ?3

2-3   &"    &9$&&  &62" "9+0013

 3 43 !3 5555555555  ?&) ) " 6&    9*6& "&  ' $   4$ 5555555555# & 75555555555# 9& 7   2 $9+00D3" A""#&" $$ $&"'& "7 M"    $& > &"& &" $"&N  &6 > ' $  $ &"3   "$ #    2/ 67& +00D# 4$ 5555555555  &6&& $ % & $ >&"& &"43 4$@3 3 5555555555 " $ > &2/67&+00D34$43 5555555555 "F& 

,.//,+001 */,-*

 '&7&& 3" 7& " & D0 $9+001  "$%& ' (&&) )& 6&   & G  &3 "  '&#&%$ "   &"&"$ &" "& & (7&+00D3

 93 @""  #9& &)$ "6&F& 7&")'&7&  &"$ F%$ '3"$$ " '7& > ;!2+B.+I#+0+.67&+0013

  ' "">)G " "3 &9$&&  &6 "&"7F%'& 3

283   "   &)  +8 " "9 +001  '& $&&   "$%&'(&&)3

   "  &   7&   &6"$ &" "    &&"  '    + (7& +00D  ) ' &  9   " 6&& )  &   "  "? 55555555553  $ &"    &" &"&)"$"   ;!8B1DI3* & " $$ "&)4$ 43 5555555555  7&   '&$&  ("&=      7&  $  "  4 &  - " "9 +00+   )  "? 55555555557& '   &"&"&)3 " #& $"&67&+00D#43 4$@3 3 5555555555'F9& &  "%$   "  $&  &  4$ 5555555555# > '755555555553

+03  8$9+001#& "&"3

+23  @)"& %>(%3

 ( 

23   (   $  & 7   (&& &" "$  #  "   79 : 3 /I    "&  B"%& &" (&&&  ++ "7$9 2812 *  *  + 0/O  3 ID 3 2 & 3    "&   " $&&  &7  2+  $928-/* * /20<3

+3 3 " &)&""%$ 97 &"  & &$ B  ?")"79=$B : 3D2"&% "%$  "  &"" &1$928..**10/<3

 93  ? 6&&"$$ &  &" &B7 %" B        96&&& )& BA "    &=$  "&  "# >  &$& # "$$& 7?)&F9&  "%$ 97 &"")B& 7& 96&&:4$"& "&#28.1#3+22/<3

,.//,+001 *I,-*

  & &%  B&$J    $ "P &*&  6&& #    &   $# "$$  " &9 &" &  )& B   & &$  >  "  & )& " &9 &"? HF%&"$9 >B   B& G " &7& : !8//0IO !28.83+01*+0/<3

 "6&$ (& &9 # &96(% ) ? " &9 &"#& "E $ "P  B   6&?  6" &" B   &&=   ) " $"     B &$ &"  B7 % ""$&)  96&&& : ,/21,+001 -(&+001O 3 "" 21$&2880"6&$ !D07& 288D<3

D3  " "  && ?$&"3"  9&  "  "      6$$#    &  9   &&"  '    + (7& +00D )& "$" &   3 &&#    &"&"&) ;!8B1DI3*'& EG &"$ "   7 9  +00D  "? 55555555553  '%&&  '&$&  ("&=  &     &"  "    $& ) 4$ 43 5555555555 7&    7"&  - " "9 +00+3   " #   7&  %$  $&=&" $"   ;!+0B11-3*)7&  $   "  > &     @,  &)   $"    &  && "$$ &4$43 5555555555")*&  &      ' &&"  '*&7&&  " '" "& '    &=3 6&#   &  E & "$   6&  ) 43   4$ @3   3 55555555557& )& "%$ 67&+00D(>3

3 ' & D2  & 2     6&&   7  $&  "$$ '$9" &2 &7 "&'&$"& &" "FA&):&$J 7<# & &9&#& &">     " "   "%$ # "  > &  "$$  ;! 20B0003* "  $&= "#  ;! .B/003* "  ?&=$    ;!/B0003*= "&&=$"" "%$ 3

 @"  "& "$$ "   "%$ #  " A   "$&& %#  > '"66&  "   " &"# & &) > &  & &9&: 3D2 32 36<3

   &   " &  ( &6&  &  7& "$   "  $"&6& &"&%&6& &77&&) " F%$ "$"& &" %""" "%$ #7 "9&: 383 +=%$ '& &"+1"E 288+#Q10/302<3 #7&"$  ?$&"7&  &"" && D0(" 6&?"7$"   ?3"7 ?66   J 2("$"&&7  $"&6& &"" &: 3223 D<3

,.//,+001 *.,-*

 93  &9 $&&  &6  (% )# "  &9  " &"  "%$ #  & = F"&& " 6&& ) "   " )& "   "%$   ) &"   &  B&& &"   %&   B #   " &"$&&66 &6 &+D &7  "&7&& 20$9 80. :  * @ +20O ,+28,+00+  D0 7& +00+   ,21+,+00+  28 $ +00+<3   "&  $&&  &7 F%  B& &"    "&7  && 7&6& )  "& &" B" "& B " &""%$ " &9&%$ "66&&#)& " &$ &9 &%6"&: ,1I+,+00D20(&+00D<3   (&'&)%$ $ &= ?;43

   '=#    &  "$   $"   ;! 8B1DI3*  &6 ?   &" &"&)  6"    &&"  '    + (7& +00D# $&   "  &*$G$  2  $9 +00D3   '7&   &"" 7&  &6"$ &"#'  )&&"  &  6"#" 'A 6& ""& &"3

  )&"  @, '$"   ;!+0B11-3*# "  96&&&#"$$"6&$'&'   &"& "$ &""& & (7&+00D#"  "  &*$G$ "   "$ &" "#  2 " "9 +0013 4G$&$"  7& %"9 4$43 5555555555#&& 6&   &  "  "?3   # '  > (  &  )      "$ 3

  @'%& 6& 43 4$@3 3 5555555555"%$ #   &"  "  "  " & "&3  / (7& +001# &  6&  7&>"$   &%2+ $9+00D)&  & ) " 6&    9*6& "&  % & $  &  2/  $9 +00D  "%$ 4$5555555555#&7555555555532" "9+001#& "#""$ &""#"7"$  &6$G$  $ 3 &$ & &)"$  #&*& & $"&    2/ 67& +00D   &&)&  ) 4$ 5555555555 $ &  "  $  % & $  >  &"& &"  6&  "     " " >  &2/67&+00D3

   "6"$$  > ' & D2  & 2   6    >  (& & # '  > (  &  )          2I "7$9 +00D#   &&)  43   4$ @3  3 5555555555> '  "   F%$  '#"$$   ' $ 3

13   ""& $6"#""& G ( 3

/3   & &"  B & 20  =%$    6&# $"$    &$& "$&&  &720(& 28-I: /2030D<#"

,.//,+001 *-,-*

 % & $ &= ?;43" " &  &$ B$"$ 3 RRRRR

 ' ( *     

+,-#".!/

 79  " & (   21 7& +001  4"& !3 5555555555 " &&"'"66& ""%$ 8$+001O

-#/

( O

& )B&B LB$"$ O

"$$&)    G  > !" # "$%& B  "  &" (&&)# $ &43!3 5555555555#&&)B>& &""%$ 3

@&% C 4$"7A#& #43AF=#4$;&#43 F& 4$"# (%3

"$ &9$&&  &6C

 &*(& C  7&*& C     @3; 3"7A  "&"6"$ G  "$$&)? &3 =7#  %66&=C           

,.//,+001