Liquidated Damages vs. Penalty Clause Validity
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe decision addresses the validity of certain contractual provisions regarding the payment of a fixed percentage of revenue upon specific triggering events, specifically focusing on whether these provisions constituted an unenforceable penalty rather than a valid liquidated damage clause. The court reasoned that because the stated percentage was disproportionate to the actual anticipated or proven harm from the breach, or because the percentage was applied without a reasonable estimation of potential losses related to the specific triggering event, the provision was punitive in nature and therefore void as against public policy; however, the court also considered whether a different, related provision for a fixed fee, absent a reasonable pre-estimate of damages, was similarly unenforceable or if it represented a permissible alternative remedy.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Liquidated Damages vs. Penalty Clause Validity: The court reasoned that because the stated percentage was disproportionate to the actual anticipated or proven harm from the breach, or because the percentage was applied without a reasonable estimation of potential losses related to the specific triggering event, the provision was punitive in nature and therefore void as against public policy; however, the court also considered whether a different, related provision for a fixed fee, absent a reasonable pre-estimate of damages, was similarly unenforceable or if it represented a permissible alternative remedy.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for the allocation of procedural costs.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of party costs.
Testo completo
!
"# # " $ % # " " &
!"#
() +, -. /01 23 .04 ,
- 542 676 , . ."08 859 659 !'': .;8.7. 78.-+8...0823 69.5 5. , 645. 576 /9.3 55 045/.576/9.5.0.(< 859(<<%-#':)'(2045/.576/9. 5.0=.8.!&>(<<<-#':)'&2)
!) . % 859 !'':3 ! 53 ! < 5. !''#3 8. 55.. (#3 !$ ?8.3 &( 53 (< ?. !''#3 =6 /.. 564. 9@.53 083 55.. A9. +..-. /01 B 23.8;.6C4 D5/6C.%.=66E9(<<< .. 5..5 8. . //.9 F 8. 676+.5C5/45-.8. 6762 -6 + E!&)!'23 /.6 . 5 5 /5D/..5..58.. 8.4,08C.8.6.66)
&) C==. C./. . 8. -. /01 C==.2=.5G5&(93!&859!'':3:8. (#5.!''#)
$) &'5.!''#3.6.5/)
:) (%?.!''#3C .8.6,=.8..CG 6..F?)
.//($?.!''#C ;8.66 .=.F.<(!.=66(&5(<#$8. C..3C.55- +E!!)((2..;C,C. (& C ( (' 5. !''' .8 , . 8. - ( +E!!)(((23/.=.,6).//8.8.5 )
/3 . C F3 .. 5..5 .C8./66/6)
#) =F!$9!''#3.=56 F;85 .=6?5.;./5.859659 !'':8.66==6)
"$%!&"!''# &"#
%) 6.. < 859 !''#3 C .=.46 , 5 HAE'') 3F;C?.=.,7 HA:'') 655 HA !'') 3 . 5 HA (I:'') ) C.=. F .. 5..5 8.3 5 5...8 HA :I''') / 6. /6J . 6. 6. ; C/. 66/..=.)
. 6.. ..;. 8. 6. .9 5...=)
E) /6 6.. /6.6 / &' 859 !''# 6 , C 5. / . .9 5...= ($659!''#)
859 !'':3 8. 5/. .8 5 53..56/C ) /0 5..538.K.C 8L F .. 5..5 8. +. M=9. ...N) 558../97C.8.6 ; C 6. /. . . 563 8. 6566 5 9 =. =565 , 8.) /0 CF6. 8F3 8. 5/. 8L6 =5. 56) 5/. / 5.0 C4. C==. .5. C5.?.=.6)
<) 6/!E=68.!''%3C C//6)
8.. .. . 5..5 8. 66 /.5 /;.C8.?5.69. =6?5 .F..6/ F;C8.==.8586,8.) C8. / 5 8.6 .. 5..5 5.0 .3 5. 645 =. 8. 5/L6 7 C7. 5 /68 / 8. .8 8. - 2 -) !)'!23 ..64.,=./055../..5/6) =.3C6./98...<(! )
C5 .=.46 8. 9 ...=3 8. , ; C/. 640 /. L65.;5 C596 . 5..5F 8.4+.)=.FC55...83C .5/ 48.6 C.=.) C/03 C6 . C68. , HA $I(::)
- !I:<%) 3 F 74 (3#23 ;. 8. 56 C==. , .=.4 56. HAE'') ) F=.D3.6./68/ C.<.6!6)C6556.;,./68/C. ##.6$045C//...C./.. 8.- (':)'(2)
"$%!&"!''# $"#
"
() ?6 5/ . 8 ?... 5/63 89-):# .I4..?...!!859(<$( ! ':J ) #& ) ( .) . /6 5...8 (!/59(<E: :('2)
!) ;.6C5/LL.04,C6435. ,6-.(2)
&) C9? ..4 .5.6 , C5 5...8 .=.46 , / C8. / /6 .. 5..5 8. . 8.4+.36/6.6;.96C/5/6 8.C//.66..;..5.-)#(.6! 2)
$) //.. C. < .6 ! 63 C.6 5/6/.=.455...8 HA:I''') 5F.55 C.=. / 48.6 , C. ! 63 ;. / 9? ..5..58..)
) 5 5...8 /63 .0 /5 ..4 .5 5 .. / ; 5/65...8/5.0./5.F.) I.;;.6/.5...8.G=.F65/ /../466F64../6- "$:&"!''#&(>!''#J ) O3 . 5...= 1 5...= D3 8) !3 !''!3 7) ()$):):3 /) (&< J ) +) H+ 3 +7P.Q.7 +=7 1 45. Q4 +=9R.3 3 #05 6..3 S.7!'''3/)&%2) 8I.(./648. (%859!''#- $':23.L.=.//.../.. 466/6!(659(<&%-+ &(()'2)
9) /.9..6 8 F.4 ; . . . 55. =
- G ():&("!''! /6.6 J A ('( 9 && .) & J "(#E"!''$ !:=68.!''$J)O3/).)3)()$):)23=> =5I.5/ 64.4) . . / /../ //..6
- "(#E"!''$!:=68.!''$J):>(<<%2)O6.53546 I/ 6/. ..8. ;I 5 / /3 I5... .58././F;..8435. ./..05;8..4835.=8.4./ 686.6 . ;I / - A ((( 9 !(&J ('& 9 (!# J ('' ( &#J ) O3 /) .)3 /) ((E ) ()$)&)()2) 9. 5G5 /../ //..6 . G /6 I5 5...8 . G 56 I/0 . 3 686.6 I.5/ / 6
"$%!&"!''# :"#
8 .5 / . I.6G .8.6
- A(''()
+ ?./3 I.6 ;. / 5 5...8 ./ I 4 /8. I//6..J I ;I IF0 ; .9 5...= - "%$"!''% !' =68. !''% 6=6.62)
5.C.=.;..6./763.;C 865/65.,8.)+45..8, 9=.0/./;.;...4.3 ,8.;.6C55...8)
C/038/48.6C.=.5/=.; 6/6 C.=. ;. . 6. /763 C5 66 6. , HAE'') 3.,5..;.05C55F.5)
C.<.6!6/68.;C.6/5 /.=.D,74C5/L=.=)C G6, HA:'') .=.;.59.98.)
+C4. =. C655 HA !'') .=.46 , //..C.##.6$ 3.C4. ,55F.55) 8 .5/59;C>==.9. F;C 3559?.=.6)
8 ;. /603 . //T ; C C / F66 /8. C//6.. ; 6.. ;. == 4.= . G =.56)
:) ?6) C. ..43 655 HA:'') 5.,74;.59)
UUUUU
%# "
'()*+,
6 89 .?6 & 659 !''# / +, 6.. C==. I./. . 8. <859 !''#J
"$%!&"!''# #"#
)*-,
?J
5,74655 HA:'') J
. ;3 =565 F . E! .8 . =66 .9 =66 (% ?. !'': - A + (%&)(('23 /6 G / G /6 ? ;. .8 .=.. / 8 .9 =663 / 8. 5.0./9.J565....;.3 5.=5L/8/.45.J. . G 6 .9 =663 (''' ($3 / 8. / / 8. 6.; F .. I. $! A) /6 G /.0 /. 3 .8;6 55 5L /83 .8 G ?. , I8.J
55.;/6G,+,..;C,C==.I./. .8.)
+.641 O58L3/6.3O)L703O) 76.3O53?43 O) 3?4//6)
5 .95...=1
4==.0 ?.?)).)1 8. /6.1 ) )8L
/.=5G6655.;6F/.)
083 4==.01
"$%!&"!''#