Liquidated Damages Clause Enforceability Due to Damage Election Provision
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the enforceability of a contract provision stipulating liquidated damages following a termination without cause, where one party sought to recover actual damages despite the clause. The court reasoned that liquidated damages provisions are generally enforceable if they represent a reasonable forecast of the harm caused by the breach and are not a penalty; however, because the contract allowed the terminating party to avoid the liquidated damages by electing to pay actual damages, the provision was deemed an unenforceable penalty because it offered an option that negated its intended compensatory function by allowing the breaching party to escape the stipulated sum without demonstrating the impossibility of the forecast.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Liquidated Damages Clause Enforceability Due to Damage Election Provision: The court reasoned that liquidated damages provisions are generally enforceable if they represent a reasonable forecast of the harm caused by the breach and are not a penalty; however, because the contract allowed the terminating party to avoid the liquidated damages by electing to pay actual damages, the provision was deemed an unenforceable penalty because it offered an option that negated its intended compensatory function by allowing the breaching party to escape the stipulated sum without demonstrating the impossibility of the forecast.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the costs order, as the appeal was dismissed.
Testo completo
!" #$%&
&
! ! ! ! " ! !
#$ ! ! %!!& ' ! !
# # ! ! ( !! ) * ! & ) * !'(&#)$%&
*+,-*
23 ##&204%#+11-$5#'#6%#&44## ++ 4%# +11-$ 7 & #& 8&&)# 6#4&7 #& 9#*: ; < #% &# #& & # 9&//60+2*=< > &# #7 ?3 3 9#*: ; #7<$ #:) > :%$ & # #& 6 #775 7## #4$ &77# 8@ # # &# &77 #$ #*# A 75B$ 87#& 3
+3 ?&6&# #&A &#) 5?#B9#*:; ?<$ #:) > #$ 6&# #& A' #& # #& 6 &7&5#B 9#*: ; ' <$ #:) > # )7 $ &77##& & &7 #:& #&9#*:; ! <6 &# #& & # #% 20 4%# +11- 7& #4 " &C # #)#D6 # &4&7&#" #9 <$#"68@ &C # : +E1 7: "6 &) #& # & && #&65F #7 $#7 6 #4 )G # 3 6)## 6 7# #& "# &%# H "#4# 7#I6 # 6# H )$#"& #&68@ # &C 6# H 4###73
.3 +E& &5+11-$#7&& ##& ! & >6 #&&&##"6>&4#7 #&A%## B 6 &# #& & # #% 20 4%# +11-3 6 &# #&& #%# #%5%##77 4%&53 ##& " # 8 6 7 #3 68@ %# H #4# 8& #7: # > & %DJ&5 G&3 )5# # 5F #7 6%# >K )G**8 &> /3 6 #.#=&# ) G& %&7 +/ C# 2/E0 9#*: ; L M 2.E<%# 7#:2%#+11= 7 # "6&C 6 A7&N7#&# 8#" &#& 7& #46# H )C #4#B3
=3 2/ 75 +11-$ )7 & > 6 #& ##& ! 5#7 6 &# #& & # & //O0+*=$ 7& #4 " 7 C&## 6 ) &%&# 6# #&&& @&4&7# 6&C %&# " #$ 6%5 A):7 B %# #7 &% 2 %#+11= D 6 #.#= L # 6 &C && 3
,./+0,+11- *.,-*
6:$ %&J# 44 #%7 & #&68@ $7# #%# ## #7 #7 G&# # @ 68J&5 #3 & #&$ # %# #% 6 &# #& & #3 7# #& &%# H &#&77):I%8$& # # #& #& %# &%675 %#3
E3 2/C%#+110$ ?##"' & #4&7 #5"6# # %>&%#7 &# )7 >6 #& ##& ! 2+ 75+11-##"6>&4#7 #& 6 &# #&4## #%& ##%204%#+11- & &//60+2*=3
-3 +EC%#+110$ #& #4&7" # )> C)3
!
23 &+E& &5+11-& ##& 2+ 75+11- 7#& #4#+E7H77&#$& %5&# %3 6 )7 )&7 #59 3E- &# O&)# #&C###++&%752/=2** +1EI 3-.32 3&#&7## #%2+ 752/KE* * E 21<3
+3 6 #-/#2 $C## #&7## #%8) #&#& #3&$C## #& 7## #%&# &# 6&44#3
6:$ 675 # # #)$ J &7# # #7$ & > 6 #& ##& ! 5#7 6 &# #&& ## #)#3
.3 6 # . # = L$ &C & #& 5# & &7 6 G& %&7 &#% H &4&7 "6#& & 3 & 4&#$&& @&4&7# "H 6 &# #& & # % $ 7 " &C 6 7&N7#&# 8#"&#& 7& #46# H )C #4#3
3 ?&C#& $ 4## 7#:## &7: " & & >6# ##7: "6#
,./+0,+11- *=,-*
4#D 9 ,-2K,+11E +1 75 +11E ,-K=,+11+ 2+ &%75 +11+<3
53 ?& 67# &# # 2 %# +11=$ &C # #)#D &%# 6 "A):7 B 3
&C& & C#$ 7 6 5F #7 6 7: &&# > 7# #&7#9 !32+C%#2//.<## " #&6P#)& ##&6# H 5#& > # #&4# &44#D85# #775&$ ## " 9 . & &5 2//1<3 7# 7 # 211 7+ P#) & # 6 &# &77 7# #& 7#$ 7# &77 8)7 7##5 6:
9 ,EE/,+1112= 75+111<3
?6)# # #)$# #& 5"&C &# 6 " 7# #&# H &#&77 7#$%7 6# 65F #7 3 7# #& & 6)7 675 &# %# &&> 6# H )#"67 6&#)5F #7 " #&G& & #&#@ 68J&5# # &#&77#36# H )&776 7# #&$ &% & 6& #& 6 #& #& : ##: 6:$ "# D#) G& # &@ 3? # #"& >&#> 67##&&3
=3 # 4&$ & &# H 7# ##& ! 2+ 75 +11- $ 6 &# #& & # & //60+2*= 5#36J#&7& #7 6#7# & D# #7$:&" &# &7&& #) &&7& &"%# H &73 J # 4# &7 &C&# 7 &##7 675 # > & 7#: # > 7&7 Q' +O1113* 9 3K0 <3
RRRRR
,./+0,+11- *E,-*
$ !
+,-./0
%5&# C +E& &5+11-&# #7?3 3 & ##&&77##& &&7 #:& #& 2+ 75+11-I
-.10
67 I
##&&77##& &&7 #:& #& 2+ 75+11-I
5# 6 &# #& & #&//60+2*=#%204%#+11- 7 & #& 8&&)#6#4&7 #&I
&7&# #7?3 3$' #&# #&6 &7&5#9' <$ &#) 5 ?# 9 ?<$ ## " 7 & #& 8&&)# 6#4&7 #& #7 $ &C&# 7 &##7 $ 6 7&7 Q'+O1113*I
# "6#6 &6#7# I
# "$ &4&77 D # K+ #% &# 4 #5 4 20 C# +11E 9 '*? 20.3221<$ H H & C& "# #% & #4# #& *% #5 4$ %&# &7 #:&# 5#I77&#&&# ##"&#&$ 7& #4 7&J% & #) & &&7 #I# &# H #5 4$ 2111 2=$ %&# & & %&# &#" D &# #& O # =+ '3 H #: &#&& $#%&"&777&J%$&#% H C&# > O%&#I
&77#" H >!" #$%& & ##"O> &77##& & & 7 #: & #&$ 7 & #& 8&&)# 6#4&7 #& ## "6> ! '(&# )$ %& ' #&# #&6 &7&5#9' < &#) 5?#
9 ?<3
,./+0,+11- *-,-*
?#) ; !7&%J$# $!3J8:$!7Q#$!3 8#$!7&$ C)3
&7 #57## #4;
)44#:*C# C33#3; %#*# ; 3 3&%J
&#&4&7 H &77#"D #3
:%$ )44#:;
,./+0,+11-