Contractual Interpretation of Post-Termination Adjustments Valuation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned a contractual disagreement over the calculation of post-termination adjustments, specifically regarding the valuation of work in progress and materials, where the contract provided two potentially conflicting methods for determining these values. The court reasoned that while the primary contractual provision dictated one method, the later, specific provision concerning termination was intended to control in this scenario, requiring the application of the method stipulated for termination proceedings to resolve the outstanding financial adjustments.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Interpretation of Post-Termination Adjustments Valuation: The court reasoned that while the primary contractual provision dictated one method, the later, specific provision concerning termination was intended to control in this scenario, requiring the application of the method stipulated for termination proceedings to resolve the outstanding financial adjustments.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive order regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!"""""""""" !""# $%#
#
# $ %#% &'$%## # #%&$ ## # # & # #
&'()&
#
*. !/0.1111111111$2.11111111113"&45!/0.1111111111 # # 6 # 1111111111 *7)' !#" 0.1111111111 3"& 45 !.0.1111111111 # 89&#:#" 6. "# 8; 0.1111111111 1111111111*7)<.
*'# #=',,,$ "=/"4" $ / #%"#"$ # // ;"9 # "= "# 8 " !.0.1111111111>!/0.1111111111. :?/ ;#/ # : " # @ *+ :" ',,*$ ;"9 # "= "# > 2A*B7C+.&#"#*:%"<,:"',,,$"> 2A'B+,,.&4 *:" ',,,.');%"',,'$ "=/"4" "# "%#/"?#90.1111111111#/ !.0.1111111111 "/ 8# "= "#>8 "!/0.1111111111>D 2AE,,.&/#":F8>8G? " .
'. 8" %$ !/ 0.1111111111 %" / %" # 8% #%/ "# "/ " 3"&45 0 6$ #% "# 'C #%/= ',,*$ # /D " 4 # 9	. 4 * /= ',,*$ % /8/# 2A)<<.&" #.
!/ 0.1111111111 # # 'E #%/= ',,*$ " # #9	##"/ # "= "# " 8 ";/".
<. 89/ # ;# " # !/ 0.1111111111 'E #%/= ',,* 3(*C*<*(',,*6$ "=#"#>" "#.#'/"',,'$!/ 0.1111111111 9# F8 D=" " #;;""/ > 9$ %"% " DH/">!#?I$A%#"".D#"9%"%2 &0%#" %" " "# ##/"F. #"" # /"$ !. 1111111111$ " '+ /" 8 " " "/ % " F " ;" 8',,,.*' /=',,'$ "=#"# "4 #. /#" #;"/ F8" %" D /"# > !#?I /#" :" ',,, # I %"% % !/ 0.1111111111. "/ $"D=?" D #/?#"/"#$ #J;" # ;#"#/". /#"" " /#" /=',,, /"4" 8" A.
:?/ *C/=',,'$ "=#"#" F !/ 0.1111111111 " #/""" 8 ',,,$ > # /#"
('*+,(',,- &<()&
:F8/#" /= &>$ #4%$# F :"" "# "" " #/ # %"# "# 8#="? "#8 "#//"4/#":%"',,,.
-. K8#"#8##3(C<+C(',,'6#% # !.0.1111111111>" 8" #0 # "# /#" /= ',,* > " / ',,'$ "= #" #"$ :?/ *, /= ',,-$ F8" %" "#/ "# "$ !/ 0.1111111111 %"% " A%#""L#//# " M# "#NF8%" ;" #(*C*<*(',,*O.
+. ""#'* /=',,-$0 /";"/ F"" %" #;" !/ 0.1111111111 'C #%/= ',,* /# "; F 8" 8 " #/"""$ " "" /"4 / #. " ?/ "%" >?%%"##%" /#" /=#/ %F""%" %" */=',,*$#" #// 2A*,BCC*.&.
C. ', # #= ',,-$ !/ 0.1111111111 # # ""#
0 . %" "$ "" F # ;" *7)<$ /#I # #9$ F" " F" 0" # %" ;"F. %" #% D ##/"">4%#J"" 8 / $ F D=" " #% # " #"A.0## $8 "E3"PQ 5)6#" B% #%/ "#"/ "''%"*7EE3 & *'+6$I " #/"""$ F" "" FL#=;"" %$"%" @ #/""" #"/#" 3" *6O %" @ #/" #// 89"# 8" "# ?" ;%#" # " % # 4%. 8 " # . I %"" I F" " "/R $ # "= ""="&@ ?.#S $" "##?/ " F###/"F/ ;"= " # " #?D# #.
!/ 0.1111111111 / =/ " "# 8;; ";. # >8 "#""# ".
E. '7# #=',,-$0 8 ##>/ " "# 8;; ";/# ";F8" @ ="# #//" ?? #%9 ;" ;% # $ F" =;""" / :>8%"#"<*:%"',,<. "#" ;; % " > 9 # 8 " + 4?/ B" "##"B% #%/ "#"/ "
('*+,(',,- &-()&
':"*7)C3 & *'+.,*6$#"%" 9 "## %"" "/.
). - #%/= ',,-$ " "= /"" "; : //#%""#/#J# " 89 "# / 0 "#%$# # F / /=#/ "4 8%" 4 "//" / 9 #".
7. *,/=',,-$0 ##." $" ;""" # "##/"".;" #;9 "'< #"%""*,/=7,E3 0&0'*,6# :" "= /"" "; 3 (E<E(',,< E # #= ',,<6. # %" 8"&/@/""F##" "# "= #"F8"" DH/">!#?IA F8 " " "/ %""*)/#"/#/ #" "#. %" # " #>8 ? #>9#J " # " 8 / .# 8%" ""#" 9%/ 8% %" /" /=#%" ?" $#" #// 2A*,BCC*.&.
*,. *E/=',,-$ "# "=5
. !/0.1111111111#;"/ "#F8%" ;" # 8" "=#"'/"',,'.0"%" F" # 4%$8 " ##%#"#?>/#""9>!#?I#JD=" " # /". / " F8#%" ;" / %"%A$/"" "/ " > 4% " 8%" . #"F8G? '' $ # ;" " #:# "4/ > D?. "?#" #J #%" # 9&#:#" . "" &@ DT#DH#;4$/""8?"" &>8"/ #" "#. 8"?#" 9 $ /" "/" F #" 8 " 9 "# ##/"F . # " # "= "# # 4% # %" "/R %. " 4#> #8".
=. 0 9# F %" # " /" A$ #DH "4. 8 " # #/"""0".""# " #;#/>#" # # "# #" %"# "# "" 8?" " / . #S $ "=#"8 " "#/ "#"*, /=',,-3(C<+C(',,'6 "I%" ""%:?/ .
9 "# " #"# "= ";#/F " ?>:?.
('*+,(',,- &+()&
# &
*. : / " % :"" "# #/ $ # %=3 .+C #"B#?" "#:"""''#%/=*7-*& & ',+Q .C<.* .#"#/"" "%*' /=*7)+& & +*,6.
'. # 8 > ""# 8 #" " "/ '* /=',,-/# ";F&"" # ">#"$/"F #"&/@/" 9"# 5
. 0#:" "=;$:? $""$" 9 ? " F"%#F. "" 8 =#. ;; $ " #"= F 8 #/ ## > # %" =. ""$8 #" F""F#" 8 F8"9" /# ";"9F 9 ## ##" %" = "#" "# %". /# "; % %9 #"$;#/ = " "#$""F "#%8 "#" "#3 A*'-'C+#".<.'C)Q*'*-C, #". -(== . -C+ @ " 6. D# "" ;""$ #" "# ;# #" "= / 8 9 "#" # " 3 A)<<<#".<.<-'$ E+'<#".*.+'+6.
=. 9 > " "% 5 L# =;"" %$"#" @ #/""" #"/#"O 3 " ) " * Q # /?"5 L#/"" "O6$ %"?"+;%"*7)<.
0#:" "=$ 9 8 ")"* ".""FF#=;""%$"#" @ #/""" # " /#". %9 #" ;#" "?/ #// "$ " 8 F #/"" #" @ ;" "; F8";;" 8@ #/""">4%/"F8"; I " ;; "%/ 3!/#" #" *7),$ .*-C)Q *7)'$.<''*Q (*)*(*77)<*/*77)6.
# #F"F" #4%8""#" > %> 8 ")"*/#J#/ " %#" ##/""3 (*)*(*77)" 6.
08?" "" 8 9 "$ %"? + ;%" *7)<$ # // #;"/:" "=$"8I "#8 .0#" 9%0 #F" #/""" #4%# // .8I"8"
('*+,(',,- &C()&
/ #/"$%#"8 8" "#/# ";F8"" ""4/ ";;"" #9#? #.
<. 0#8 "'< $#/"" # # "#J" %8" "#8I =".# "##/""#8 %## #" ;U#= 8 $/"; "# %## " ;; "% ". ; F8" I " " "# #% " " / 8 ;"$ "#$ "##.
84$"# "## &/@/ % "= "= #" F 8 /#" % "4 :"" "# F 8" %" /"# D ##/?#>!#?I/#":" ',,,. F#" 9 > F # 8I =" % # /" " "/$ "'C#%/=',,* #% "# "8" V #I8;; $8?" > # /#"%$# #%" =;""" "#8 ") .%U# # %/"4" %# @ /=#.
-. 8 #" " "/# "/ />##/ " "# 8 " ' " * $ # F$ # #= " 8" % "# %"$ " #" @ #/""" # " ;U# / #.
!@/"# #4%/ /#I$" F8 " ' =## # / %" % /" =" # " % "#0 >#" "##/""#"/ # 3 " ' . *6$ ; " =" "&/@/ #/""" # " ;U# / " # 3 " ' . '6. F "# %#"" "#" "#?/ ""#8=?;;" / ""$ # " % "# %" " $ 84$ %# > 8D ;" #/"" > 8 ? # / " "4 /" #=" ".
84 # ;#"$ # #/"""$ #// # 8 % A =" "8 #0".8" % "#8 #" ="F ?%#"8" 4# # $ # F ""# " "?"$ / #J #/# ?/ ;" / F""" 8" "/># @ ?/ #;"/.
+. # : .
K 8 ")E"* $:"" "#/"" "%F" ""# ;"# /#/ .8/#/ 8@
('*+,(',,- &E()&
894 2A*,B,,,.&%#" 2A*+B,,,.&3 .'.* '4?/ ;"$/#/ "/" #/"" "%<,:" *7)C W +*,.,<6$ "% DI# D4. #/" 8" #%/ "# "/ " ;"? " 9 "# "" "/ ;"$# 8 "*,4?/ .I#";" " "# "" ? F # # 3;.# // (<*E(',,- ', %" ',,- "" F ())<(',,< '/=',,<6.
/#/ 2A<,,.& /" > D? # $ F" #/= 3 . )E D. * 6. # 8 # #" > "/" #. XXXXX
%#& ( #
)*+, -
%= # " : ', # #= ',,- !/ 0.1111111111 # ""# %" # B% #%/ "# "/ "'* /=',,-Q
+,-
: Q
/ >D?# /#/ 2A<,,.&Q
#//"F @ > ! "" # $ %# # "" FB %" #B% #%/ "#"/ ".
0"? 5 !.ID4$" $!/#%I$!/2"$!. D"$!/#$ :?.
#/ "=/"" ";5 ?;;"4&:" 5 " 5 ."#&0"?" A.ID4
('*+,(',,- &)()&
#"#;#/ @ #//"F9 ".
4%$ ?;;"45
('*+,(',,-