Private Construction Under Governmental Franchise as Public Works
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute centered on whether a certain type of commercial construction was subject to a specific statutory requirement for public works projects, where the entity initiating the project was a private party acting under a governmental franchise or privilege, or was instead considered a purely private undertaking. The court reasoned that because the construction was undertaken by a private entity utilizing a governmental grant of authority to perform what was essentially a public function, the project fell within the statutory definition of public works, thereby mandating compliance with the associated procurement and labor requirements.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeELIMINATION; CIRCONSTANCE EXCEPTIONNELLE; ETUDIANT; UNIVERSITE | Rappel de la notion de circonstances exceptionnelles. En l'espèce, la recourante a dû faire face à l'attaque cérébrale de sa mère et au décès de son père en 2002 ce qui l'a plongée dans la dépression.Cet état dépressif a affecté son jugement et sa capacité de concentration lors de la session d'examens d'automne 2003 (selon certificats médicaux). Recours admis. | RU.22 al.2
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Testo completo
!" #$% !"# $!% &'%
%
&
"
' ( (
)*+,)
'
01 !2$"1&0/3'$0454&6%$7$%2$& $22 $8 9$'$ :'$2 6;$'*..*1 2$8< $ %%2$= %$ ($):> ? @ ?$ 6A $' $72 $ $%$ $%: '%$$6B2 62$$%86$'$ % $ % 6$C2 71
*1 6$$%6B22&3$ % %#*../&2%A 7%# !2"1 $ *&D/ ,&..'&%222$ & % /&*D1
/1 %:)'# $% 9% %# *../& 05 % %# *../& % $ $ $$% 9B$%1 $$% $$= = !2 "1 %' $2$? ? 9'%$%# & 22$:6 & 2%A7%$8/&..1
-1 *E % %# *../& !2 "1 ?%2 %%$ $% % $$% 6$2$ $% %$$ 6 %$ $%%'%$%#2$:1 $'%=?$ =2:'$ '$ $26 =#2%$2$ *..* =%: $ 2%$6% %#2F21 $% %#:2 ?2$$B& G %2$ 8 $ $1 % &:%:$7';%2% $%=$6%7 $%1"%%#:2 &8'%$6 $?=6 %'& $ % A ;2 9 $7 # % %'%$ % $%' $%6B21
D1 $$% %%$ $% 0 2# *../& ? %?$2 $$% 6B$% % =6 $% ?$# %# 2$:6 %2 ?$ =2% $?$'%=8 6$%%%$ $%$ $??$ 1
,1 *0 2# *../& !2 "1 $$ %22$$% % 9$'$ ( @ 9 % % $$% $ 1 6 $$2 ? B 2% $? $'%= % % %%$ $% ?$ 8 6$7 %$%%;?$6 %$8 ?$2$:$ $%$ $%1
51 $0-3'$*..-&!!16 % $ %?$ F !2 "11 2 6% %$ 6 $ 2 $ ?$ %'%$ %2 6 %1 #2 & $ % 8 $ $% 6?? $? $$2 86 $%$$%=1
+*-,,+*../ )/+,)
E1 $ %22 $-?'$*..-&!2"1%?$2 $% % =6 ' ' 6 2$= *..*+*../ =$ $ 8 # 7'2 1 % ;% 1 $$ = A;%%7 $ !1 '$ %?$2 = 7' %#:2 2: :%:&B 2 $2A;$= : $2% & '$ H $?)B$B ': =$ '$ $2 ?%2 $ $ $ $ 2 A;% ; $= 2$2 B1 $$ '$ 72 %?$2 =6 $' $ 2 = & %$ $ $ 8 $ % $'$ $1 !2 "1 % $$2 8 = $$%%%$ $%%$ 8=9%$ %$8%22 2$A6 :? 2 6;$'*../+*..-1
41 '$ 8 2$ = $% 6?? $?& ? 6A %%D?'$*..-1
0.1 $$%D?'$*..-2%'$$%& 3 2 $ $%6?? $?1
001 %?%0*2*..-&6$'$ %3 % 8 %?$2 $% $$% =1 %$ ?$ = % 6$ $22$ 2 % 2$ %$: B =$$ 6$8?$?8%#:2 $%??$% $1 % &=$'$ 38?? $'$ $%A&$ G % 2%A ?$ 6'%$ 2B$22 6$ 6$ %%%%# $2%$2%A2$$2$2 %#1
01 $$7% $$%%%$ $%02#*../ $ 3 $ 7 ?%2 $ : 9 %$ %2 & % '#( 1,*%$9$'$ *,2$045/)I 0/.J 1E5 :72 9$'$ 5 2#04EE)I 0/.1.,J 1*, *5 :72 $ $? B % 9%%$ $% % *D ?'$ 0455)@1
*1 "%9 1,/1/&%$ $%9$2$ $% $ % ?$B 1 9 1 1 * $% =9 $2$ 9 $ =$ ;% 8 B2%8$%9B2B=$ ' :72 9 ($ 1@%9 $ =$#$ B2 2$ $?$B:72 9 ($ 1#@1
/1 1 "%6 10*1* D:72 6 ? " "6% %# *..*( @&$ $$$ %# $ 2%A$%7
+*-,,+*../ )-+,)
8 -&.. $ % 6 $?$ 8 /&.. (1 *@1 6; 8 $% 6 %2&6 $ ?$2$:% =6$$ %# 2%A7%$8/&..(1D@1 9 10/10$ 1# &#$ ;?$$ $? $2$? &6 $ =$6%# 2 2$:6 2%A7%$8/&..1
#1 9:& 8 6$ $% 6B2 6% %# *../& % %# 2%A 7 *&D/ ,&.. '& %22 2$ & % /&*D12%A%# $?$ BB$7 10* 0/ 9B%$ &%= &8F $2$? 1
-1 1 % 8 2$ $ ? $ G $ $% B $%&9 11/&' 6$2$% 1
#1 "% 3$ % & 9 B $% = $ $% =$ $$:2 7' % 9 $ 1 %= $% B $%% &$ $%'F :B $%= $ ?? # % G2 %'% 19B2 $% B $%& %A % $ $% 9 7 %'%$ 9$ $% =$ $ %?: %$#$$ ;%$$ $ % $%1 & ?$ & # $ % $ $% 8 9 %$ 2$= $2$ 8 '$?$ = )$ 9 # %'%$ 9$ $%=$$ %?$($$% 1052$*..*J1 D ?'$*..*J"1*-2*..-@1
1 $=% %H =:6%; 7%$$% B $%($$% 1* 2#*..*J1,%G *..*@1'2F27'%#:2 =$ ' 72 F 7 $ $% B $% 3 $?$ %%7 $% $%$ $% $ ($$% 103$ *../@1"97$ %#:2$8 A;$= ;A$=& % 22 %=?? $%& % %=9% ':&' $A ;2 '$9 $ $2$ %%'%$ % $%1
1 6:& $ $% = % G ?$ ? 8 6 = # 2: $$ =6 : % : 6 *..*1 $% 2$ A;%%7$= %$ %& 8 '%$ ;%1$$=A;%%7$!1&%?$2 = %#:2A;%%7$=% %??% %=':2 2 $ #$ = % $? ?? % 372 $ % $%%$%9B29 %2*../1
1 62# 2 2 $ 72 %2 $% 8 2F2 6F =$?$ 6B $%1
+*-,,+*../ )D+,)
% %$ $$ F 2$ $$% = 1 % %$ : % F 2$ 8 %# 2$: $ % 6 2$=*..-+*..D1
D1 6$ $ $7& $ 6A $ '%$ 2%2 1% A $%$%'$ ?$ & %22 K<D..1)$%8 $ 6$2$ 6 1E51* %$%2$$ $'0* 2#04ED( ) D0.@1
LLLLL
) '*
+#,-!".
'#%$ 3 *02#*../!2$"1% $$%? $%%2$= %$02#*../J
,/.
92 J
$$%=J
'%$%$8? $%%2$= %$%%'$$% %$ J
$ =9$9 M92%2 J
% 8 % $2$ % K< D..1)& 8 ;7 9$'$ :'J
%22$= $$%8!!1&'% !2$"1&8? $ %%2$= %$& '$ 3$$= 9$'$ $$ =9 2 9$ $%#$=1
$01"/ 2.
!2%'A&$ & !2<$;2 !2 %) 2$$'$&22#1
+*-,,+*../ ),+,)
%2%22$$%%9$'$ >
7??$:> $ > 1<= 1%'A
%$%?%2 $$% %22$=B $1
:'& 7??$:>
+*-,,+*../