Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ACOM/10/2008 • CJ GE ACOM/10/2008 Generato dall'IA

Secured Creditor Priority vs. Anti-Deficiency Statute in Collateral Proceeds Distribution

Numero d'incarto ACOM/10/2008
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute involved the interpretation of a provision regarding the allocation of proceeds from the sale of certain collateral, specifically concerning the application of an anti-deficiency clause to proceeds recovered in a third-party bankruptcy proceeding, where the collateral was subject to multiple security interests. The court reasoned that the relevant statute, which limited deficiency judgments against the debtor, did not preclude the application of the contractual priority agreement among creditors regarding the distribution of funds recovered through the bankruptcy claim, as the anti-deficiency provision was concerned with the personal liability of the debtor, not the contractual rights between secured creditors concerning collateral proceeds.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

; INSTITUTION UNIVERSITAIRE ; ÉTUDIANT ; EXAMEN(FORMATION) ; OPPOSITION(PROCÉDURE) | Procédure en matière de contrôle des connaissances ; art. 15 ss. RIOR Recourant contestant la notation de deux examens jugés insuffisant dans le cadre d'un recours à l'encontre de la décision d'élimination, alors qu'il aurait dû le faire à l'encontre du procès-verbal. Cela étant, en l'espèce, les deux procédures - celle dirigée contre la notation des deux examens et celle dirigée contre l'élimination proprement dite - sont tellement entremêlées que l'université ne saurait en refuser l'examen au fond, sous peine de réaliser un formalisme excessif. | RIOR.4.al1 ; RIOR.15

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
privilegio nel fallimento responsabilità personale pegno appartenente a un terzo interpretazione della sentenza diritto di mettere in circolazione utile

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



         

    

  



       

 !"#







$%!"#&'''''' 



(    



 & )                       



     !"#

 (

"'   () )** +* * ,  (-*. )**    /* ##& 0 1!2"! ##&3 (  --**    4*5*) 0*(.6 3' 47()  +* (*  (*   (-*. )**  -())()5((-*5()*-'

'  1* 8888889 -***) , .59  *--*)  *  4*5*).50*(.64*5*)3+)*0*(.6  +)3 (* : ##$'   *5*  *;-  :) *5**  :*<*-*'  /5* ##=9 *  ())  - 4)>*5**)>4*5*()?));+) -)*9-*""+)5* ##=9-))+)'

  4)*())7-/* : ##=' - *.*9*4()*47-(()*>:) :*<*-*@:(-*.)4)957(*> );()*,=)>*'

$'  4))-*> ##= ##A9*+*(-*.) :)  :*<*-*  *  ())  7-  +)5* ##A'  -* ##A9*4(**)*(*4)) ##A' : ##A9 *  ()) >> 7- -* 4 ( )* 47- (()*>'

='   *;  % 5-: ##A9 4)*  )) *+-) >4 ((**4*"#*) .;-4);))9*4)*( *) , *5  **.- +*  (-*. )9  >4* )* )*-*)  :):*<*-*'

A'  7 - 4 * B (  +)  " 5-: ##A9 1'888888  -) , <;  * ( C -*  *  *(<-*>' *9***))>*5'

2'   $ 5-: ##A9  5*D   +)  *+-) 1' 888888 >4* )* -* , * ** 5  :))+*  7 )>*5  **(<-*>' (9*5*5*)*4**, * 4: ##29   7-  (-*. )9    :-(*:'()*E*)*-** :)'

&'   4) )-*> ##A ##29 1' 888888  *5*  *;-  (-*. )  :) *5**  * (<-*>*())7-+)5*/* ##2-C-

!$" %! ##& $!"#

>4: ##2'+*)<),47-:*>D)-*> (<-*>9 > *  :    $9  , * 4** 7 *(<-*>9>*: 9A'47-(()*>4)* **()*'

F'   * )()  )*  )*  # : ##29 1'888888  )  7  ()*)  -) , ()  7-'

%'  ()***5*))*,*;():- (.  *; ) +* > 7* * 7(*>   >4* *)*--*/*+*)'

"#'    --)  " 5-: ##29  +)  *;*+*) , 1'888888  )*-**  :) *5**  * (<-*>9  ** ()     $ 5-: ##A *5,-**,***4D())()'

""'   (* B  2 5-: ##29 1' 888888  +* ((** ,  )**'  4)* ( 5  ?* ( +*  *- )-*>  <**-*)5(D' *** <(()-*97(+(:-*.G*5* )<))44;**(;,*7(** +)4(*'

  4)*-())((**"=5-: ##2'

" '  +*9()**"&/5* ##&9+)/)4((**  +   ()5*   *  * (<-*>' 4)* 45*(*+*7**()*)'9)*:<: (<-*>4)*4**7*(<-*>)* *'  (  --  ()5D*  .;- 4)9  +* 45* -D()*,=9-*);-*++* :<:9()*)9)*)*-**'

"$'    ()  "A +)5* ##&9 1' 888888     )**(. '7(**>4*5***(* /7*++*>**5*))*:)45*( 5*'   ** *>*  +* > (   -**)  )* >* 5*)*4)5*-D*+)*,*9-C-*7* 45*>4*+)*,='(9*(5*(-( *)>4)*9>*(*4)>*5**  :*;*  )*  (-:9 *   -D  $9%F9 -*  *+)*,=9>*45*(-(C<))*' )*  :*;* 5* )) 5)   , $9  >4 * +*

!$" %! ##& =!"#

4;-*4$,='45*(-)>4*.5 9-**5*C*),+*77-**;*7'* , (*5  )  )<  *(H-'   5* ( +*  -<;-+)'

"='  "A- ##&94*5*)/95 >$5-: ##29 5*-) <;-+) ( C ** ,  +)  * )-*>  * 0*(.6  +) ? ?3 +* 4D *5  *;-  :)  * **'  5* )) -*   +) , * ** ( *D %5-: ##29)*)*(-*.) D))+*7)*-()*5-,(-: ##&9(*4)*-**'

"A'  D-),)(*>9*)()5)* & 5* ##&9    - 4 )* >* 5*9  *9 )) +5*)'  (9 *  (B*   (*. "%  # (* ( 4*5*) , 4((*   )('  - )* ()* ,  )**((****9((-*9((A- ##&  (+ I888888  /  47-  :*> D)-*>  (<-*>())"#: ##2(9(9 ((%- ##&):*((+888888/47- 4**7*(<-*>())(1'888888'

"2'   $# -* ##&9 4*5*)  (*>)  +* 5* >    )* *) (   )* - *++)   +* +9 ((9((7(+()*)'*:) :.-  4  4  7- **;*7 )* +*-)    5*C/)'

"&'  "F/* ##&95*()* )*( -4*5**)C,(*>4*)**--*) ,***(* %5-: ##2,+)? ?'

"F'  )( #/* ##&>5*(> /-*:/'5*-)-**(.+)? ? :4)5*7-**'(9*5*(-:*-( *()*5,*7')*)* )*4:**(H--*5(D'

"%'      /* ##&9    (*- -*    1'888888'+)45*(*7(** ((7(+--)**((**'  *((-C-4(5*47-**>,*  4; <;)  *  ((**9  5* 5D  * ,  +)(5)**'

!$" %! ##& A!"#

#'   "# @ ##&9  +)    5 )**  4)*-**'

   5*  5 *  7 (( -*)  * >4*+*-**:)')>9-** *:))**4)*-**"5-: ##2'

"'  1'888888+*)**(*;) "&@ ##&9()/-C-B #@ ##&( '

    (*  -C- -*5*  /*+**+ >   (-* (()>4*<**()77-7-*. G*)*)<9>4*5*:'

'  4*5*)  )(    & (-: ##&9 5D 7 ;-)5(()(-*.())()9( (9 >   : (   7 7 7-  )< )*/*+*)9>7((+*-*' ,);*+ 4:**4*);*)*-'

$'     & 5-: ##&9    -) , 4*5*)  -()- 4*+-*9 4;*   () *5* (   5)**((**'

='  4*5*))( $5-: ##&'

   4: 4 * +-  7  47- (  9  5* *5*  () ;)) ()5 (  .;- * *+ 7 () 4((**     A +)5* "%&& 039  )5) H*' +)-*, --** <;) 4**  ((**  -*.  *   47- >   G 4)* *5>*  -*+ ( > * *>+@*++*'

A'  *),)-*)(()*)4*5*)91'888888 **>)9 /5* ##F9>(** 9(*):*75*+*'

2'  ?>*9));),/;'

  

"'  **;))**((**"#@ ##&*/) )* );    +- (* (.  4*) -()9   5:0'$$*4*5*) 2-*"%&$JJ "$#K'

!$" %! ##& 2!"#

F&F%.;-4*5*)&(-:"%FFJJ "$#'#2K' 2 &3'

'   4((*   9 1' 888888   *   7 7- *++*  *5> *5 ))- 9  *9 , )D  *);*)*-**))5**-'

$' ' (-*;*+9*+,*7-9( (:.-()*-**>4*5*4D(***-'

  ++994((**B(+)25-: ##2-()-)"=5-: ##294+-->)>  )** 4)*-**  " 5-: ##29 , 47*  7  :7-**;*7'

  9  (.5: )  # : ##2 >*  *  47-:,*4: ##2*)** * 0' " '  3'   *9 * 59 (  *   47-9)*/0'='"3' *+-*+*; -(.5:>*'

  *;79**.((*:4**()  5   )** 4)*-** ( +* 5*  ;*+   H  *9 > + 4:/ 4 () ()*0'"A'3-*,)**)('* *5*,*-*7)***9 - G  5**  (*:**)  -  >*9  --  4)*-**  4)*9   47- : (* ) (59))'

     **;)  ((**   )** 4)*-**    *   () 7 7 7- **;*79 , 47*  *:():'

  (-*.594*5*)*@ +4 -*.  ;*+ *+ ,  *  7-9 (*>4*  ); ,  ()*5,)**4)*-**'

 :' )-*9--**)**-(-(- 7 (*   *   4(. ( /; 4*  /*+*) 47  () **;  ;*+   *+ ,  *   7-'

   ++9 * 5*  (  -(  +* >  (.5:  4)*-**9 >*  () +-- 7 )** ** (*:   )()9   ))   (  -(

!$" %! ##& &!"#

7C-- :+6  (-*   # : ##2     "5-: ##2'

  *9*()**(<-* # : ##29    *- -*+)  ) 5*,5*  7*++*>4*5*5*'()*** )(9 =: ##29>4*5*((:+ )* 5  *; )9 (* +*   )<)  06 ((**3 (.  (+ 8888889 >*  ( *  *;*  **+*)*-**'

    (-*  5  9    7()- **>)>4*4)*(45:777-'

    )(9 4*5*)  *-) >   L*M 5*)(++*--:*777-(D:*-D  +* , 4((*   *  (( ( <> 7- **;*79 <)*;)((+(:'

     <*) )(*>9  >    ()'   *9*)(4(;,)+(((+I888888 (,47-:*>D)-*>(<-*>'   5* >4* 4 * *  ()*  47- 4** 7 * (<-*>9 , (( > * 4 :) , 4*;   D(  :.-**)'

  (*>94*5*))(,;*+9**>-- >*9  9    -(*  4(()** >4* +**  ((()*)'

  N     > (* 4*;*  **;9  7 () J  **;)   *  7 7-   **;)  4)*-** ((- * J   -C)  > 4*5*) 47*-5*7-'

 ' 45* 94*5*)9;*9;*-*. +- 7 7*; **'  ++9 4* *5 * )) **54+-*-7*+'

   +-*- 7*+ *  );* (**.  )*  /*'L)*)>*((**4.;() /*+* (  *)C *;  (*9 >4 5*  +*  *9 -(*>-*.*:-*O5*-)*5  -*. *-**: 4. 7 *:7M 0  !1  ! P  9 * ** *9 5' 9 Q "$#$K 5* );- N" A"229"&#3'

!$" %! ##& F!"#

     4(.9 * * )) 7*5- *;7  +* ((/*9E*)4*9(  ;*+ *+ ,  *   7-  >4*  5*   ** /**> *5- -(79 D B 7 * **  4(R/'

  94),*)+*(*7(  )   *  7 7- **;*79 *) >* *  *)(5(+:<) )<)+*0***>***7*(*>4*4;* <*>-4((**3(.1'8888889*)/,))5) >4*)**;*)**4)*-**'

  4-: * * 9)**  /* ##&9,*)>+)5*(,5  9   -(  5  **; (   *  7:7((+*'

   )**      /* ##&9  ((**   /*(  *: +)) 0C  *: +)) ' #%! ##&  A5* ##&39 5D* **   7 *) +* ( 5 )**((**'

 ' 94*5*)9--4**>))(*5D) ( 9**)();))4((**>*()5 -*.H*'

  /*+*<*7(4:;*+5)( 47-'))5)(-:* >5***>))57:   (**  )* +*  47-  :*> D)-*>  (<-*>)(*> &5* ##&'

   5*    , 4*5*) (  --**  ) 5* ()*)- ( : >  *.   5 )**  ((**>*(*7-:*>D)-*> (<-*>4**7*(<-*>'

  ()4((**H*)( ,()(**.9+*7)(0'"A #39>**++. ();))()54((**'

  .9();))**)(+)(5 )**  ((**  ( (-   (   *  7-'

!$" %! ##& %!"#

  95)**((***>4(()**  7-  9 **> >  +)   *5-  7 ((9 >4  >4* 7(*>  +*-   *:)  >4+)5**>(:**'

  )**9>*(7*5-4(()**7-9  (9 ,   9 C   *5  () ;)) 4((**9-***(C5:+*4:/() ()*+*>7*47-'

 '  5*   5D , 5   ,  +)9 +* >4 (5)**((**+-,()-*. H*()57*"A*5'

  +*9 * 5*  ** 4:/   5 )**  ((**6  +)  5  (< >  47-  :*> D)-*>(<-*>9,4>+*5* ;*+ ()*9    47- 4** 7 * (<-*>9  > * 4*5> >4 ;*+ 5;   )D)' 4*- *  9 >* )+ 4(** *  -*. 7C--;))9*-*+**'

  **;9*((BS)--0'$$3'  TTTTT

*  (+        

,-.$#/"0

)5:*/)"&@ ##&(1*888888 )**((**"#@ ##&+)*K

.$0

4-(*-K

5*,+)*(5)**((** ()-*.H*K

*>4*4((B4)--K

!$" %! ##& "#!"#

* >9 +-)- 7 * F   *5   * +))   *: +))"&/* ##A0 N?"&$'""#39())**(C() />**5*+**(5 *:+))9(5* -*.*(:*K-)-****>*9 -*+-D(5(*;-*K* * C )  *: +))9 "###  "=9 ( 5* (  ( 5* )*> 7 **  4* =   N'  () )**   (*.  (*  9 *5>) -- -D  (59 *5 C /* , 45*K

--*>  () )** , 1* 8888889 ,  +)  *9  5*/**>4*5*)9**>4)(-4**(:*>'

?*);6 1-5D9()*911'?<<9--:'

---**4*5*)6

;++*.6  ()*6       '1*<* '5D 

(*+-)**))--*>)7(*'

 .59  ;++*.6           

!$" %! ##&