Discontinuation of deadline-setting application after lower court decision and statutory exclusion of web service fees from cost reimbursement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Vienna Administrative Court dismissed the petitioner's request for increased costs as unfounded, but ordered the Federal Republic to pay EUR 793.20 in legal expenses within two weeks, thereby upholding the taxpayer’s claim for standard cost reimbursement while rejecting the additional fee. The case involved a procedural application to set a deadline for decision-making in tax litigation; the court noted that the Federal Finance Court had already issued a final decision on November 9, 2017, rendering the pending application moot. Relying on § 38(4) of the Administrative Court Act, the court determined that the main proceeding had to be discontinued due to the issuance of the lower court's decision, which remains in force. Regarding the expenses, the court applied §§ 47, 56(1) second sentence of the Administrative Court Act and the 2014 Administrative Court Expense Reimbursement Regulation to grant standard reimbursement, explicitly excluding the requested "Web-ERV fee" of EUR 4.10 plus VAT, as such specific digital service fees lack statutory support under these provisions.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IA§§ 47 ff, insbesondere § 56 Abs. 1 zweiter Satz VwGG in Verbindung mit der VwGH-Aufwandersatzverordnung 2014: The state is liable for procedural costs incurred by the applicant, but reimbursement is limited to fees explicitly covered by the applicable regulations, excluding the Web-ERV fee.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProcedural basis for discontinuing the proceedings because the lower court issued a final decision while the deadline-setting application was pending.
General legal basis for the award of legal costs to the successful party.
Specific provision determining the amount of the fixed cost reimbursement of EUR 793.20.
Regulation cited in conjunction with § 56 VwGG to define the specific expense amounts allowed for reimbursement.
Testo completo
Das Verfahren wird eingestellt.
Der Bund hat dem Antragsteller Aufwendungen in der Höhe von EUR 793,20 binnen zwei Wochen bei sonstiger Exekution zu ersetzen.
Das Mehrbegehren wird abgewiesen.
1 Das Bundesfinanzgericht hat das Erkenntnis vom 9. November 2017, Zl. RV/7103020/2013, erlassen und eine Abschrift samt Zustellnachweis zusammen mit dem am 30. August 2017 beim Bundesfinanzgericht eingelangten Fristsetzungsantrag dem Verwaltungsgerichtshof vorgelegt.
2 Das Verfahren über den Fristsetzungsantrag war daher gemäß § 38 Abs. 4 VwGG einzustellen (vgl. etwa VwGH 17.3.2016, Fr 2016/22/0001).
3 Die Entscheidung über den Aufwandersatz gründet sich auf §§ 47 ff, insbesondere auf § 56 Abs. 1 zweiter Satz VwGG in Verbindung mit der VwGH-Aufwandersatzverordnung 2014. Das auf den Ersatz von "Web-ERV Gebühr" in der Höhe von EUR 4,10 zuzüglich USt gerichtete Mehrbegehren findet in diesen Vorschriften keine Deckung (vgl. etwa VwGH 30.6.2016, Ra 2016/07/0034).
Wien, am 20. Dezember 2017