Cassation annuls appeal order for detention repair, ruling on formal vs. substantive injustice criteria for custody compensation.
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe Court of Cassation annulled the appeal court's order rejecting the request for detention repair under Article 314 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The appellant, Francesco Di Bella, argued that his prolonged pre-trial detention constituted an injustice requiring compensation, while the lower court dismissed this based on his alleged serious fault. The Supreme Court held that the lower court failed to distinguish between formal and substantive injustice, incorrectly applying the fault requirement without verifying if the annulment relied on new evidence or the same facts as the original detention order.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 314 c.p.p.; In cases of formal injustice, the court must verify if the annulment of the measure relied on the same elements as the original order or on new ones; if the same elements were used, the applicant's fault does not bar compensation, whereas if new elements exist, fault may be considered.