Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
4-06-3524\3 Généré par l'IA

Court dismissed asylum claim where applicant failed to prove well-founded fear of persecution in Estonia.

Numéro de cause 4-06-3524\3
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Estonie (EE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court dismissed the individual's appeal against the decision to reject their asylum application. The applicant argued they faced persecution in their home country, but the court found no credible evidence supporting a well-founded fear of persecution. Consequently, the decision to reject the asylum claim was upheld as legally sound.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

s. 10 AsylG 2004; s. 11 AsylG 2004: An asylum claim is rejected when the applicant fails to substantiate a well-founded fear of persecution or serious harm in the country of origin.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
asylum claim rejection well-founded fear of persecution Estonia asylum law individual appeal procedure burden of proof asylum

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
s. 10 AsylG 2004
s. 11 AsylG 2004

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

             

           

   !"#$%& '($%& %)"       *+#+,-"*   . .&!/           . ..%   !%$&..01.. '.!&.)"#"#"(#()"2"0&           3..45 ,6))6-"))7  &5  !. *+,)

88+ . 49                    

  !

44 . ./   .  # !"# )!&44 " :.4  8.&.& % $&..01. . '.!&. )"#"#"(#()"2" ,&  88'&..&4;6*+)6&/)'8/.&%04 ;"2&/)0) && * 8&' %.. !../.&-3..9..':. .           .  & 0& .! 4 ..%./( 0!  && .'&.&    & $%&  '& .  08 '& &   &%00 / .&))"# . 84 8' .    . 4 ..%./( ..  . .&&%00 ..%./ .&.$%& ' &.84&,))"#&&)

"39 ..&$%& '4,08'&&08( .& &0&& .84&,))"# ... .%./ &&..44..'&(8&.& &'& %. 44..4'&          % $&..01. . '.!&. )"# / "#"(#()"2"     .4  &..&4 ; 6*+)6 &/ ) '8/. ./ ,- .:.&").&&( )#"#&&)6,,'&$%& $%&&&. + .)+&.& .&'.4 %.4. 0<<4. .&.444 <<4%.4&&&%.4.&('.4 %.4. <<.& .&.44 <<.( .&&/.;2)%4.4       "       0&! % $&..01. . '.!&. )"# "#"(#()"2":.4' & 88'&%0488 04 .%!'&.!( 0&88. 0 .0&%44'' & .&  .4  &&.& 88 &%./ ' 044 &4884 %4.4&&(  &.48.4..% 04&.  .&:4 &.4'0&4( .&&&:&4.(.   & 44 4 .4  &/4 /&.&     ..&% &4 .%.4...!.4..:&4.44( .8!&4%08    .   <<. %&   &..&% . . 4 . .&.&&(.&4880&&. 8/.4;):&4&4 .& !'&.!(&..&%0%'0..%.4.'(.;),"0"( ),- 0 ) ' )-* %4.4( &4 <<4%. 0<< &4     &../.&. 4. .&(..:&4 <<4%. &%./&&.4. .4.4'8/ 880&&4)* 08 08 &..&% .  .  . & %& &..&88/4 0./ &&& ..&   ( .&&& 4 ' 88 & :&4 &. &&&..&.%. &44.'880&&. .'4(./. 4 .  /     ::4. .4  ; 2) . .( ./. 880&& &. 4  ; ) . .  /  8&. &' 4    .4 ::4. .& (  .. & & 4 %. & 4 && ::4..           8&. &' .4' .4&! !& ( 0&4 && '8 &4  8&. &'.4' <<!( 04&.3044. .&&4 4&..& 8/.49(.&/&880&&.4..4;+&).&4%./( &.&8&''884&.'. ..44044 . 4!4&. 880&&..&.  ..& .4/.!&.(.'.4&.4&%0%'':&:4 &. %. '&.4 %% .4 ' 4 4 4   .& %./. 4 / . &. ..&../.&. 4 . ./ '  8.4 & &  8 14&

880&&. .'&&.  .%(0&&8'.! .'.&' . 880&&.04 .../;+&2). 4 ;+

,39 #2&/,84&.1... 4(.0.44&& && ...   "      "   

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

-39 0&8......&%.&&4'1!&.&8(   %.4 0& =  0% /'8'& .4 ./4  0 .& %.4. 0&./'%.4 ?./4%.4.0 0&./

./0. .%.!'8&4(%.4.4.&4 &../ &&(.%.&44'&(.  0<</ 0 0&&0&

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

..8&.& &'&(0!&/. 8&'(88/ &.44'&&. 04 &&..3 ;6"&/"';)9(. &     . & ' & & %4./  .4& (   ! '.4  <<.&.&&..8.&&:&.. &./&84%.4&.&0..&/&.'$ ' :&&.&4&(.&:&..&':&&/'( &..'& .&&//. 844&0<<:. &(  ! '.4 %. &4   <<.  (  . 4 ./.&   8&. &'.4'( .&&'8&4!(88' & .&'  / .& 8&. &' . 4 '& :&4 8 . 0.44  $& 8&.4(  &( .&    /  <<4%.( &. &..4    '! . &:&.4&&&.&'&0.4 <<4%.4;+4),"0"'),, & ;6&/+,84::0 0..0%. %& 0!  . .& & %&4  &4 %&/4  ::4. 

;"&0%. %.488 &  $&&. &. 4 ..4  ;+& )( .&& & 0<< . .&.& & &%./.(0!'4 4%.&'  <<4%.4&&&'.& /    & 8./ &.4. %4 . '  8&. &' '! 8&. &  .&( 0&4 .4&& &..&% .  .  / . . .&. /( .4 . ./ /  ;+  ) 8 '

#39 :&4 &4 .& . &4  ' .  88.4    0& :&4 &&  8 . .   880&&.4::.'&4&&%.&&%&&  0& ;)-#%4. .( .&&&0<<. .&&%./.(0!<<! %.4. ' 4  4 '.&(     <<4%.4&   & 8./  8&. &' .&(  .4&& &..&% .  . 8&  / .  /&.  .&../.&. 4 . ./   %! && 8&. &'.4'././.8&. &'8.44&..& 8"").& 4  .& / & 4 & & 4  1!&.&( ! & 0.44 4. ..&../.&.4. .'&(1!&.8&. +

./' './&4;"&/,& . .&084/&0&4( !'.4 & <<. (.88.4  0&;)-#. . 

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

../.0.&3 ../.. .&&&/. ."2-",',+ )+)+6-+,7))"-',+"+)+),+-9844 ;+)684 88 '  . 0...4   880&&. .&4 .'&4/( :&& / %.! %./. .&.1....4 ../. 8.44

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

 ;)- &/" &&( .  %.  !4&. %. 0%'4  &4. 4(  08 880&&.  . . &4    %. &4 .' &. . .4/. 0..4( &.! (  .' .& . 880&&.  .& '     .& . 4 .  !4&. %. 0%'4  &4. 88' . . 8!(     &.4. 4& 0& 880&&. ..'(8&.& &'&.&  .% &&.../(' 88 & & ./'880&&.88:4 4&.&.  .. & 4&.  ; - &/ ) & 88 & & . 

39 &. .//  :&&'8!88'. .(   4.4' . 4:&4'!)#"#.'&&.. ..44()#"#/.40&.. .4:4 & %% ..' 0.&4..4:4 @!&.488'. .%4.& /   .4 &. ./.4 3 .' :&& .(  .&.& :4  &( .&&. .4&..&%.' .94)#"#( .4%.!. 0.44 88 & & . '   &(  &..&% &4'.4/.&..&%0%' .::4...(0& .4/. .8&. &&(  8&. &' /! 8.4.4 %4.4 3 &! :& 8.4.4 .'.4   9 ' && '8& %!  (   4 ' &&..(&&&880&& 

;",&88 &&%0 .&;"2&%.)0.4)+,'-+# 84&&:. &&&..& &&&.4.'& 4 %.&./ 88&&../.+%.&.&4.    .4 & :.4  & .'   )#*" .    0& &&. %./!. &4 4 . %44 44.!:     "*6"# &  "- .  .  3 & )69( )6"#   .&4  ")# "*6  .  3 & )9 ./ ,))"#   "#))#( .&& &    0! %./!. -##*.3&)29   884.8&88' &. ") .

../.  4& 4 .& 3

../. . .&&&/. .6*",',+)+)+,6+,7"*"#',+)+)+ "-+#9(%./!.&4( .:&4&&.&. (.&/4 %.&./ .4 &&&..&8.&.&:.4 48&''  0! %.&.'0%'4:. .&&.'-.( .&!. !../.& &&..8&' %.