Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/743/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/743/2007 Généré par l'IA

Security Interest Transfer as Sale Disclosure Liability

Numéro de cause ATAS/743/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on whether a series of transactions involving the transfer of security interests in property constituted a sale under a relevant statute, triggering specific disclosure requirements. The court reasoned that the substance of the transactions, viewed objectively, demonstrated an intent to effect a sale due to the presence of specified consideration for the property rights, even though the documentation might have suggested an alternative arrangement like a loan or security agreement. Therefore, because the transactions were deemed sales, the related statutory disclosure provisions were applicable, and non-compliance resulted in liability.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Security Interest Transfer as Sale Disclosure Liability: The court reasoned that the substance of the transactions, viewed objectively, demonstrated an intent to effect a sale due to the presence of specified consideration for the property rights, even though the documentation might have suggested an alternative arrangement like a loan or security agreement. Therefore, because the transactions were deemed sales, the related statutory disclosure provisions were applicable, and non-compliance resulted in liability.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
opérations portant sur des titres transmission de la propriété responsabilité pour le prospectus d'émission condition légale contrat de prêt obligation de renseigner

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Costs imposed on the appellant for the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/1943/2005
Property Transfer Validity: Security Interest and Procedural Compliance Dispute
A/570/2007
Statutory Classification of Security Transfer as Contract for Deed
A/7/2005
Fee Imposition on Transfers with Purchase Money Security Interests
A/1421/2000
Entity Asset Composition and Statutory Obligations in Share Conveyance
A/1310/2004
Statutory Disclosure Requirements in Commercial Transactions

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs imposed on the appellant for the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



           "##$%"%&&'  "(#)"%&&(



* +,*    * +

-.  )

! %/ 0! %&&( 



  !" #    $

$

%%     & '' (      $!" )*+ 

                 ! ! 

   (.,0(  

 1+

12   "  1*-*  "3"  3!4   ! .-51*+62 7".*71*6.2

.2 .+7!81*60"3"  !2 "9!$ 7"359!$$":0 "!8.//.2

;2 &:: $  &(7 $" < =   > &"  9" &7 $"  1//? > !3$  ;/ 5 162  8 $   @$ 1;$8 .//A59"B&"37$ 3"$ 7!$ C$$4 41710<$3  17.///=2

-2 '$ > $ @$ &      7 "  $  .. 5 .//0  B   :D"  !$$   $ " > &$""2 &   "9!$$)"$!3"!$> "3 &"$ 5B& !  3$!8 .//12   "$" 3"" B  7 "" 3  "3D 3 $  " 7  !9 !! 7$ "$" "3$ $ $$8"3!$">E &D2

A2  .15$.//0 ">& &"$$" "  .. 5 .//0 &33$ >  B& F $ GH $ 7"  33$ 7  !B&GH$::!$ 7"F2

02  "33$ .0$8.//0& :!" "  ..5D3B$B7$3" "3"$B":" 3$9 79:$3B7 &"7$"$"3$9" 5B& .//- ! $$ !3!$ B 3     $  7$ "$" 3" "3$9 7:!"!$D33$"92

+2    .0 7!8 .//0 &"  $5$" 2  49 B&  "3" !$$B&7$ & "!8 1*60 ! " &$   !9 B  59!$  7 B  :!$ "$"   3"$ B  3$ &7$ 3  3"$$ > : 7 & 7 &$2 &" !  B  $ &7 $" $ "3$!3$$$$" 72

62 7$">3&  "3 .57.//+&$":""> "2





,--*.,.//0  (;,0(    +

12 :!"!$ > &$2 A0 2 1 $2  E2 .    97  &9$ 5  <=  8 $    I$  $ B  $$$ 3"7 > C$ A0    :" "   3$ 9""  $  0$8.///< =$7>  :" "C(7 $" 1*51*A*< =2'!3"$3 59  C34$"$82

.2 $5$"   :! $ " 3"7 3    3"$  $ 78 <$2A0>0/ =2

;2 $93$ !$$ $ &7 $" $$3 3$4!$   3$$9  7 B  "$" 3"" $   3"    !92

-2  3$    :" "  &(7 $ 77$ < '= $33839 $  &7 $"<$2;02 .$; =2!@!&$2;.21 49!$&(7 $"< = 7 D $2 A/ > A;8  49!$  &(7 $ 77$ < '=2

' 3$$$ 1/4!"7 & '<$$21= $ $"791571+&33B$>$$$ $ $3 34;1 "!810!"9!$>$$ $!3B5$ 8"": $ $> $  7 34  ;1 "!8 10  B  !9 $  34$$ $2

A2 = D$! &$2.*821 ' $$ "$!"3 "  $$  7 37$ & $7$" $7  B  8:$3$JE" $73$JE &$$157 B$ $K&)$ $./"7$;1 "!8B3"4  "$ B"<J9 $$ "4=2 8=  "  $$ $ "3$" !34$ B& 3 3"$  !@! !8 &"  $$ B  "    &J9 <$2.*$21 '=2'$ ""!!" $$3" L =3 $B33)" $$M 8=3 $B5$ &$2;2; '7" ! 8 $$!!M =3B 8:$3$JE" $73$JE &$37$@$3!3$<$2.*$2. '=2 =7!)!3:!"!$>&$2.*B$ 'L  7  &$7$" $7  8:$ 3 $JE " $7 $ 



,--*.,.//0  (-,0(   8:$3$JE &$2'$3 "$7 & $7$" $7  B  $$ $ "$" 7" <$2 .*BB  '=2

="37$3"$ >8:$3$JE" $73 " $BD$&$$"3$3:$ J9" ! 10<$2.*D21 '=!"9!$3" 3 $B7$9  &:$ $ "$$3&$$" 3$<$2A.$2 '=2377$3!"37$ 3"$  > D 8:$ !$7!$ <$2 .*D 2 1  '=2  8:$ $$8" 3 &" 7  !9 $  "3$ 3 !$" $  5$ <$2 .*D 2 ;  '=2 '  5$ &"$$ 3 " 34  & '   8:$ $4 $ $$8"  3$ " <$2 A.:2- '=2 8:$&$$)"3&"   $<$2A.:21 '=2

02  &34  $ $9  B$    7 "$!$2 3 $ : $  $$ B &$!"    &$ $$!$ :!">&$2.*BB 'B3"7$";B7B  "3D $ "" 3 $  " 7  !9 !! $ 3 $ B"$$"34 & '$"3$$$$8"3!$"> E "3D2"3$$$::$"BL ( D5$$ $>$M (777: $>$ 7M (!9$ 3 72 3$9 7&$::$"B3"7$"$1 57B$&!3!$ ./4!" 5$35$ ;1 "!8 B 3"4   7   & 3  &J9 &9$ 3!5$)$ $>$27B5$ $"" &"  !9$ &"  $ !9$3!3$9<$2A/82; '=2 7 !@! D"" $&" 7 B" 3!5$)$ $>$<$2.*BB2-$2 '=2

$@$$!! $  $ !9 &$":  59!$  72"B$3$9 $"9!$&::$3 " 3 $ B  3$ $ "$" "3"  :$  5 !$ <    3$$9 " $" 3 &:: :" "    E2 1//.=2

&34&$ >5$$$B&$"$"3$9"7B3&"  3!!9BDB  D4!!9



,--*.,.//0  (A,0(   5$B53 "7 &$2A.:2.8 ' 33$     $  &(7 $ 77$ $  $!3"$:2!$"3B "3D> 3$$ &$$ ( >   $  !9  >  3$$ 3  3"7) 3:      .4! 3 & 3 3 ::$ B  $ 7$@$""3$$ 7!!$ 7   & < ',A.1,.//A=2  :$ B  59!$  7 3" B"3D&$3 3"$$>:7&7&$&$  37$&9$  $ $2

 "9  D  "$ B 3"4 $  8  " $$ B    !$$   $ &7 $" "  $  "$" ::$" :!"!$ D 3$ "9 338  $ B   $ 5$"2



,--*.,.//0  (0,0(  

  2 +1  +,*    * +

!

  3 .

12 "782

! 3

.2 5$$2

;2 $"!!$ .//:2>E9 $2

-2 :!  3$   BC 37$ :!  $  3"$ @$   "  ;/ 5 4  $:$ 34  8 :" " <'ENOE:B00//-  =37 !$4  $ 38:!"!$D$26. :" " 8:" " 1+ 5 .//A < %=M  !"!   $  B   !$: $ !) 37$3$9$ $ ! $M $ @$  "  8 :" " 3 7 3$  3 7 "$B D  $  &$2 -.  %2  3"$ @$ $  34  3  $7B"!!!) 37 7$@$5$>&72  9::4  3" $         %% P'  P



3:! 3"$@$$$:"D3$BC>C:::" " 39::



,--*.,.//0