ATAS/432/2006 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATAS/432/2006 · Property Distribution Dispute (1770-1777) (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a dispute over the rightful distribution of property interests among various claimants stemming from transactions occurring between 1770 and 1777, with the court reviewing numerous deeds, land division records, and historical documents spanning those years. The court's reasoning focused on interpreting these complex property instruments, often referencing statutory provisions and established property law principles to determine the validity of successive conveyances and the precise boundaries or shares each party was entitled to under the historical context of the grants, ultimately resolving the chain of title issues presented by the evidence.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Distribution Dispute (1770-1777): The court's reasoning focused on interpreting these complex property instruments, often referencing statutory provisions and established property law principles to determine the validity of successive conveyances and the precise boundaries or shares each party was entitled to under the historical context of the grants, ultimately resolving the chain of title issues presented by the evidence.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

droit foncier partage de la propriété legs de la chose d'autrui objet du litige dévolution de la succession calcul du loyer

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/1167/2006

Property Conveyance Dispute Over 18th-Century Chain of Title

A/664/2006

Land Conveyance Validity Dispute

A/3834/2005

Property Boundary Dispute Over Sequential Conveyances

A/2846/2007

Property Proceeds Distribution Dispute

A/3643/2006

Property Rights Dispute and Preclusion Analysis

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Texte complet

%&'(%)& +%',)%)&

+

+! +" "

-. ( $ /* . )&

!"#$"%%% !!" &$"'"! ( )*!%

"!

++ & (( , ! %"%$ -./ "0123133 34

!" #$

,1531,

0+

38 $1.9%"3.20"!#%$!%!% !: ;!"%"$$ <%"%:!=%":<>(?(( 8(%" $ " @ "" "! !% = (% "!" "!#% $"$ !$%%$ !43%17748

18 % 3! % 1771 " !!A" "!#% " B$$;%%$ %%"$ 9!%:! &! !" C% -! " !$ @%#8

48 ( &""""% 12 #B! 1771 "! &%"$!$ ;;! & ;%B!-C% # ! !"%%! "% D% " "" "B%%$ ! "!%"" "%,%;"%! " <-%"<$! %8 !$"$C"$""$ !%;"B%%$ !"!%""%""%, $ !!"@%-"%D8"!B$$;%%&"%"&%#% -<%"!%D ! "! 8 ;% " ""%" & <- "<-!E%B$$;%&B"%""%<!8

08 ( !"%;%" $% 16 #B! 1771 "! "%" !$" $ % $ !%; -8 " "%,$ !! " @%-"%D8 B$$;%% $C" & "!%"" <- "%D B"%""%&<!"<-!E%8(% %"$"!#%""" % 0 "B! 1771 " $"" &" "%B # ! !% &"%#%"$ !;%8

28 ! !F 47 #!% 1774 ! &;;% " &!,%#%%"$ G%, !: H I &%"$!$ !D% !""% &%#%%"$ # &B""%&!"8

68 &! !" C% -! ;%" &B9" . 9#%!1774&@$% !"! $%%" -<%"!% " -<"<$! %8 ,% %C"%D "" !: <- "<-!E% $ % $ !%; - D !!%" A"! "!" ! "!B "%D "<-!E " "!B = $ 8 ( "" !"%% &!$ ;;! $C" ;%B!-C% " %;%"% "$ !%" !$%%#"8 " "!%"" -<"<$! "%D " $%"@8 &% %"$ "!#% " "" % !"%&$%!"% %"$"!#%";#!B8"! "%%%D& !!%"A"!C"$=27J% =#%!8

560251776 ,4531, /8 (! !"$%12#!%1774"! $%%" $% %"! " !<"C% &!$ ;;! & ;%B!-C%8 @" @ !$""$$";#!&!<"%%;"%!8

K8 ! !" 47 "B! 1774 = &"""% & "! 9" %C"% ;%B!-C% % &$"" $ !%;8 "% $C" <- "<-!E% "" D %C"% !$ !% ! %"$"!#%8&@=! !"$%A"% " D&% - %%"% !" 17 = 47J " D &"%#%"$ @!$ 9D&= !$""!@%C%B8

.8 ( ! !" $% 32 "B! 1774 "! &!$ ;;! "" & ! !""% !" "!B &<! !C%D & <- "<-!E% B"%"$ & ;%B!-C% " "!B !<%!#%8(% %"$"!#%"377J %3!%1771 ! !$%$"!%$8

378 47 "B! 1770 &!$ ;%" &B9" & @ -<%"!%D ! (!#% $% !$C% $ G%, !: H (I8 ( ! !" / "B! 1770 "! + ;;! & ""%" = "$ -<%D # !$ !% ! %"$ "!#%8 "! +"";%!"%C"%L"!"!B"@= $% -;"%" $!$B! ;;"% <-%D !":! %#%"L8 &@ %%D " -<%"!%D & "" "!$ $ !%9!&@%$"$C$$!%$"!B <B%D"!B !%"$ !B% -! !@ ";! !%"" " !"!B"% &#%!" -<%8 ";% "! + " D &!$ !$" !"%" -<"! "@" ! <!%D " "<C% "<-!E% !"%" D% 9"%;% %%"% !" 17J8 !% &B & #$!%"B"%"$"!%C"%-!!@";! !%""&" !"8!%!- ""C%$ !%#"@% " @"!A" $C:!8 ( $#$!%"$ " %;;%" ! 9"%;%! %C"% &$ %$ !%;$C!-8

338 ( ! !" $% 37 #B! 1770 "! &$"""$&!$"""%%!"% %"$"!#%""8 "" !"%% $C" """$ D - "M D "%" !$" "" " %D" %$ = $"" $ !%; " = <- "<-!E% B% "<-!E% $"" """ !!%C$ ! B"%""% <!8

318 (& !$%"%$%(6$B!1770 %"$"!#% ""%:!&"%#%"$<B%"&!$#%%"%!"

560251776 ,0531, 17J 9"%;%$ ! !"%" -<"!8 ( !"%" $C" D ;%B!-C% &" C$ & !B%%"$ -<%"!%D %C%;%"%# 9!% !8 ( !$%"% %"$ "!#%"/2J8

348 ! $%% 33 % 1772 & !; = &!$ !%" = !" &%#%%"$8

308 31%1772%%!;$C"! !;%8

328 !"%;%" K 9% 1772 "! ;%! %C"% !$$" $$8 "% %C"% &$ % $ !%;8

368 ""!3/9%1772"! ;%!"%! &!$%C"% !$$"$%8

3/8 12%1772&!$;! %"%8 :",% !!!%! "%! 13 9% 1772 %C" !"%%! D "! % % %"$ "!#% ""8 ,% $"$ $C" ! ! &!! !" C%8 ! %! "! ;%!$D& !$"%"$""$ !%;$#:!D&" !"%# &<- "<-!E%"&% %"$"!#%""-$"%#8&!$" %% = &"% $%% 33 " 31 % 1772 & %% D&= &"!%&!"&%#%%"$"%:!B%%%!"! !;%8

3K8 (&#%$%169%"1772(!"%;%"$%K9%1772 "! ;%!%C"%8(!:#D !%!$%!"%"D"!B&<!!C%D" $ !%9!8!($9=" " "<C% -<%"!%D !%"B%!"12J"""%#%"$8 " %C"% "! % " %;%!$ "" ! "! D !"!+8D%!! !" "! %,% " 9#%! 1774 " &" &"%"$(8"!&B!B%%"$ -<%"!%D& %"$"&!$% !""!":!%#%" "A"!!= ;%B!-C%8 ( "% $C" D D"% % "! &<- "<-!E% " &""%" -<%"!%D " %% ! N D D %" &!%C% "!B -<%"!%D % &C!" %#%%"$ $!%!=12J8

3.8 ! $%% ! %"% 14 9#%! 1776 & !9"" ,% ;"!&@ !"%"!+8

560251776 ,2531,

178 ! " 13 ;$#!%! 1776 &!$ !!" "! "" $%% ! &%"!$%%! % " !$B" = % O#! & @ !"% -<%"!%D 9%%%! " !%% " = &"% $%% ! %"% " &"!% & !" &%#%%"$ "%:! %" $ 8 ! ! !C""% "$!%! " %C "" D #% $%@ %! " "!%"%!8 $"" "% $%! &!!@ !"%$%"!8

138 14 ;$#!%! 1776 !!" %D !%B $ % ""! "! 11 ;$#!%! 1776 = "%!8 ( ""%%#!!";;!&$""$ !%;$#:! %1771! "%C"%D$ ! %! !"%%"""" !"%%""! %%D !$%,%&! !"C%8 &%#%%"$ "%"&" B$!;%B!-C%%! $""$ !%;$#:!8"! $!$C"D&%"%"$ ;%B!-C% " " D D%"$ #% !!" " """ %%$8C"% "D %! !""<!<!;%! %%% !"!"!:%;;%%8 B% D%"$#%CC!# "<C% !%%!%"&$""$ !%;$#:!8 "" !"%%%"%"D&% %"$"!#%"""8"&#%D& #@ !"% -<%"!%D"!"$%!8

118 17!1776&%"%$$"!%!!!"=!9"" !$;$!" !"%#"%=$%%! %"%8 "=& !$%"% $% @ !%$ ! "! ""! 14 ;$#!%! 1776 % !:# D&% " %;%!$ ! "! %% D "!+8

"+

38 %C#%!P!C%"%9%%%!GI$"$%;%$"%"%"$: 3!Q"1774 !%B"!% $29C " !$%""#%, !$%"2 $""369C!G!"83"8 !"26 I8

(%"=P"%P$"%369C! ! !%B;$$! 1/9#%!1770G +347376I! %C#% "$34;$#!%! % %"%"!%"%!!C" !""" !%B"! % %$C! ! = "!% 9C "%"%! P""" P$"%#@9C!8

560251776 ,6531,

18 ;!$" = P!"8 26 8 3 "8 <8 1 !%B '" %" %D"""% !$#=P!"826%! !"%C$$!!%" ! % 6 "B! 1777 G I !"%# "" = % ;$$!!P!,%#%%"$3.9%3.2.G%, !:H I8

( $" !9C!P :"%%$"B%8

48 I % ;$$! ! !"% C$$! !%" ! % 6 "B! 1777 G I " "!$ #%C! 3! 9#%! 1774 "!'" %;%"% B! % %"% $C % ! %8 (! "$!% %" #%! D !%" & %D %" A"! "!<$ = %:! !%% D !:C %B " #%C!"N;%"9!%%D"$"!%"" !%"G + 347147%8383R442%8381R +31.0%8381R +31/06/ %83316346%80B"!$;$!I8!:C !$!D"= & %D"!$!#:9!"!$#%C!G +33/.4 %8 6B 331 467 %8 0R 3..K * 4/ 8 436 %8 4BI8 P %DP :8

BI&!!!!""!!A""!#% %3!%17718( !%" $#" = !" !!%" '"! "M" 3! % 17748 ! $D" " %B %% D # % %"% $C %&!,%#%%"$8

08 "!9"$;! "$%$C@!!"!#BG!"8262."67 I8

28 " %"%C% &!! D"% #%! % !!" !$" ""%"="$ " "!'"%#%%"$8

68 #!"!"8K83 "!"808 "!$ "$%#%%"$&% %"$ C%"" !"% !$$ !"C!$"!$""& %;%!%"$C$%"&%&%"8 "=&% %"$C% "$;%%=&!"8/ %%"%&B& !"% %B%%"$C%&!$!!<$"!#%$D%%B!$D%"! %$!"% % "" %%"% !$" & ""%" = "$ <-%D " " D& !%" !: "!%"" " ! !$ ""% @%C%B8

@"!P!"81K83 #%C!9D&439#%!1774P!$ !%"=!""%:!P%"%#%=66154J%=%,!"P% " %#% = 27 J % = D!" !" P% " %#% = 07 J %R $%BP!$ "P !:P!"81K83B% !$"! %,!"P%"%#%=07J%8

560251776 ,/531, :3!9#%!1770&!$!%"=D!"!" !"@&%#%%"$ 07J%=%,!" !"@27J%"!%,D!" !" !"@67J"!""%:!= !"%!&"@&%#%%"$ /7J%8

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

%%B " @ "% !":! @%C%B & ;;!" #"$ # !"! ! " !$%"$C!"% ! "!#% <D %" !$ %;" &

560251776 ,K531, !B%%"$ -<%"!%D & %"$ " & !$ % !"" %" &"!!%":! !$""!"%%"%"$""8 !G3I ;;"%! !<!%D& !%;&$""! %! $!$%%!BG1I& !"&%"$C!"%%"" %;""%#%G4I&$"" -<%D!%"%$$#"% %B "<$! "%D!D"%"$"&$<"%B$!"% ! !$"%;%" -<%DG !;%" !%%!"%!$%I;%G0I &$<"!%""B"%!""%%!;!@!:C&!" " ! !$<B%%""% $ %" "%#"%";;!" !!$ !!"!;;""!B";!!@ G(1777 8322%81R!!A" 8 !$%"$%818184%;%I8

: ! D& &B !$"" ! "%D %C"% "!B ";! !@ ;;%" ! 9"%;%! !%" = !""%&!%%%B=&@ !" -<%"!!!C @&%%D!=&%%"!"%G"9C%"%CI%" D!!$% !! -<%DD%,$C!$C" @ !%":! "%$ %, , % !""" !"! !8 &C%" ! % &$"B%! %:! B9"%# % " " "%""% -<%D &!$ " @!! "%#%"$ ! !<$ "!#% C!$ !D&%!"G;8!!A" 8 !$%"$%8181808"!!A"%"$I8

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

560251776 ,.531, .8 ( !%% %B! !$%"% !#D%& %D%B% !$!%%"!"%#D& !$!!!!%"%%"!"%;G!"807 +!!$"%#&!"83. R!"8.281%%#!"8334" 341I&%%"!"%9C !$%%B!" !#A"!%$ ! !:C ;! !$" = !$%"% :" " !%C! !#8 : ! 9C %" @%! %:! B9"%# " - !#DD&%" !# %$%!%"=% %"% !""" !"! 9C" #B ! !%" %"%C%@8 (% ! !" $%@""!%"%!% ""!<!&;;%! !$%!&B !#"%%D!!% !D%;! %% $%" !"!G +312423I8

&$$" $"!%" ! #! !B" & !"%;%" $% &" % !%C%%$%C"%;!&! !"&@ !"%%B" B%"8 " $C!%% !"D %"%"%C%@% !""%" ;%"&B9"&$";%$D! !";!@ " D&% !$C"%$!"% %"@ !%$D&%%"$"$$"B% % % %! G:I D !% "% %"!;$! $%%"%!";%D%&@ !"%"B%"%#$8

( !""! !%% %B! !$%"% !# 9!% ! $ %C %!"!% D% ! %:! & !$%!!"%"- &@ !"%! !"$%@8!D " !$!%%"!"%#@ !"%;%$=$%%$ "" $"B% ! $%%" ! ! B &B!#"% !;% " &%#"%C"% :" %% D& % % %! " D &@ !" B"%" = !$"" #%" 9C !%" $!"! % C" D&%%!" !""!!B%,;$8

"!9"! !"$"B% !$%"!%""9C ""%" "%! " ;%" D &@ $!% $% "!%"" " C$$!" %"= !! !"% ! "%"!%!"% ;%D%&%"=!%!G +312423%84B5BB"I8 ";% % ;%" D& !"%;%" $% " $"B% = & !"% " !%" " !$!9"%;% %"D"=#! !B"8 @ !"% !$"$ ! !"% "$C"#%!- !#8 #!" !%% $$ ! 9!% ! !" & !$%"% !#9C""";%"&@%!%" ! != ""!"! %"%"%C%@% !""& %%"% &@ !""$ !"!%B8 ""9!% !& %D%B%!D& !$"!""!-&@ !"% !%#$% &@ !"%$C$ !&!!,%" !;;% G + B%$12"B!1771172570I8

560251776 ,37531,

378 & :!!";%"&B9"&@ -<%"!%D !"! (8 ! !" ,% ! %" !%":! 9!% !"% ! % !'"! % #! !B"8 ";% % &@ !"%"""$ !"! 8!%!!" & !$%"% %"$ "!#% ,% "!#" $C" "!%"%#&$#"%"! D%$!$D !!" !$" % %"$ "!#% "" ! D "! &" D& %%"% !" &!! 17J8 "! "% ! %! D !!" ;;! & %#%%"$ !% & $ % $ !%; $#:! %$ " ;%B!-C% %C"%D$8 #%" : ! &@%! % #% "!%! $% "!%"" !!" " "! = %;%!! = ""! "%&@ -<%"!%D(8

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

560251776 ,33531, $"" !%B $ " #% ! % &@ -<%"!%D !(""%D,%" %" ! $%"!%""!!"8

338 " = ;%B!-C% % - % %$!! D %"% 9!% !"% !$%"$" ! %& : !%!'"! !":! %#%" %8 ;;" !!" ;;! & !B%%"$ -<%"!%D&%"$"&!$% !""8 "@"! !%":! 9!% !"% % #%" !" &""! D& ;;! &;;"% ! ! <!%D " & ! %; &$"" ! %! $ !$%% !B " D "!%"" B"%! " ""%%! ;! @ !:C &!" " $<$8 $% !%":! !" &%"$C!"%%""%;""%#%"&@%"&$"" -<%D!%"%$$#"% %B! "<$! "%D" $8(@!%":!9!% !"%$""!$%$% "A"!%D ;%B!-C% !!%" A"!!"$& : !;;!"#"$8

318 #D% !$:!!!!9"$8

"+0 +! +" "

$

123.. 4 5 67 /&) "#8

3.

38 $!!!!#BR

$ 3

18 !9""R

48 %"D !$!"C!"%"R

08 ;! !"% DP #" ;!! !! "! !$" !!A" $% 47 9! : "%;%"% ! % !$ !$ !%B ;$$! ! (<S%>!<;D% 6 6770 "!%

560251776 ,31531, @ %!8 $% " A"! !C$8 $%! %"H I %%D! @""D$%%!!"$%!B"%!%" $%% ""D$R BI @ ! ! D "%; % "% #%! ! "" "! $%%R I !"! %C"! ! !$""8 (% $%! "%" "!% $$" $$!$ ""! I BI " I %, !%B;$$!! !! "!!"%:!!!!DP% #!$!!%!!#B8$%!!!"%!!- !# D% !" 9%" %% D $%% ""D$ " P# D$"$@ $%$!!"G!"8341376"37KI8 C!;;%:! !$%" TU V -

%;! !$"!!A"""%;%$@ !"%%%DP=P;;%;$$! !% !C!;;

560251776

Property Distribution Dispute (1770-1777)

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet