Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/74/2006 • CJ GE ATA/74/2006 Généré par l'IA

Breach of Contract Dispute and Material Breach Ruling

Numéro de cause ATA/74/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involved a dispute arising from an agreement, where one party alleged that the other failed to fulfill specific obligations, leading to the filing of a lawsuit. The court considered the terms of the agreement, the evidence presented regarding performance or breach, and the governing legal standards. The court ultimately ruled for the challenging party, reasoning that the evidence demonstrated a material breach of the agreement by the other party, as the essential terms or conditions promised were not satisfied, thus entitling the aggrieved party to the relief sought under the applicable contract law principles.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Breach of Contract Dispute and Material Breach Ruling: The court considered the terms of the agreement, the evidence presented regarding performance or breach, and the governing legal standards. The court ultimately ruled for the challenging party, reasoning that the evidence demonstrated a material breach of the agreement by the other party, as the essential terms or conditions promised were not satisfied, thus entitling the aggrieved party to the relief sought under the applicable contract law principles.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
obligation de conclure règlement du litige manquement du bailleur compétence en matière de contrats conclus par les consommateurs défaut de la chose violation essentielle du contrat

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This article is cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs.
Art. 64 LTF
This article is cited in the dispositive regarding the awarding of legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/2465/2005
Material Breach of Contract Dispute
A/741/2005
Contract Enforcement and Material Breach
A/2301/2006
Contract Breach and Damages Dispute
A/1251/1999
Contractual Breach and Damages Determination
A/2479/2003
Contract Dispute and Failure to Prove Breach of Contract

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive regarding the awarding of legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

         

 

     

  

 !"#$%&





''!((((((((((  !"# #"#$ %% %&

" 

)*+ ,,-), , ), 





     '()*'

, 

+. . /0 12222222222   33## 4  5 # %"# %# 6"# #"#784 $#'79#&6"! ":#8 "#"#0#.# "0#4;# !33#3"#$1 %&.

 :. "#  5 #%"#%# %. .$#'79 %%%. .&6 <  4 6 "" " 00  4  #   '0# "00 #.    "0# 4  ;#  !33# 3  #;$1 &.

(.   " " ":(,,(6#" #3#4/012222222222";  #3#  !6 = 0 <  #0 0  ! ":#8 "#"# # "  >1?,@.A,4 >1?(B.A,.

-.  3"0""# #" 0 #4!" !80  #" #0!'0#"!(,,-.

  : 63#= #"#0!":#8 "#"# ;#     ## !<#;    ";   3#6   80   "3"0  ##  !8#   # 0 .  ;  !": #"  !"33# 3   "# $#'79 !"33# 3&5# #8#;# #C 3"#.#;# 80  0" 6#7 4!#6<##0 #";#    D0         3#= #"   #0 " ! (,,-.  "## # 3#<#" #3###"""# #".

?.  #"3#0"# #"##"*";0:(,,(6< " # !## #";"# #!""# #".

E.  %## ! ""# #"      /0 122222222226  # ! F ##"(,0:(,,(GH-,0:(,,(.

  ;"# #" # ##<.

@.   " (,F;#(,,-6/012222222222""   ##" 7  #: 0##  #36 3" #"  " "00 #:  "   "#.  " 6 " #   3#   6 4 ! #"   ##"  <6   4  <!# "#  "   <  #0  !0#":#8 "#"(,,-# #<43#="! (,,(. "## "  #  #"!33 #34"".

)+,()(,,- '-)*'

  5#0! # F #3#60"IF #3# #3  5"D !;#  "F" 3"#. #8"# "<  # :< 5# # 0."C -+ 0# (,,(6  #: 3   ;#  # <!#  #   #:  "   "#   ""   8#   !80  #"  #0.  #  #  " "0   " "J    " #8# 56! " 00 < '#  #   ## !8#   # 0    !<#;. "  3#6 " #7;#= #*E *@!""! 0#  (B F# +AAE $ / G % *-(.+,(& ;#  C  "#    #.

B.   (- F;# (,,-6 0   "#  " 4  #6  #: 0##  #3  "##   " #"  "   #7 ;# 4 ! # *E  /  #; 4  #0 (,,-6 ## <  "   !"8  ;##" "0C0#"$ .*@ /&.

*.  #! """+-0(,,-.

   ;:##   "  #  " 6   0 "I /0 12222222222 # # 3#" K #:=!"" #  !0: #36;"#!0: #3 "=#. ##6   0 "I  " #  #<0  4 3# " K  #3 (,,- " "7;6# # #;:.

  %  3"6  0"     #0 ;#    3#= "3"00  = ##   8# 6  !8#   # 0 6   "" #"#     0 #  !<#;6" <60C0!#;# C "#"00 ;:6";# C F .

    80  "#   #7 06 "#  " :#6 " "0  !="#  #"6 " "   8 #" " ! (,,+6  ##"  * F# (,,("#"# #"  ": #""0 (,,+6 #3  #0 (,,- "   "  7;6  :   #"  #0 (,,-6    "0    :8  (,,+6 (,,(   (,,- "   "  7;.

A.  (B0#(,,-6 #:0##  #3#3"0 #<  # F<!4"# F8 #:3 33#0::.

+,.   #:3L   C  +3;# (,,E$M?E),-&6 #:""#!#  #" ##"(+;#(,,E.

)+,()(,,- '?)*'

  "3"00  = "#   !C    >  "6  #: 0##  #3#0 ##-+0#(,,E4#"<!"# " #7 # :# 6"58 "# 6<!;#   "0 :## # # "!0#"# 66 "0 :##   " ! ":#8 "# "##  "#6 "  3"0  ##7 !    ! # @(   "# 3  !'0#+*0+AA?$ /G%*-(.+,&.

   #7 "#  ;#  C   L   "  "0   "8  ;##" "  "# #7     " < #0 # "  6"# !7(,,,6(,,+ (,,(.

++. . -,0#(,,E6#"# #7"## 6"# "  8 #"(,,+6(,,( (,,-6##<" ! #;# ! (,,,.

 :. 80 "00 # #7.

 '  "   8 #"  ! (,,- # #8#  :#6    # 3##76:5!'0#"#$":#8 "# "# 3  #;!#0# F"#7 /&! 6  :5"00 #6!  . 6#0" #  <!;#  "0 :## # # "!0#"#. "   !"8  ;##"  -+ 0 (,,?6 <# 3#8#   8 EE  " 6 ##<#  <6 " !# #"  ;#6  "0 :##     "0 ##<""# #" #;4!0"#:3#:#  # "3"04"## =   .

 '  "  8 #"!(,,( "# #<0 :5  !'0# "#.  0" #  80  <! ;#    "0 :## # # "!'0#"#." !"8 ;##"  +B ;# (,,-6 <# 3#8#   8 EA  " 6 ##<#  <! # #";#  " 0#7" ;#  #<78  #;4  #""0 .

 '  "  8 #"!(,,+ "# #<0 :5  !'0# "#.  0" #  80  <! ;#    "0 :## # # "!'0#"#." !"8 ;##"(E;#(,,(6<#3#8# 8?-" 6##<# <6" !# #";#6"0 :## 6"0    # #<  # 3"00  0 #0 "3"04"## =   6 <# #0#<#  <  "0  # #  #     "  3"0  ##7!! #@( /.

)+,()(,,- 'E)*'

 ' " ! #;# "!(,,, # "0 8":=" "   :5 ! <!  #<# .  "   !"8  ;##"+B;#(,,+6" F"#8# "# =6##<# <6 " !# #"  ;#6  "0 :## 6  "0        # #< # 3"00  0 #0 "3"04"## =    6<##0#<# 6:#D6<"0 # # #   "  3"0  ##7 !    ! # @(  /   " !!#0# F"#73  #;.

+(.  F88#;# #4"0 #7"# # +,"D (,,E. 33 6" ! #;# (,,,0 # ;#3# <!;#  "0 :## "!":#8 "#"## "#. " 6" !"8;##"+B;#(,,+6#8 806;# C  # 3H#688;  #:=8;"#.

+-.   -, ";0: (,,E6  #  3#  ;#  #:    "0 06"# 9

 ' "3#0 #"""8;##"= 6"# M2222222222 $#'79 !"8  ;##"&6 <! #   "0 :##   " !":#8 "#"#6"3"0 ##7! ! #@( / "!!#0# F"#7.!"8 ;##""3#0# 80 <580##  #; #  #  #33  "0# !6  <# ;#  4 # <  3# !0##  #" ;#    "0 :##  0   5< :5 !N

 '   #"83H#!"8;##"""  ;##"+B;#(,,+.

+?.  %<"#6 84F8.

,- 

+.  "#3 # 8"# "#@ " ":(,,,$ &  ;#8+F;#(,,-.%"O #*(  6#"# #"0 # "#" #:=   #"" =3#=; " ;#8.

  O76##"3"0###<O""# #"3"04 O"     #7   "  "   #  -+ 0: (,,(.O# <O7 8##"# #" /.

)+,()(,,- '@)*'

(.   F   0  # ;   F## #" "0  6  "   ;:$ .*@.+ - /6"  (? 0:(,,(N .E@   ."#!"8# #"F###((";0:+A?+'' (,E6 "  +F;#(,,,&.

-.  #7"# " 33#00 #"< #: "# 0F86<!#"# #"4!# #" ;#$3."#.?#3#"&.

?.   "  "   !80  #"   #0 !'0# " ! (,,-6    <    #3#  #   3"  "# .

 . %" ! # @,  /6 ! ":#8 "#  "#   3# !7  L 70    # #"  .   " #    ; 33#  3#  "   "D  33  = 0# F4 ; 8 #";:## 4"8 0$.+&.3#0 "#  C  ""0.  0 :#";##"  ;  # 4 ! ":#8 "#  "# $. (&.   # "0 !="#  #"# # "!":#8 "#"#. !=#"0 :""4!#;#.0"  #0    #"  #; =   0#   !#  "  ##< 0  $.-&. :# "5<=#" 8 #"<# "0""  "0 . "#3 0#    <  "0   8" "#  80  C   :# $. ?&.  "   8 #"    :# "3"00  = 78  "  ":#8 #" #;="# "L0 =#"# #" "# $.E&.

 :.  "   !C   #: 3    + 3;# (,,E $ 1 +-+  @@&6 <     " K   8#      < #"6F8"#"# =0##'# "3"0 L 70    # #"   $ . @, . +  /&    ##  3#0   ""0  O ":#8 "#  "# $ . @, . (   -  /&.  ##6###"0:;#3##"  "6  <# "  58    "# 6   "0 :##  # #  " O'0# "#  6   6  "0 :##   " O ":#8 "# "##  "#6 "  3"0  ##7 O    O . @(  /   " O O#0#  F"#7 $ . *+ . +  /&. O=#8 O "0 :##  # #  "#  C  " K 80    <# "  3# O0##  #" $ . *?  /&.

 .  ##4""8# O"# #" O #3  #0  O'0# ":#8 "#6  F8  

)+,()(,,- 'B)*'

"#"# 3#4## "83#= #" O": #"  #3#0. 0 6#3  # "0 O   ##  " = # #8  0 #7  #3  #0  O'0#9  " #""0  "":70"= 7 # 8"#  #$"# O" #76 O33 "#&""#  33#$#<  < "0 :##  O    "; 5P  " &. O  "<"#   < #"=<F8"# C 04""     " K <# # #"0: ;  OL   0"#88 $#  " "&  O"8  ;##" $ . *@  /&6 "  O#   0"#$ 1+-+B@&.

  !76#" "0:#7;"## # #0 <  "0    # # #0 "    33 #;0   0 !8# (,,,4(,,-6##<!    ## " !"8;##" +B;#(,,+6(E;#(,,(6+B;# (,,- -+0(,,?. " 6" 8 #"(,,+$.-*'

-A&6 (,,( $. ?('-&6 (,,- $. -*'A& 3"  "   6   :#< Q "0   8"#R!"0 :##  !":#8 "#"#  /   ! !#0#  F"#7 3  #;  /.  3"0  ##7!" < 4 # :#<;"= "0    "#  %% %. .6 " 0 . "3"00  = ## F# #  #'6  0   3#  33#  " "   <   #3#  # "   "0 :##  # # 6 "3"00   L 70    # #"      ##  3#0   ""0  O ":#8 "#  "#.  !  7 "  #"4!# #";##.

  "!;7##03".

E.   # #860"0 H$ .*B"# "0##  #;+( 0:+A*EG G E+,&.  SSSSS

.),-  ,    

/0'%!1

;:"# F (,F;#/0122222222226"  ##" 5 #%"#%# (,0:(,,(N

)+,()(,,- '*)*'

'%&1

F N

# <O#O HO0"0 N

#  <6 "3"00  =  # AB   #;    "# 3 O"8# #" F###6 C  C " 6;"#""# 0##  #36   F"7" #3# #"67 #:3.#    C  ""8.  00"#  "  6  "# =0#6  #:36%5T#P5"3<#@6@,,?N

"00#<    C  4 !"# #" #   $ %% %&6 4  5 #%"#%# 6##<O4!"33#3"#.

%#8 9 /0";L6# 6//.L576 5#6F8.

"0 #:0##  #39

 #'F# 9  ;#'# 9     %.>U .";L   

"#"3"0 C  "00#<= #.

 7;6  833#79           

)+,()(,,-