Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/608/2005 • CJ GE ATA/608/2005 Généré par l'IA

Moral Duty Insufficient Consideration for Enforceable Promise

Numéro de cause ATA/608/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involved a dispute over an obligation, where the court examined the validity of a written instrument purporting to reflect that obligation, ultimately finding that the instrument was not supported by adequate consideration, as the purported consideration was merely a pre-existing or concurrent moral duty that did not constitute legally sufficient value. The court reasoned that without a new or distinct legal detriment or benefit bargained for, the written instrument lacked the essential element of consideration required for a binding contract or enforceable promise.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Moral Duty Insufficient Consideration for Enforceable Promise: The court reasoned that without a new or distinct legal detriment or benefit bargained for, the written instrument lacked the essential element of consideration required for a binding contract or enforceable promise.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
devoir moral validité du contrat valeur litigieuse violation par négligence du devoir obligation d'entretien des enfants promesse de payer

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the allocation of procedural costs for the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/3797/2006
Contract Enforceability and Consideration Dispute
A/38/2007
Contract Modification Validity Based on Lack of Consideration
A/3602/2007
Enforceability of Contract Modification Lacking Consideration and Clear Assent
A/637/2006
Contract Modification Lacking Consideration
A/1491/2003
Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of procedural costs for the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

       

 

       

 !"







#$ #$ $  #$ %&$''    '' $( )  (*) )''  !"!#$%$ &'( 

( 

   + $$,+     !!$)* $&'( 



  #  $''

-. ($ ''





     "+,-."

$   

-1  2( $($3($ $(4'&5( $(($ 6$ 7$"48  5( $(9   ($ $  6: $;   (;3 3(& < =3 $(   ) >& $ <  (  2?($"@(   "

#(3,4'1

+1  (64;= )$  ($   &5( $(;   ( (6 +..+ !($ $ 1 (& (     (;$   ($   6 )( & ( =   (A  =$$;   ($  )-&+&B 01

  (( C'$+..D&!1( ($;$ ;&  ;;   +..D   ($    ) -    ('    "$    ) + 7($'91   $  ('    = )$  E#5$F  -&+;; =$ (  -/G. H$& (;       & '$ I ;;$$1( 6  '3 3($ 6: $; <$H%: $;(  %I1

  =3   $ 3;$  H $(  )($3  @ 4; = )$ 1 ($@ 4; $   (  7#5$&6$%;  91 #('( $( $(64; )$H& ($@ 4; = )$  ('$  ('$1 =;   ;$   )($3 '$  I   (  (J  '$1#6; ($( =3 &)($3@ 4;E#5$F$$ &< &(;; ' %31

D1   ( = =(55      G A$  +..B   5( $(1#$3 $(;(  $'$ <(;$$(1

   (;  ;$ 3  $ $$H$  H  3$% $5$H<=('%&$; )%;$$6&$$& (  H$ & $3&  6$$ &  % $   '$  5$  (   )($3   @ 4; E#5$F& +;;1   $  %;  $$H   ($ $( %   (;$$( H =  ('$  ((  '$ 1 "$ '$ &  ) & I   6$  ( $ %$    (; 31'$  $$ $($ $(1

B1  D(J +..B<=(' (;$$(&5( $('$ ? ($ (55& (       (( $; 5(;    $ #$ ($  #1 1 K (%   4' #1 1 K  ( )$  #1 1 7$"48  (( $;91 $"$ '$  (  (;$$(    D. A$  +..B (  ($ )- ($'( (  L2-*++B*BGG1"1

,-./-,+..0 "D,-."

  #( )( &=@(555$$ M %;  $( $3( <'$;'$+..+1  $55 $  $$;  <  6   ( $ <   $(  (( $; =  &   <  ($ $( =  $& =   1   $;$ H=$($3((&'$ 6$"()76$%;9'$ < ('I $(; 1

  ($+C(J +..B&5( $($5(; $H '3  ('$  I  A%1  ('   '$  I   $ 5$ ('( $(5$$4;  61

01   (' ( = =(55  $'$  $(      +D (';6 +..B   5( $(1 "$  '$  ;$ (;$$($ H  '3  $  (   $ ; +..0    $  -0 ;6 +..B   $  $; $ (  (  (' (;$$(&  )  3 ($ $( ;($5$  $(  (   '31 3  $ ; $  $  $'$  < (;$$( (   $ $(  '3'($ E#5$F&'($6$$ = 6$'$  $H  $ %   56$   ($  E6$%;F  $  $'$  <  (;$$('$@ 4;1

>1   '3 (    A% 3  $ #$;( (% ($  #1 1   !N  $#1 1&%((=($( @  (55' @ 4;E6$%;F1  $(  $5(;($ -C;+..01

C1   (( $;  $$  $6 ;$$  $5 = ( (  =A$ $(&     -D '$ +..01   ( 6;  <  H  (($ ( $=55 $5 &5(&<= $($$(  -C ; +..0   <  H  ;) $ ($  A%& ' $   5$   1

    $   -D '$   -G ;$ +..0&  (( $; $'(H$   '$( $(  = $ 0   ($ 5   ;) $ $  > ( (6 -//07!K#/BD1.+9 $($ $(=($  ( ;) 6$  +0 (';6 -//B 7 ! K  > .09 $$ H   4%;  $(;)6$; $4(  $(-/ (';6-//C7! K>.01.-91

  5( $('$ 3%(= $$'$ <(;$$( '$( $$=$ $ $($$;$ $(( <= $0$ - !1  &  (( $; '$    ;I)     '$  '  @ 4; E6$%;F$(55($($ ' ($ < $H=$='$ %1

,-./-,+..0 "B,-."

  =(55 = $ ' %  ((;$H& H=3 $'3 )$H   ((%$H1  $$( = $6 $( '$($  $$ $$$A$$H$6< $(;)6$ ( = $B/! 1

G1  $$($ $+G'$+..0&=55 $5  $ (1

/1  ;;($+C'$ D-;$+..0&5( $(=  ;$  (  (  < ( A  $$ H= ';  = $;$   (1

  (= $ '6H;(O$$'(H$ '$( $( !&=A$ $(=;)((;$<=($  (=   A <(1

  $$;$ $(!('$ I  &)($3   ( $( )$H     (   ;M   =('%1 =(55  (( $;  $    $ <  5$;  )($$1   $ $'$  <    (55 '  @ 4; E6$%;F  $    )%56$ &H$; $ 65$$=% $ =$1

  %( =6((( $;&$(= $    3$4; (( $;&  (  '$  )($$  $  (&H$'$ (55 $ ( $'$  $(1

-.1   -C A$ +..0&   $ #$;( (% ($  #1 1   ! N   $#1 1&A$ $;)&&(  ;$ 5'A (1

--1   ( & $    ($ H  / ; +..0& ($  4  ($ ;($ 4  $  ;$  (;$$(& = $ $  #'$ ;6) ($<= $#$ ($ #1 1 (55'($ #5$< $3$5$<5$ (( $;1

-+1   5$  6$$4($( $&  H 6($& $E($ F I 1





,-./-,+..0 "0,-."

$    

-1 1  $6;$$  $5 (;  ((M ( $5< '$( $(!7 10>1B 1($=(%$ $(A$$$ ++(';6-/B-K K +.0P 1/ 1+ !P ,G>B,+..B+> (J +..B91

 61 =6$($ $($(&( $5< '$( $(   !   %$   (;    ($   ( ;$$  $'-+ ;6-/G07 K 0-.P ,G>B,+..B+>(J  +..B91= $>D$-  '($ $(D.A(1

   =4& $ A    $ % '  =$  (;  &  (   '6    H=$ (    '$( $(   !1  '6$$  %$5'(H3;$$"(1 

+1  =(6A   $ $%    ($  -C ; +..0   5( $(& '  $$(    = $ B $5(;    $ (   A   =(55H='$ (==(55$'$  $( +D(';6+..B $5<5 $(= )$  ($ )-  ($'3(1

D1   (( $; 5( ( (   % $ $   !  = ! ! 1

  ('$ ($($ $; (H $(($ $6  ;) 6$ $ $%$3   (A($ ;    %$5 H$ ((  I  3;$ $6 (1

B1 1 = ! H$ '$ < % $ 3 (;$$($&   6$$  4% $&  (  & ( $$;$ ($ 5(   $6 (& ( $ & '  $($ $( =3 $(&  %;  $( $$;)6$ (31

  #( $>$-  C$- &= !=$H ( ;;  <   $(  ;)  (  $( (   '  $;  $  L2/*C0C*...1"1;) ;)( ''($$ ;$$(5$&'(555$ (;$$($1#( A$&= ;(@(55H$ ;$';)

7 ,>-0,+...-.( (6+...91

   =4& (   (55    %;  $5$  $ 5$3  = !&$"$=$H;)$ $%$31



,-./-,+..0 ">,-."

 61  ')&  ! *$H < (  ;) 6$  (3   (;;3 7< *3$(  ;)   (5 $(9& $;;  '$  @;)7 1   &=(' ;) 6$855 $'$  (  $(A$$H&2$6(%-//C&1BD0 BD>91 $$& ;) 6$  H $( (;6 (  (    ($& H$ 5$3  $ 4% ;$$; H ($'     ('($ A$   (3   (;;3( $(;)6$7 2-+0 G>($1- 1/-91

  = $/$+!$;( ('($;($'($ ( 4 = $   ( $  H$   $$(5$$ $'&  (  ($  6$ '   $6 5    '1   '($  (   ('  ( ;  3 (;$$($ (   $4% (  (;$$  (' )(   (& ;$ $ 3 (;$$($(37 2-+0B.>($1+1B./"B-.91

 1 #=%$ =;)6$%'($&! 5$3( ;;  @  ( < H = ($  A$ $ ' ($  5( $(   ';)1

  (  ;) (   '   $5$ 3 $  = $ C  = !& = ($  A$ $   ($ <  (  $'$  $( ( $H  ( ('  (  $' 7 1 B/ 1 - ! 91    = ( =$'$  $(     ;  ($6& ($ (55  ;$$;;( ;7 1B/1+! 91

  ($ %'($'($ %; H$$(  =A$ $( = ;) ( (;$ < =( $  (  (   A <(7 10.! 91

   (H&  H $(   (5(;$    $$( $ $%$ 3 $($ $( (%( %; $( I  3;$ $6  1  ')&  %$5 % '    !  ((  =I 1

01   (( $;  $  = $$;$ $(  ;( $5 H=$ =      '$  '  @ 4; E6$%;F&  $(  5  5($1  ( )($$   5( $( ($   < $'$   $  $ < (;$$( '  @ 4; E#5$F   =  '  @ 4;E6$%;F$ $$;$ ($1

 1 #(( $-&!% $ < ( (@ ($4%((  6$; #$&=4$6 ($$;$ ($;)5$H= $ 3   $'$   $'  (   $ ($ $1  !  ( $  H= ($" ($  '  (  $(  (;$$($

,-./-,+..0 "C,-."

3  =$5$ $(;)$1 '$<=$;;$ %;  $(  (& ;$  6( < 3$% H  $4  ( $      '  $6")%  '$    ;)$& $$H=<$6 (= 6$ $7!% ($ 5+D(';6-//B( !&22-//01-+BG"-+B/91

 61 #( = $ 0 $ - !&  ;) 6$   (&  (;;  (%;  :) (((;; (  %$   ($   ( ( $  (P  $($ $(& $$ H  $$( 5(  &  ($'   $$;$  ( @   $4% (   6$;   #$  ;$4 ( $ < * $ D ! H$ $$H < H ($ $(   $ $( <  $6  =4  ;) =(553 ' I '1

  !(;( $$ $% $'$ $$; <( %  (;$$($ 3 1  5$3  (;6 $;$   $$ 5(; 3 (   (5 $(&   (    (;; ($'  $ (;    $HH $'$ %$ $'7!% ($ 5+D(';6-//B( !&22-//01-+D-91

 1 (;$;)6$&$$;$ $(5$$ (;; $ ; 5'(6= $ %($(;$$($&$( ( ($%$  %4 ( 3 $    (;$$($ (3 (  $(3 71 Q&  ( $$;$ $(  ($   ;) 6$& $  2+..B++C"+BD&+D/91@$ ( ;;  $H$$;$ ($$  $5$ $( )$H 3$%  $  (     $ (   3$   5$    $ 3 $  $(  @  ($  $5$&  (; 4 ( ( =3$% H   $  ( $((=) ; $371 Q&(1$ 1&1+D/91

   =4&  (( $; =4% &    < A  $ & '($   $$;$$( (($%$&;$$H; $(5$ H=$=  $'$ < (55'@ 4;E6$%;F H=$= (( '$ $(556$ 1

  &5( (  H($ $(=$  $55 =$'$   $'$ <(;$$('($ E6$%;F(;;$;1  55 &=$=5$= $H; $(3$%(  56$  ( = $$ $(  ($    (   $(   ( $'$  = ($  A$ $1  56$   '  ($  E6$%;F H $ $(('%$;(  H=3 )%&($  '$% "$H  $ $$ (;$$$  (   %$( $%$ $H#$1

,-./-,+..0 "G,-."

  $$& (;    5$  H =$   ($  E6$%;F ($  I %56$ 5$65$$% $=$&=$%$ H$    (  (( $; = '   $6 4  ;)    ( $ $$$;$ $(()$6!1

    &$5 ($H)($3@ 4;E6$%;F=  5$ 5( $(' ==(55&;$6$<=$$"$P  $ $H  ($   $$ 76$$ & $ 9  (  '  $3 (( 5$%  ;$  ;  =$ $(  (551 = $$ $( = @ 4;= $ $$3='&6$( $&$H '$  $ ($61(( $;=$(((55' ($$4;@ 4;1

   (H&%$5 $5<$$;$ $(;($   $(;) (5( (A ($ 1

>1   (( $; () ( <  5( $(  ='($  )($$  ( $(' %1

  = ($ A$ $$(=%$6 =$ $(( =A$ $(1 $$& ;I;   ;) 6$  $;(  & (;$ < = !&  =   $   (  ; )(& ;$ $ $   ($$6  )($$  H$    ;$3 ($  ;)1    ( 5$ ;  ;$$6= $6(;($%$;( < ( $ 4& $3  3;& $'   @  ;) < A%1  & =(55 ((;$H ' %$%$5$H=($ I ;($)41  =  H=   6$  $ H =A$    (  5(3$'; $ 4$367 2-///1D.091  $ A%; $('($A$ ( $(=(55 ' % ((;$H;    =    % H  (;$ =$ $(   (; 3$%  ($ )$H   H = ($  $ $;(5$=@(55<6$$7 -///1-BDP ,C+G,+..++>(';6+..+ A$$ 91

  =$ $( $6$ (6 $ < ('($ A$ 1 # =6 ( =34  ('($ =$ $( ($  I   $(&H $65 55$; <;$ $7 2-/// 1D.-91 ( &(H(($ 5(&$5 (H  & ($  ( ;6& ( $   % 6$5 ( 3$5  ('($ =$ $(7 -///1-BD91

  =4&( $; <H=$55$;&=(55(( $;=  ' %($ 4$3P=$'H=H $4;($ $( (555$ '($ E#5$F& $(; =(55  )($1

,-./-,+..0 "/,-."

   5( $(   $; H    '$ $  ($  E6$%;F "       $ = '$% $ (  ($  E#5$F " $$ H  ' %  ; $4  $  3 $;  (;$ $3$='$(-G&0R1=(55)($$ $ ;($)4;$ '( $(E6$%;F1

   (H &  ('($ A$ $ =  5$   % 6$5 ( 3$5  ( ('($ =$ $(    (  A    ($  %; 1

C1   $4; ;5(&(A 1

  =$$ $%&;(;  L2+*...1";$<)% (( $;&H$(;67 1GC 91

  $;$ ( L2+*...1"(<5( $(&< )%(( $;1 $;$ (3 $$ $;& 5 ($(1

SSSSS

+($   $       

/0123" 4

'6($ A -D'$+..0(% 4'#1 1& #$ ($ #1 1   ( )$ #1 1( $$(2( $($ 3($ $(-C;+..0P

12354

A P

;  <  )%  (%   4' #1 1& #$ ($  #1 1    ( )$  #1 1&$(A($ ;  ($$; &;(;  L2+=...1"P

(  $;$   (  L2 +*...1" <  2( $(  $  3($ $(& <  )%  (%   4' #1 1& #$ ($  #1 1    ( )$ #1 1&$(A($ ;  ($$; P

(;;$H    I  < ! "! #$%$ & '(   ( & < !!$) = $& '(   =$ $; $$ H*< #$;( (% ($  #1 1   !N  $#1 1&1

,-./-,+..0 "-.,-."

#$% 8 !;('@&$ &!1@)4&!;L$&!1 )$&!;(& A%1

(; $6;$$  $58

%55$4"A$ A18  '$"$ 8     !1 (($ 1('@  

($(5(; I  (;;$H3 $1

 4'&  %55$48           

,-./-,+..0