ATA/567/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATA/567/2005 · Statutory Interpretation of Transaction Classification and Taxation (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party sought review of a judgment regarding the classification and taxation of their transactions, arguing that the lower court erred in applying a specific statutory provision concerning the nature of their activities. The court reasoned that the clear language of the controlling statute and the established facts demonstrated that the transactions in question fit squarely within the parameters of the provision the party sought to avoid, thereby validating the original tax assessment and upholding the judgment against the challenging party.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

CONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION; AMENDE; FAUTE; LOGEMENT; SANCTION ADMINISTRATIVE; PERMIS DE CONSTRUIRE; TRAVAUX D'ENTRETIEN; TRAVAUX SOUMIS A AUTORISATION; AUTORISATION; DROIT D'ETRE ENTENDU; BONNE FOI; LEGALITE; LOYER; CONCOURS D'INFRACTIONS; TRANSFORMATION | Transformation lourde d'un immeuble de deux étages comportant 28 chambres louées en quatre appartements de 5 pièces sans autorisation. Amendes, fixation des loyers par le DAEL et décision de restitution du trop-perçu des loyers. | CST.29; LDTR.1; LDTR.2; LDTR.3; LDTR.9; LDTR.11; LDTR.44; RDTR.5 al.2; LCI.1

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

interprétation de l'arrêt taxations fiscales opérations imposables autorité judiciaire fiscale étendue du devoir légal nature de l'infraction

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order to rule on the costs of the federal procedure (costs awarded to the respondent).

Généré par l'IA

A/2603/2004

Tax Statute Interpretation and Transaction Characterization Review

A/1024/2000

Taxability of Commercial Transactions Under Statutory Interpretation

A/1538/2002

Tax Entity Classification and Assessment Dispute

A/3226/2006

Tax Assessment Validity and Statutory Interpretation

A/920/2006

Statutory Interpretation of Tax Assessment Procedures

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order to rule on the costs of the federal procedure (costs awarded to the respondent).

Texte complet

!"#$%&'''''''''' !"#$%&

&

( )(* + )(, -* .--. - .- / .- . -

'()*+'

+/ &0 1/2222222222 & 3 304 ##05! # 2222222222$ 6 4$ 70 & 0 3 ! 8 22222 22222$ !! 22222$90!!222223!3&##0/

(/ ##05!&70/1/222222222204 :%$ 3 ! 3 3 ! !703& &&3 3 ! & /2222222222 ;/ / <':=/2222222222>!*.?0(..($043 1@+AB..A.../'/

*/ 5C#22222$7033+DE(&0%0 #2222222222$ 5 ?070F (..( 3 %!!0 & #!&G 3 !F /2222222222/ ##05! 3 304 %04 0 H'3' 0 &#& ?070F63$6 70"$+- #5$+9&$(I (3&0 /

-/ ! &0 3 !F (..($ 3 ! !703& 3 ! 9!! 3 !F/2222222222$5C#!!# 5!!# 70/!F!000539&3"3&/

,/ +. #5 (..($ !& 70F! 3%0 & 3 !04$ /1/2222222222!!70!70&35!&0! #5 35C#F3003#3!F#"#$3!F70# 30 !&"# <':= > &0 "! 3 %04 3F 0 !F##05!0'3/!#!09&#0!3F&0%03 %! J# 3 !&"# 3& 70"K "! ! %04 0%=

'0

' "#35"&

'%L#3&!

'9&35&3&

'3&05!"3%

'!"

E/ +*#5(..($//2222222222$%&#&G3!F##05!3 /1/22222222223700 703F#&%04&0 3!F##05!70F000&&F3#3/

B/ 9900&M!0!!-&&5(..(/

)+,-,)(..* '*)*+'

F##05! %3 3 &0 &0/ %04 3 9&#& &0 < 3 !&'!C 3 3 !C>/ & &0% 9903%043!C'0/!&06! & 3 3%/ #04 3 &0& &N 3 ! 5C#!""/H&33 "#3F%0&33 !!0!N"305C#/

O/ 3&30D&&5(..($! &3&!FL30 /

& 30 &M! 0 ! 990 ! - &&5 (..($ ! % & 70!5C#9!F&5?3%0439&#&&0#60&&/

/ 1/2222222222 3 3& 0 3#3 3F0&& 3 &0&0!F#5!3%04&?3!5C#$3! ?&0 3: & 3 !3 3&/ !!' 40& &&5 &0&0#0&0&0!0%/

D/ //2222222222!0G"!70!0$! F6&0%0300!!04!(O&&5(..(/

+./ 0&&70! &0/

++/ &&$ / 1/2222222222 4!70 F%& P0 !F&3 3FL3 /9&#! 3!F433&$ !370%&0!&FG&0#903!&# &/

+(/ ;06%$/ 1/2222222222&00%&$70 3 0&00 !(D&&5(..(/

/1/2222222222F%?#9&#3!F&33FL30 30 D &&5 (..(/ !!0$ ! % !# 3#& 4& 0 $ % ! %04$ 70 04' !# 6 3 %04 3F 0 703&!?0036&&/$%04F &0#60&&&0%L&00%/!&%$&70$ 3&3!33&/

+*/ FGP03&30 03#33&3&$ /1/2222222222&000:30 50!3&!F&33FL30 30D&&5(..(<08 )+.(-)(..(>30++&%#5(..(/ !&!!!F9909&!06!F0!&3!3&670! 50!&70!%04F&0#60&&/

!F%?#30%70!3&&$3&70 &3&3FL30%%&!/

)+,-,)(..* '-)*+'

F##05!9!F&5?70370!70%043F/

&0'&!305C#!&0&00#&3 1@+A,../' #&30!+&Q(..(/""!&0 1@O../'/500430H'

3' 0!&0 1@-A.../'#&30#5(..(/

+"&09!F&5?3F00%04/

(:# " 9& # 9 !F&5? 70 3 %04 3F&39&#&&03&%&/

&70F! % #! 0: 30 3!& 3F&0%0 3 ! +. #5 (..($ & % 3 &## ! %04$ ! % 4&&!#70F!33/!0%!#370$ 6&&$70%043F0&&/3& %&!3&!3!5&9&/

&9&##670F!%"!$!%$%!F33 9!$!%040%=

' %0&30%04#&5!$3!%!!#&70$3&$%&! %R

' #!#33!#3009R

' 03#00R

' 39&3"3&0'&!R

' #!#30%I 33&0 R

' 35&0 "3!&R

' #3!F!!&!70R

' !!&3F0 &!!%R

' 3!F&/

&3!0&M!$!030 %P03!70 3!C/!%330$&09&%&30/1/22222222226 0?$70!0'&03!&&/$9"!# &/!%0!3!703!C&05&0 !&0! 3 3 & !!# 3#&!$ # %04 F !# 6 0 #&60#&39&3!&9"0&305C#/ !%04F&0#6!!&0!&0&!!!& 3% 30 +- %! +DOO < ' , .,> 6 ! !& 0 ! 3#&!&$

)+,-,)(..* ',)*+'

9&#&&%&3#&3A 5&30(,?%+DDE< ',(.>/

+-/ +(&%#5(..($! 30&06/1/2222222222/

! 3& 3F!# 099 &0 3# 0 !F0'

?# 3 %04 6 ! 6 ! 70F! &S ! &?39&3"!&5!/!&0%$&70$&3 !F&33FL30 30D&&5(..(/

+,/ (( &%#5 (..($ / 1/2222222222 370 0 70F! F3 #&39 ! &9"0& 30 5C#/ ! F%$ 0!$ ?# 0 !F& 3 30 &0 3 &0 3 &0%!! !&&/ % $ ! 30& ! &0& 3 !&& % #!F/2222222222$#&#0!9!!/!% 3&3Q!#/ %&&09&4L##09!! 3F0&&/

9$!#&5!70!F0%03!&'!C36 !9&&06!&0&3!&&$#0F%0!/

+E/ 3& 30 (O &%#5 (..($ ! 50! 3#9 ? ! 3#33F9909/

!G%!03F3#$#9$70!%049903%L 0&%3FL/ 3L $ 0%0&#'

#3!0&30# !&96:%34"3! 6 "3$&##3303!%04?070F63&?0"/

+B/ O ?% (..*$ 0 0 30 % 0 &0%!! 9& ! 30&3F&T!3&0!!!#0%/

"# 3 3&& 3 : & 04 ! 3 +DE( 3!+(:#"%&/!&0%3&#$6 03 "$ 304 # 3 , : !0 ! 3 +- #5$ 3 ( I $ 3 ( 3&0 30 9& 9"0 0 !3 !/ &0!& ! 3 " % 3&05! &0 0 ! 350& 3 : 3 !3 # 70 !&& % 0# &0 9 0 "3 :<?&0>#/!"!F&33FL30 $3%043 0$3F!!&3!!353 0$70F0 "# "!&5!3!G&!&"3!&04%990/

+O/ 0!!04!&3%$/1/22222222223!70 9&#& % 40 % 70F! 70 !F##05!/ ! % !0'#L# &00% 9&#& & 30 !" 0 ! &!$ #"303!!353! #5&!!

)+,-,)(..* 'E)*+'

!&&/ ! & 70 %04 &0# 6 0&& F""63&070L0:30 &004'/

+D/ +B?%(..*$! 3!F&3/1/2222222222 3 3& 0 3#3 3F0&& &0 ! %04 &0/ ! !F % 6 L! &&0!970!&#3! 3%L70&!#&3!&G3'

##"/

(./ +B 9% (..*$ ! !F&3 3FL 30 30 D &&5(..(9!"6/1/22222222220#33 1@+,A.../'/

!F&&3F0&0%0&M!0!990!B9%(..*$0 0 3 ! &! 3 &0& % & 70 ! %04 &'

0$ #!" ! ?$ ! 50! 3#9$ 3 ! 3#3 3F99 09 9&# & !FL 30 !"04/ 3 0 % &0&0%3!F3/1/2222222222$70!! 3 !!9U3!3M&!05C#/ #!&G%370 %&70!FL30 &%"00/

(+/ ! G !0 3 70F0%$ / 1/2222222222 % 3 6 9!F9#!!1/22222222229!$!3!F !%3"39&!&/F#!&G3&0%70& 990 39&3035C#/

((/ +- # (..*$ / 1/2222222222 3&$ !F#3 3F0 #3$ 0 3#3 3F0&& 3 &0 & 0 ! %0499004+(:#"3!F##05!!"04<DOF*,E'-> 0 3#3 3 # &9&# 3 %04 990 0&& &30/

(*/ +O#(..*$0030 &3 60&0%!!% 0 !/ / 1/2222222222$ % 3 ! 3 3 0 3 !&$F300!!04/

(-/ F0&703%043%L#3&!3#0 &00H'3' 0/!304"3!&"#$!%04 #$G&#!#"#&#!303!! 35/

(,/ 30+D#(..*$/1/2222222222&000:30 50! 3#9&!3&30+B9%(..*<0 )-+B)(..*>/!&!0 6&0!&/

F##05! % 05 3 3"3& % # % ! % ' 070# 04 + (:# " ' 3 #! %04 3F/

)+,-,)(..* 'B)*+'

0!O?%(..*$!F%!099000%043!5C#/ ! % 70 :% 30 + 9% 0 + # (..*$ : %& & 3 9#6!&0!3&5C#$3&70F!#&5!70 ! 0&70&70&3&3/3&$70 9&300&M!0!0%0!B9%(..*$&3 5 3F0 #&$ &# 5!$ 00 &0% FG "30#&3%!3&3/

?09 & #3 3 1@+,A.../' 9&3 0 0 30 & % 0 &0%$ 370 & &#$ 70 #L /1/2222222222 3F39 & 3F! ! & 3 0&0305C#?&0'!6/

F0& % 3& 5! ! 9 !F3 0 !5!$!%3&0#&G3393$%&!&"%3& 3&3FL30/

F#3 !"0 9&3 !# 0 ! 9 70 3 %04 % 0&&/ $ 9 & 30 ! 350$ %04 3 #! %04 3F/ ;!& ! ?003$ ! #!# 3 &! %0 &0 &## 0 & &0# 6 0&&<;+DOD/(,(>/!!!3#L#3!&3F! 09&03&0%04!"<;+DD*/,BE>/

9$ ! &0% #0 6 / 1/2222222222 ! #&39& !! 990 0&& % & 70& 0 &/

(E/ (B # (..*$ ! / 1/2222222222 3 !0 9&0 !F !&93!F##05!%:%04/

(B/ &030B%!(..*$:0&0%0&M!0!$! #33#03!F&33FL30 30D&&5 (..(/

%04%0H'3' 0$3!5004/ 70F! 90 !&0 6 0 & 3& 9! &$ !&04 ! & 3 / 1/2222222222$ 70 3% &3 3 %04 /

&0&0!0&0%04!!0%/

(O/ ! 30 (, %! (..*$ / 1/2222222222 &30 70 ! %04 990 !& F !# 6 3 #! &G"$ 0 #!#33043!#&70R%04F&0#6

)+,-,)(..* 'O)*+'

0&&/!&0%!!0L0&0&5!$3:!& 70F!!%/

(D/ 3& 30 (D %! (..*$ ! 50! 3 ?& ! &30 )+.(-)(..( )-+B)(..*/ ! && !0 0&$ 3F ! $ 3 !F 3 ! 3& 30 0 ! 3#3 3F0&& 3 &03&/1/2222222222!+-#(..*/

*./ 0 # (..*$ / 1/2222222222 !&0 ! 70 # !"04$ &0 0 !&G 3 1@ (A*../')#&$ 3 !F0&& 30 /

*+/ +*#(..*$!3&06!3#330 &!F !&9305C#%%04/

!%70!F##05!04 :00:&#5!F4 3!F3%0!F!&90/F:! 70F!% 9900:3399&$!#5!70!&9! 0%=

' 1@*../' #5 04 + (:# "$ !70! & +O #5"$&0!&0R

' 1@(A,../' &0 ! 5004 30 H'3' 0$ &0 !F'

/2222222222R

' 1@(A,../'&0!&0'&!$&0!#L#/

&!3!F!&90=

' #5= 1@+.AO../')#&$& 1@+(DAE../')R

' 5004= 1@(A,../')#&$& 1@*.A.../')R

' &0'&!= 1@(A,../')#&$& 1@*.F...)/

!9!!9!#3303&!70&073&'&0&/

!&9%&!=

' + "= ( # 3 , : 6 1@(A*../')#&$ & 1@(BAE../')R

' (:# "= ( # 3 , : 6 1@(A*../')#&$ & 1@(BAE../')R

' 5004= 1@(A,../')#&$& 1@*.A.../')< ">R

)+,-,)(..* 'D)*+'

' &0'&!= 1@(A,../')#&$& 1@*.F...)< ">/

;!& !0!$ !F !&9 &0 ! 70 !&"# 3% L 3 1@+..A-../')$& 1@,A,(./'):/

*(/ &0 30 +. ?0 (..*$ ! 9&# / 1/2222222222 70F! %&3600!0!3!F!&970!F#65!#& 30!&G06 1@-A*O*/'):/

;!&!!305C#$46!3#33F0&&3 &0 3& ! &0$ ! 5C# &#&$ % %04$ +- #5 "$ 70 9 (O #5 &0$ & *E/ (O #5!&0 1@*../'#&$70#30 !&9 3 1@+..AO../') < 1@ *../' 4 +( #& 4 (O #5>/ &09&$ &# 0 3 ! 09 90 6 D #( 3 +- 3 #5$ ! &3 70 !!' 3 3#':$ 70 3% &# &##B::03! /!G%(*:&0& B:3!03D#("<+-:>$+-3#':0! 304"<&#&##B:>$70(9&<(:>/

F:!0!$!F!&9%%04046!: 3 1@-A*O*/'<& 1@+..AO../'=(*:>/

9&#&G70#3,:$&(.: 0 &!$ !F !&9 3#5! 3 1@OBAEE./' <& 1@-A*O* 4 (. :>/ !0! &30 6 0 !&G #4#0# 3 1@(+AD+,/' #/

9$!&G 099&0#0&3 0& &&#70# ! &Q 3 %04$ ! 6 3 3F 9 ! 3#&& 0 !0! 30 3# 3 9&3 & & 0 !F#5!3!F##05!!&3!F!++!* ,! ( 30 :"!# 3A!& 3 ! !& 0 ! 3#&!&$ 9&#& &%&3#&3A 5&30(D%!+DDE< ',(./.+>/

%/1/222222222263#070&% 3303&9&#!!/

/ (-?0!!(..*$! #6/1/2222222222!F&33 &0!%04&033&03#33F0&&3&0 & 0 ! 0$ 3 ! ?&0 3: & 3 !3 3&/!!0"!#9!"0#33 1@BA.../'/

!0!3F0&M!9900!!(O#(..*70$#!"! 3 &3 3FL 30 ! # "3 30 B %! (..*$ ! %04%&0/&0'&!3!F##05!%"!#9

)+,-,)(..* '+.)*+'

<&$ !9&3 &! # 6 09>/ H'3' 0 % "!# 0 6 ! 00 3 !F 3 !F##05! 6 "0 #5! %& #"5004/ 9$!+(:#"%#"70 #3,: 0&0!&0&0$&#6 !!&$00#3F&0FG3!%/

3&&3!#3!F!(D(30 &3!0 30(+3#5+D*B< ';*++/>/

*-/ &030*.?0!!(..*$/1/2222222222&!970!0 & /

!F%99000%040H'3' 00&0'&!3& ##05!$6!F4&3%0430/

! % ! 6 &3 6 0 &0%0 & 0 ! &0%0&0%!!&303#3!&3&3! 3&30(-?0!!(..*/

*,/ &030#L#?&0$!F3#0!!0!30 !96 !F!&903!F##05!/

! &% 3 &#$ &0 3# !F !&9 ! % %04$ 30 9 70 ! #5 &0 !&0 6 3 #!&G 3 !F/222222222270!!&G$0!:#5$&#3 !&3%!9&0!F#!&G/

!9!!"!#&#30&Q3%04990/ "3$ /1/22222222229%%!!3&#&!<3F&Q 6&&5(..(>/

*E/ &306&0!+*&Q(..*/

&!F!&9%%04$!FG%3&3F 3 1@*../') #5#&/

&#5 3 : 0! 70 6 !0 3 ! 3#3 3F0&& 3 &03"0!&$70/1/2222222222%!0'#L#3&/

0 0 &Q 3 %04$ ! F3 5 0 3 #&&!!$#033%90/FL3& &09&!9$!!&G33?6$!0!$!%0304 &3045&3!&0!&$3&70!!&G%%043% L#0/

*B/ 30((&Q(..*$/1/2222222222?&03%! 50! 3 & ! 3& 30 (- ?0!! (..* !0 !F&3 3

)+,-,)(..* '++)*+'

&0 %04 !0 9!" 0 #3 3 1@ BA.../' <0 )+,-,)(..*>/

;&3&3FL30%%&!$!F%30! %!33&/

! "!# & ! 9 70 !0 & / 04' F% ?# 5! 9&3 0 ! & 3F0 0 70 F 3 ! !&04$ 3 #L# 70 0 ! 3 3F0 30 #!&G 3 / 1/2222222222 !& 70 3$ 6 ! $ F% !0 3F#!&G30!00/&#3#!&G9"03! &$3&70F!!0%#&5!3&!!5&6!F5!#3 9$ 3 &0% & ! & &0 !70!! !! 0 ! !04/ 9$ ! 3& 9&3 0 !F 3 !F&3 3FL 3F0 70 F% ?# &0# 6 0&&$ ! %04 3 #! %043F/

*O/ &30 6 &0 ! + 3#5 (..*/ ! &!0 6 & ?/

70!F0F03!!&04$!%30(O# (..* % 5! 6 9& 3 3& 70 ! !&04 30 &0'&! % :#&%$70!H'3' 0%#"70!%04 30 + 30 (:# " % # 3 9&# ! : 70 #!&0$0&&/

!470/1/2222222222F%!&3 % 70F! F% !! % ! 3 ! 3& 30 *. # (..*$#0&F#&3%&!&303&3FL30$ /1/2222222222%3##370V00&30+O#(..* V70F!&3L&5!3%043!&0'&!/ ! % !!0 9&#$ &0 30 B %! (..*$ 30 70 70F! &0 3FL &/ 0& 70F! 9Q$ 0 %&!& 30 3& 3FL 30 3% L &$ !! % $ /1/2222222222 G 0 9%!&"0#3!&303&0$703!0 &303&033%!#L#?03&/

;F"3%043!"<-#3,:>$0 3#33F0&&%3&!+B#(..*$0!70!!! F%&0/

/ 1/2222222222 % % ! 9&#& 3 &0 0 ##05! 0&& &00% %04 #!" ! &3 3FL 30 &0 6 9% (..* 70 !0 % #R 90 &5?%# "% ?09 !F#3 & 3 1@ BA.../' 0 6

)+,-,)(..* '+()*+'

!F#3 3 1@+,A.../' 30 +B 9% (..*$ !! &0% ! #L# 9$ 070F!! % 6 & !F 3 &3 3FL 3 069%(..*/;05?%#$/1/2222222222%%&!&# 993&330 99 0# &0%&0!!&4 70%04F&0#60&&/

*D/ +. 3#5 (..*$ ! 3!% 0 0&& 3 &0 &0 ! %04 990 04 + (:# " 3 !F##05!$ 94 ! !&G !5!6!F##05!9!"0&0%!!#30&0/

!&G0!3!:94$&00&33, $ 6 1@-A*O*/'633!3!&&$&9&##0!0!9"03 &&030+.?0(..*/

3! 3 ?&0 # 6 / 1/2222222222 &0 & ! #&39&004!&!&'P0/

&0$!!09!"0#33 1@,A.../'&0%&%&! ! 70! /

9$&!H'3' 0!&0'&!$! 3&0 303&!F030&03&0 50!3#9&! 3&30(-?0!!(..*<&33!%040H'3' 00 &0'&!$ 3 3& 0 3#3 3F0&& &0 %04 #3 3 1@BA.../'>/

-./ / 1/2222222222 &00 & 3: 3& 0: 30 50! 3#9 ! +( ?% (..-$ !70! # ! 0 6 ! &##& &! 3 &0 #: 3 &0& <':= ! &##&>L30(B?%(..-$!3&70%3 %040&&$#!94&3!&G!&3! /

-+/ L30+.#(..-$! 50!3#9&&!3 !&30&!F&33FL30 30D&&5(..(/

-(/ (+ ?0 (..-$ ! &30 0 &0 ? / 1/2222222222&!F&33FL30 30D&&5(..(/

& ! %&!& !!"0 30 3& 3FL 30$ ! 3& 70%0060%0!3%L3# %0 !F%# 3 %04/ F0" % "!# #&% ! : 40& &&5 &0 3 ! 3&/ / 1/2222222222 G 0 9 %!&"0#370L0&3!F99094 & 3& 3FL 30$ !F%0!! %&!& 3 3& % 0 L

)+,-,)(..* '+*)*+'

! 50! 3#9$ 70 3& 3F0 ! &0%& 3F4# !#:/

;F" 30 3 ! 5& 9&$ ! &3& 3 & !& F #!$ 00 &# FG 9 6 / 1/2222222222 &!%04/

9$ ! F 6 0 & 3 70!9 !0'#L# ! %04%"&0#0!5!&&?0 &070!0'

3#6!00?< 30,#+DD+!0/>/ !F:$! %04 70& !# &0# 6 ! 6 ! /1/2222222222%&%06!!&$3&70F!5!3F0!! 3&!&!F!-- /

-*/ 04 9 3 3# !F 30 5C# % %04 !F !&9 0 6 !F 3 !F##05! / 1/2222222222$ ! 50! 3 30$!+&%#5(..-$304#&G 50!!04/

#&/2222222222=

! % 50 #22222222223+DO,?070F6(..(/ !%!! !& &0 !F /2222222222$ &$ 70 !0 !&0 0 #5/ 0 H'3' 0$ ! G % ! 5004 3 !F /2222222222$ 70F! F%?#%/ 0&0'&!&0%0!3#7070&0 "!# &0 ! !&04 &0 ! &0 70 9 3 !F /2222222222/ !36!F3%&03!F/ !"$!G%3 #5$0"30&0&0! #53!F"0!!35&##0"/!G%%&+( #5"/&0 #5$!%G$!#:$ 1@+,./' #&/ !&G % &"%# %&!0 &0 % 6 1@*../' (..(/ &0 ! #5 !&0 0 #L# 4/ &70F! % 70 ! !04$!F/2222222222%399!!/;&""%9#$ #!!%!50&03 &0!/

#&;/2222222222=

!&70F!#!&G3!F/22222222229:<303503 &$?070F(..(>$!% 50 #2222222222<+">/ ! G &0 0 3 +- #5 &0% 6 !F"/ ! G % 0 0 &##0$ 304 &! 304 3&0 / ! % &0?&0 G 0 !&G 3 1@*../'#&/

0H'3' 0$!G%!50043!F/222222222270 &0 &0 !F" <- &0 , :>/ 0 &0'&!$ !F 9 3 ! /!FG!!!0'#L#$#! 70G%!! 0#/ 0&0'&!$!G%3# /

)+,-,)(..* '+-)*+'

&01/2222222222 30 &#0&&!!6 &&/

&70!F/2222222222$!!%!!5C# 30 &0%5!/ &0'&! 0%3&&70F!%3Q "!#&G/

--/ /1/22222222223&3&!0&:70L!(E&%#5 (..-/ ! 3 ! 9 70 ! %04 0 &0'&! F !#63#!%0439S #/

-,/ 3&&!0&:70L!+B3#5(..-/

!03%&!&3! $/1/2222222222%"!#%&!! / 3?6$ ! & 9&3/ !0$ ! 70L % 3#& 70 ! &0'&!$ 99 0% 6 0 ! 3 #70 3 <5 70 & 0&>$ % " 3 3&$ 070F! % 0?&03F 0 6 !F&" 3 #! 3 5&0!"/ 0 !0 3F0 % 30!!$& G&0%3&#0%!R "# &0# 6 0&&$ ! 0 ! !05 3 !04$ 70 !F 3 #& 3 ##& 3% 9 !F&5? 3F0 4# ! % &/ #&93%"!#L&#&0?09!F#3 3 1@BA.../'/

;F" 30 H'3' 0$ ! 9!# 3# 70 /1/2222222222FG%3%04&0#60&&/

-E/ (( &%#5 (..-$ / 1/2222222222 ?& 6 & &0 3% ! &##& 0 #& 3 ! %!0 3 & 5 ##&5!$ 9 &0W/2222222222$"0/ 43700!&90! %&! 3 304 5C# &9&30 3 1@ (B-AO../') &0 0 "!&5! 3 1@ +AB..A.../' # ! %!0 3 %04 990 6 1@,..A.../'##05!$& 1@+A...A.../'&0!3045C#/

-B/ 50!3F&0!6304$!D9% + #(..,/

#03500430H'3' 0%!70 9 6 09$ !& 70 ! $ 9L 30 F% &0 /

0&0'&!$&0%0!&!3F&"3#!35&0!"/ & 3 5! 4 % !F70& 3 !F##05! / 1/2222222222R0!!!&% "/

)+,-,)(..* '+,)*+'

0 % 9 3 &0'&!$ 70 &#& "!#70%!&0/5&0 3F&#5!0%/

-O/ 3&30(O?%(..,$!&##&?!&0? /1/2222222222&!3&30 30+.3#5(..*94! #& #4#0# 3 !&G$ &3& ! 0& 30 &'P0 !0 9!"0#33 1@,A.../'/

!0! 3 !&G 9 ! &9&# 6 ! !& ! & F% 3#& 70 ! !&G 94 !0 # 3 0&!&Q3%04#?&&3!&G/

&0!#L##&9$!3&30&"!#9&3/

06!F#3$/1/2222222222%#!&&3# 0&&$ ## #!" ! &3 3FL 3 70 !0 %#R!#&0&&&6!"%&5?% 05?%3!90/

-D/ / 1/2222222222 &00 & 3& 0: 30 50! 3 !+.#(..,<0 ),E+)(..,>/!&!06&0!&/

5C#%9&#%#%/ 0!$! !&& 4 +DE( % 50$ 70F! & 3 ! 30 5C#33F03#33F0&&3&03+DOO/

F##05! 3 0 3 3"3&$ %& 3 3%& !! 70F!%9!!0!%33&03 /

9& ! 5C# %3 3 &#55! 30 #04 3 3 !F /2222222222$ / 1/2222222222 % &3 6 ! #305C#/

&Q 3F!!& 3 0 !! 3 5 F #& 6 1@*.A.../'#$& 1@+(.A.../'0&!/

F!#&!%&Q 1@E.A.../'/

!$!&%3F?&0=

' !F%0&30%04#&5!$3!%!!#&70$3&$%&! %!0#!#3009R

' !39&3"3&0'&!R

' !F!!&3F0 &!!%R

)+,-,)(..* '+E)*+'

' !&3F!#3 0993R

' !F&!&3!9&3R

' !&39UR

' !0!&3F300!#0R

' !%L#3&!R

' !03!F%!&305C#R

' !&M!403#0R

' !&G"3!&/

90&0!F#5!3%04F!%6 1@(*OAE+-$B+$ 670&!9!!?&0!%!990!&09#!!/

9&%04 %$/1/2222222222%## !&&$90#&3!F!&90!539&#& 3&!3&3970F!%""/

3&$! F%&#!970!!&& 3 #5$%!F 305C#$9!F/2222222222 6&#!&G/ !&G&#!&03 #!&G$ ! !&G 0!:# 5 3& ! 59 0 9&# 3 #0& &/ 3% 3& &3 70 ! !&G %5! 006#&/

!!0$! F%5!69&33&!&#53 : % %04/ 3!& 3 #& 30 ! 50! 3 %&3&/ !&5!70F! G 0+O #5 "&+-/

&##&%"!#90#0%!&3!F!++ /

9$!F#33 1@,A.../'F?09/ & 0 &03F%&#!&&#!4"3 ! $ !& 70F! % # !0'#L# : 3 09 #& &0 0 0 3#3 3F0&& 3 &0/ 03 3#& 70F! % 0 &33!F0&&$!0!&303&#504#& 3!&G/

)+,-,)(..* '+B)*+'

,./ E%!(..,$! &300&0$&!06!&9#& 3!3&70/;"0#&$7035&$3! 3&':/

-

+/ ? # 0! 3% ! ?03& &#$ ! &0 & %5! </ ,E 0% 3 ! !& 0 !A&"& ?03 30 (( &%#5 +D-+ ' ' ( .,R / E* !/ + !/ 3 ! !& 0 ! &30 3#%30+(#5+DO,' ' ,+.>/

(/ &7039999&600&370&060 0 ?0370 &##0$ !A0& 0 3A&99 ! ?&3 0 #L# &30 </ B. !/ + >/ ! ! 3 !F&3 3FL 30 30 D &&5(..(3&#370&0%&$703!94& 3!&G370#&0!70!!F&33FL30 &3&<08 )+.(-)(..($ )-+B)(..*$ )+,-,)(..*$ ),E+)(..,>/ &70$0&?&&0!8 )+.(-)(..(/

&01""2#13$$#3$$456 "#$758$#9

*/ &%3&$!&0!3F0%&!&3& 3&3FL30$!F0&#!FG%6F4#%3 33&/

! 70 " !F! (D ! ( 3 ! &0& 93! 30 +O %! +DDD < ' ; +.+>$ ! 3& 3FL 30 &#3 &0 !F ! 3& 3F&99 3 0% $ 3 3 & 30 3&$ 3F&570F!&3&06&9930%$36 !F3#&30%!!&0$6&0!#&$3F4#0& 0!$ !&70 ! 3 0 6 9!0 0 ! 3& 6 3 < )OBD)(..*30(3#5(..*>/

&09&$!F0&F03F3!!&70F!G! !3#0</-*!/3 >/

!F:$ ! &0 &0% 0 % ! 9& &#!: 3F0 5C# 3F 5&/ : %& % ! !04$ ! % 6 ! &%& 70F0 3" 04 4 70 3 %04 0 0&&""/:!&70F03&040!70!9&3 %04$!F%30&00!70&F3069!0! 3& 6 3 70 % &0 0! 9&& 3F#L $ % 70F! & & 3$ 70 3 %04 & 6 ! !& & %/ 0! #&G & 6!%!3&030 0!70&3F4"30&

)+,-,)(..* '+O)*+'

70F! 3& 0 3#3 3F0&& 3 &0/ #&G % &0 &&!! 0! 3F4" ##3#$ 3 !F 3 9&#& 70$ !FL 30 / $ !F&3 3FL 30 % 0 : 3F0" 70 # 6 !F0& # 3 3 ! &0%333&/

"93!%&!&303&3FL303&3&L/

-/ ;!&!F!+(D! V!5!%03!F!--!+ '! 0&3&!0&3%04&0#60&& !&70F000&&F3!%$70#0&360L 05!70F!!S&9&#03!&&&!/

!F:$ ! 70& 3 %& ! %04 &0 & &0# 6 0&& !"0/ 0& 0 &0 0 !G !F!& 3 3&&/ 99$ !&70F0 3&0 4 0 ! &0#& 3 %04 6 0&&$ ! 9&3 6 &3& ! 0& 3 !F 3FL &#!:# "0!:# 9&# 3 #"# &? 3 &0%& 3# &70/ 0 ! 0&4L##3030# 30!&"#$!?09$30&3 %03!FL05!$70! &3&!FL30 3!F30 3M 3 ! 70L 3F0&&$ 70 0! !0 # 3 &S ! ! &? 30 &0 3F !0 & &: 0 ! L 05! &"! /&009"90 3F%&3 50#$ #0$ ! 9& 3 & 5C# !& 70F! %&!&# ##$ 0: 3 3$ !F#& 3 ! 9& %" <%& ! ! 3 %04 3& 0 #5 (..( ! !3%04709"03&&030+.#(..,>/F&3 3FL30 !0!#0&6%!L05! 0$3&70!3&&&!F%&!/

&!0&$ !F&3 3FL 30 30 D &&5 (..( &0 &&9&#6!!&/

& :";# 5#3 #$"!" <$1#!$=:#>>#52!9

,/ &0&$3399&0$70!%04 &0# 6 0&&/ ! &3: F%& 990 70 3 %04 3F&0!70!000&&F/

E/ !& 0 ! 3#&!&$ 9&#& &%& 3 #& 3F 5&30(,?%+DDE< V,(.>&0503%!F 5 </ + >/ !! F!70 &## 04 5C# &#& 3 !&04 70$!0#"#!0350&$&996!F 5&</( !/+!/5 >/

)+,-,)(..* '+D)*+'

5C# 3 !70! ! %04 & 990 &#&$ 04 + (:#"$70#3,:36!F 5&/

!3&5&0#6! $&##!&0! /

B/ %& 3 & 6 ! 9&#& 0 "# 3F99&3#&3F 5&</+!/(! >/

0&&0!&0&09&#&&0 &%& 3 6 #&39 ! 350& 0 3 &0 &0 3A0 #&3A 5&</D!/+/*!/+!/ $/+!/+!/5 >/

O/ ;!& !A! * ! + ! 3 ! ( $ & 70!9 3 9&#&!%0470&&0&5?!&%&$A'6'3!# $#L#!!$3&0&03A0#&3A 5&$#!& !&9&4#&39!350&3!&"#$&0%70A! A"3%043A/ 3$&0?6! $& !%04&09393A4!&&&33A0#& 3A 5&/ %04 &5! 3A "0! & &3 &## %04 3 9&#&$ &0 0 70A! A"3 0 #!&&30&9&4< ),(()(..-30O?0(..->/

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

D/ ?003 & < )E,D)(..- 30 (- &Q (..- 9 >$!3#$F"3!3&%043A3'

&%& <&0 3 9&#&> & 6 !F! * $ 3 0 &#304#$6%&=

)+,-,)(..* '(.)*+'

'F5&34#$3!00!%040!:% 3 !F &0$ 0 &$ & 3 %04 3 &%&/ &!&"# 3 3&$ ! ?003 3# 70 3 %04 3F & 05! 3F5&0 6 0 &%& &0 6 0 9&#& &0# 6 ! $ !&70 FG 40 &370# &0 && &0 0 !&" 3 !F4 3 !F##05!$ &0 & 70F! F& 4030&033&#50$!00#0!&$#L# &#3F040&&!!&##30"&0#$!0 &9: 0 3 & 6 "3 0 "# 3 3" 3 !F##05!< / $!&0%!! 0"33!?003$ @+DDE/*+-!?003>R

' 0$F 6!F#!0$$0&Q33%046 !0 0& 0 ! #& 30 !&G$ 3: !& 70F! &0 0! 0 "# 3A99& 70!9 0 ! !&"#$ 3 &3 !0 04 5& &3 ! &0!& < )*E,)(..+ 30 (D # (..+R )(E+)(..+30(-%!(..+!9>/

+./ !& 3 $ ! 50! 3#9 &## &3 &## !% 3 !A !A!!& 3 &0%04 $ !A"# 3 0$ ! # &9&# 3 !A!!& !70$ ! & 3 &0%04 %L# 3 &! 3 &$ 70 3 %04 3 0 3 0 < )+E()(..* 30 (, # (..*R )*E,)(..+ )(E+)(..+9>/!&09&30L0$ 70A! &% 3 &# "!# 3 & 3 !70!! ! %04 &#! &## 3 !0 0#0!& & 3A0 390 3A &0 3 5C# & < )EOO)(..( 30 +( &%#5(..(R )*-)+DDO30(B?%+DDO>/

++/ &## %0 '30$ !A4# 3 ! 0 3 %04 0 L &09& ! 0! : 6 3 &3& &0 3# ! %& & 6 ! !&/ !!' 0% 3 0 #!0 !! 70A!! & 05! 3A5&0 6 0 "# 70!9 3 !A##05!/ #L#$ !A0"#& 30 !&G &0% 6 3 %04 0 %& &0 99 3AS 0 "# 3A99& 70!9 3 !&"# < )O.()(..+30-3#5(..+>/

+(/ ! #0 &T ! !& % !# 6 # 0 5 &&3$&##&0!A"!&&#70$045&&33 !&0!&$!90%703%04&&0#6!!&&306! !&"060&&303 5/ 3A0#!!& 6&0# 0 &M! 3 !A "& 3 %04 3%" 9&& 3 70 70A! 9& 0 ! : 5&35! 3 !&G 70A 9&& 30 G 3 %04 04'#L# </ ; 1 $ @/ W 1 $ Y ?00330 50!3#930 &3:%#:

)+,-,)(..* '(+)*+'

3A3##05!Y @+DDO/*EO>/ 0A!A"3&0#0 "# 3 9&#& %04 3A &0$ #!" !A5 3 "0!$3#!%04639&#&$!:39 3& !0 &Q &70 0 ! : 5&35! 3 !&G </ ; 1 $@/ W 1 $&//$/*ED>/

! 3F:$ ! %04 990 04 + (:# " 3 !F##05! !"04 0% L &3 &## 3 #! %04 3F/L#!F#& "#3!350&3:% &## & 30 <30& &0& !! 3 !&&>$ ! &0 990 !F! 3 %04/ : !& 70F! & &306!9&#&3(O #5-#3,:$% !F!!&3700$370!!35$!9&&#!:3 !!& !70$ ! 3&05!" 3 !9&3$ ! & 3 !" 3 9U!03&0!:3!F%!&305C#$!F 305! 70 04' & 3 %04 3 &%& 0 3 ! !&/ !!0$ ! %!0 # / 1/2222222222 &0 !0 40& < 1@ ,..A.../'> %! 3 !F#& 3 %04 #L# $ 0 3%30!!#$3F04F03F0&&!& !?003/ !F3&004&!070!%04 % #!# 6 ! 5C# # 6 ! 9&# 3!#$#!&"3#!&9&4!36! !&&&009&#?070F!&4/

&0$!&0&070F00%!39S #F% 990303&#50/!#L#37070!F##05! &0% "%# 3"3/ F 3 70 ! %04 3F % 3!&"#399/

!3&0!370:370!%04!"043&%L&3 &## 3 %04 3 9&#& &0# 6 0&& !& ! ! D +!+!5 /

+*/ & ! %04 990 0 H'3' 0 0 &0'&!$ ! 3&0!3304&0!990! 50!370F!& &3#!%043F<#0$709609 5&0 3F&0%$!&70!$9L30F& &0 >/

0:70L$! 3#70%04 3F0&&$3&70F!FG!03FG%/

+-/ % $ ! # 70 ! 70L & %!$ & ! &0'&!$ 70F0 "# 3 3& 0 0&& %

)+,-,)(..* '(()*+'

$ !F0!& 3F0 "" 3F0 ! 3 6 !F&"3#!35&0!"!!&&370%/

99#& F 099## G &0 L 0$ ! #&"" 0!! ! 3&0# 70 & 0 L &50 ! $ !F $!&##&! 50!30!F0!&03 &0'&!#3F5!!#0 "#33& !!#0!0/

+,/ &!0&$ 0! ! %04 04 + (:# " 3 !F##05!00&&0%L0&09&30 9&/

+E/ &0%0&303!5&9&RG"!0 ! %04 70F! !! "" % 3 ! 3$ 3 !0 0!370F000&&F&004'/

3!& 3F&0%0 3 30 +. #5 (..($ ! &0 F 3 0 3 #&39& #& 70FS %040!!&"#4/ 0!$!F370%&0!& 9&# 304 " 3 #5 3 6 ! !&& 70 #3,: 0/!!S70F!5&6J# !F##05!0&K$#&39!F0"70%9?070F!&/ !0$!F0#70F03%04$##!F#!03 !&%&/

&$ !&00 %!&303 ! 5&9&$70&0%!&!F:/

&":" #!1?#$!<$1# 9

+B/ ;&0$!!"&6!94&! 3!&G 370#!&070&0%04+(:#"3!F##05!/ !&G30305C#<&0'&!$H'3' 0$3!70! &0%35C#60"3F 5&> 0&M!#& ! $70!F3#!0!"/

;!&!F!+. $! 94$&##&3&3!F0&&$ ! #& #4#0# 3 !&G 3 !&"# : %04/ 30 30 &M!3&&0!##05!9&#&0&%/ !!0L &6739&#&!&03</+( >/ &M! F&: &09& 70 0 ! # 70 &&3 6 0 5& &33!&0!&/

5&&0 !"&3A#&T%!0</(,6 *D >/ 3#& 3 "& 3F# &0

)+,-,)(..* '(*)*+'

& 9 !A&5? 70 3A0 L ! &! 3A / !A:$ !& !AL 3# 0 #&# 3 9 &## !& !0 0!!# %"00 30 (D &%#5 (..- <,(./.*>$ ! G 0 3 &0 ! "& 3A# 3 6 L !&0 ! &0 ! #3+6B:!0%#/

!F:$ !F !&9 % %04 0 ! 3 1@+..AO../'/!!!&&3+- #5"$&(O: 0&!$6 1@*../'! #5#&<&!= 1@*../'4+(#&Z 1@*AE../') #5!&0R(O #54 1@*AE../'Z 1@+..AO..>/

3$+-3(O #5!&03&3F009906 ( D # $ : & !0! ! &## 3 3#':/ &#5&!3:#6(*$&=

' B:3!03D#("=+-:R

' B:3#&3D#(0!304"=+-3#':ZB :R

' (9&=(:/

; 9&3 0 !0!$ ! & ! !&G 0! 3 70 #6 1@(+AD+,/'$& 1@-A*O*/'):< 1@+..AO../'=(* : Z 1@ -A*O*/'): R -A*O*/'): 4 , :)# Z 1@(+AD+,/'>/

+O/ &0&!0!/!&3:3F5&370!F!&9% %040! F5!R3033#00 ! &#5 3 #5 4 " % ! % 3 !F##05!$ 70 306#&39!#&3!&G0/

&0%!0!F!&9%%04$! F9&303! 33+DOO$?&!F 30&063#33F0&&3 &030+-#(..*/ !9&3+- #5$3F09&$ 33043&0 3304I "/#&6!&30$&0304 !&3F0 #5?070F(..(V3!%3!F##05!3 %04V&&9#3&&3!04/L#!F03F04 % !0 4# 70! &#5 3 : &0% "$ ! &3!0470F!9&&3&0&6!$3& 70F! G !0 3F3# 70 04' ! 3&& 3 !&04 !! 70F!!&0%%!%04/

F%00&3F3!$3&! &9#!3#&""/

)+,-,)(..* '(-)*+'

+D/ ! F !!0 ?# !"04 70 ! #& 30 !&G 3 #5#&6 1@*../'#&/

(./ &0&0!:%370!&G3&0#"93:! 3 !F !&9 % %04$ ! !&G 3 #5 G 00 6 1@*../'#&!!&F%3#!&G3!F & 30 5C#/ ! F #&5!$ 99$ 70 3 ! &!70 # !F$ ! #& 3 !&G &# 3 ! & 3 %! 70F0 !&G 4"# 5 94$ &0 0 9&# 3 #0&&#!#0!%/

G& :3&3L/ 99$!$ !F:$ 70 !&G 4%# 5/ #5 &0 4L## <O 6 ++ #(>/ !! 3& 3F00 I 3F00 3&0 33/ 9& &##0 6 !0 "3 70 ! #5<%/+*#(>!FG%703043&0 304I &##0 "&0+-!&/

!&G94&0 #5&9&#044700 !# !&96:%(..(/

(+/ &0 & & 70$ 3 ! !0! 3 !F !&9 % %04$ +- : < 0 ! 304 "> &# &0 3 3#':/

&0 !0! ! &#5 3 : % %04$ 0 3 ! $ ! F 9&3 0 !F! + ! , ! $ !& !70!&0 #5 3A0 09 90 6 D #( &# &0 0 3#':/ 3&&F!700!0!30&#53:3!&"#&0#6! $&04!&"#3F0!05!70</+E>/50&00% ! ! !:% 30 #L# &0 3 % !F 5 3 !0 & ! 0 3 !&"# 6 :%/ 0 3& 9# !70$ !&"$ 0 !0! 30 &#5 3 : !& ! $ !F! + ! , !/

70 ! !:% ! &##& 3 &0$ !0! 9%&5! 0 &0R ! 0"# ! %!0 3 : 0 !0 3 !F5 < !F& 3% (O:0!03(*$#:60!&G:3 1@*AE../' 0 !0 3 1@ -A*O*/' $ & 1@ +..AO.. [!&9 0\= (O : 0 !03(*>/

&!0&$!&#53:70!#&3!&G0 0 ! 3&% L &9#/ &9&## 6 ! $ ! &%3&3FL0!&G6!:3 1@-A*O*/'):$70 !F9!F0&#/

)+,-,)(..* '(,)*+'

((/ &70 ! !&"# &3 04 5& &3 3 ! &0!&$ ! !&G : 9&#& 3& L &# 1@ (A-../' 1@*A((,/'!:</D!/*++!/( >/;!!&G% 9&#&&0&%&3!%03!&G&3045& &3 3 ! &0!&$ ! #0 ! 3# 0 #L# %0 !&70F! S 70F! # &&#70# 0 & 3 0&!&Q3%04#?&&3!&G</++!/* >/

!F:$ ! !&G 6 ! : 3 1@ -A*O*/' $ !F! ++ !* &0%6F!70/

50!93!0!F&&3F4#!F!++!* 30&0&!!&< @(..(/*O>/F&&9&#6! &0&33&&#!7070&!&&!#04 3 !&"# 70$ L 3 !&"# 3 !04$ & !&0 6 0 4 70 S$%!%04$&##50%#!%70&&33?66 703#5!:9&#&/ &%0'3!6 3!&&&!!&G&003#509</(ED >! %!&!70!!!5!&"3!&G3&L&&#70#0&5! # 6 !F0& 3 ! 3 ! &&&! !& 3 !F!&33&&/

;F0G 0 ?003$ ! &0 &0 70 !F! ++ ! * !0 !5!$ ! !&"# 3 & ##05! F!&060470509%!%04/

&#30&00L0%/ 99$&#6 70F! &0$ 0 4 6 ! : 3 1@ -A*O*/') &0 0 J!&G 50%#!%K03! $!&70F!3!#&3!&G &3045&&33!&0!&946!F!D!* 70!5!&"3!&G&&#70#0&5!&0!F00 3%04$&##F!!F:<%&&(*'3&0>/9$ !F!++!* !0!5!/

(*/ ;!& ! 50! 93!$ ! 5!&" 3 !&G 3& L &&#70# 0&5! &0 ! 3 ! &&&! # !F!&3!F!++!* /

:"!#0!3#&!&$9&#&&%&30(D%! +DDE< V,(./.+>%&70F!07033#&$ &0 : 0!$ 70F! F #0 3 0& &&#70# ! &Q 3 %04 #?&& 3 !&G/ : 0!$ ! 3# 9 &# 9 6 0 !0! 3 3# 3 !F##05!/ ;053#$!0L&006003&#%!!&G3 !F##05!040!37005! 70!&$

)+,-,)(..* '(E)*+'

70F6 3 &0& "!$ ! !# 0'3!6 3 !70!! ! & 0# &0%& 0& &&#70# ! &Q 3 %04 #?&&3!&G94$094&$0* 70!/3# &#$ 3 & &$ 3 0 90 3 0 3 5 6 3 &3& 0 3 ! (ED 0% 30 &3 3 &5!"&</,!/( >/

!F:$ ! 4# % ! &0 6 9 3#&&%333&<&030 30+.?0(..*>/ &0FG3&0/!!F!&6&3!F!++ $ ?# 3 &0%& 0& &&#70# !3 %04/ &30 5! 70 ! &0 !&0 0!!# ! 70 #!"04&00!&G3 1@(A*../')#&#$& ++.A-../') &0 ! 70 # 0 !0 3 1@ +..AO.. 94 ! / 3& 30 3& 3 1@ DAE../') ! #& P0$ # !! &3 0 !&G 70 3 3 1@ +A+,O/'): ! !&G #4#0# &305&&33!&0!&/&0F?#3 70& &## 099 &0 0& ! &Q 3 %04/ F4 3 !F##05! 30 (( &%#5 (..- 70F! 3& 3%# 3% ! &##& 5& 6 &3 70 !F0"#& 3 !&G J !0M #&3 0 "3 3 &## %K$ # !! 3 0 !F0993!&G94! !&%!%04/

&0FG&!3#&&%!F!,!( !& 70F! 4# 70$ ! 3& L &3 70 ! #&3!&G94! !0#30&&&#70#! &Q3%04/

(-/ 9$F!%3&$&9&##6!!&$070L0&& 3 &0 "! ! &0& 3 70 # !0 !3(O #5$! 00&3!0'#L#$%%04$60 !0! 3 3# 3 !F##05! 3#$ ! $ # ! %04 %"$ &3 04 5& &3 3 ! &0!&3%L""/&00F370F6 !0'#L#0&F0L!G70!!0!&&3F 0L9/

!&G3 1@-A*O*/'):3%L&9#/

(,/ 04#3!F!+( $!!&G!43%#4#04 &&0#0&M!3!A $30&337634&0! &0& &0%!! 3 0 &3 3 & &0 ! ##05! 9&# &0 &%$ 30 70 0 L & 6 7 3 9&#&!&03/

)+,-,)(..* '(B)*+'

94!&M!3!&G6,/!3&9!&3! 3: G& :%3&&&370!&0% 99039&#&!&03/

& 3#5!$ ! %04 G &30 6 ! 9&#&3(O #533-#3,:/

3030&M!&9#/

0&25"!" #$#!"" $<<#$@#!1?#$!

(E/ &0&3%&0!399!!&GP0 0494!F0&#/

50! 3 3?6 ?0" 70F0 #0 % ! 0& 3 !&G&'P009&#3#03!F!+(D! < )+D,)(.., 30 , %! (..,R )BB-)+DDD 30 (+ 3#5 +DDD &9# 0 L 30 50! 93! + /*B)(... 30 +* %! (...>/ #0 % &%# ! !&G 70 &0 0 #0 3 5!#3F00&&9&#03&R!F&330!&'P0 3!&G&360L05!!3!&&&! < )BB-)+DDD9R @+DD-/+.B>/

!F:$!F!&9!"04&9#$!F&330&3 !&G070FL&9#"!#/

&70$!&0?0&/

0&A# #!

!"

(B/ 5!3F0#33#%3 1@+../'6 1@E.A.../'&0 &%6! 6! </+*B!/+ !&%!F/--!/ + >/ #& #4#0# 3 !F#3 3 1@ (.A.../' !&70F0 &0&$ 0 !!& &0 &0 0 &0%" 0&&$ # 70 ! %04 & &9&# 04 & !"! </ +*B !/ ( >/ ! 0 &# 3 ! 94& 30 #& 3 !F#3 30 3" 3 "% 3 !F9&$ ! 3% &3 &## 0 &""%</+*B!/* >/

#3 3#% & 3 0 !$ 00 : # 3 ! 3"0 !# 3 #3 &3 &0 !70!! ! &# 3#% 3 #: 0 0 3#0 0 4

)+,-,)(..* '(O)*+'

< )*E()(..,30(-#(..,R )O+*)(..+30-3#5(..+R/$ &3#9=!0&M!$&#($(..($ /+/-/,/,/ +*D'+-+R / ;/ 1; $ ; ]H ;9 = !!"# &0H0"3;95N$ $,:#3&$^0 +DDO$/-.>/ A 370!70&3!3#%3&L94&#3 "04"!3&!/ %03!A!+!(3!!& ! "%& 30 (. #5 +DO+ < V * +>$ ! G !0 3 9 !&33&&"!&03! &3!030(+ 3#5 +D*B < ' ; *++/>$ &0 % 3 4& %0 ! !"!0&!6!A!(-/

!70!&%&##090$9Q'&0 !9&#3A0#!"!"/;!&370A&# 0$!A3#&3&90%3%93A0!3! !& < / ; $ 3 3& 3#9$ %&!/ ($ 0 C!$ +DO-$ /E-E'

E-OR / 30 (. #5 +DD-> ?&0 3A0 !" &0%& 3A& &09!"0#3< )(-,)+DDD30(B%!+DDDR/30(.#5 +DD-R" /30O#5+DD(>/?03&3!070A 3A4:< )+*+)+DDB30+O9%+DDB>/ 9$!F#33&! 3!&&&!< )--*)+DDB30,&Q+DDB>/

(O/ A0& 70 && 0 #0 3#% G ! : 3A0 &3&9!&3:"!&06!A!EO !&700 &0 !00 $ ! #L# 3# &0 !00 & < @ +(( +O('+O-R+(+(,+(.5,B',OR @+DDB/+..'+.*R )(-,)+DDD30 (B %! +DDDR )+B+)+DDO 30 (- # +DDO>/ ;!& 3&&$ !A00&0!00#3$!?0"&&00070$ 3& ! #& 3& L &&& 6 ! 0!5! </ EO !/ + >/ !0$!&70A0&&&039&##%3A%& &3#&0009&$!?0"3&94!&3#:6 70!&%&0!0%:#7000!?0"#% &&</EO!/( >/;!A00&0!00#3$!A!EO A!"!33!!5!</EO /+!/( >!?0" A&#70!&3!94&3!A#3%03!E*-O 99(!+ </_ ;$33&!"!$(:#3/$ (..+$/+BE$8++(E>/

990!%04!"04&!03&35!63 &3&3!&G006!!##4#!0&!!&94 3!F0&&3&0$!&0&%0043&&3! 3! /!F070!3F0#33#%6& &70/

(D/ &9&##043&&$!#4#0#3!F#33 1@ (.A.../' !&70 ! %04 !"04 & &9&# 04 &

)+,-,)(..* '(D)*+'

!"!/ F0& ! #4#0# 0 F 43 &&0%&3F&/

!F:$ ! %04 !"04 & 9!# 0&/ &! 3 #394! &0! !"04F!:%6 1@(BA.../'/ 70F!!3!#&#4#0##&!!&$!F#3%&!3& !3!!"!3&L30/

*./ 6 3# 70! #& &9&# 04 ! '

30/

!A:$ ! G !0 3A990 0 & 3A#5! 3 90 &##!&0/

5?%#$30&3%0303&3!&0&$!&0F &0 6 !F%!& 30 5C#$ F 0"# &0 3#0 09 55!/ % $!350!:""0&%&"!&5! 3 " !"04/ 9 70 # !0 ! 3 (O #5 4$ ! #&39 3!# ! 0& !&% 30 5C#/ 9$!P03!&G006040&!!&$&00#& &! 3 1@DAE../')/ ; 90 3& 3& L 70!9 &5?%# 3 #&G#"%/

;0 ! ! 05?9$ ! &0 %&! &5!"& 3 #: &!!/ ! F 3F99 0 # &0% &0 ! !&/ ! F 0 &# 3F00 3 3& ! / !" ! &3 3FL ! $ ! &0 %04 ?070F6 ! #$ 0&&/!940!!#!&G$3!3#&30 :7030&&0!3F&50 3&%3#!&&!3#/ 9$!F 33&&&90&3&0!%04$!F!&9 &0 ! 0& 3 !F##05!$ &#!70 ! &30 3 94& 3 !&G/ ; 90 3& 05?%# "%$ # ! &0$ 70 #5! F%&?#&3#0%$F3%/

0 %0 3 70 :3$ ! #3 !"0 & 0! 0 #30703 1@+,A.../'94$70&#3!0!5!30 &0 3 & 03 0!:# 00 3 3& 03#0!!&&0#`0%!&5?93FL 05!70F!!&00/

*+/ 9$!"93%&!&303&3FL300L0$! &0G"0!:#9&#!F0&703&!! L & !0/ 9& 30 3 ! 3 3 399 &30 70 "" & !0$ ! F 3 0!5!/ !

)+,-,)(..* '*.)*+'

F 4# 6 3 : &#50 0 &0 ! 9 3F0& 70 0&!0<9&6! 6! >/

*(/ &0 & !!# 3#/ 3$ &# 0 3 #&9 3F3#& 3 &0$ 0 #&!0# 3 1@(A.../'$ # 6 ! "30&0/&0!#L##&9$!FG!03!0&30 3# 3 &30/ 9$ ! 9 3 &30$ 1@ (,./'$ & "!##6 "/

/ 70F! 0&#5$ ! &3# 0 # 3F0 #&!0#$ !F!!"! & G &%&70 ! 0#0! 3 !00 3&70&033!#/

*-/ 50! 3 !! 9 0 70$ !& 0 ?003&$!3&00L6!&30F 6L9&#3!F03!!' < )D++)(..-30(*&%#5(..-R )BDE)(..*30+B?0(..*>/

. - B1>$A#9

3!%5!!&0?!++&%#5(..($+D#(..*$((&Q (..*+.#(..,&01/2222222222&!3&303# 3!A#"#$3!A70#30!&"#3D&&5(..($+B9%(..* (-?0!!(..*3!&##&&!3&0#:3&0& 30(O?%(..,R

<$2181#A# 9

&&!?&&308 )+.(-)(..($ )-+B)(..*$ )+,-,)(..*$ ),E+)(.., &0830 )+.(-)(..(R > 9

3#!!#!&0R

&9#!3&303#3!A#"#$3!A70#30!&"# 30D&&5(..(R

0!!3&303#3!A#"#$3!A70#30!&"# 3 +B 9% (..* (- ?0!! (..*$ 70 !! 3 ! &##& &! 3 &0 #: 3 &0& 30 (O ?% (.., 70F!! 9!"

)+,-,)(..* '*+)*+'

%# 6 &0 1/2222222222 0 #3 3 1@ +,F.../'$ 3 1@ BA.../'3 1@,A.../'R

9!"6&01/22222222220#33A0#&&!3 1@+,A.../'R

?!&0&0!0!0R

#6! "3&01/22222222220#&!0#3 1@(F.../'R

370F!F!!&03F3#R

#!93!&30$ 1@(,./'$6! "3&01/2222222222R

&##070!L6 !"#$%&30&0$70A0 3# 3 !A#"#$ 3 !A70# 30 !&"# 6 ! &##& &!3&0#:3&0&/

;"= /G :$3$/ !$#0&3$?0"$/ &!!& !!"$?0"0!/

0&#30 50!3#9=

!"99:'?0= !3= /!03&';" @/G :

&&9&#3L&##07004/

:%$! !"99:=

)+,-,)(..*

Statutory Interpretation of Transaction Classification and Taxation

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet