Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/448/2006 • CJ GE ATA/448/2006 Généré par l'IA

Contractual Breach and Defective Performance Dispute

Numéro de cause ATA/448/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute over contractual obligations where one party failed to make full payment due to alleged deficiencies in the completed work, leading to litigation over the remaining balance and related claims. The court reasoned that the contractual specifications and performance standards were not met, justifying the withholding of payment for the defective portions of the work, ultimately determining the extent of the breach and awarding damages to the non-breaching party based on the contract's terms and the actual value of the work performed.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 68 al. 1 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Breach and Defective Performance Dispute: The court reasoned that the contractual specifications and performance standards were not met, justifying the withholding of payment for the defective portions of the work, ultimately determining the extent of the breach and awarding damages to the non-breaching party based on the contract's terms and the actual value of the work performed.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
inexécution d'une obligation contractuelle versement de dommages-intérêts valeur litigieuse défaut de la chose qualification du contrat partie au contrat

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 68 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to rule on costs associated with the successful party's appeal.
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to order the unsuccessful party to pay the costs of the appeal.
Généré par l'IA
A/2303/2003
Contract Breach and Performance Dispute
A/2933/2006
Contract Breach and Performance Deficiencies
A/277/2005
Contractual Breach and Interpretation of Performance Obligations
A/1781/2002
Contractual Breach and Performance Dispute
A/1661/2003
Contractual Breach and Damages Award

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 68 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on costs associated with the successful party's appeal.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to order the unsuccessful party to pay the costs of the appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

       

 

       









 ! ! " #$  !"##$ $%&$    $    %&'()'*+,- !  !'"()""*+,%&$        ! !! ! .! !         "/ !!  !   !  ! ! 0  # ! ! 1    



     (-./-(

! 

/4  !$"!")5"  ++,$++ "6 &$764

-4    ) "8/3&"/111%!4" 8"$-39% :";%)+") %"#$6"$$++ "67 <"(=>$++?4@:320-+-% ,$  A A "" 8   #$ ,$"4 $  $ 8"" "$%  @ " ,B "C@D "$@&"")66"$-E+-4

E4  !4"  " :$+ "$=$8"" "$  F+"8"@ $" "$$ "4

   )6  ""   $ +  +$":"4  $ $    "6 $ &$"  $ "4 " & $    "    "  $+ 88"D&)"8"7$   $4--00+-    $ "   8    &  $ (& 4 :"%  $& )+"%,$)8G + " ,% 4

94    +, /111 C + -00-%   +   H+6+ %  H8"+     $6+ % & "  +   $  "$    )$$6"  @":$+ "$ <"(= >   + ?%  $$% C  $+, "%  +"       % $:$++  D  " /-1   "&    $"   $  "$    "  "$ "&  /9 &" /122 <  (  ; 0;?4   +    $  $+ !4 "   "+ "++""  "&4 "$+  $ )""$= ",+""  ":4

;4   /0 :&" -000% !4 "   $""    +  @ $" "$ @D$"   ""=    $ -39% $ " @ + @ $" "$ @),"    & 8" @7 $&" 4 *"   :   + % "   $++""$  $  $  + "=  $  "$ <"(= >  ! ?% !4 "   $ =  ", +""  ":8"F$" @+,$4

34  I -J$K -00-% ",+""  ": "+ +" $!4"   8@" " ""6$  "$+""  "&4 ""+C 'L-0@0004(+$  "8++""  "& " 'L9-@;004("" "+ &4$ % ",+""  ": $:"+""$ "4

J4  !4" $= ",:4

./012.-003 (E./-(

24  I -2+-00E%'  $F $4

  $-39 " 6+ "$  ","$6" "$ "   $  "$  :$I     $ @4    I "   C &"      "$+  $  6  &$76   @"+$   +6+ :: !4" " " $, ":" "$4

  $ :$"% @6+       "$+  <$  :"D?  $+,::"  $%$86&$76""  +  &" $:$+ C  " "$%  "   $ "$   $"  :46&$76$ " " $ 7$ "$$   ,$" ":"8 &"  6+  I   ":" 4  $8 %  @+6+ &" &$"#$ ++ $"% 8"" &"""C6$$ "$4

  "$ D ":: + +""  "&$$    +   "  $ )4   "  = $ C    $"     $& ""$ :" 8  "  $& $    "4 $8& &""& :+""!4" &"  +$"I "$" "$4 ) %" " "$&" I  :"     $  "$ " C !4 "    C  :+"    $ " + "C@),"  "$4

14   /3 +" -00E%   $"  $   $" +$":"   "+"   #$ " $"$++$"D< "$@#$9::  C @),"  "$  :$"    6  &$76   @ #$  ,$"   :$I  " "" A"=A?  @ "" ,"8" "$ 8"+ "C@+6+  #$<$"$22E3?4

/04  $"//F"-00E% $"@  )6 +  $$ C !4 "   $ C  "$ @ : 8@" &"  ++ 6$$ "":"6++""  "& 'L2@0004(4

  !4"  " 6+ "&" C+$" C"+:$% "  10 F$%  $  "$   8  &% $:$++  C @I   ", :  -E + -00E < I   ", : / 4-0;.-00--2+-00E?4 $ %=+"C"$" "$@   =& @ ++  $"% !4 "     :+" &"  8"  :"" "&+    $ -39   &   30 F$  "= "  "$8"@7 $&" 4

//4   /2 + -00;% !4 "   8"   +  H $" "$  $$ ",)+ @D& &" $-39%6" $  -9@;E-(J4

./012.-003 (9./-(

   ,)+  $" "    7    @ "+=   -0  "+=  1-+= $6% $AA%$ F$"$ D"  $6$  $4

/-4   $" "  D  &$"" 8 &"  +   ,)+ $"$ @D$  %E0+-00;%  "&+ -EF"-00;%6" "$:$$   8$++ $"6+ $F 4

/E4  I E/+"-00;% ",:F $" $$ C$"$22E34

/94  $  @D+  $"   -9@;E-(J%  &" "&  $    "&>

  (6 ":$++-3&"-00;M

  (:&$,&"" %," E0+-00;M

  (:&$,&" $":" "$@E/+"-00;M

  (:&$,&"@6" /J$K -00;4$-39  "  $"$++:@$+ 4!4" @ " 6" 4 $  "$@,)+ @D@ " "C@D$"  "$ 6"$ @&" =$$$:$+C#$M

  (:&$,$++""$+$+ %  " -- F"-00;M

  (:&$,&":$I %$  "$  76 <"(=>*L?/1$ $,-00;%$& $ :$"8" "$  &D @"   $ $8  F ":"    $  "$ "6  +"= """      8 "$ 8" &"  A $&  &$ "$ 6"$ = 8@   $ "$ $ I  $::  D 6  &$76A4

/;4   /0 $&+, -00;%   +   "& @ $" "$  $ "  -9;E-(J4

   " "$  ,)+  @ "   $" 8@C "  $&"$"    $&"     I  "&$8 $ F ":"  +6+  """  "4 D("&" I "+" G 8 ""=C$"D$" I +"C"$" "$6 &$764 @ $" "$  "   $8  D "$   &"  $  $,F ":"@&" "  "$@"," " ,$!4"   :+"4

./012.-003 (;./-(

/34   $" @    )6   +   ":$+  /0 $&+, -00;  $++ 8 @"  "$  ,)+  @D  &"     $"C " + $&"$"4

   ""$  "  F ":"  6  "$  D "$  "&C$-39"8@"@6"" @&" "  "$@","  " , $ !4 "     :+"4 @ $" "$ "&  $&"    I  $+" $++ &"     $  "$ "6 """ +     8" &"   $& $    +" = 8  ""=C$"D$" ""6&$764   6% + :"" "&":&$,$&*L /1$ $,-00;%  "8&8$ " &":""   "" 6 @ $" "$"&4

/J4  @ $" "$  $ " :"" "&    ,"   L   /3 $&+,-00;4

/24     $  /- +, -00;%  $++  $ =   ! 4 $ C@ "$@ $" "$  -9;E-(J4

   ""  6"     $$ "$"  @&"      4 '$ #$ C ,B "%  $  "$ @ "   $"% $ &  $6 "$ &  +"= D) "& D  " -9   "&    $" :  @+6+   " $"  -- F" /1J1 <  ( * J00?    @ "-J$"@" "$$":@+6+  " $" 9F"/12J< (/E0?4%,)+ +""$"  D$" "$$6 $"  $" :8 $4 $ %$ H6  ""  $$ "$" %  $ "$ +    "&   +$"% $++ @ "" "$  +""(  "$ @ "$ +$," $  N  )"+"8% "  K I  :  $+   $   D 4  ""$  " "8"   " @D$"  "$ "6   $-394

/14   /- +, -00;%  $++  +  $" @   $&+   C  I    +   $"  ""$  " $+I++$ ":8D"&$8C@"$$4

-04   $"@   $6 "&C $++  E F&"-0034

   ""$  "  "  +"     $++  "  "&"  C  :D+$ ":$ $"$/0$&+, -00;4

./012.-003 (3./-(

-/4  !4 "  @   +"     /3 F&" -00;4  $  ,+ C&@:: ": ""+ C@"&,""  $%,"""+ C$F 4

   $++ @&"    8"  $ $"4    @ "   ",  @= "8  ""$  " $"  " +   A@ $" "$ @$A   $ -39% "&   $" @    )6   +   // F" -00E4   + $O !4 "  &"     $"C&"&$ "F8@C8""=C$"D$"  I  C @""% "  "  6" "+ 8@" " 6+  $ C @"  "$ " "$:$+" &+""+D"6$" $  "$4

--4   "$    !  /J:&"-0034

 4 $++$&" &$""  "$ 4*"  @$$"  C  " "$%   &$7"   $   $,F "$ C  $  "$@:$ "84

 ,4    + $:"+8@+6+  " "=C$"D:"" @$,F @@::  "$F$@)"  :$4@  "$" 6+ @$" @D$" "$@)7$ )=$O $   +) @,$ ""   &  $" "     "4  $  %  " "$   +6+  &"  I   "  + -00J   4   C   "$  $& :$  "8% " F$@)"" " C=&4

 4 !4 "   "    :"  8 @ $" "$  "  " &"    $8@C " $&"$"4$&" C $6 "C $++ 8  C  +"       %    $  " "   $ $$F "=C$"D4&"6 "$% $  " : % &"&"  C  F$   4  $+   $  @D   "   $8  "",4  $K  @  $  "$ @&"  C 'L E0@0004( $ 8 @"& "+  $  $  "$@:$ "8&$"""  'L9;@0004(%&$" 'L;0@0004(4 $","" @"  $" )"+"8&" @$ FC &"6 +"   +  @&"   "&   $" "$ " C   :: 4   C   @ :$  "8 D ,$   A A% " @ " D8@"&$""": 8" @4

-E4   ""$  -J :&" -003%  !   & @::  ":  $+ "8 )$ @F 4

  $  "$" "6" " $&"$"@ "E"J 4 $-39&" I & 8"+ "+" G 8  "   "= C $"D "  +" C  "$" "$  6 

./012.-003 (J./-(

&$764$" "$% + &" "8$ + @ " -J      ,  %  ,)+  @ " "$ @D  "   @= $++    "+$    " "$4  )$"D   $  "$ @ $+  &"   @$$ "    )"  ""  $&$"$6" "$@ $" $4

-94   $-J+-003%$++$= ", +""  ":4 $ C@ "$""$ ! P/3 + -003% C   "  "$  @::  ": "" 8@ &$"  $"   +  $ "  "$ $++ " @6"  @&  +   "&@"+" "$D4

  @ $" "$ 8   :$"    , 6 &,4  $  "$$&" I $"$++"+$ " "$   @ " -J     8@  $&"  @7  @I   ", :  -2 + -00E4  ""  $$ "$"     ,""" @&"   "8$ "$  "&%$++ @"  "$@+""(  "$@ "$+$,"$:$ "8%@&"    "4$@"&  ! %!4" &" +":  "+ $+8&$$ C8" 4+$+ $O " " 8"%"H+I)" @D$" $++ "C,B "4

-;4  @" "+@  +" E&"-0034$ ,+  +" "   &  @::  ":% ""+  C @"&,""   $ ,"""+ F "("4

  *$"$ +$ ": " +I+8D&$&  ! 4

-34   9 &" -003%   +  @  $$ C   "  "$  @::  ":4

-J4  "  ",+""  ":F + "  "$ @:: ":%""$J&"-0034

   $ "   "$   ""=   @= 8  +6+ " " " $&"$" "$&" D6 &$76"  "$@"," " ,%8"$ " " " I ,"   "& "+$   F ":" %  6  @ " 33 " -   $"   $ +""  "&  /-  +, /12; <  (  ; /0?% 8 @::  ":$"  " 4

-24    +  @   +"   :$  -2 &" -0034  $   F $ C$:"+ "$""$ ! 4

./012.-003 (2./-(

  :"" "@6+  "$&$ ! ""$  "4

-14  /9F"-003%F66" + ""  "$$8"&"  $ "$  "&&"6C $  "$H,)+ D4

E04   // F"  -003%  "   $+"  H  ""8 8  /0 F"  -003%  "   &" H "       &"      " )$"8&!4" 4

 4    "  8 "  C  ""$   ! %   & H$  $" "&$""% &D+" ": 6$ &"  "M" " 8;0+= C$$F$"  $    $   $%  8" "  :"  = 8  )+   $& $91" +$"$4

 ,4 &"&" &":&$,+ $+ D $ ,"%" "$ "3;C3J$" $ D;F" /13/< (-(0;?4

  " 8  $6   " "$  $+   "  ":" C E00+= %""  $",$6C $,"6 "$&H " 3J " /  %  6  8 (" H "   $$   "$  $  =$&"$"4

   "  $ : "  "  "$ H "$ +$(,"$$6"8 6 "      $+  F % $++   "  D"6 $8  " $+ CH6$ ," " "CE00+= 4

   + H " H=:&$,C $ "$>

 ("$$$K % ""=+ &%H % "$:" 8  "  "$6 ""  $+F M$%  " ,$8" ,"$$6"8 $ " +F  HD$+ " 7:$ "$+ H"  "$4

 4  :$  "8 & F  "    $ H H "    $"    $  =&4   :$ "  "&" ,+   "+  6 ":   8"  ,"$$6"8    %  8" H "   +"",$" &$  "$D4

 4  :$  "8 "&" H ":"  "$  H::  H "   & 6 &"6,%  &"  6$$6" 7  ""8 8  $($     "  $ "  H +$" "+$$(6" =  +,%  :&$,CH":"  "$4

./012.-003 (1./-(

    $    "   ,$ H $ H%   $ "$$&" I  4

  H"  "$  N  )"+"8  + "    "   D $&   $)%  "" $  +)" C &% 8" :"""  " + "4

 4 :"%:$ )$+ $$  $ " D  H "   8  $ >  +"   &"6 6"=  :: +"$$F $   "$H "$%8"  Q" :""$$ "$4

E/4  /9F" -003% + $"68H&+ " %  ""$ 8H" &"  "  "  ,"     D "$ %    $" &H::""8"$K 64

E-4   $+  $    +" D  "4 (" $    "&"  C   +" C  F  H""  E/ F"  -003M =    %   "  6CF64

EE4   "H$H$,& "$"" 4

E94  *8$"% 6CF64

 

/4   F   +  " &   F"" "$ $+  %  $   &,< 4;3 $"@$6" "$F"""--$&+,/19/( ( -0;M 43E4/ 4$"$+""  "&/-  +,/12;( ( ;/0?4

-4   $++  8"  $ $" $   "&  @ $" "$ $C@" "+%$:$++ C@ "/9;"-%/=) 4

E4 4 *$ H " / " /     %    %  $   " $"   $%7&$"  $"%& $ $ "$  "$$ "  "$4

 ,4 $  "$$"  "$%$  $ )$"++$,""=$ +$,""= ":" ( $ ($  $ "" 8 $    " " 6  $"< 4/4/=6+ @" "$$" $  "$ "  "$"&-J:&"/1J2(  (;0;0/?4

   @$% !4 "  % C F  " % 8"   +    $" "$$$ "$+ $ D4

./012.-003 (/0./-(

94    ," $$  8$  "$,)+ @D @ $:$+C#$6"$%!4" @  6" 4@"% @ $" "$ "& + "$ D+  8@" @6"  @  $" "$ $6 $"@ "-J 4

;4  $I -2+-00E% ",:$+  $   $  "$ "6 """ +   !4 "   $ :$4     $  $"    +"$"   6  &$76 "  &"& $ " "$ "&" $8 $"  $C  + " :" 8  " $"  +" C "$" "$  D(" , 4

  '  $$++D $"  $@D $I   +"= "::" H6"  H    $  "$ " C @),"  "$  % H   %    ":"   $ " $  +"4

   $"  $$ "C "F$ "$4""$// F" -00E% !4 "     $++  +$"    "+  $  "$ "6 """ +     C @D "$   " C $ $6+ 4 "=&$ +$"I &"30F$ C "+$+ $O@  =&+ C"$" "$++   ""=C$"D4

  =$8!4"  :+"$  $"C&"&$&"$"+  $-39%$  "$@" "$$&D   " $ 6 "  $" "$ @)76"= + "     "$ +$"4  @6"    ":"  "+ ": @" I  ,"   "& "+$  4

  $ % " I ,"$"&$ @7$$ @$4" I $++$ &"8@ $" "$ $ "    $ C "  +$"   $ $" "$4 @"  "$ " "$" :: I &:$=8 ""=C $"D $  "$",4    6%          " "$% "+  +$ ,% $"  +   :""   +"     "   4  $  "$  ,)+  @D   )  6+  C  " I "&"8$" ":$&$""$ @$  FC$$D &D& I :: 4

  $8 %$6 "$F ":""+ @=4

34  $++$)C@ $" " "+&$"D+"$F  " "6"D $ @6   $$ "$"      ,"""     @I 

./012.-003 (//./-(

$  $  88 "$@$$ " )" C$$&$" $6" "$4

    $  8F"" "$+""  "&$ $+   $"@$$ " ""$ 8%:D "$& $"< 43/4/ - ?4

   $++8"  &$"$" + $"  "$ $++ "% $    @&  +   "& @"+" "$  D4

  D" "$ ":$"$,$+"H $$"//F" -003+  $"8 +   " "+     $",""  D"  4 (" $      $"$$K  .$H::"" 4

   Q  "" 8  &D  $" (  " 8H "=+  "  H" & ( $ "    $ "$   8      $$ "$6"$ H=2

J4  !:$%$$F 4

24   +$+   'L /@0004(  +" C  )6   $++4     $ H"+"   $ C ! " % :   $"$ D"" < 42J ?4

 RRRRR 

/ !  !       

3-4)5(6

 &,  $ " F   -J + -003    $++  "67 $ ""$$++""$ $$+ "=$  "$ -J:&"-003M

4%6

F M

+ C)6$ +$+  'L/@0004(M

./012.-003 (/-./-(

" 8H"H $H"+" $C!$"!")5" M

"  8% $:$++  D  " 1J   "&    $" : @$6" "$ F"""% I  I $ %&$"$$" +""  ":%    F$ =  $ ":" "$%  &   ", :M  ++$"  $$" ""8$"$%+$ ": +$7& $ "6  $ $$+ "M"$" I  $"D+"+$" ", :% /000  /9M    I     "=  $"$  $ %"&$8$+++$7&%$"& I F$" C@&$"M

$++"8    I  C ! " ##$ $% &$    $ % C !'"()"" *+,% &$   !$" !")5 " % C  $++""$  $  $  + "=  $  "$ "" 8H  +   $  "$  )$$6"@":$+ "$4

*"6 > !+$&7%" %!47)=%!+'"%!4 )"%!+$% F64

$+ ",+""  ":>

6::"=(F" F4>  &"(" >     !4 $$" 4$&7  

$"$:$+ I  $++"8D "4

 =&%  6::"=>           

./012.-003