Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/201/2005 • CJ GE ATA/201/2005 Généré par l'IA

Traffic Stop Legality Based on Officer's View of Alleged Lane Violation

Numéro de cause ATA/201/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant challenged the denial of a motion to suppress evidence seized following a traffic stop, arguing the stop was unlawful because the officer lacked reasonable suspicion to believe a traffic infraction occurred, as the alleged infraction involved the observation of movement between lanes that the officer could not clearly perceive from their vantage point. The court reasoned that the officer's observation, based on their position and the visual constraints encountered, provided a reasonable basis to suspect a traffic violation had occurred, thereby establishing the necessary reasonable suspicion to initiate the stop, which justified the seizure of evidence found thereafter.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

IMPOT; BENEFICE; BILAN COMMERCIAL; COMPTABILITE; SOCIETE IMMOBILIERE | L'imposition du bénéfice des personnes morales repose sur le bénéfice tel qu'il découle du compte de pertes et profits établi selon les règles du droit commercial. Le bilan commercial est donc déterminant également en droit fiscal. Dès que le bilan est définitif, l'entreprise est limitée dans les changements qu'elle entend lui apporter. Distinction entre corrections et modifications de la comptabilité, les premières pouvant être effectuées par le contribuable jusqu'à l'entrée en force de la taxation alors que les deuxièmes ne sont possibles que jusqu'au moment où le bilan est porté à la connaissance des autorités fiscales. Ces principes valent également pour les sociétés immobilières qui sont soumises aux mêmes principes de comptabilité que toutes les autres sociétés anonymes. | LIFD.58 al.1 litt.a; LIPM.11; LIPM.12A

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
violation des règles de la circulation séquestre de moyens de preuve appréhension acte d'usurpation ou de trouble exception d'inconstitutionnalité intention délictueuse

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision is cited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/159/2007
Vehicle Stop Based on Anonymous Tip Validated by Independent Traffic Violation Observation
A/617/2007
State v. [Defendant Name/Case Number] Regarding Admissibility of Evidence from Lawful Stop and Search
A/1476/2006
Vehicle Equipment Violation and Fourth Amendment Stop
A/534/2006
Police Officer Traffic Infraction Appeal Rejection
P/562/2020
Traffic Violation Appeals Upheld Against Claims of Officer Misconduct

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

  

     

 







     !  "#$% %&"# '###

" 

      !! !  !  " !# $% 





      !   ! 





     ()*+,(

!  

+%  . /"0  '# &  $%%  1#" 22222222223#(45  $%%&  " #66"" 7 # "# #/8## 2222222222& 91#22222222220# # "" #"##0%

  $"0 #"#8" #8&#/:# /8#;<-1) #+,=<>+1)6"%

 ?#'#+@@>

)%   "1 "'#    A+16+@@>&B"# C #" '#+@@>" #66&1 #"# "11#0"# $%% "!/1"   DEAF,=,,,%(%

  "1   /  ## #"  / #"#  DE -<>=>-,%( ? 9:$%%0#/8# C DE<+;=F+-&FF&6'#/?#/  8C DE)+=))F&-F%

A%  6" #'# #' ? #"+A16+@@@&/1##  #" '#  " 3#(45 / E 7  '#? /#1G   "   "11 3 7 +@@>C DE;;=+-;&+,%

  / E  /  6   6'# #1"6  DE +F+=))F%(& 0# ""#  C  #  DE +A,=,,,%(   "! 3 # & 8 " #870/ E  #1C DE-<,=,,,%(%

-%    1 #"  )+ 16 +@@@&  " #66  "    8 " #8    / E   ?#0  0  "!  DE AF,=,,,%( # "1 H"6B #81 "#6"# #"19I%

F%  )>"816),,+&9#  / E / '# "C? #8#%

;%  $"  "  #  9#    )< B8# ),,)&  8 " #8  '#?C DE-+-/)FF%(&"#C DE-+-=,,,%(%

>%   "#  +- 1 ),,)&  " #66   C / E   "8?6# "1 "'#   1"#'#"+@@>C +@@@&0## "1 "88" #8 DE-+-=,,,%(%

   #1"     B" 0/8#  H'#      '##  ?# "& '#   1# #  "'"1#  8"# I%'# & 1:" #"8" #8&'' 

*++,*),,- (A*+,(

 / E &  6'# #1"6& "  " #66& /8#  C DE)F=+,A&-F%

<%  $ '"        " ? #& / E   1  6'# #1"6 DE+F+=))F%(C DE<F=))F%(&##"+,8#),,)%

  # #0/'"#1# 1#/ "#  ? #"&     '## / " #66  "8#   J  8   "#:#%

   ##" # "1:/6" #'# #'+@@>#  /#1G  DE;;=+-;&+,CF>=A-A&,F%

 ?#'#+@@<

@%  " / '# +@@<&  " #66    6'#  DEA)=@F)%('""! DEAF,=,,,%(%

+,%  6" "8#"## " #'#+>16+@@@%

++%   +< 16 ),,,& / E  #  " #'# " 6"  #'# #'   +@@<%

+)%  $ 1 #"   " #66  +) B8# ),,+&  6'# #1"6    1  DE +;)=@F)%( C DE @;=@F)%(&  ##"  +F 8#),,)% (# # 6" /? #8#)<B8# ),,)%

 ?#'#+@@@

+A%  " / '# +@@@&  " #66 /  :1  '"   "! DEAF,=,,,%("6'##1"6 DEA+=F;A%(

+-%  6""8#"#+@16),,,&/ E  6'# #1"6 DEA)=@F)%(%

+F%  6" #'# #' +@@@+<16),,+&/ E '#? 6'# #1"6 C DE +;)=@F)%(&  0# ""#  C  #  DE+A,=,,,%("!%

+;%  $1 #"@B8#),,)&/ E 16'##1"6C DE@F=F;A%(&##"+,8#),,)&6/? #)<B8# ),,)%





*++,*),,- (-*+,(

 ""8 "11##" "

+>%  >1#),,)&" #66"8 "11##" " "  1 #4 /#1G  3#(45 K7 "   "# ##"  1 #"1 #"%

  6 & # 08" #8 DE-+-=)FF%(&'#? # C/? #""/ E &"# #0 " #81 &" ?#'#?&1#1# 0"1 1"#'#&8"!C / E   "#  +- 1 ),,)& "#  #  "# #"  #   ?1### #1 8 #"'#+@@>C+@@@%

  # "1 1"#'#" # C ## #"/ #"# ?'#:?$%%% '' &#1# #" ## 1   9:  / #"# ##  /    6'# #1"6&  0# 1 #   "1  6"  # /:1  #"  /   " #'  DEAF,=,,,%(C DE-+-=)FF%(%

  "0&"# ##1 C"8 ? #"" +@@> +@@@0## "# #""1 1"#'#%

  $/:#   / '# +@@<&  "  '##  8"# 0  6" ? #""8#"# # 8'## #'&' "/ E # 8"# " #'#  6"  #'# #'   # / %  "#  "C# 6" #'# #'%

+<%  ")- 16),,)&/ E " " /6"0  #'# #"   ? #" +@@< /8#      # / &  "  0/ 1 #    4 '## #'  6" "8#"#  +> 16+@@@%

  # &8# 0" 8# 0/?   / E   #   6 4 " 0/#  #  H"1 & #& 1 9"#0   1 91 #0/819I%

  " &/ E "## 08" #8 DE-+-=,,,%(8#   861 #"# #""'#+@@> +@@@& 1"L" ? #""/ #  1#" / 6#1 " /? #%

  '#& / E   #1#  0  "1 6##  1# ## #1 & / (C(# 8G  #"'#&"8# J 1"#'#8#" H##:# / 6#1 6#I%

  "0&"# C/ #"6" #'# #'+@@< +<16),,, B ""%

*++,*),,- (F*+,(

+@%   "#  +> " "6 ),,)&  "    1# # " "%

  "#:# / 08" #8 DE-+-=)FF%(8#    %

  /  & #1# J "# 1"#'#"1 ?# +@@>   +@@@   1 "L  $%% /?M#    #8#  H'##4& "11# "  I% $  B #'# #' "1 6  "#  0 9:8#&0#/8# 1"!C DE<,,=,,,%(% "#   ""#  C    '' #8    6'# H #   /"1'#0##1"99"'# I%

),%   #  )+ " "6 ),,)&  K  1#  "68 #"   " C/ E 0#/'"110%

)+%   KB "##"+<16),,A%

  4 8"# #  0   #  " # #:#  ? #" +@@>   +@@@ #8?"1 ?# & K0 / "#  '#  '"   6# "11#  0/#       "#  0# J "#::#"# #"'#%  & "1 6##  #@F>  8  #    4 '## #'0#""1 "'#    6#% K  "   # # #" ?#     " #"   1"#'# #"  "1 6## % #4" 9:1 0/ #" C" 6#"8"#/# #"0##"# "11#%   "  "#6 0 B0/ 1"1  "L  6#   "  C  "#   "#  '#    1    C   #  8#   # " #" "1 6    #'# "     'M" C "6 # ? #"'8"6%9:1 """  " #  1"#'# #"&"8# J B %

 ""8  #61##  #'

))%   " "  +; B8# ),,- 4  #6 1##  #'&  " "#C/" /#1G  "+@@> +@@@&## 0/C/" /#1G '# +@@>&+@@< +@@@%  #/:1  #"8"8  K%

  " '# 8"#6 0"1 /$%%"   6#"4:"# "11##0/$%%/?  #8#  "11#% "11 / E   1"#'#  14    "1 & "#   8 " #8   8#&  "   #  '# 1   "#   1"#'#/ 14 '#06'#  "1    "'#  #61 # #01:#"/ E %

*++,*),,- (;*+,(

)A%   "  +<  '8# ),,-& / E   " C /#86##   "#" !  #  C /#1G  ' "   +@@>& +@@<   +@@@&    " 0  "11##"  "  "  /#1G  ' #  /8# "   "6B %

  / E # 0$%%" "# "!1&"1#C  "#  /#1"# #"  " 1" ## 0/? 4:  #6?"# "!11 #4"1 6## % " B "%

)-%     # 9: /# &  ?  # "  #   "#"%

)F%   / # #648)FB8# ),,F0/#116 8" 1"#16 ),,-% '# "8/ /##   " 0(#" ?#'#?+@@>&+@@< +@@@% "0&  :CB:% 

!   

+%   B   1  # 8   B## #" "1  &  "   863 %F; "#=":# #"B###))"816+@-+( ( ),FN %FA%+"#"'#-" "6),,+O E# O  A +>N  % F> C ;F   "#   " 1##  #8  +)  16+@<F( ( F+,&#68"#/ %FA%-E#7%

)%     " #   " # B     "  C /"    ##"   K  +< 16 ),,A& 0# " #  #01 #1G  "? "11?"+@@>&+@@<   +@@@%  "0& "   "#"   "  !  #  C /#1G '# " #86%

A%   6" "8#"# " /#1G   "   "11 +@@<  +> 16+@@@  8'## #'&# #:" #01 "#  " 1"#'#"1 +@@> +@@@%

-% % ."1 &" "# #11"6##43$%%7 8  "  /"'#N#""" 11 C'"1# # "# % :&"0#'#"11 "# " 6 ##"/ #8#  "# ?#81 "##1 C0#&:&?"# "C# #1163 E+,-)F+7% "#  :1 '"1 "# # ?N1 "" #83P% $&"# '# #&)# #"&Q),,)&%),;7%

*++,*),,- (>*+,(

 6% ./#  "# # ?&$%%"# !#1G " 6'# 3"  "1       "'# 7%  6'#   " #  :1 #'' "!M3" 9"#01 7    9: 3# J  #'&   #7%    "  "   "#    #"#*" # 8  $%%&  '# 8#   #81   #   1"  "!?#:1#&"119:#  "3P% $&"%# %%),;7%

   8   0# 4&  "#  #11"6##4 "   "#   # ?&#1""11 " "# # ?6'#&"#  "  "1       "'# % K:   ##  0#   0  "# " " # "!M3" 9"#01 7&"  "1#?#"# #"::# '"1"# 9"##%/#  0/# /!    4:  ##4 #6 C  $%%& " 11  "     "1 6##  "11#%  $%%  #  " /''9#  4:    1 #4 "  ?  0/  "#   #8#  "11#%/:1  #"" # "J   "# %

F%  =#1G    6'#  " "6B   6'#   3 % ++   "#  =#1"# #""1")A 16+@@-(K(A+FN %F>  F< E7% $" = # +)    K   = # F< # +    E&  6'# #1"6 "1   "'# %

  =#1"# #"6'#"1"""6'#  0=# "  "1       "'#   6# "  4:  "#  "11#%  6# "11#   "  1#  :1   "#  '# 3RK:6#9S# #T#R7 3P%  $& "% # %& % +<+& U )7% $"  B#  #6 '&   #0 '# #  '"   6# "11#& 4 " 0=#  8#"   #"# #" #1 #8  "#  "11#      4:  ##4  "#  '#  #8    6'#3 E),,)+A+(+A>&%)&%+AA7%

   4: " # 8   "# '# 8#  C    6# "11# ? ?#:  "#  '#& "  ="6B #'    '  " #66 "   #  " #6 #8%  1  ''   = "#  '# '"1   6# '# 3V% W$    % & #  "#  '##&-41 # #"&),,)&%)+)7% =?# ?6#  '# 0"# "11# "# '#"#8 6 #'' % " 0  "#  "11#   :#   ##  & 0#  C "1"8"#  "9 "8 #  = # ?   8##"  G  #1#   =8#&  "#  '# 99 C ?  "#  =4  8# 6 #  ""1#0 3P% $& "% # %& % +<)& U -7% " '"#& = "#  '#'"6#"11# 0 "# &0/#?1#  &9 &"#::#"# #"'#%  0 

*++,*),,- (<*+,(

? #"6'##1"66#'#&"# 6#"11#  ?"6B #'"# '#3K%  &"61#T6#9 #::& # 9#8"# '##),,)&%F-+7%

;% % 4 0  6#   '## #'& = #   #1#    9:1  0=   # " %  #1#  0# # "  #1" #''4 &  & " 0= "4 C  " #" " C  1"#'# #"   "1 6##  3 E+@>>&A>+(A<A&%A>;7%

  " #"" "6 "'"1"# "11#6# 0#8#"#"# #"#1 #8""6#: #"%1"#'# #""   9:1  0=  # "  C " 6#     "8"# =# #"0##"# "11#3 E+@>>&A>+(A<A&%A>-7%

   " #"  6# 8  J  ''    " #66& 1# 1 B0=C= '" ? #"%" #"" #"#"  "86 0    = "  8##"%  1"#'# #"  6#&  89& "  "#6& B0= 1"1  "L  6#   "  C  "#   "#  '# 3P%  $& "% # %& % +<)& U)7% ##& = #    8#   # " #" "1 6 #01   0=  #:"  #  '#&    #'# "     'M" C "6 #  ? #"'8"63 E+@>>&A>+(A<A&%A<,7%

 6%  4:  #( '"  /"6B  / B# "    #63 *;;@*),,A) 16),,A  *A+-*),,-)F1# ),,-7%

 %  & #  ? 1 #"   "  "   8 " #8   8#& / E   " C  ? # "         1#    #% '# &:#"'"11 C #01 #4/#1"# #" "# &   6#   6# '#%  9:1  "  " #"#   "  "   1"#'# #"  6# 8#  C "6 #  ? #"  '8"61:" #"8" #8"/ E %"  "  /#"# 58"# B #'# #"1#4/:# '# 0$%%// #8# "11#%&# #(0  $%%  6'##   / # 1   ## / "#   8 "1 6& 1# "  "1# ? 4:  #6 " "   "# %  "0&  #"1    "     J  #8#    " "#  J B %

>%   1"1   DE )=,,,%(  1# C  9:   " & 0# "163 %<> 7%"/#1# % XXXXX

*++,*),,- (@*+,(

$  ! & !     

61 " C/1##  #"'# "0/ #6"  #'# #' +@@<N

'()*+,

 86  " # B   +; B8# ),,-   $%%  K#" 2222222222"   ##"   "11##"  "  "  1 #4 =#1G +<16),,A  0/#8##1G  "? "11? "+@@> +@@@N

#86"N

()-,

B N

1 C9:" 1"1  DE)=,,,%(N

"11#0 J C"# '###!  "#$% %&1 #   " &C"11##"  "" 1 #4=#1G ##0/C =1##  #"'# "%

$#: 5 K%!94&# &K1"8!&D#&K% 9#&B:&K%D" #& B: %

"1 #61##  #'5

:''#4(B# 5  # 5       %#"($#:#  E%!94      

*++,*),,- (+,*+,(

"#"'"1 J  "11#0? #%

 48&  :''#45      

*++,*),,-