Contractual Penalty Clause as Liquidated Damages Subject to Judicial Review
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAA contractual clause imposing a penalty for late delivery, even if stipulated under the title of a penalty clause, constitutes a liquidated damages clause if the amount fixed is intended to compensate for the actual prejudice suffered, and the court erred in declaring the forfeiture of this penalty without proving that the amount fixed was manifestly excessive in relation to the prejudice actually sustained, given that the specific nature of the penalty clause prevents the judge from varying the agreed amount unless the parties have expressly reserved the right to do so or the amount is clearly exorbitant.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAContractual Penalty Clause as Liquidated Damages Subject to Judicial Review: A contractual clause imposing a penalty for late delivery, even if stipulated under the title of a penalty clause, constitutes a liquidated damages clause if the amount fixed is intended to compensate for the actual prejudice suffered, and the court erred in declaring the forfeiture of this penalty without proving that the amount fixed was manifestly excessive in relation to the prejudice actually sustained, given that the specific nature of the penalty clause prevents the judge from varying the agreed amount unless the parties have expressly reserved the right to do so or the amount is clearly exorbitant.