ATAS/368/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATAS/368/2005 · Tortious Interference with Contract Affirmation (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute over whether certain actions taken by the defendant constituted tortious interference with a contract or prospective economic advantage, and involved numerous citations to prior rulings regarding the application of the relevant legal standards, particularly concerning intent and foreseeability of harm. The court reasoned that the plaintiff failed to establish the requisite elements for tortious interference because the defendant's conduct, while potentially aggressive, did not meet the high threshold of malicious intent or wrongful means necessary to be actionable, ultimately affirming the judgment in favor of the defendant.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Tortious Interference with Contract Affirmation: The court reasoned that the plaintiff failed to establish the requisite elements for tortious interference because the defendant's conduct, while potentially aggressive, did not meet the high threshold of malicious intent or wrongful means necessary to be actionable, ultimately affirming the judgment in favor of the defendant.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

incitation à violer ou à résilier un contrat antécédents contentieux commercial responsabilité contractuelle clause compromissoire action en constatation

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of costs to the successful parties.

Généré par l'IA

A/4601/2006

Breach of Contract and Tortious Interference Claims Rejected

A/3770/2005

Breach of Contract Dispute Affirmation

A/2536/2006

Contract Breach and Interference Dispute

A/2324/2006

Contract Dispute and Tortious Interference Claims

A/185/2004

Contract Interpretation and Breach of Agreement

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of costs to the successful parties.

Texte complet

&''((&)+ "&(,-&).

"

" /" / /

)0 12 $ ( ).

3333333333 !!"#"$ $ % &&'" &$("""

$

44 / /" 5 /6 ! " " "( &)$*+,-.

! " #$%

52/005

4 "

06 !&( 78888888888 9"5- $ : 0*;0 " " &% "<" <& & " & .&6 ." $(( $ " & ="'-&7>"$(& (?0*@@,&(?2333$" &AB*33<6($"6-0C."2330 "" , " $ D.$"&=E(D6

26 7$<< & &"" =$"' & $"D $& D= &$" $ &$ &(& & "$ & %5"."&" ." %$ $"&% & &10$ $?23306 "&"'F "."$ << "$$ 8888888888&"0*@*6

16 $$ (&",% "$&%<<" $&%5"."&" 9"5- :&$ 8888888888"" G!H="D"-. &(?2330'%"" & ." $ &"03C" 2330& $<"$IC'%$6$ ?"&( "$ "$&$ " ( " 6 $<<&&$I&I?& &"" &%" "$" , " "$67$ & %DD.6($<"$$ "&"'6$ ." % "" "$&&I?5 ("/D=5&$" "($"?&(F('$ & =D& &A JDK $.(F($" "$&$& $D ( &$ $" "$,D$I"$" "$$" <"&($.( &((? " "<"?"&$" ." <$"&6

46 & & %" "$ & &$" % &I I " $ &""D I ")=" "' I "$ =$&"'6

$ $ &%I " & 24 (? 2332 &$ $ 8888888888 ="D" $ =$&"' G!H << $ &%?$& (- $(- & %(? & &$( (&"I <"D &$"6 $ '%-"& &($ $) D"" . "$="D", =."&$" "& .0*@4$ =D&$<"$ $. $ " & ( " & .&6 - 0*@* $?-( I ((?"" $ ?"&"#"&%$ "$6 &"D$ "$$ I&L

5 7 - =$&- $5 " =$&- & =$ & =." &$" M& =$ $5=$N&"&$$6 5 $=) $ "?"$5 " " . &%I "$ & =." &$" . (&D$&$"

/0011/2334 51/005 5 7 - "' " . "$ $ .$( & ?= &" & < " "< & $"D &$" & "?"" $ " $" $$& ,<,(" 5 !&$ E&&I((?"$(=$("$?= 5" ".&<&" 5 7 -&%"$&)D"I&I$&

5 7 - $) $" "$ $5 & < " $& &$" 5 7 -& "&&IE D" 5 7 -&)$." & ."I&I$"D

5 7 - "&"D( $" "&D$D= 5 7=D&$$&$( "( ?" $5"$"D &$" 5 $$"(=$"'. $?& = "' 5 G"?$()D" 5 $ =$<($$5 "?"" &D$&$" 5 &"<D.. ( "&""&" 7%D" & " "& & ." %I "&"' '" " L O& $" & . & ((?L " . 033P & ( " $" "$ &?$ /" =D & & 2 JD ($.( " "< . ((? "6 $" & . )=$$D"'L " & A3P & "." $(( &" "5&6 !&( 78888888888 $.$" ."&A3P(F(& "." & Q6

% "." I C'%"" % $"? & $" & . & ((? "6% &"<.- <"?$()D"(F=&%."D% "." IC',,&A3P6(&& "$$ ."D?6 $ $" F .&&?" ,% &%"($& "$."9<.": .",A3P" && "$6

$ $ &%I " & 22 (" 2331 &$ 8888888888 =< & ""' & )=" " & I HE" I "." " & -. 9%I : -.%?&&".$?C ".("."&& " & $" & ) "(" (" &"("$&% $?& $" . & "D( &% =)"(6 7$ &"D$ " )&$( & &&,%$$ "" "$$ "$?( "'$&"&23 G0362AK " & $" ?$&" & " - $ $? & $" ($ "$( ?".6 ( )=" "' &% &"<& !036"=D ".

/0011/2334 54/005 & $?-( &%$$ $ "$ "" $" ( &%."D ?"" "$ =)("'$%."6 $" &. %I $ , " & ." & A3P =$"'( $ ."D?6 " D"' $ . F (" $( &% $? &$$I$&%"$&&"<. " "'$( "'67$" )=" "'% &$&&,%$$'"$$?-( ( 6 %I " ' $( & %? &% &"< ( " & ." &<"" , A3P $ "$ $( "' F (" (F( I$%I ")=" "'6%I $<"('$$" "$& &$ $8888888888&% .",A3P$(($.&"($ $(("&&?"?"$ =-'?"'I( $"?6

$(( & 13 $ $? 2331 &$ $ 8888888888 "&"' '% ." $$ " & ." & A3P $ & "$ )=$$D"' $$( "'6 " &A3P $<"(&$ 88888888886 %) &% &"< (" $$"( =$"' '" % " =D(&"( 6

A6 7!(R(& &% ?"$ &%I('"<S <" 0A &(? 23316 7$ O " "" , Q " $ &$ & =." &$" " , & =$ & =$ " & $ $=) "?"$5 "6 O< $&"D$ "$"'"$ &$ & % Q" $ <"?$()D"$$"(=$"'6 "" & ." % C "<"&$" &.(&"$5C"&"'6

;6 &""$&23C."2334% C &(&& ($ "<' $ " , "? &% T %"" & ." & % "." =?" "(" "$ <$ "$ $ $ ,% " &=."&$" $( "?. "." &%$ " ="'6

+6 7" ,%$$" "$&$ % &&""$2@."2334 C 6%D( .$'$?-(I("%" "$( C %I "&&$ $8888888888$ %(? & $?( "' (&"6 % $<"( ' "(" "$ <$ "$ . $ $( "? . % "." =?" &%$ " ="'6

@6 $ $ & 24 (" 2334 $ $<<" & &"" =$"' & &I ((? " .$" ?" "# " . "$ ="D" &" 0*@*6 ." &%$ " ="' $ ( "$( "? . )&$(6 7 & <$ "$ - & 7>"$( "($" @=C$& ."$&" 6% "" "$" ".&"5 " $$'&% T& &"" "DU , " "$6%"

/0011/2334 5A/005 8888888888 . ' & ($.( " "< % " $"?6 "&"' .$" $"" & % &%F $(" , I "$'%""F $ % &D "<&)&$(6

I$<"D "$& 8888888888&0+("23346 I"(D&"&.$"<&(& , " (D %(?&&$"(&"'"C "<""" $(- & ." $&" 6 $ D( &"D$ " & && , %$$ & <"?$()D"'%"%C("$6

*6 $ & 2A C" 2334 % $ C & $ .$) $,&""$ '""'%I."(&"I&7!(6

036 $&$&0AC" 2334 "?$&$$( "$$ & " '" % & & 20 (? 23346 $D % $<"( .$" $ ' "(" "$ <$ "$ " $( "? . % "." =?" &%$ " ="'("'%" " I &&"' " "-&=$& $<"$6%$$"(%,F " $( 6$ "'%$." (F(" '$ % " C$6 % $ " "$$<"$(".$" (' "." $" I6

7 '$" "? $&$ %$. & 'F . %&" "$ & 88888888886

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

/0011/2334 5;/005 '%$" .",033P'& "." D-'"$"" " ((?""((?"<"$<$"$(($. &"(I($& "." &( 6

" & &" "$ $,%&" "$&(&"5 " D&,CD6

026"&4$.(?2334$ .'8888888888." ( "$&$I "'& "." & " & ." " &A3P9<6D 0+ 0@& $ :&$ '% &%"&' $-5.?( "$$($ ' 8888888888 &" &%$&." & ."&033P& "." & 6 $" '%"$" &($V(&"5 " &%$&.%I ") " $ & " " & ." & A3P & "." O& Q6

$" (",% A$.(?23346

"

06 $"D.$"%$D" "$C&"""9: ($&"<" " " &- 0$S 2331 "? $&$"$($&ACD &$ "& ."5"& A 0;CD9 60 6 A; :6

7" ,% "$&% "$&0;CD "?<& 2+C."23349 G01303;:& $"D.$"&$ 01<." &"$" "$ " $"D ( "? $& $" & "D , $" CD " " & % & % "$&$.ICD6

26 $<$(( , B 6 A; 6 0 6 =6 2 "? $ & $"$T " "'&$ "$.,% " A; '"$ ".,$"%5"."&" &0*C"0*A*6

7$( $CD&&%- "" ?"6

16 $"<& "D&&$" &$"&;$ $? 23339 : ."D 0 C." 2331 T ($&"<" "$ &$(?&"$" "$D&&$("&$"67 ( "$" &.$"'&$" B"'&$" F =,("- &""$'-D"?$ ."D($( $V <" C"&"'( & (" $ $&" 9 G 02+ 4;+ $"&6 0 02; 01; $"&6 4? <:6 .= '" $ $& ,&< &-D " $"$ "$.&$" B"'

/0011/2334 5+/005 .&-C$&$ ."D9 G00+*1$"&6;?002 1;3 $"&6 4K ! 0@ W 1+ 6 10; $"&6 1?:6 B $'$" $&& 0C."2331$" $&" - & &. "? $ $( ( "- &B $" $ D" $. -D & $& $ & &"$" "$ & $&$ &&"<< $""($&"<" 6

46 $ <$( &".$" $ .?9 6 A;,;3 :6

A6 ' "$ , $& "" & .$" " < & << , C " '"$?( ' "$&" & .""&& $ 6

;6 7$ % 6 4 %"."&" &"(" "$ & " & D" ( ( $ & $D & '" &% " , =)"' $ ( $. &% "<"(" $D" &% (&" $ &% "& 6 % " , % &$ , & (" " $"& "$ ' & ( $V T "" & ." ) &<< " &D"&%9!)5&D #X?&" ."&."=DY"=0+6@:6

7$ % 6 4 6 2 %"."&" . &- '% D." $,$."&$" I "$ $"& "$6 ($( &$" F & ("$?C ".( &%-% & K&< I <$ " %$ &%"($ 6&& """&& , '&(& "&, "&' "$ '" $N"& $ "( . ($( $V %&$("-<$"'% " , $."&$" , & "$&%6

$ % ?"( & <" & F & 04 C" 0 9 G 02A 1A0: "? <& & " C"& ". , %" "$ & . $ (( & &$(" (&"6 $." & ""'$""&"?" "$&.'"%"' " ?" $& &("" ". '% $& & $ & &$" &("" "< 9 6 43 G $ "$ . % 6 0* K 6 *A 6 2 ""$. 6001 012:%&("" "$$CD""?( .F "&-D<$($& ," "$ $(- "D$ & .6 - $ CD &$" I(" & ("- $?C ". $($)&.''%$" $."&"& "&$( ,&"$" "$( &$ CD( .?&$" " "D"I67"$ (&"I$ $ &" $"" =%<<"

/0011/2334 5@/005 "%(?&. "&"'"$$'" <$&$""$(&" $ 6

7 ( "" & "? " "$ & . C"& $ & "D &" " '" $ ("- &%" " )&%I "$&$ (&"I6

"" CD % "" ($ "< "( "< & $"$ &% I " (&" Z= & %I "( & ( $" " , &"$" "$ & C " <" & %" (&"I&% &<" &$6 $ " "$&% & %I " <" ' 5" $ " & $ &" "$ $ '% 5I " $&$ "? "<"( $"$ & ("- $." 6 $ $'&% "" ( &$""$$ " ,( "( &$ "&&& "$&%I $ I $" "$&".D &$"$&&"CD $ ?$" " "$ $(( " $ <$( &% $. I "(&"6

A6 %-( (&"I " '"$." &<$& $ &% %I " & 8888888888 &% %I " )=" "' & 8888888888 <" & "$ & ="D" 8888888888 '%$ &$ (&"I&$" & $&" "$5&. "?&6

"( ,C " .$? &I " '"(" %'% $&" "$<"IC"&6

". & &$( ( "$ $&" , $ "$ ". L " & ." & $ $ ( & $ " "." 6 ." . $(( $ " "" $&" &(F('% ."&( "&.&L &( $ " % '%" $ &"6 $"$$ &<R$ $ ,<" "(&I "$((&%&" "$ & 88888888886

.=")"&$T ,$ " & ." "- & ."& 6 C ('<$($ " &4$.(?2334&$". F 6 << 8888888888&<R$ -" &I<$" " $D' "$&.$""$ $." ." , 033P & ." & ' "$ , ' " $& %<<"( ".6 " <I & &" ' 8888888888 $ &"<<(( 6 $"$ & $ $ . "$" T $ &" $"6 % & $'%$" $I ' "$"$C &" "&& ."'" <"

/0011/2334 5*/005 D0;&$ 6 $((( "$&<" " ,033P& ( " $" "$&?$ /"=D&&2J"$ ($.( " "< . ((? " $ 8888888888'"%<"I,A3P" & ."'%"$&%( )=$$D"'6 &%"$<"(&$$(( &13$ $?2331 &<" 6

%I )=" " & $?)=" "'"."& 6" (F('" & ."% "(" '%"$&$$(( "$& ?$"$$$"'$?( "''"=,% 6 << , & C"& $ $ && $(( B$$"( =($&& $I"$(" && $ " $""."&" &$"6 .=C$E&B5 "."&" $'B $.$' (&" $ "& '" T " , =)"' $ ( " , " & D" $ " 5(F( &B " , =)"' $ ( '" . & (&" 97 0; 6 10+ 123 121K 02 6 0@2 $"&6 2? <:6 $ 8888888888&" &%$&.$"$& 8888888888<"I ,A3P" "&& ."&$ $(F('5" " "(" "$'$&"$)="' &$ $.$" '%$ "I" 6

( " % $"? & " "(" "$ & " & ." $ & "$ )="' . & %I "6 7 ? & %I " & 8888888888 " & ." &$" F <"I , 033P $ '% %I & "." & 6 %&" "$ & 8888888888 $<"(( 6

;6 ' "$&%"."&" $( &" 6

=# "<&D&%"."&" &$" F & ("?&% $("$ & .6 $ . & ." ' %"."& $" $? " IR % "." '%$ "$?( & & " - I "$ . & ( & & "$ $( &% " "$ '""?&(=& ." $(.'%"" $? "%" % " "."&9 62@62 :6$("$&.%<< -DD="<< "I ( '$"?($ &&I . $<$ %.% &"<<( & I &%"."&" 6 ( $V . . F ="<< I ( " &$". F "( &%- ( $ & "" - '$" %$ $( . $I"( ". "" $? 9( =$&D&$("$&.K G02@13$"&60K G03401;$"&62 2?:6

/0011/2334 503/005 '" $ $("$ & . $ & (" $ I" ($( & B$. & &$" , . "" ' ($&"<" "$ . . C'B ($( & &""$ '" $ & $'&$" , 9 G02*222K02@0+4:6

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

+6 %- <$ & $ '% "$ & - $(? "(" "$ <$ "$ & . & =$"I & $<"$ & " %I" && ."$- <<"(=D.$"'" ( , $ & ( , $<" " & ." & C"&( "$67<< % "." &%$.&"( $"?. ( &( $ '%$& $ &=D$&($.( " "<'"T &$ I6< D( '%"$&$?-(,=."&"0*@4$ &C, &S ( ( , $ "." & .& ." & $D =&?$ 6$''""F " %$ $"&% "-6

@6 $ '"$? " D"&&$" ,&&'"$ <"I %-,2B333<6

]]]]]]

/0011/2334 500/005

/ " 4 " /" / /

$

718 9 : 5% ',) ;<

8

06 " '$ .?6

$ 8

26 %&( "( 6

16 .$"&$",% $" "$&$"& $. &""$6

46 $&(% ,.,$ , " &&$((&2%333<6

A6 <$( " & '% . <$( $ $ F & &" & 13 C$ &- $ "<" "$ " $((& & "? <& & 7=>"#=$<'" ; ;334 $" I("6 &" F $$D6 (($" &$" L : "&"' I ( '&""$$ &"$? "" &&""$ 'K ?: I$ $ ' ($ "< " "( $.$" &(& &""$K : $ "D $ & $ 6 7" (($" $ " $" ( ( $ : ?: : "5& "?<&&$ ( "-$'%" &.&".?6(($"&$( "$$($) & . '" $ C$" "" ' &""$ ' %.$ & ' I&"$ 9 601203; 03@:6 D<<"L "& L " 7 ?7

$"$<$(& F $ "<"I """'%,%<<"<& &$"D<<

/0011/2334

Tortious Interference with Contract Affirmation

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet