COMPANIES ACT (RECOGNISED INCORPORATED CELL COMPANIES) REGULATIONS
Table of Provisions (28)
Statutory Text (28 Articles)
SUBSIDIARY LEGISLATION 386.15
COMPANIES ACT (RECOGNISED INCORPORATED
CELL COMPANIES) REGULATIONS
17th April, 2012
LEGAL NOTICE 119 of 2012, as amended by Legal Notice 292 of 2025.
The title of these regulations is the Companies Act (Recognised
Incorporated Cell Companies) Regulations.
(Regulation 3)
Administrative Services which may be carried out
by Recognised Incorporated Cell Companies
A Recognised Incorporated Cell Company shall require recognition in terms of
Article 9A of the Investment Services Act to provide one or more of the following
(i)
Provision of administrative services related to the establishment of
incorporated cells;
(ii) Procurement of external service providers and approval of any changes
thereto;
(iii) Negotiation of service provision agreements and changes thereto;
(iv) Submission of any model agreements to be used by incorporated cells of
a recognised incorporated cell company;
(v) Submission to the competent authority of any changes or amendments to
model agreements and submission of any new model agreements
negotiated with service providers for the approval of the competent
authority;
(vi) Signature of tripartite agreements between service providers, the
recognised incorporated cell company and an incorporated cell based on
the model agreements;
(vii) Standardisation of any other documentation to be used by incorporated
cells;
(viii) Approval and joint signature of any applications for licences (including
variations, extensions thereof) to be submitted by or on behalf of
incorporated cells which are in the course of being formed;
(ix) Provision of written declarations identifying any changes to model
agreements already submitted to the competent authority, including a
NIL declaration confirming that no changes have been made;
(x) Provision of ancillary services as may be approved by the competent
authority.
(1)
In these regulations, unless the context otherwise
requires -
"the Act" means the Companies Act;
"collective investment scheme" shall have the same meaning as
that assigned to the term in article 2 of the Investment Services
Act;
"competent authority" means the Malta Financial Services
Authority established by article 3 of the Malta Financial Services
Authority Act;
"Continuation Regulations" means the Companies Act
(Continuation of Companies) Regulations;
"Financial Services Tribunal" means the Tribunal referred to in
article 21 of the Malta Financial Services Authority Act, and the
term "Tribunal" shall be construed accordingly;
"incorporation agreement" means an agreement setting out the
terms upon which a non-cellular company becomes an incorporated
cell of an incorporated cell company in accordance with the
provisions of regulation 23(5)(a);
"incorporated cell" means, unless otherwise specified, a cell of a
recognised incorporated cell company created in accordance with
the provisions of these regulations and licensed as a collective
investment scheme in terms of article 4 of the Investment Services
Act;
"non-cellular company" means a company which is not an
incorporated cell company, an incorporated cell or a segregated
multi-fund company;
"recognised incorporated cell company" means a limited liability
company formed, continued as, transformed or divided into an
incorporated cell company in accordance with the provisions of
these regulations and recognised by the competent authority in
terms of article 9A of the Investment Services Act;
"relocation agreement" means an agreement setting out the terms
upon which the relocation of an incorporated cell from one
recognised incorporated cell company to another or to a SICAV
incorporated cell company is to take place in accordance with the
provisions of regulation 23;
"segregated multi-fund company" means a multi-fund SICAV
with one or more segregated sub-funds, each treated for all intents
and purposes of law as a patrimony separate from the assets and
liabilities of each other sub-fund of the company in accordance
with the provisions of regulation 9 of the SICAV Regulations;
"SICAV" means an investment company with variable share
capital established under the Act and the SICAV Regulations;
"SICAV incorporated cell company" means an incorporated cell
c o m p a n y e s t a b l i s h e d u n d e r t h e C o m p a n i e s A c t ( S I C AV
Incorporated Cell Companies) Regulations;
"SICAV Regulations" means the Companies Act (Investment
Companies with Variable Share Capital) Regulations.
(2) Words and expressions used in the Act shall, in these
regulations, have the same meaning as in the Act.
(1) A limited liability company may be formed or
constituted as a recognised incorporated cell company to establish
incorporated cells formed and constituted in accordance with these
regulations and to provide such incorporated cells with
administrative services.
(2) A recognised incorporated cell company shall require a
recognition by the competent authority in terms of article 9A of the
Investment Services Act to provide incorporated cells with
administrative services.
(3) The administrative services which a recognised
incorporated cell company may provide to its incorporated cells are
listed in the Schedule, and the recognised incorporated cell
company shall provide such administrative services in accordance
w i th t he ap pl i c a bl e r u l e s an d c o nd i t io n s p re s c ri b e d by t he
competent authority.
(4) An incorporated cell established by
a
recognised
incorporated cell company shall be required to be
(a) in possession of a licence to carry out the activities of
a collective investment scheme in accordance with
article 4 of the Investment Services Act; or
(b) included in the List of Notified AIFs or the List of
Notified PIFs, as the case may be, as defined in, and in
accordance with, the Investment Services Act
(Notified CISs) Regulations.
(5) The competent authority may, in terms of articles 6 and 9A
of the Investment Services Act, issue Investment Services Rules
applicable to recognised incorporated cell companies and to
incorporated cells established under these regulations.
(1) Subject
to
the
provisions
of
the
Continuation
Regulations
(a) a body corporate registered, incorporated or
constituted under the laws of an approved country or
jurisdiction outside Malta, which carries out similar
activities to those of a recognised incorporated cell
company as herein defined, may be continued as a
recognised incorporated cell company in Malta
Provided that if such body corporate as aforesaid has a
cell or cells which are similar in nature to incorporated
cells as herein defined, the continuation of the body
corporate in Malta shall also require the simultaneous
continuation of all such cells as incorporated cells in
Malta;
(b) a body corporate registered, incorporated or
constituted under the laws of an approved country or
jurisdiction outside Malta and carrying on the activity
of a collective investment scheme which is similar in
nature to a cellular or non-cellular company as known
under the laws of Malta, may be continued as an
incorporated cell of a recognised incorporated cell
company;
(c) a recognised incorporated cell company may be
continued as a body corporate similar in nature to a
recognised incorporated cell company as known under
the laws of Malta under the laws of a country outside
Malta
Provided that if such recognised incorporated cell
company has an incorporated cell or incorporated cells
in existence, the continuation of the recognised
incorporated cell company shall require the
simultaneous continuation of all such incorporated
cells under the laws of such country outside Malta; or
(d) an incorporated cell may be continued as a body
corporate under the laws of a country outside Malta.
(2) For the purpose of sub-regulation (1), the expression
"approved country or jurisdiction " means such country or
jurisdiction as may be established from time to time by guidelines
issued by the Registrar of Companies pursuant to the Continuation
Regulations.
No event described in regulation 4 shall take place except
in accordance with the terms and conditions of the prior written
approval of the competent authority which shall only be granted
(a) in the case of a body corporate which is or which is to
be granted recognition as a recognised incorporated
cell company in terms of article 9A of the Investment
Services Act;
(b) in the case of a body corporate which is or which is to
be licensed as an incorporated cell in terms of article 4
of the Investment Services Act as a collective
investment scheme.
The memorandum of a recognised incorporated cell
company shall, in addition to the matters prescribed by article 69 of
the Act, state that it is a recognised incorporated cell company.
The name of a recognised incorporated cell company shall,
in addition to compliance with the provisions of article 70 of the
Act, include the expression "Recognised Incorporated Cell
Company" or its abbreviation "RICC".
(1) Subject to the provisions of these regulations, and
unless the context otherwise requires, the provisions of the Act
shall apply to a recognised incorporated cell company and to an
incorporated cell established under these regulations.
(2) In so far as the provisions of the Act are inconsistent with
the provisions of the Investment Services Act or these regulations,
the provisions of the Investment Services Act and of these
regulations shall prevail and the provisions of the Act shall, to the
extent of the inconsistency, not apply to a recognised incorporated
cell company or to an incorporated cell.
(1) A recognised incorporated cell company may establish
an incorporated cell by virtue of a resolution of the board of
directors (the "cell resolution") which
(a) approves the name of the incorporated cell being
established;
(b) approves the terms of the memorandum and articles of
association of the incorporated cell and resolves that
the said memorandum and articles of association are to
be entered into by the recognised incorporated cell
company; and
(c) authorises, if applicable, the subscription by the
recognised incorporated cell company of a share or
shares in the incorporated cell.
(2) An incorporated cell shall not be validly constituted unless
a copy of the cell resolution is delivered to the Registrar, the
memorandum and articles of association are entered into in
accordance with the provisions of sub-regulation (3) and a
certificate of registration is issued in terms of the Act.
(3) The memorandum and articles of association of an
incorporated cell shall be entered into by
(a) the recognised incorporated cell company, whether the
recognised incorporated cell company is subscribing to
a share or shares in the incorporated cell or not; and
(b) such persons, other than the recognised incorporated
cell company, subscribing to shares in the incorporated
cell.
(4) The memorandum of association of an incorporated cell
shall state that it is an incorporated cell.
(5) The memorandum or articles of association of an
incorporated cell shall provide that the incorporated cell may not
own shares in its recognised incorporated cell company.
(6) Without prejudice to article 110 of the Act and unless
expressly prohibited by any applicable rules or regulations or by its
articles of association, an incorporated cell shall be permitted to
own shares in any other incorporated cell of its recognised
incorporated cell company subject to any conditions that may apply
in terms of the licence issued to it by the competent authority.
Without prejudice and in addition to compliance with the
provisions of article 70 of the Act, the name of an incorporated
cell
(a) shall include the expression "Incorporated Cell" or the
abbreviation "IC"; and
(b) may be similar to that of the recognised incorporated
cell company of which it forms part but shall not be so
similar as, in the opinion of the Registrar, could create
confusion.
(1) An incorporated cell is a limited liability company
with separate legal personality.
(2) An incorporated cell is not a subsidiary of its recognised
incorporated cell company solely by virtue of the fact of it being an
incorporated cell of its recognised incorporated cell company.
(3) An incorporated cell may not itself be a recognised
incorporated cell company.
(4) An incorporated cell may be a SICAV or an investment
company with fixed share capital.
(5) An incorporated cell shall have the same registered office
as its recognised incorporated cell company at all times.
(6) Subject to the requirements of Directive 2003/71/EC on the
prospectus to be published when securities are offered to the public
or admitted to trading and of Directive 2004/109/EC on the
harmonisation of transparency requirements in relation to
information about issuers whose securities are admitted to trading
on a regulated market, as may be amended from time to time, an
incorporated cell shall use the standard form documents provided
by its recognised incorporated cell company and shall not amend or
alter such documents in any manner without the prior written
approval of the recognised incorporated cell company
Provided that nothing stated in this sub-regulation shall
prejudice the rights and interests of investors in the incorporated
cell or affect the relationship between the incorporated cell and its
investors.
(7) Without prejudice to the requirements of article 6 of the
Act, a recognised incorporated cell company and an incorporated
cell shall also indicate in a suitable manner in all of their business
letters and forms that they are a recognised incorporated cell
company or an incorporated cell, as applicable.
(1) It shall be the duty of the directors of a recognised
incorporated cell company and of the directors of each incorporated
cell, as applicable
(a) to keep the assets and liabilities of the recognised
incorporated cell company separate and separately
identifiable from the assets and liabilities of its
incorporated cells at all times;
(b) to keep the assets and liabilities of each incorporated
cell separate and separately identifiable from the
assets and liabilities of the other incorporated cells of
the recognised incorporated cell company at all times.
(2) The duty imposed by sub-regulation (1) is not breached by
reason only that the directors of the recognised incorporated cell
company cause or permit assets of the recognised incorporated cell
company or of any of its incorporated cells to be collectively
managed by an investment manager
Provided that the assets so managed shall remain separately
identifiable in accordance with sub-regulation (1).
(1) A recognised incorporated cell company shall have no
power, by virtue of its position as a recognised incorporated cell
co mp any, to en ter in to transact io ns o n behal f of an y o f it s
incorporated cells.
(2) An incorporated cell shall have no power, by virtue of its
position as an incorporated cell, to enter into transactions on behalf
of its recognised incorporated cell company.
(3) The directors or officers of a recognised incorporated cell
company or of an incorporated cell shall ensure that, in respect of
every transaction entered into, it is identified or specified whether
that transaction is being entered into by the recognised
incorporated cell company or by the incorporated cell, and if the
transaction is entered into by an incorporated cell, which
incorporated cell.
Save as otherwise provided by these regulations, the
provisions of the Act and of the Investment Services Act shall
apply to a recognised incorporated cell com pany and to an
incorporated cell as if a reference in the Act and in the Investment
Services Act
(a) to a company were a reference to a recognised
incorporated cell company or an incorporated cell;
(b) to the directors of a company were a reference to the
directors of a recognised incorporated cell company or
an incorporated cell;
(c) to the memorandum or articles of association of a
company were a reference to the memorandum or
articles of a recognised incorporated cell company or
an incorporated cell;
(d) to the members of a company were a reference to the
members of a recognised incorporated cell company or
an incorporated cell;
(e) to shares in a company were a reference to shares in a
recognised incorporated cell company or an
incorporated cell;
(f)
to assets and liabilities of a company were a reference
to the assets and liabilities of a recognised
incorporated cell company or an incorporated cell; and
(g) to the share capital of a company were a reference to
the share capital of a recognised incorporated cell
company or an incorporated cell.
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the definition
"company secretary" in article 2 and in article 138(3) of the Act,
the company secretary of a recognised incorporated cell company
and of an incorporated cell may be a body corporate.
(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of the Act, an incorporated
cell may have its recognised incorporated cell company as its only
member and the provisions of articles 212 and 214(2)(b)(i) of the
Act shall not apply in relation thereto in such case.
A recognised incorporated cell company and an
incorporated cell shall each submit an annual return containing the
information required by the Seventh Schedule to the Act.
The financial statements of an incorporated cell shall not
be consolidated with those of a recognised incorporated cell
company or of other incorporated cells except when the
incorporated cell is a subsidiary of the recognised incorporated cell
company and only to such extent.
In addition to the requirements of article 177 of the Act,
the directors’ report of a recognised incorporated cell company
shall also include the names and registration numbers of all its
incorporated cells.
(1) A recognised incorporated cell company shall be
dissolved and wound up in accordance with the provisions of Title
II of the Act and any regulations made thereunder.
(2) A recognised incorporated cell company that has been
dissolved and wound up shall not be struck off the register until
each of its incorporated cells have been either -
(a) transformed into
non-cellular
companies
under
regulation 23; or
(b) relocated to another recognised incorporated cell
company under regulation 24 or to an incorporated cell
company under regulation 24 of the Companies Act
(SICAV Incorporated Cell Companies) Regulations; or
(c) expelled under regulation 25; or
(d) continued as a body corporate under the law of another
jurisdiction; or
(e) struck-off,
and the Registrar has obtained the consent of the competent
authority to the striking-off of the recognised incorporated cell
company.
(1) Without prejudice to the provisions of regulation
19(1), the appointment of a liquidator in respect of a recognised
incorporated cell company shall not affect the position of its
incorporated cells, subject to any direction to the contrary given
during the course of a winding up by
(a) the court; or
(b) the competent authority.
(2) The competent authority may make an application to the
court for the court to give a direction under sub-regulation (1).
The competent authority may be heard on any application
to the court requesting the dissolution and winding up of a
recognised incorporated cell company or an incorporated cell.
The memorandum and articles of association of an
incorporated cell may be amended by an extraordinary resolution of
t h e i n c o r po r a te d c e l l fo l l o w i n g t h e w r i tt e n a pp r o v a l of i t s
recognised incorporated cell company.
(1) A limited liability company may, by extraordinary
resolution in accordance with article 79 of the Act and any other
applicable provisions of the Act, and in compliance with these
regulations, and provided it is authorised to do so by its
memorandum of association, be transformed
(a) from a non-cellular company into a recognised
incorporated cell company or into an incorporated cell;
(b) from a recognised incorporated cell company having
no incorporated cells or from an incorporated cell, into
a non-cellular company;
(c) from a segregated multi-fund company established
under the Act and regulation 9 of the SICAV
Regulations into an incorporated cell;
(d) from an incorporated cell into a segregated multi-fund
company
Provided that a transformation from a non-cellular SICAV
into a recognised incorporated cell company, or vice versa, shall be
prohibited.
(2)
(a) A segregated multi-fund company established under
the Act and regulation 9 of the SICAV Regulations
which has one or more segregated sub-funds may, in
accordance with Part IX of the Act and any other
applicable provisions of the Act, and in compliance
with these regulations, be divided into one or more
incorporated cells of a recognised incorporated cell
company.
(b) Where a segregated multi-fund company is divided in
accordance with paragraph (a), the non-cellular assets,
rights, liabilities and obligations of the company and
all claims, actions and legal proceedings concerning
the non-cellular part of the company shall be allocated
and delivered to the recipient incorporated cell; and
the assets, rights, liabilities and obligations of each
segregated sub-fund and all claims, actions and legal
proceedings concerning each segregated sub-fund
shall be allocated and delivered to a separate recipient
company constituting an incorporated cell.
(3)
(a) A company shall not carry out any of the operations
mentioned in sub-regulation (1), except with the
approval of the board of directors.
(b) In a division of a segregated multi-fund company as
referred to in sub-regulation (2), each of the directors
of the company shall sign a declaration stating that he
has made a full enquiry into the affairs of the company
and each of its segregated sub-funds, and that, having
so done, he is of the opinion that the company and
each of its segregated sub-funds are able to discharge
their liabilities as they fall due and that there are no
creditors of the company or of the segregated sub-
funds whose interests will be unfairly prejudiced by
the division.
(4) The operations mentioned in sub-regulations (1) and (2)
shall not be carried out except with the prior written approval of the
competent authority and in accordance with such terms and
conditions as the competent authority may establish and such
directives as the competent authority may issue.
(5)
(a) A non-cellular company that intends to transform itself
into an incorporated cell shall enter into an
incorporation agreement with a recognised
i n c o r p o r a t e d c e l l c o m p a n y. T h e i n c o r p o r a t i o n
agreement shall be approved by
(i)
the board of directors and by an extraordinary
resolution of both the non-cellular company and
the recognised incorporated cell company; and
(ii) the competent authority.
(b) An incorporated cell that intends to transform itself
into a non-cellular company shall, within fourteen
days of the extraordinary resolution taken to so
transform, notify its recognised incorporated cell
company in writing of such decision.
(6) In addition to any document which is required to be
delivered to the Registrar for registration in accordance with the
applicable provisions of the Act, a company which intends to carry
(a) any of the operations mentioned in sub-regulations (1)
and (2), shall deliver to the Registrar for registration
evidence of the written approval of the competent
authority required under sub-regulation (4);
(b) any of the operations mentioned in sub-regulation (1),
shall deliver to the Registrar for registration evidence
of the approval by the board of directors required
under sub-regulation (3)(a);
(c) the operation mentioned in sub-regulation (2), shall
deliver to the Registrar for registration the declaration
mentioned in sub-regulation (3)(b).
(1) For the purposes of this regulation, the term
"incorporated cell company" or "ICC" shall be deemed to refer both
to a recognised incorporated cell company established under these
regulations and to an incorporated cell company established under
t h e C o m p a n i e s A c t ( S I C AV I n c o r p o r a t e d C e l l C o m p a n i e s )
Regulations.
(2) An incorporated cell that intends to relocate from one
incorporated cell company (the "Exiting ICC") to another
incorporated cell company (the "Recipient ICC") shall notify the
competent authority of its intention. The competent authority may
impose such conditions and issue such directives as it may deem
necessary in the circumstances.
(3)
The relocation of an incorporated cell shall only take place
if
(a) it has the written consent of the competent authority to
so relocate;
(b) the incorporated cell passes an extraordinary
resolution to so relocate and amends its memorandum
and articles of association accordingly; and
(c) a relocation agreement has been entered into between
the incorporated cell and the Recipient ICC and is
approved in accordance with sub-regulation (4).
(4)
(a) A relocation agreement shall be submitted to the
competent authority for prior approval.
(b) A relocation agreement shall also be approved by
(i)
the board of directors and an extraordinary
resolution of the incorporated cell;
(ii) the board of directors and an extraordinary
resolution of the Recipient ICC; and
(iii) the board of directors of the Exiting ICC.
(5) An Exiting ICC shall, within seven days of the approval by
its board of directors of the relocation agreement, ensure that all
records, documents and other information pertaining to the
incorporated cell are duly transferred to the Recipient ICC.
(6) The Recipient ICC shall, within fourteen days of a
relocation agreement, deliver to the Registrar for registration
(a) evidence of the competent authority’s written consent;
(b) a copy of the extraordinary resolution described in
sub-regulation (3)(b), together with the memorandum
and articles of association of the incorporated cell
being relocated;
(c) a copy of the relocation agreement and the respective
resolutions approving such agreement;
(d) a declaration made in accordance with sub-regulation
(7), signed by each director of the incorporated cell
which is being relocated; and
(e) the incorporated
cell’s
original
certificate
of
registration.
(7) The declaration referred to in sub-regulation (6)(d) must
state that each director of the incorporated cell being relocated
believes on reasonable grounds that
(a) the incorporated cell being relocated is able to
discharge its liabilities as they fall due;
(b) there are no creditors of the incorporated cell being
relocated whose interests will be unfairly prejudiced
by the transfer; and
(c) the relocation agreement has been approved and
executed in accordance with this regulation.
(8) Upon delivery to the Registrar of the documents referred to
in sub-regulation (6), the Registrar shall, if those documents
comply with this regulation
(a) register the relocation of the incorporated cell and the
new memorandum and articles of the incorporated
cell;
(b) issue to the incorporated cell a new certificate of
registration indicating the name of the Recipient ICC;
and
(c) record that the incorporated cell has ceased to be an
incorporated cell of the Exiting ICC.
(9) Upon the issue of the new certificate of registration as
aforesaid
(a) the incorporated cell shall cease to be an incorporated
cell of the Exiting ICC;
(b) the incorporated cell shall become an incorporated cell
of the Recipient ICC;
(c) all property and rights to which the incorporated cell
was entitled immediately before the issue of the new
certificate shall remain the property and rights of the
incorporated cell;
(d) all liabilities and all contracts, debts and other
obligations to which the incorporated cell was subject
immediately before the issue of the new certificate
shall remain the liabilities, contracts, debts and other
obligations of the incorporated cell; and
(e) all actions and other legal proceedings which,
immediately before the issue of the new certificate,
were pending by or against the incorporated cell may
be continued by or against the incorporated cell.
(10) The operation of sub-regulation (9) shall not be regarded
(a) as a breach of any contractual provision prohibiting,
restricting or regulating the assignment or transfer of
rights or liabilities or change of control; or
(b) as giving rise to any remedy by a party to a contract or
other instrument, as an event of default under any
contract or other instrument or as causing or
permitting the termination of any contract or other
instrument, or of any obligation or relationship.
(11) An incorporated cell shall not be relocated under this
regulation if such relocation is inconsistent with the memorandum
or articles of association of
(a) the incorporated cell; or
(b) the Recipient ICC.
(1) A recognised incorporated cell company may, subject
to approval by the competent authority and on the grounds listed in
sub-regulation (2), expel an incorporated cell.
(2)
The grounds referred to in sub-regulation (1) are
(a) that the affairs of the incorporated cell are being or
have been conducted in a manner which is unfairly
prejudicial to its recognised incorporated cell company
or any other incorporated cell of that company;
(b) that the incorporated cell is being or has been used for
fraudulent purposes; or
(c) that to fail to do so would have a serious adverse effect
upon the members of the incorporated cell or on the
recognised incorporated cell company.
(3) In determining whether to approve an expulsion in terms of
su b-regu l ati on ( 1 ), th e c om p etent authority shall take i nto
consideration any representations made to it by the recognised
incorporated cell company, the liquidator (where applicable), the
incorporated cell and any other party deemed to have a material
interest in the business of the relevant incorporated cell, and may
give such directions as it deems fit.
(4) The provisions of this regulation are without prejudice to
any and all powers granted to the competent authority under the
Investment Services Act.
(1) An appeal shall lie to the Financial Services Tribunal
from a decision of the competent authority
(a) to refuse to issue a recognition for a company to be
formed or constituted as a recognised incorporated cell
company;
(b) to refuse to issue an approval for a segregated multi-
fund company to be divided into a recognised
incorporated cell company and incorporated cells;
(c) to refuse to issue an approval for an incorporated cell
to transform itself into a non-cellular company
carrying on the activity of a collective investment
scheme;
(d) to refuse to issue an approval for an incorporated cell
to relocate from one incorporated cell company to
another incorporated cell company; and
(e) to refuse to issue an approval for a non-cellular
company carrying on the activity of a collective
investment scheme to transform itself into an
incorporated cell.
(2) The provisions of article 21 of the Malta Financial Services
Authority Act shall, mutatis mutandis, apply to appeals brought
before the Tribunal under this regulation.