Art. 5 LOI sur l'expropriation (LE) - Proportionnalité

PE.2017.0491 · vd (art. 5 annexe I de l'accord conclu le 21 juin 1999 entre la Confédération suisse, d'une part, et la Communauté européenne et ses Etats membres, d'autre part, sur la libre circulation des personnes (ALCP; RS 0.142.112.681))

Judicial Review of Residence Permit Revocation Based on Serious Criminal Convictions

Cited in reasoning as the basis for restricting free movement rights, which underlies the decision to confirm the revocation.

PE.2017.0129 · vd (art. 5 annexe I de l'accord conclu le 21 juin 1999 entre la Confédération suisse, d'une part, et la Communauté européenne et ses Etats membres, d'autre part, sur la libre circulation des personnes (ALCP; RS 0.142.112.681))

Revocation of Residency Permit Upheld Due to Persistent Serious Criminal Convictions

This article defines the public order limitations applicable to the right of residence under the ALCP, which the court used to assess the proportionality and justification of the revocation.

PS.2011.0059 · vd (art. 5 de la loi du 10 février 2004 sur le recouvrement et les avances sur pensions alimentaires - LRAPA; RSV 850.36)

Social Welfare Payments Upon Remarriage Income Threshold Case

Cited as the general provision allowing the right holder to request appropriate aid from the service.

GE.2011.0125 · vd (art. 5 al. 1 du règlement sur l'organisation et le fonctionnement de la commission de dégustation des vins d'appellation d'origine contrôlée)

Vigneron Appeal Against AOC Denial Upheld Due to Contradictory Fault Assessments

Cited to define when a wine is considered of insufficient quality (refused by majority).

PE.2010.0044 · vd (art. 5 de l'annexe I à l'accord conclu le 21 juin 1999 entre la Confédération, d'une part, et la Communauté européenne et ses Etats membres, d'autre part, sur la libre circulation des personnes (ALCP; RS 0.142.112.681))

Immigration Refusal Upheld Despite Marriage Due to Criminal History and False Statements

The court confirmed the decision to refuse the residence permit based on this article concerning the free movement of persons, in conjunction with the LEtr.

PS.2008.0085 · vd (art. 5 de la loi du 10 février 2004 sur le recouvrement et les avances sur pensions alimentaires - LRAPA)

Child Support Advance Denial Based on Statutory Income Threshold

This article establishes the right of the beneficiary to request appropriate aid from the service regarding unpaid pensions, which is the subject of the recourse.

AC.2001.0244 · vd (art. 5 du règlement du 24 juin 1998 sur les émoluments et les frais perçus par le Tribunal administratif)

Gravel Pit Extension Approval and Reforestation Postponement

Cited in the reasoning section III as the legal basis for setting the increased court fee amount in the final orders.

PS.2000.0133 · vd (art. 5 de la loi fédérale sur le libre passage dans la prévoyance professionnelle vieillesse, survivants et invalidité du 17 décembre 1993)

Administrative Court Upholds Repayment of Social Assistance Due to Subsequent Pension Fund Withdrawal

Although cited in the reasoning section (Considerant 1) to justify why the funds were available to the appellant, it was not explicitly mentioned in the dispositive orders (I, II, or III). Exclusion based on the rule.

GE.1998.0105 · vd (art. 5 de la loi sur le Service de l'emploi (LS) du 6 octobre 1989)

Appeal Against Placement Authorization Revocation Due to Bankruptcy and Practices

This article was the primary legal basis cited by the administrative authority for the initial withdrawal of the license, which the court subsequently addressed.

FI.1997.0141 · vd (art. 5 al. 1 de la loi du 28 novembre 1916 sur le Service de défense contre l'incendie (LSDI))

Fire Service Tax Exemption Appeal on Spousal Eligibility

Cited in the reasoning as the predecessor law, but not in the dispositive.

GE.1995.0006 · vd (art. 5 de la loi du 22 mai 1984 sur le commerce d'occasion (RSV 8.5.H))

Revocation of Scrap Metal Trade Authorization Upheld Due to Persistent Regulatory Violations

This article provided the legal basis for the administrative decision to withdraw the authorization.

FI.1994.0068 · vd (Art. 5 al. 1 de la loi du 28 novembre 1916 sur le Service de défense contre l'incendie (LSDI))

Taxpayer v. Municipality (Fire Tax and Gender Equality)

Although cited in the reasoning discussing the basis for the local regulation, this article was not explicitly cited in the operative part (dispositive) of the final orders (I, II, III).

GE.1993.0087 · vd (art. 5 al. 2 sur l'ordonnance réglant le placement d'enfants du 19 octobre 1977)

Age Gap as Sole Bar to Adoption Overturned

This provision outlines the dual verification required for granting authorization to host a child for adoption (legal impediments and best interest of the child), applied when reforming the lower authority's decision.

GE.1992.0146 · vd (art. 5 de la loi du 9 juin 1947 sur le statut général des fonctions publiques cantonales (statut))

Teacher Tenure Claim Transfer to State Council

Cited in the facts section regarding the appellant's initial engagement, but not in the dispositive.