735.1
ENTG
CH-SG
CH-SG
Art. 6 Enteignungsgesetz (EntG) - Verhältnismässigkeit
II. Enteignung - 1. Enteignungsrecht
Art. 6 EntG · Verhältnismässigkeit
1. Die Enteignung ist zulässig, soweit der Zweck auf andere Weise nicht befriedigend oder nur mit unverhältnismässigem Mehraufwand verwirklicht werden kann.
2. Sie darf nicht zu einem Nachteil führen, der in einem Missverhältnis zum verfolgten Zweck steht.
Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (12)
B.2021.101 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Road Project Expropriation Partially Overturned Due to Insufficient Necessity for Bus Shelter Land
Cited regarding the principle of proportionality in expropriation, relevant to the partial success regarding expropriation.
B.2020.114 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Road Widening Plan Appeal Dismissed
The court confirmed that the expropriation was proportionate by referencing this article, which requires that the disadvantage resulting from expropriation must not be disproportionate to the pursued purpose.
B.2020.114 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Municipal Road Expansion Approval Upheld Against Property Owner Appeal
Cited in connection with the proportionality assessment for the expropriation (land acquisition).
B.2020.183 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Landfill Expropriation Upheld for Public Interest Waste Disposal
The court found that the principle of proportionality (Art. 6 EntG) was respected in the expropriation.
B.2020.183 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Municipality Expropriation for Landfill Expansion Upheld
The court used this provision to confirm the principle of proportionality was upheld, as the purpose could not be otherwise satisfactorily achieved.
B.2017.240 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Appeal Against Road Construction and Property Appropriation Partially Granted Due to Insufficient Necessity Finding and Defective Traffic Safety Plan
Cited in the reasoning regarding the admissibility of expropriation based on proportionality (E. 3), but not explicitly in the dispositive orders.
B.2017.240 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Appeal Allowed: Insufficient Necessity for Expropriation and Unlawful Planting Restriction
Central to the expropriation assessment regarding proportionality, leading to the remand for further factual investigation.
B.2017.113 · sg (Art. 6 Abs. 1 EntG SG)
Expropriation for Roundabout Upheld Despite Loss of Parking Space
Cited indirectly as part of the context in the analysis (E. 3) justifying the admissibility of the expropriation based on the required conditions being met.
B.2017.113 · sg (Art. 6 Abs. 1 EntG SG)
Expropriation for Cantonal Road Roundabout Upheld
Cited in the reasoning section to establish the condition for the admissibility of expropriation based on the proportionality principle.
B.2017.76 · sg (Art. 6 EntG SG)
Expropriation for Shooting Range Overturned Due to Inadequate Noise Remediation Assessment
The appeal was partially granted by remitting the case to the lower court for correct procedure and new decision, as the proportionality test under this article was not correctly applied.
B.2017.76 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Expropriation Premature Pending Noise Abatement Permit Review
This provision embodies the principle of proportionality which served as the main ground for sending the case back for further review, specifically regarding the failure to coordinate expropriation with the permitting process for noise reduction measures.
B.2010.7 · sg (Art. 6 EntG)
Cantonal Road Infrastructure Project Approval Upheld Against Property Expropriation Challenge
Cited in connection with the principle of proportionality required for expropriation.