731.1
PBG
CH-SG
CH-SG
Art. 159 Planungs- und Baugesetz (PBG) - Verwaltungszwang a) Anordnungen
D. Verfahren und Vollzug - IV. Vollzug und Strafen - 1. Vollzug
Art. 159 PBG · Verwaltungszwang a) Anordnungen
1. Wird durch die Errichtung von Bauten und Anlagen ohne Bewilligung oder auf andere Weise ein unrechtmässiger Zustand geschaffen, wird
a) die Einstellung der Arbeiten verfügt;
b) ein Benützungsverbot verfügt;
c) eine Frist zur Einreichung eines nachträglichen Baugesuchs angesetzt;
d) die Wiederherstellung des rechtmässigen Zustands verfügt.
2. Die für den unrechtmässigen Zustand verantwortlichen Personen wirken im Wiederherstellungsverfahren mit. Wird innert angesetzter Frist kein Vorschlag für die Wiederherstellung vorgelegt, legt die politische Gemeinde die Wiederherstellungsmassnahme im Rahmen des pflichtgemässen Ermessens fest.
3. Für das Wiederherstellungsverfahren werden die Vorschriften dieses Erlasses über das Baubewilligungsverfahren sachgemäss angewendet.
Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (126)
B.2024.151 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 1 lit. d PBG)
Sludge Spreading Illegality and Restoration Obligation
The court confirms the competence of the municipality to order the restoration of the lawful state based on this provision, which mandates the authority to order restoration when an unlawful state is created.
B.2024.151 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 2 PBG)
Sludge Spreading Illegality and Restoration Obligation
Cited in the reasoning section (3.4.4) to establish the responsibility of the liable person to participate in the restoration procedure and submit a proposal.
B.2024.166 · sg (Art. 159 PBG)
Campsite Demolition Order Challenge Based on Insufficient Legal Basis and Proportionality Review
The court determined that this provision was not applicable for the revocation order because the existing use was presumed lawful and no illegal state had been created.
B.2024.153 · sg (Art. 159 PBG)
Appeal Dismissed for Unauthorized Construction in Protected Landscape Area
This provision was used in E. 8.1 to justify the mandatory ordering of the restoration of the lawful state (Wiederherstellung des rechtmässigen Zustands) for illegal constructions.
B.2024.93 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 1 lit. d PBG)
Administrative Decision Enforcement on Property Forecourt Upheld
This article provides the legal basis for ordering the restoration of the legal situation due to an unlawful construction/installation.
B.2024.57 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 1 Ingress und lit. c PBG)
Local Authority Refusal to Process Identical Building Application Upheld on Res Judicata Grounds
Cited in the introductory summary, this provision governs the possibility for an owner to submit a subsequent building application when facing restoration orders.
B.2023.261 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 1 lit. d PBG)
Property Owner Ordered to Remove Unlawful Photovoltaic System in Protected Townscape
This article forms the substantive basis for upholding the order to restore the lawful state (Wiederherstellung des rechtmässigen Zustands).
22.6401 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 1 Bst. b PBG)
Building Permit Status of Parking Areas Near Former Military Facility
Cited in the reasoning section as the legal basis defining when a usage prohibition (Nutzungsverbot) can be ordered.
23.8154 · sg (Art. 159 PBG)
Cost Allocation Review in Mandatory Restoration Works Execution
Cited in the introductory summary as context regarding coercive measures (Zwangsmitteln) related to building law.
24.372 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 1 Bst. d PBG)
Administrative Appeal on Proportionality of Building Restoration Order
This provision forms the implicit legal basis for the restoration order that was appealed, as the decision to uphold the appeal concerned the lack of proper application of proportionality required for such an order under building law.
22.8018 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 1 PBG)
Property Owner Fails to Overturn Mandated Forecourt Restoration for Illegal Development
This provision forms the substantive basis for upholding the administrative decision regarding the restoration measures (planting a tree and creating flowerbeds).
B.2023.213 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 3 PBG)
Property Owner v. Deferral of Floodlight Removal Amid Road Decommissioning
This provision concerning the application of building permit procedures to restoration proceedings is discussed extensively as the legal basis for the administrative actions under review.
23.7344 · sg (Art. 159 Abs. 2 PBG)
Improper Dismissal of Building Application Without Required Public Notice
Cited in the facts to reference the right of the property owner to participate in the restoration procedure.
B.2023.194 · sg (Art. 159 PBG)
Refusal to Retroactively Permit Unauthorized Canopy Extension Violating Setback Regulations Upheld
This article provides the legal basis for ordering the restoration of the lawful state, which the court ultimately upheld.
B.2023.194 · sg (Art. 159 PBG)
Appeal Dismissed for Unpermitted Canopy Extension Violating Setback Requirements
The order to restore the legal state was based on this article regarding enforcement measures in planning and building law.