213.1
VSG
CH-SG
CH-SG
Art. 123 Volksschulgesetz (VSG) - Privater Einzelunterricht
VIII. Privatunterricht[[1]](#titletitle_text_fn_57644_2_1_c)
Art. 123 VSG · Privater Einzelunterricht
1. Für den privaten Einzelunterricht werden die Vorschriften dieses Gesetzes über die Privatschulen sachgemäss angewendet.
2. Der Bildungsrat erteilt die Bewilligung, wenn zudem die Erziehung zur Gemeinschaftsfähigkeit sichergestellt ist.
Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (19)
B.2022.65 · sg (Art. 123 VSG)
Appeal Against Refusal of Private Home Schooling Due to Insufficient Social Skills Instruction
This provision was the central legal basis for the appeal regarding the denial of the permit for private individual instruction.
B.2022.66 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 1 in Verbindung mit Art. 117 Abs. 1 Ingress und lit. a VSG)
Appeal Against Denial of Private Homeschooling Permit Based on Insufficient Social Integration Concept
The finding that the private instruction was not 'established for the long term' was rejected based on these provisions.
B.2022.66 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 2 VSG)
Appeal Against Denial of Private Homeschooling Permit Based on Insufficient Social Integration Concept
The appeal was upheld and the case returned to the lower court for re-examination based on the requirement to ensure education for social integration.
B.2022.67 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 2 VSG)
Appeal Against Rejection of Private Home Tutoring Allowed Due to Insufficient Examination of Social Integration Plan
The court overturned the decision due to the authority's failure to properly exercise its discretion concerning the requirement of ensuring education for social skills (Erziehung zur Gemeinschaftsfähigkeit).
B.2022.65 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 2 VSG)
Administrative Court Quashes Denial of Home Schooling Permit Over Insufficient Scrutiny of Community Capability
The appeal was allowed and the case returned for reconsideration because the lower court failed to properly assess the fulfillment of the requirement to ensure education for social competence.
B.2022.66 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 2 VSG)
Administrative Court Rejects Rejection of Homeschooling Permit Based on Insufficient Sociability Assessment
The provision concerning the securing of education for community ability, which was central to the lower court's rejection and the Supreme Court's finding of insufficient discretion.
B.2022.66 · sg (Art. 123 VSG)
Administrative Court Rejects Rejection of Homeschooling Permit Based on Insufficient Sociability Assessment
This provision governs private individual instruction and is the core legal basis for the appeal's outcome (remand for reconsideration regarding the securing of community ability).
B.2022.67 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 1 VSG)
Appeal Against Rejection of Home Schooling Based on Socialization Concerns
The court implicitly used this article as the basis for the possibility of granting private individual instruction, which was the subject of the appeal.
B.2022.67 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 2 VSG)
Appeal Against Rejection of Home Schooling Based on Socialization Concerns
The appeal was granted and the case remanded because the lower court failed to properly apply its discretion regarding the requirement to ensure education for sociability, which is governed by this article.
B.2021.265 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 1 in Verbindung mit Art. 117 Abs. 1 Ingress und lit. a VSG)
Administrative Court Upholds Appeal for Private Home Tutoring, Remanding for New Decision
The court found that the requirement of 'auf Dauer angelegter Unterricht' (duration of instruction) under these provisions was met after the submission of supplementary documents, leading to the reversal of the decision on this ground.
B.2021.265 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 2 VSG)
Administrative Court Upholds Appeal for Private Home Tutoring, Remanding for New Decision
The court found that the authority failed to examine the criterion of ensuring education for social skills ('Erziehung zur Gemeinschaftsfähigkeit') under this provision in depth, necessitating a remand.
B.2021.265 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 1 in Verbindung mit Art. 117 Abs. 1 Ingress und lit. a VSG)
Administrative Court Overturns Home Schooling Denial Based on Insufficient Review of Duration and Social Competency Measures
This provision governs private individual instruction and was used to determine that the requirement for 'long-term arrangement' of instruction was met upon supplementation of the request.
B.2021.265 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 2 VSG)
Administrative Court Overturns Home Schooling Denial Based on Insufficient Review of Duration and Social Competency Measures
This provision regarding the education for sociability was deemed not sufficiently examined by the lower court, leading to the remand for further decision.
B.2010.77 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 2 VSG)
Right to Homeschool Limited by Mandate for Adequate Education and Socialization
The core of the dismissal of the appeal rests on the finding that the proposed homeschooling plan does not meet the requirement for ensuring education for community skills (Erziehung zur Gemeinschaftsfähigkeit).
B.2010.77 · sg (Art. 123 Abs. 1 VSG)
State Interest in Mandatory Education Trumps Unsupervised Home Tutoring Exemption
Cited as the main legal basis for the proportional application of private school regulations to private individual instruction.