370.100
VRGLGA
CH-GR
CH-GR
Art. 59 Gesetz über die Verwaltungsrechtspflege (VRG) - Beschwerdegründe
Verfahren vor Obergericht - Verfassungsbeschwerde
Art. 59 VRG · Beschwerdegründe
1. Mit der Beschwerde können geltend gemacht werden
a) Verletzungen von verfassungsmässigen und politischen Rechten sowie des Grundsatzes des Vorrangs von übergeordnetem Recht;
b) * Verletzungen der Autonomie der Gemeinden, der Regionen und anderer öffentlich-rechtlicher Körperschaften sowie der Landeskirchen.
Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (16)
V 2021 5 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Landowner Challenge to Municipal Ordinance Permitting Winter Field Road Opening Upheld
The main ground for rejecting the appeal is that the appellant did not successfully establish a violation of a constitutional right (like property rights), as required for review under this provision.
V 2020 2 · gr (Art. 59 Abs. 1 lit. a VRG)
Voter Challenge to Municipal Council Decision on Development Plan Revision Submission Method Upheld
Cited in the reasoning regarding the possibility to challenge political rights violations, but not explicitly in the dispositive orders.
V 2020 2 · gr (Art. 59 Abs. 1 lit. a VRG)
Municipal Council Competence in GEP Revision During COVID-19 Restrictions
Referred to in the reasoning establishing the procedural admissibility (legitimation) for filing the complaint concerning the violation of political rights.
V 2019 4 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Property Owner's Challenge to Municipal Traffic Regulation Law Upheld on Standing, Dismissed on Merits
This provision allows the Administrative Court to review an enactment for violation of constitutional and political rights, which is the basis for the abstract norm review in this case.
V 2019 4 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Co-Owner Appeal Against Municipal Road Regulation Dismissed
Although cited in the reasoning regarding the scope of review for abstract norm control, this article defines the court's power to review enactments for violations of constitutional and political rights, which forms the basis for dismissing the complaint.
V 2019 5 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Challenge to Municipal FOIA Adoption and Constitutional Revision
Cited in the reasoning (E.1) concerning the grounds for appeal, but not explicitly repeated in the final orders. EXCLUDED.
V 2019 5 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Voting Rights Appeal Dismissed Over Municipal Referendum on Access Law and Constitution
Cited as the legal basis allowing complaints regarding violations of constitutional and political rights or the principle of primacy of higher law.
V 2019 2 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Swiss Federal Supreme Court Upholds Partial Invalidation of Popular Initiative on Cinema Ban Retroactivity
Cited in the reasoning regarding the admissibility of the constitutional appeal against the invalidation decision.
V 2016 8 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Administrative Court Ruling on Popular Initiative for Ethical Hunting
Cited as a basis in consideration 1.1 for the admissibility of the constitutional complaint against the decision to invalidate the initiative.
S 2014 148 · gr (Art. 59 VRG)
Claimant Appeal for Ongoing Disability Pension Denied Despite Multiple Ailments
Cited in conjunction with Art. 1 Abs. 1 IVG to confirm the appellant's active standing (legitimation) to file the appeal.
V 2015 4 · gr (Art. 59 Abs. 1 VRG)
Challenge to Municipal Leasehold Approval Due to Conflated Voting Subject
Cited in the reasoning to establish the grounds on which the appeal could be lodged (violation of constitutional/political rights).
V 2015 2 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Constitutional Challenge Against Initiative Limiting Primary School Foreign Languages Upheld
Cited as a basis for the admissibility of the constitutional appeal against the invalidation decision.
V 2015 2 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Appeal Against Invalidation of Popular Initiative on Compulsory Primary School Foreign Language
Cited as the basis for the admissibility of the constitutional appeal against the nullification decision.
V 2015 1 · gr (Art. 59 lit. a VRG)
Constitutional Challenge to Abolition of Special Hunts Upheld Due to Conflict with Federal Wildlife Law
Procedural basis cited for the admissibility of the constitutional appeal against the invalidation decision.
S 2015 110 · gr (Art. 59 Abs. 1 lit. a VRG)
Disability Benefit Appeal Regarding Psychiatric Evaluation Findings
Cited in connection with procedural assessment (competence) of the Administrative Court.