150.1
VRGCPJA
CH-FR
CH-FR
Art. 57 Code de procédure et de juridiction administrative (CPJA) - Principe
Procédure - Règles générales de procédure et procédure de première instance - Droit d'être entendu
Art. 57 CPJA · Principe
1. Les parties ont le droit d'être entendues avant qu'une décision ne soit prise.
2. Sauf prescription contraire, elles n'ont pas droit à une audition verbale.
Décisions judiciaires appliquant cette disposition (18)
602 2023 170 · fr (art. 57 ss CPJA)
Municipal Development Plan Revision Appeals: Zoning Disputes and Unbuilt Reserve Limits
Cited as the codification of the right to be heard.
601 2024 92 · fr (art. 57 ss CPJA)
Appeal Against Refusal of Conditional Release Based on Reclassified Psychiatric Diagnosis
Cited as the procedural basis for the right to be heard (procedural review aspect).
602 2024 159 · fr (art. 57 ss CPJA)
Appeal Regarding Grouped Residential Complex Permit Based on Access Road and Building Regulation Compliance
Cited as the basis detailing the right to be heard, examined in the appeal.
605 2023 210 · fr (Art. 57 Abs. 1 VRG)
Social Assistance Reduction Upheld Due to Failure to Pursue Subsidiarity Requirements
Cited in the reasoning to define the right to be heard, relevant to procedural considerations concerning Order I.
601 2023 121 · fr (art. 57 al. 2 CPJA)
Teacher Termination Upheld Due to Confrontational Behavior
Cited in the reasoning section regarding written procedure, not cited in the final orders.
603 2023 12 · fr (art. 57 al. 2 CPJA)
Speech Therapist v. Cultural Affairs Authority (Unit Allocation Reassessment)
Cited in reasoning when discussing the right to be heard and the general rule regarding oral hearings in cantonal administrative procedure.
603 2022 143 · fr (art. 57 al. 2 CPJA)
Company Ordered to Repay COVID-19 Aid Due to Dividend Distribution Despite Subsequent Cancellation
Used to dismiss the complaint regarding the violation of the right to be heard, as the appellant could not claim an unconditional right to an oral hearing.
601 2019 210 · fr (Art. 57 Abs. 2 VRG)
Correctional Authority Termination of Therapeutic Measure Upheld Due to Untreatable Profile
Cited in reasoning regarding the right to be heard and the general written nature of the procedure, but not explicitly in the final orders (I-IV).
602 2019 105 · fr (art. 57 al. 1 CPJA)
Cantonal Court Upholds PCB Landfill Remediation Guarantee Against Corporate Successor
Cited in the reasoning regarding the right to be heard, which was ultimately deemed satisfied.
603 2018 179 · fr (Art. 57 al. 1 CPJA)
Driver's Appeal Against Driving Ban Due to Pre-Emptive Administrative Ruling and Lack of Proper Notification
Cited as the basis for finding that the administrative authority did not respect the obligation to hear the interested party before making a decision.
603 2017 106 · fr (art. 57 al. 1 CPJA)
Tenant Farmers' Right to be Heard in Land Use Appeal
Cited as the basis for granting the farmer party status and the right to be heard.
603 2018 102 · fr (Art. 57 al. 1 CPJA)
Administrative Driving Ban Annulled Pending Criminal Proceedings Outcome
Cited in the reasoning to support the annulment due to violation of the right to be heard before a decision was rendered against the appellant.
603 2017 197 · fr (art. 57 al. 1 CPJA)
Violation of Minor Patient's Right to Be Heard in Medical Confidentiality Waiver
Cited as the cantonal expression of the right to be heard, violated by the lower authority.
601 2018 31 · fr (Art. 57 VRG)
Denial of Conditional Release Upheld Based on High Reoffense Risk Assessment for Child Sexual Offender
Cited in the context of the appellant's rejected claim regarding a violation of the right to be heard.
605 2018 21 · fr (Art. 57 Abs. 1 VRG)
Social Assistance Reimbursement Limitation for Excessive Rent
Cited in the context of examining the appellant's claim regarding the right to be heard.